Case Study: My Stomach Hurts

It's late in the day on a beautiful Saturday in late summer. You are finishing up your shift at a local urgent care clinic when a 28-year-old, white male comes in complaining of diffuse abdominal pain. You bring him back to the examination room to assess his condition. 

Updated:  

Diffuse Abdominal Pain

"Mr. Halpert, what seems to be the problem today?” you ask as you scroll through his unremarkable medical history on your tablet. On paper he looks completely healthy. His heart rate is slightly elevated -- probably due to the pain --but all of his other vital signs are within normal range. He looks pale and slightly diaphoretic.

His face is tight with pain as he says, "Please, call me Jim.” He groans and continues through a grimace, "Sorry about this. This is really embarrassing. I've been having pain for a few days. I thought it was just a bad burrito or something. I don't normally come to places like this, but the pain seems to be getting worse.”

Abdominal pain is the most common cause for hospital admission in the US. It represents a wide spectrum of conditions from food poisoning to appendicitis. Jim's pain could be caused by something as mild as emotional upset over his annoying coworkers, or it could be as serious as a perforation of the gut that needs immediate emergency surgery. You've got plans for a barbecue right after work, and in fact, your friends have already started without you. They've been texting you to get moving and join the fun. The last thing you want this evening is a prolonged session with a patient. You know from experience that an efficient assessment is the key to clocking out on time. What questions could you ask to get to the root of the problem as quickly as possible?

The Root Of The Problem

I'll bet you're thinking of one question, in particular, ...one that makes you want your pathophysiology textbook. There's a picture in there that will help. You know the one...it's an image of a torso with a tic-tac-toe board drawn over it. Each quadrant has a list of possible problems related to...LOCATION!

Regions of the Abdomen

Before you click on either of the references below for help solving this problem, take out a sheet of paper and see how many possible problems you can list (no peeking!)

A Thorough Pain Assessment

You feel Jim's forehead with the back of your hand, even though you've already taken his temperature. It's cool to the touch. "Where, exactly is the pain?”

Jim says, "In the middle, right here" and clutches his abdomen right above the umbilicus.

"It's up above your belly button?” You ask and he nods in affirmation. "Not down below.” You point to your own belly, circling the area below your umbilicus. He shakes his head back and forth. "Is it worse on either side?” You point to your right and left abdomen as you ask the question.

"Maybe just a little bit worse on the left, but I'm not really sure.” He lightly pats his stomach with his left hand right below his breast bone.

"On a scale of 0-10, with 10 being the worst pain you've ever had and 0 being no pain, what is your pain right now?”

Jim thinks for a moment and then says, "I broke my leg playing football in college, and it's nowhere near that bad. I guess it's around a five or a six?”

You feel a sense of relief that his pain isn't severe. You know that in mildly ill patients watchful waiting and diagnostic evaluation is often the best approach.

The Options

Here's a list of the more common reasons for diffuse abdominal pain (we're going to look at these first...though it is possible he could have typhoid fever, it's not very likely!)

  • Pancreatitis
  • Gall stones/Cholelithiasis
  • Gastroenteritis
  • Peritonitis
  • Gastritis
  • Peptic ulcer

What else do you need to know to narrow this down? Make a list of questions you'd like to ask Jim.

History Lesson

I'm hoping your list of questions looks something like this:

  • Pain: location (check!), severity (check!), radiation, movement, onset, duration, severity, quality, exacerbating and remitting factors.
  • Associated symptoms: fever, anorexia, vomiting, syncope, GI blood loss
  • Medications: NSAIDs, prednisone, anticoagulants
  • Psychosocial: Drug and alcohol use, prolonged stress

Jim asks, "What do you think is wrong with me? Could it be food poisoning?”

You respond, "That depends. Let me ask you a few questions to help me narrow down what it might be. First off, does the pain radiate at all?” Jim shakes his head back and forth. You continue, "Does it get worse with movement?”

Jim replies, "No, not at all. It comes and goes. There's nothing that really seems to make it worse... or better for that matter.”

You continue, "You said it started a few days ago? Is the onset of the pain linked to anything you were doing?”

Jim pauses to think for a moment, "I can't think of anything. I guess I mentioned I went out for Mexican food with some friends.”

You ask, "Did any of them get sick?” He shakes his head no. "Have you had any vomiting or diarrhea?”

"Yeah, a little diarrhea, but I haven't thrown up. I do feel a little sick to my stomach occasionally. I guess that means it's not food poisoning, huh...It's weird...I haven't wanted to eat at all. Every time I try to eat something, I feel full right away. I guess that's why I thought it was something I ate.”

You add, "Food poisoning usually comes on pretty quickly with some fairly unpleasant side effects, but we're not ruling anything out yet. Have you noticed any blood in your stool?”

Jim turns slightly red and says, "No, I mean, not that I've noticed.”

You ask, "Have you ever had anything like this happen before?” He shakes his head back and forth. You continue, "Try to describe the pain for me. What is it like?”

Jim replies, "It's horrible!...but I don't think that's what you mean...”

You give a sympathetic smile and say, "Is there any cramping? Is the pain sharp, or more like a dull ache, does it come in waves?”

Jim responds, "No, there's no cramping, no waves. My stomach is tender though if I press on it, it hurts. I guess the best way to describe it is kind of a gnawing or burning pain, if that makes any sense? And it comes and goes...and I have lots of indigestion like I said...no appetite and feeling nauseated. I'm just so tired…”

You look up from typing in Jim's symptoms to ask, "Tired of being in pain?”

Jim answers, "Yes that, but also just tired all over. All I want to do is sleep, but I can't because of my stomach.”

You nod and pick up the tablet, "I hear you, it's hard to be in pain for a few days. It's good that you came in. I'm going to have the physician come in here in a sec, and she's going to do a more thorough exam. I just have one final question.”

What Is It?

There's one question that will really seal the deal here. What's one thing from this patient's history that might give you a big clue to what is causing his abdominal pain and get you out of work on time?

Stay tuned for the exciting conclusion! I'll post the final puzzle piece of Jim's history, and give you some diagnostic clues as well. Feel free to ask questions and make comments below.

Specializes in ICU/Management/Holistic Health.

Need abdominal scan. Most likely an ulcer possibly advanced stage. Or a precursor gastritis.

Specializes in Education, Informatics, Patient Safety.
On 8/31/2019 at 1:00 PM, JanetCR123 said:

? pt/ptt, inr

Episode 2 will have all that info! Stay tuned ? Be sure to post your guesses in the admin link as directed in the article.

Specializes in Occupational Health.

Can you tell me when the answer will be posted?

Specializes in Home Health, Primary Care.
On 8/30/2019 at 4:57 PM, JKL33 said:

This is only straightforward enough to require one more question to seal the deal if you already know the answer.

So I'll start w/ these:

1. Vital signs. T, P, R, B/P

2. Reported hx of fever/chills

3. Tobacco, EtOH and other substance use

4. Medications - regular or recent use

5. General social/sexual/living hx including possibility of sick contacts and recent travel

6. Other known recent illnesses that may or may not have required medical attention

7. Proximity of dining experience to onset of sx

8. Number and description of stools

9. Abdominal exam findings

10. CBC

I like question #7. This sounds like it's gonna be fun ?

Specializes in Education, Informatics, Patient Safety.
On 9/4/2019 at 1:21 PM, Ckcsky said:

Can you tell me when the answer will be posted?

Soon! I'm getting it ready for publication right now! Thank you so much for reading!

Specializes in Occupational Health.

I’m looking for the answer - has it been posted?

Specializes in Education, Informatics, Patient Safety.

Are you ready for some more data?

Let’s do an SBAR (remember Situation, Background, Assessment, Recommendation?)

THE SITUATION

Mr. Jim Halpert, a 28-yr-old white male complaining of diffuse abdominal pain. You’re working him up to see the physician. This is your last patient of the day and you’d like to get him out of here. Your focus is on ruling out anything life threatening and getting him the care he needs to feel better.

BACKGROUND

You’ve asked a lot of good questions, done an assessment and taken vital signs.

ASSESSMENT

  • Unremarkable medical history per patient
  • Vital signs: HR 92, BP 125/72, RR 18, Temp 98.4, Pulse ox 99%, BMI 22
  • Pale, diaphoretic, face appears tense, patient groaning with pain
  • Pain: 5-6 on pain scale, first time occurrence, increasing over 3 days, Epigastric, possibly worse on left, no radiation, not worse with movement, abdomen tender to touch, gnawing, burning pain
  • GI: diarrhea, nausea, no vomiting, anorexia, indigestion and feeling of fullness after eating, pt. states no blood in stool
  • General fatigue
  • Rule out food poisoning, patient states he might have east a bad burrito 3 days ago

Before we get to a recommendation, I hope you’ve reviewed some of the possible causes for Jim’s pain (check the references for ideas). Epigastric/left sided abdominal pain could be many things, but let’s examine the symptoms some of the more common ones:

  • Food Poisoning: N/V, watery or bloody diarrhea, abdominal pain and cramps, fever beginning with hours after eating contaminated food, or days or even weeks later and lasting from a few hours to several days.
  • Gallstones/Cholelithiasis: most common in overweight, middle-aged women, often asymptomatic, pain in upper right side comes and goes, within 30 minutes after a fatty or greasy meal, severe, dull, constant lasting from 1-5 hours, may radiate to should or back, frequently at night, N/V, fever, indigestion, jaundice
  • Gastritis: irritation of the lining of the stomach due to excessive alcohol use, chronic vomiting, stress or the use of aspirin or NSAIDS, H. Pylori infection, bile reflux, infections. N/V, recurrent upset stomach, abdominal pain and bloating, indigestion, burning or gnawing feeling in stomach between meals or at night, hiccups, loss of appetite, vomiting blood or black tarry stools (occult blood), can be asymptomatic
  • Gastroenteritis (stomach flu): watery, nonbloody diarrhea, abdominal pain and cramps, N/V, muscle aches or HA, low-grade fever appearing within 1-3 days of infection, symptoms last 1-2 days, occasionally persisting up to 10 days
  • Pancreatitis: More common in those with gallstones or heavy drinkers, typical in men between 30-40 yrs old, pain radiates to the back, aggravated by eating, fever, swollen tender abdomen, N/V, increased HR
  • Peptic ulcer: Most commonly caused by infection with H. pylori, long term use of aspirin and NSAIDS (Advil, Aleve etc…) Stress and spicy food do not cause ulcers but can make them worse. Burning stomach pain, feeling of fullness, bloating or belching, fatty food intolerance, heartburn, Nausea. ¾ of those with peptic ulcers are asymptomatic.
  • Peritonitis: Related to a rupture, can be caused by medical procedures, ruptured appendix, stomach ulcer, perforated colon, any of the other “itises” or trauma. Can develop with advanced cirrhosis of the liver. Abdominal pain or tenderness, bloating or a feeling of fullness, fever, N/V, Loss of appetite, diarrhea, low urine output, thirst, inability to pass stool or gas, fatigue. Life threatening if left untreated.

In part 1 I suggested there’s a good question to ask that we haven’t covered yet that might narrow it down. What are we missing?

MORE QUESTIONS

You ask Jim, “I forgot to ask you about hydration. Are you getting enough fluids? Diarrhea can cause dehydration fairly quickly.”

Jim thinks for a moment and then says, “Yeah, I guess. I drink a lot of water.”

“How about your urine. What color is it?”

Jim wrinkles his nose (this guy sure makes a lot of faces) and says, “The usual color, a light yellow I guess.”

“That’s good to hear, one sign of dehydration is dark yellow urine. Also, I want to clarify – you said you get full when you try to eat. Does eating cause indigestion? Does eating increase the pain?”

Jim says, “All I’ve been able to get down are saltines, but no, they don’t upset my stomach or cause the pain to get worse. I’m just not hungry. The indigestion comes on after the Rolaids wear off.”

You raise your eyebrows and look at Jim’s health history, “You said that you don’t take any medications. That’s pretty unusual, actually. You’ve been taking Rolaids, which are an antacid for the stomach pain and that has helped?”

Jim frowns and says, “Oh wow, I didn’t know you meant stuff I just take every once in a while. I thought you meant like, prescription drugs. Yeah, I’ve been taking Rolaids, Tums, eating them like candy in fact.” He turns pink and then says, “They help, but then they wear off and the pain is worse when it comes back.”

“Do you take any other medications just every once in a while?

“Oh sure, like when I’m sick and stuff. I take Tylenol and ibuprofen. I pulled a muscle playing soccer a few weeks ago and I’ve been taking stuff for that.”

You wonder what other meds he’s been eating like candy. “Do you remember what all you’ve been taking?”

Jim gives a goofy grin and says sheepishly, “I ran out of Tylenol and kept forgetting to go get more, so I borrowed my coworker, Pam’s Motrin PM.”

You inwardly roll your eyes – maybe that’s why he’s been so tired? You keep a good nurse-game face as you ask, “How many have you been taking and how often?”

Jim looks at you closely, as if he can sense you’re on to something. He says with a look of chagrin, “Um, well…I’m not really sure. I just take them whenever I’m hurting. I just shake a few out and…” He trails off as your game face fails.

RECOMMENDATION

Do you have enough information now to make a good SBAR for the physician? What tests would you like the physician to order? Is Jim in danger or will you be able to send him home with a prescription and orders to stop taking Motrin? Just remember, the director of the acute care clinic doesn’t like spending a lot of money on extraneous tests. What could you ask for that would give you a good idea of a diagnosis?

Additional reference: image.png.6ed81ca65dea26415052c43d6f477ecc.png

REMEMBER: If you think you know the answer to the question or know the patient problem/diagnosis …

Please start a thread in the Admin Help Desk and post your guess there. Only the Site Admins can see your responses. We don't want to spoil it for others who are late in joining us. We want to see how many great CSIs (Case Study Investigators) we have among us. After the diagnosis is posted, Admins will announce the names of those who correctly identified the problem. We hope to turn this into a friendly competition with more Case Studies to come.

STAY TUNED......

Good Luck!

Specializes in EMS, ED, Trauma, CEN, CPEN, TCRN.
4 hours ago, SafetyNurse1968 said:

Mr. Jim Halpert, a 28-yr-old white male complaining of diffuse abdominal pain.

Poisoned by Dwight.

Specializes in EMS, ED, Trauma, CEN, CPEN, TCRN.

I really did submit a serious answer, though. Lol

I did too, but I thought the patient was tachycardic, and I didn't think to ask him about the color of his urine.

Specializes in EMS, ED, Trauma, CEN, CPEN, TCRN.
1 minute ago, JKL33 said:

I did too, but I thought the patient was tachycardic, and I didn't think to ask him about the color of his urine.

We have had a Hep A outbreak in my area, so I would have asked about IV drug use, sexual activity, and/or if he's eaten at Steak & Shake. ? But the light urine kinda rules that out!

Specializes in PACU, Stepdown, Trauma.

When will the diagnosis be posted? It's been a couple of weeks. (I did submit a serious answer way back when).

With the new info, I'm going suggest checking at least an H&H, if not a CBC and a 30-day prescription for Protonix, as well as no more NSAIDs... if the H&H is low may have to consider requesting an EGD.

Is it OK to put the info above on this thread since it doesn't contain an actual suggested diagnosis? If not, let me know and I'll remove it.