Not a Nursing Question, but Has to Do with Work, So...

Nurses General Nursing

Published

I work with two CNAs that don't drive. One (Amy) simply doesn't have a license due to a mental/physical disability since birth. The other (Kim) has a license and a car, but the car is broken down and she can't afford the repairs. Both expect a ride home from coworkers every day.

Amy often goes to a friend's house instead of to her home. Her friend's house is literally two blocks from the facility where we work. She has never even asked me for a ride, she simply waits by my car and gets in when I unlock the doors. Kim lives about three miles away and used to ask for a ride, but now she simply tells me she will be waiting for me. They do the same thing to other coworkers who drive.

It isn't a big deal because it only takes about ten or fifteen minutes to get them both home. I don't think that any of us spend much extra money on gas. I think there is just some frustration with being expected to deliver them to wherever they need to go. Neither has ever offered to pitch in for gas.

Kim is a single mom who leaves her children with her mother while she works. A few days ago, Kim's mother called her while we were on our way to her house. She was concerned because Kim wasn't home yet. I only heard one side of the conversation, but Kim made the comment to her mother, "The nurse who is taking me home didn't manage to get out on time. She really needs to be more considerate of the fact that I have obligations at home." It was a long and lousy night. I was tempted to pull over and tell her to get out (not that I ever would, but it certainly annoyed me).

All of us who take them home have similar issues. We are just seeking some advice on how we can reduce our frustration about this. One of the CNAs that gives them rides has said she is going to start charging them fifty cents every time she gives them a ride.

Also one day when someone was dropping Amy off, her car died in the parking lot of Amy's apartment complex. She ended up having to call her husband to get it moved and eventually restarted. Amy told her that her car is a piece of junk and that she got in trouble with her landlord for having a friend's car in the lot overnight. She said that from now on Amy and Kim can just walk.

This must be why I was never very popular in school..... because I would have been like, "Excuse me, why are you getting into my car?"

Coffee on my computer screen removed.....and I thought I was just old and jaded.....HAAHAHAHAHA

Nope...small town. The only thing resembling public transportation is a van that will take elderly people to the grocery store or clinic. I don't know why I am beating myself up over this. I just don't feel like giving them rides and I think my coworkers agree. It is almost comical (but kind of cruel too) to see us trying to avoid them so they can't ask for a ride or wait patiently by our cars.

They both have rides to work, but no one wants to drag out of bed to take them home at six in the morning. Amy's sister drops her off. Not sure how Kim gets to work.

Well, if Amy has a disability that precludes her from getting a driver's license, then perhaps she has avenues available to her to make use of any services for disabled people that your town has--which may in fact be the bus that takes the elderly to their hair appointments.

Again, not your issue.

And if the other one is in a place where she has a bucket load of children, then one would assume that she is getting something--whether that be child support, public assistance--and again, using resources she may find that transportation is part of those benefits--even in the form of a taxi--not unheard of.

Repeat after me....."The circumstances in my life have changed, therefore, today is the last day I can give you a ride home." Do not elaborate, do not apologize....YOU are not responsible for other people's children/siblings/relatives/friends unless they are your patients. Then you are only responsible when you are in work.

Specializes in OR, Nursing Professional Development.

You can only be taken advantage of if you allow it to happen. With an attitude like what is being displayed by these two, I would not be willing to continue the free transportation service either. I second the idea of having other things to do. I'd also only be using the key to unlock the driver's door- no more key fob so that the other person can simply help themselves to the passenger seat. If the other staff are feeling the same way, it's time to also show a united front.

I have to agree with everyone else on what is being said however I cannot help but feel sort of bad and so I can see why you might feel guilty. These individuals seem to be on hard times but are breaking the cardinal rule of being someone on the receiving end of charity.

I remembered a CNA I worked with at my first job. She was the CNA who oriented me and partnered with me. Easily the best CNA I have ever worked with. She did not drive or own a car. She asked for rides home and was responsible enough to offer me gas money. I had no problems giving her a ride and took no money from her, just because I enjoyed working with her. Quite the stellar opposite of the behavior of these two mooches.

Specializes in Med/Surg/Onc, Peds, Tele, LTC, Hospice...

You may want to have your coworkers conspire and have a car pool that fills the car.

Sorry full car!

You don't even have to say "My circumstances have changed." Honestly, the first time one of them waited by my car without asking and definitely as soon as a snarky remark was made, I would have been OUT.

Say it with me. "You can't ride with me anymore." No need for explanations. Just, "You can't ride with me anymore."

"But, whyyyyyyy?"

"Because I said so" or, "It doesn't matter, you will need to find a different way home." "But, but, but...." Walk away.

I would do it at the beginning of shift so they can have time to mooch off someone else. Just realize that they are going to be mad at you for a while (mooches never give in gracefully) and have strategies in place to deal with it.

Good luck.

Easy- JUST SAY NO! ;-)

While I am a big fan of carpooling and ridesharing for environmental purposes, it needs to be with the consent and voluntary participation of all involved. :) It is a basic expectation of the CNAs' employment that they will get themselves to and from work. It is not in any way the responsibility of any of their coworkers. Has anyone spoken to the nurse manager about the situation? I would think it would be appropriate for the NM or some other administrative type to speak with the two CNAs and explicitly tell them that they are not allowed to (continually, on a routine basis) solicit coworkers for rides home, just as they would not be permitted to sell Mary Kay or impose on coworkers in any other way inappropriate in the workplace. If they can't get back and forth to work on their own, they need to find some other employment.

I agree with the excellent suggestions already posted of things to say to these individuals to put an end to this.

It is one thing to ask for a ride home, it is another to expect it. To have an attitude with the person who is doing them a favor just lost them a ride home in my book. They get paid for working at the facility too, right? Time to call a cab or someone else who gives a heck how they find their way home.

Eh, I'd just give them a ride, unless I truly didn't like them. To me, it wouldn't be worth the potential conflict and/or bad attitudes I may have to deal with.

+ Add a Comment