Family issue..Thoughts?

Nursing Students General Students

Published

LONG POST****

Hello guys,

I have been a lurker of this site for about 4 years now and finally decided to make an account today. Before I get started here's a little bit of background information about me.

I am 21, from Texas. I am a senior BSN program. I still live at home with my mom and 2 younger siblings.

Now for the story...

I am having family issues at home. It has not been the first time, it actually happens very often. My mom and I have never really had a great relationship since I can remember. She seems to have a "favorite" child, whom is my 16 year old sister. Since I can remember she has always gone out of her way to satisfy my sister, kiss her **s just to make sure not to disappoint her. She will pretty much agree with anything my sister does and says just to please her. Recently, she brought up the idea of my letting my sister go off to college. This is where my problem comes in..

When it was my time to go off to college she absolutely said no and threatened that if I left she would not talk to me anymore. I didn't have a car, had never held a job before, and the first person in my family to attend college so the thought of me being out on my own without a parent to talk to scared me, so I followed my mom's wishes and stayed close. She then told me that if I went to a local college (20 minutes away) I could move on campus. Once I agreed to go to the local college and it was time for me to look for dorms, she said no. Fast forward 4 years later, I'm a senior in a nursing program, 21 years old, and she still will not agree to let me move out!!! She has also tried to talk me into living here once I graduate college as well. NOT HAPPENING.

It angers me because she's agreed to let my sister leaves once she finishes high school. Today I brought up the option of moving into my own apartment (about 15 minutes away) and she flipped out. I am not happy living here because she is controlling my whole life. Not to mention she also tries to control my friends, who I date, my money, etc. Pretty much my whole life. Meanwhile, my 16 year old sisters lives a better life than me. She claims that she doesn't care if I left, but soon as I bring it up all hell breaks loose.

The only reason I have not up and left yet is because I do not want to upset or disappoint my mom in any way but it seems as though she is going to control me as long as I allow her to BUT now I think its time for me to go whether she likes it or not. I do not feel like it's fair for her to choose my college and place of residence for 4 years of my life, meanwhile actively plans and help look for colleges for my sister to move to once she graduates. I have basically lived 4 years of my life for my mom. It has been so miserable.

I have no clue what it's like to be a college student honestly. All I do is go to school, work, and home. No life at all.

PS: She MADE me stay here and MAKES me pay rent as well. She has never put in a dime on my college education. I've paid out of pocket or loans.

Any thoughts of my situation?? What would you do?

You're right. She can't make me. But when she threatens to never talk to me again that's honestly what makes me stay. Our relationship really has never been good, but I will still feel guilty by leaving and disappointing her.. Which she takes advantage of.

I want to chime in to say you are using the word "guilt" in the wrong way. Guilt means you've done something wrong. You haven't done anything wrong here.

I'd try to find someone you could room with or if you can afford it, get your own place. Get it all lined up and then just move. You are an adult. You don't owe her anything due to the way she is treating you.

Wow I relate to your situation..In a sense…my parents were never there for me..cops were over our place many times…I have come far from that..I was a little kid that God was watching ME!!!

I now am in a FNP program..don't really speak with my mom..our relationship was like me being the mother and her the daughter..in high school I used to help provide for my needs and hers ! Like clothes, dental bills etc.. anyway…I felt the same guilt as you when I moved to college (which was 2 hrs away) the thing is my mom never really cared….but I felt guilty….that I had left her there (bc my stepdad was abusive) and I was off to my "great life".

Life was hard…I had student loans…and when you don't have help you know how that works….can't buy books until 2nd week of class so you're behind because the loan refund didn't come in..

Now after many years of school lol I feel I have made the right decision! You have to live on your own at some point…right? And you will be a RN…luckily you have the means to do so..

So i would leave if i were you but tell her in a nice mature conversation. I am guessing she won't understand but eventually she will!!!! and ? then? she won't ever talk to you? if that really happens..she is really not a true mom ( I know that is harsh) but ..how will you ever grow and have a family? how will you have your own life? It is not greedy…it is for your own future especially if she is not finically helping you at all? Who do you have to turn to? yourself...

it will be hard but you will get through this! :)

That sucks. Don't get me wrong. She has 100% provided EVERYTHING for my siblings and I by herself, it's just that she is so controlling with me and only me. I am an adult and she doesn't seem to realize it or even care. As long as I'm doing what she wants she's happy. She basically wants me to live my life for her. And honestly if she treated both my sister and I like that it wouldn't be such a big deal to me, but its only me. My sister lives her life how she wants to. No questions asks. I think I should be able to do the same. After all, I'm 21, not 16. It should be the other way around.

I want to chime in to say you are using the word "guilt" in the wrong way. Guilt means you've done something wrong. You haven't done anything wrong here.

I'd try to find someone you could room with or if you can afford it, get your own place. Get it all lined up and then just move. You are an adult. You don't owe her anything due to the way she is treating you.

That's another issue. I had a friend I could have roomed with a year ago. She said no, so my friend moved on and found another roommate. So the only option I have is to move in with 3 other people I don't know.

Specializes in Psychiatry, Community, Nurse Manager, hospice.

Move out. She will get over it, and then you will have a real relationship with her, adult to adult. First she'll have some sort of tantrum/silent treatment though. See that as a vacation. By the time you really start to miss her, the dynamic will have changed drastically. By the way, go you! Getting it done at 21.

Specializes in LTC,Hospice/palliative care,acute care.
That's another issue. I had a friend I could have roomed with a year ago. She said no, so my friend moved on and found another roommate. So the only option I have is to move in with 3 other people I don't know.

Don't build your own road blocks as a way to stop moving forward.It is scary....Do it.Living with three stranders will be fun.It's an opportunity to make three friends.If you don't mesh it will be easier to set boundaries....

Finish school first, you don't want to disrupt that. Then take a deep breath, decide where you want to go, and go. Your mother's right to dictate your life with authority ended the day you turned 18. She can still be running your life when you are 48 if you let her. Or you can take control on some date after you finish school. Good luck.

Finish school first, you don't want to disrupt that. Then take a deep breath, decide where you want to go, and go. Your mother's right to dictate your life with authority ended the day you turned 18. She can still be running your life when you are 48 if you let her. Or you can take control on some date after you finish school. Good luck.

I thought that at first as well - but she has 2 semesters to go.

If you could set boundaries with your mom and she would abide by them, then that might work. But two more semesters is a long time.

Would your mom go to a family counselor with you? You could delineate boundaries there and a 3rd party would help. I somehow doubt she would go though.

Specializes in M/S, LTC, Corrections, PDN & drug rehab.

I use to have a terrible relationship with my father. It got to the point where I cut him out of my life for awhile. But now that I'm an adult, married & everything we have a great relationship. :)

If I were you, I would get my own place & job after graduation. Leave a note & not look back. If she really is that terrible then you don't need her in your life.

My paternal grandmother said & did some pretty nasty things, so I cut her out of my life. Just because they are family, doesn't mean they have to be in our lives.

If you truly have the financial means to move out then I would. I don't know what part of the country you live in or how much you are currently paying your mother to live at home, but the cost of moving out on one's own for the first time is often a lot more than originally anticipated. Once you've looked into all the costs involved (deposits for rent, utilities, insurance, food, minimal furniture, etc) and you can comfortably afford it and not let it jeopardize your finishing your degree and getting your license then I would move out. This situation is unhealthy and it looks like she may have an issue with letting go but I doubt she would never speak to you again. She may give you the silent treatment for a little while until she cools off but you cannot stay living at home forever (that's not healthy either). You're still her (adult)child and she'll come around eventually. My parents and I butt heads constantly when I had just graduated high school and starting college (a lot of you live under my roof you obey my rules, still feeling like a teenager asking permission to do anything outside of the home). When I was able to I moved out and my relationship with them couldn't be better. Sometimes parents do a better job parenting from a distance with their adult children, and sometimes we are more accepting of their advise when that's exactly all it is, advise, not an order.

I hope everything works out for you, most of the time things have a way of doing so.

Specializes in Cardiac Stepdown, PCU.

I advise moving. No sooner than you graduate and immediately. Consider this. You are PAYING to live in this situation. You are allowing someone else to have complete control over your life. I understand it might be hard, and painful... but you should never allow someone, parent or otherwise, to treat you are anything less than what you deserve. And no one deserves this. You actually, and sadly, sound more bitter towards your sister in your post than you do your mother, when it's she who should be the focus of that bitterness.

I am at a point where I want to wait ... 2 semesters is long but then again it's not. I've spent all this time here and dealt with everything and nearly at the finish line. In a way I feel like me moving out will disrupt my schooling simply because I'm use to being at home at moving out will be a big change and adjustment for me. But then again I'm also at a point where I feel like I can't continue living like this.

As for my financial situation, I'm working full time now and have about $1200 saved up, but I don't have a set job for my next 2 semesters so it can be very unpredictable. $1200 can only take me so far without a job. I would have to work more than I do now due to the extra expenses and unexpected costs of living on my own, or take out more loans (which I don't want to do). If I had a choice I would definitely tough it out but then again it's like when does this end?? Because it will go on as long as I let it ... and quite frankly as long as I'm living here I will let it because I can't give my mom boundaries and rules in her own house.

So to sum it up I feel like waiting until after graduation will be the smarter decision to make, but I also think moving now could be much healthier for me emotionally..but my schooling could be affected by that. I don't know. I'm confused. It's kind of a sticky situation. Pros and cons for both.

Specializes in Geriatrics, Dialysis.

OK...you are 21, that makes you an adult. You are already paying rent to your landlord/mother so you must have the financial means to pay rent. So, if you want to move, move.

ps please stop worrying about the "favorite child" it makes no difference in your life and just makes you sound like the jealous sibling.

+ Add a Comment