Case Study: My Stomach Hurts

It's late in the day on a beautiful Saturday in late summer. You are finishing up your shift at a local urgent care clinic when a 28-year-old, white male comes in complaining of diffuse abdominal pain. You bring him back to the examination room to assess his condition. 

Updated:  

Diffuse Abdominal Pain

"Mr. Halpert, what seems to be the problem today?” you ask as you scroll through his unremarkable medical history on your tablet. On paper he looks completely healthy. His heart rate is slightly elevated -- probably due to the pain --but all of his other vital signs are within normal range. He looks pale and slightly diaphoretic.

His face is tight with pain as he says, "Please, call me Jim.” He groans and continues through a grimace, "Sorry about this. This is really embarrassing. I've been having pain for a few days. I thought it was just a bad burrito or something. I don't normally come to places like this, but the pain seems to be getting worse.”

Abdominal pain is the most common cause for hospital admission in the US. It represents a wide spectrum of conditions from food poisoning to appendicitis. Jim's pain could be caused by something as mild as emotional upset over his annoying coworkers, or it could be as serious as a perforation of the gut that needs immediate emergency surgery. You've got plans for a barbecue right after work, and in fact, your friends have already started without you. They've been texting you to get moving and join the fun. The last thing you want this evening is a prolonged session with a patient. You know from experience that an efficient assessment is the key to clocking out on time. What questions could you ask to get to the root of the problem as quickly as possible?

The Root Of The Problem

I'll bet you're thinking of one question, in particular, ...one that makes you want your pathophysiology textbook. There's a picture in there that will help. You know the one...it's an image of a torso with a tic-tac-toe board drawn over it. Each quadrant has a list of possible problems related to...LOCATION!

Regions of the Abdomen

Before you click on either of the references below for help solving this problem, take out a sheet of paper and see how many possible problems you can list (no peeking!)

A Thorough Pain Assessment

You feel Jim's forehead with the back of your hand, even though you've already taken his temperature. It's cool to the touch. "Where, exactly is the pain?”

Jim says, "In the middle, right here" and clutches his abdomen right above the umbilicus.

"It's up above your belly button?” You ask and he nods in affirmation. "Not down below.” You point to your own belly, circling the area below your umbilicus. He shakes his head back and forth. "Is it worse on either side?” You point to your right and left abdomen as you ask the question.

"Maybe just a little bit worse on the left, but I'm not really sure.” He lightly pats his stomach with his left hand right below his breast bone.

"On a scale of 0-10, with 10 being the worst pain you've ever had and 0 being no pain, what is your pain right now?”

Jim thinks for a moment and then says, "I broke my leg playing football in college, and it's nowhere near that bad. I guess it's around a five or a six?”

You feel a sense of relief that his pain isn't severe. You know that in mildly ill patients watchful waiting and diagnostic evaluation is often the best approach.

The Options

Here's a list of the more common reasons for diffuse abdominal pain (we're going to look at these first...though it is possible he could have typhoid fever, it's not very likely!)

  • Pancreatitis
  • Gall stones/Cholelithiasis
  • Gastroenteritis
  • Peritonitis
  • Gastritis
  • Peptic ulcer

What else do you need to know to narrow this down? Make a list of questions you'd like to ask Jim.

History Lesson

I'm hoping your list of questions looks something like this:

  • Pain: location (check!), severity (check!), radiation, movement, onset, duration, severity, quality, exacerbating and remitting factors.
  • Associated symptoms: fever, anorexia, vomiting, syncope, GI blood loss
  • Medications: NSAIDs, prednisone, anticoagulants
  • Psychosocial: Drug and alcohol use, prolonged stress

Jim asks, "What do you think is wrong with me? Could it be food poisoning?”

You respond, "That depends. Let me ask you a few questions to help me narrow down what it might be. First off, does the pain radiate at all?” Jim shakes his head back and forth. You continue, "Does it get worse with movement?”

Jim replies, "No, not at all. It comes and goes. There's nothing that really seems to make it worse... or better for that matter.”

You continue, "You said it started a few days ago? Is the onset of the pain linked to anything you were doing?”

Jim pauses to think for a moment, "I can't think of anything. I guess I mentioned I went out for Mexican food with some friends.”

You ask, "Did any of them get sick?” He shakes his head no. "Have you had any vomiting or diarrhea?”

"Yeah, a little diarrhea, but I haven't thrown up. I do feel a little sick to my stomach occasionally. I guess that means it's not food poisoning, huh...It's weird...I haven't wanted to eat at all. Every time I try to eat something, I feel full right away. I guess that's why I thought it was something I ate.”

You add, "Food poisoning usually comes on pretty quickly with some fairly unpleasant side effects, but we're not ruling anything out yet. Have you noticed any blood in your stool?”

Jim turns slightly red and says, "No, I mean, not that I've noticed.”

You ask, "Have you ever had anything like this happen before?” He shakes his head back and forth. You continue, "Try to describe the pain for me. What is it like?”

Jim replies, "It's horrible!...but I don't think that's what you mean...”

You give a sympathetic smile and say, "Is there any cramping? Is the pain sharp, or more like a dull ache, does it come in waves?”

Jim responds, "No, there's no cramping, no waves. My stomach is tender though if I press on it, it hurts. I guess the best way to describe it is kind of a gnawing or burning pain, if that makes any sense? And it comes and goes...and I have lots of indigestion like I said...no appetite and feeling nauseated. I'm just so tired…”

You look up from typing in Jim's symptoms to ask, "Tired of being in pain?”

Jim answers, "Yes that, but also just tired all over. All I want to do is sleep, but I can't because of my stomach.”

You nod and pick up the tablet, "I hear you, it's hard to be in pain for a few days. It's good that you came in. I'm going to have the physician come in here in a sec, and she's going to do a more thorough exam. I just have one final question.”

What Is It?

There's one question that will really seal the deal here. What's one thing from this patient's history that might give you a big clue to what is causing his abdominal pain and get you out of work on time?

Stay tuned for the exciting conclusion! I'll post the final puzzle piece of Jim's history, and give you some diagnostic clues as well. Feel free to ask questions and make comments below.

Specializes in Education, Informatics, Patient Safety.
47 minutes ago, BlueShoes12 said:

When will the diagnosis be posted? It's been a couple of weeks. (I did submit a serious answer way back when).

With the new info, I'm going suggest checking at least an H&H, if not a CBC and a 30-day prescription for Protonix, as well as no more NSAIDs... if the H&H is low may have to consider requesting an EGD.

Is it OK to put the info above on this thread since it doesn't contain an actual suggested diagnosis? If not, let me know and I'll remove it.

Thanks for your patience with this, we are trying out a new format, next time I’ll post a lot more quickly so you won’t have to wait so long. In a couple days I’ll post the actual diagnosis!

Specializes in ICU/Management/Holistic Health.
On 9/2/2019 at 12:15 AM, ZEBRA57 said:

Need abdominal scan. Most likely an ulcer possibly advanced stage. Or a precursor gastritis.

Full disclosure: In March this year a dear friend 58 yrs old died with these symptoms in his sleep from a gastric hemorrhage. He was a professor im a small town.... small local emergency dept. This was the coroner 's report. 3weeks earlier he had been seen in the ER. First they thought it was heart; sent to CCU. Then dx. pancreatitis, but sent him home without hydration; observation or scan nor extensive blood work. They had thought about a scan but sent him home to "rest". Then told him he didn't need the scan. We lived far away and couldn't get him to come into the city. No one thought of the ulcer. He had never disclosed clues. So tragic & unnecessary death.

Specializes in Education, Informatics, Patient Safety.
1 hour ago, ZEBRA57 said:

Full disclosure: In March this year a dear friend 58 yrs old died with these symptoms in his sleep from a gastric hemorrhage. He was a professor im a small town.... small local emergency dept. This was the coroner 's report. 3weeks earlier he had been seen in the ER. First they thought it was heart; sent to CCU. Then dx. pancreatitis, but sent him home without hydration; observation or scan nor extensive blood work. They had thought about a scan but sent him home to "rest". Then told him he didn't need the scan. We lived far away and couldn't get him to come into the city. No one thought of the ulcer. He had never disclosed clues. So tragic & unnecessary death.

So frustrating- it sounds like a stool guaiac might have been an inexpensive way to determine bleeding - I’m so sorry that happened. Thank you for sharing.

Specializes in ICU/Management/Holistic Health.
1 hour ago, SafetyNurse1968 said:

So frustrating- it sounds like a stool guaiac might have been an inexpensive way to determine bleeding - I’m so sorry that happened. Thank you for sharing.

Thank you..... yes, such a simple test. Also an alert for seniors, where MD's stop routine colonoscopies & even hesitate to do the stool guaiac in patients over 75. This is ridiculous and I have first hand experience of seniors having to demand such screening when it is the MD who should be encouraging screening.

21 minutes ago, ZEBRA57 said:

This is ridiculous and I have first hand experience of seniors having to demand such screening when it is the MD who should be encouraging screening.

USPSTF recommendations.

Specializes in ICU/Management/Holistic Health.
1 hour ago, JKL33 said:

USPSTF recommendations.

ZEBRA57 has 40 years experience and specializes in ICU/Management/Holistic Health.

MED-SURG ICU/CVT/CCU/ER, HEAD NURSE(surgical unit); HOLISTIC HEALTH Practice (SHIATSU; stress management, nutritional counselling, etc. in private practice). Most recently, 12 years in AMBULATORY DAY CLINICS (lived 3 years in Tokyo & 7 years in Singapore & 5 years USA)

Specializes in Education, Informatics, Patient Safety.

FINALLY - THE ANSWER!

Here is a list of common diagnostic tests for each of the causes of epigastric pain that we’ve been discussing:

  • Food poisoning: blood tests, stool culture
  • Gallstones: abdominal or endoscopic ultrasound, CT, CBC for infection
  • Gastritis: test for H. pylori, endoscopy, X-ray with barium swallow, RBC count for anemia, fecal occult blood test
  • Gastroenteritis: rapid stool test for rotavirus or norovirus
  • Pancreatitis: blood tests for elevated pancreatic enzymes, stool tests for fat levels, CT for gallstones and pancreatic inflammation, abdominal ultrasound, MRI
  • Peptic Ulcer: same as with gastritis
  • Peritonitis: blood tests for elevated WBC, blood culture for bacteria, X-ray for perforations, ultrasound, CT, peritoneal fluid analysis

Your recommendation to the Physician is conservative – check the stool for occult blood and do a CBC with H&H to rule out infection or bleeding. Based upon your fantastic SBAR, the physician orders what you’ve recommended and the following results come back:

Guiac of stool: negative for occult blood

CBC: WNL

DID YOU GUESS CORRECTLY?

You breathe a sigh of relief that Jim doesn’t appear to be bleeding internally and text your friends that you’ll be on the road to the barbecue in a few minutes. You tell Jim he’s most likely got gastritis or an ulcer from taking too much Motrin (200 mg of the NSAID ibuprofen, plus 38 mg diphenhydramine citrate) and explain that the diphenhydramine may be what’s making him so sleepy!

You go over the difference between Gastritis and peptic ulcer, explaining that gastritis is inflammation of the lining of the stomach, whereas an ulcer is a break in the lining of the stomach. You tell him he’s going to need to stop taking Motrin for his pain and that if he switches back to Tylenol, his stomach will likely heal on its own. You do some teaching about the importance of following directions for all medications. Jim goes home with a prescription for Zantac, and you explain that taking an acid blocker like ranitidine (Zantac) will reduce acid in his stomach and relieve the inflammation over time. You mention that he can continue to take antacids like Tums and that he may also try a proton pump inhibitor like omeprazole (Prilosec) if the Zantac and antacids don’t do the trick.

KEEP AN EYE ON YOUR STOOL

You also tell Jim to keep an eye on his symptoms and to call if things don’t improve in a few days. Though there is no indication that Jim is having internal bleeding, it’s possible it may develop, and you teach him signs and symptoms to look out for including feeling light-headed or dizzy, severe headache, dark brown or black stool and general weakness.

EXCEPTIONS

I hope you enjoyed my first case study with the understanding that this is just for fun. I’m sure I’ve missed things and made mistakes you will surely point out to me! I try to keep in mind that diseases present very differently depending on a person’s genetic make-up and general health. Signs and symptoms don’t always correlate with what you find on the internet, so your best approach is to always see a certified healthcare professional if you are worried about your stomachache.

REFERENCES

Braun, C. A. & Anderson, C. M. (2017). Applied pathophysiology: A conceptual approach to the mechanisms of disease (3rd ed). Philadelphia, PA: Wolters Kluwer.

Cartwright, S. & Knudson, M. (2008). Evaluation of Acute Abdominal Pain in Adults. American Family Physician. Retrieved from https://www.aafp.org/afp/2008/0401/p971.html

Ansari, P. Acute Abdominal Pain. (2018). Merck Manual Professional Version. Retrieved from https://www.merckmanuals.com/professional/gastrointestinal-disorders/acute-abdomen-and-surgical-gastroenterology/acute-abdominal-pain

On 8/29/2019 at 1:09 PM, SafetyNurse1968 said:

juviasama, thank you for reading and commenting! Why do you think you were misdiagnosed? I'm glad you are on the mend - having a healthcare provider who will listen is crucial.

Honestly, I have no idea either! Probably because when I reached the ER, I was already feeling better-- the pain wasn't as excruciating as before I reached the ER. So the doctor discharged me, thinking that I shouldn't be in the ER for gastric acid reflux. The next doctor thought it was just peptic ulcer and prescribed me with PPI medication. I took the meds for 5 days, but something was still wrong. I still had fever and I still felt nauseous almost all the time that I didn't have appetite at all. So I went to another urgent care and after an NP examined me, she told me to go to the ER soon because she's suspecting a gallbladder infection at that time, which eventually turned out to be appendicitis. But I am glad that she believed it was emergency because the other two doctors didn't think it was an emergency situation which made my husband thinking that I was exaggerating my abdominal pain ?

9 minutes ago, juviasama said:

But I am glad that she believed it was emergency because the other two doctors didn't think it was an emergency situation which made my husband thinking that I was exaggerating my abdominal pain

Illnesses evolve over time and being the one to have a crack at it when symptoms are present and have been evolving for 5 days despite reasonable treatment is very different than examining someone early in the course of an illness who says it is significantly better by the time they are being examined and does not have any kind of toxic/ill presentation. That's why it is pretty standard to advise patients to return if worsening and to follow up with their PCPs.

I'm glad you are better now. ?

On 9/28/2019 at 5:43 PM, JKL33 said:

Illnesses evolve over time and being the one to have a crack at it when symptoms are present and have been evolving for 5 days despite reasonable treatment is very different than examining someone early in the course of an illness who says it is significantly better by the time they are being examined and does not have any kind of toxic/ill presentation. That's why it is pretty standard to advise patients to return if worsening and to follow up with their PCPs.

I'm glad you are better now. ?

Hmm it makes sense that you mentioned this. My husband was upset in the beginning. He believed my appendix had been ruptured since my first visit to the ER and it was untreated for one week. Only by the grace of God that I am still alive ?

Here are the responses from members who came to the Admin Help Desk to submit their diagnoses for the 1st Case Study Investigation (CSI).

CONGRATULATIONS and THUMBS UP to those with the correct diagnosis!

Thank you to all who participated. We hope you enjoyed the CSI.

Be on the look out for the next CSI installment coming very soon!


8/29/19

@debrasimons

Quote

? I think the next question to ask is if the pain is typically worse a few hours after a meal. After the stomach is emptied.

That might point to a peptic ulcer.

@BlueShoes12

Quote

? This is a reply to the case study: My Stomach Hurts! 

I'm guessing that it's peptic ulcer disease based on the early satiety, burning pain, indigestion and nausea. Maybe a bleeding ulcer with the fatigue, paleness and tachycardia.
I'd ask him if the pain is worse when his stomach is empty or he hasn't eaten. Curious to see what the final answer is!

8/30/19

@myfavoritequine

Quote

Thinking aortic aneurysm, because he said it is a burning and gnawing pain. I would have asked him to describe more in detail the "gnawing" pain and try to rule out an AA. 

update: 8/31/19

Ok, so I am now hoping this poor fellow doesn't have stomach cancer?! 

@UMBANAT5

Quote

My answer to the case study Re: My stomach hurts

I am no ER nurse but I will give it a try. The question the nurse would ask is  if Jim is on any medications and if  he took any meds. to relieve the pain? 

Thanks

8/31/19

@RNTadaaaa

Quote

Whipple disease? 

@JKL33

Quote

? PUD possibly complicated w bleeding, vs. basic acute gastritis. 

@Nursing Educator

Quote

Interesting case study.  I would want to ask about what he had to drink with the Mexican food.  Does he consume alcohol frequently?  Possibly a case of pancreatitis?

Thanks, it will be interesting to see the answer.

@RAM

Quote

Case study answer 

gastroenteritis

@DowntheRiver

Quote

? Peptic ulcer/H. Pylori 

 

@Bwolfe1

Quote

Sounds like diverticulitis, even though that wasn’t one of the options in the list

@bmelissa

Quote

I would want to know if he’s loss any weight recently without trying? Or gained weight? I’m thinking with Early satiety and fatigue if there a mass somewhere. 

September 1st

@NurseJamillah

Quote

? Peptic ulcer

@Barbeq

Quote

Abdominal pain case article:

Does your pain feel like it’s going through to your back?

September 4th

@LadyT618

Quote

? I'm submitting my guess for the CSI case. Depending on the proximity of the patient's dining experience to the onset of symptoms (one of the questions recommended by another poster), my guess at this point is either peptic or duodenal ulcer.

September 14th

@Pixie.RN

Quote

? Peptic ulcer disease. Probably needs a CBC, hemoccult, maybe a scope if hgb low and heme +. 

Does he have any bleeding in stool? Does he take blood thinners? Positive guaic? I would be concerned of a possible bleeding ulcer because of his elevated heart rate, pallor, and diaphoresis