Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

allnurses

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Discussion

Reality Check.

  • Experts

Excuse my grammar and spelling as I write this in the midst of a migraine storm. I am an experienced critical care nurse, and recently I’ve had a reality check.

I’ve wanted to be a provider since I was a child. Being a physician was originally my dream, life however lead me down the avenue of nursing. To make a long story short, ever since I was in nursing school I planned on becoming a nurse practitioner once I gained adequate experience, so seven years later here I am in my second semester of graduate school.

This semester has been a reality check, as I dive into the world of physical assessments, proper documentation, differential diagnoses, and proper clinical reasoning. I’m truly stressed and scared. I’ve always been an anxious person to begin with, I think part of it is because I’m afraid of failing, and well I’m terrified of hurting a patient and I realize the responsibility is tremendous. 
 

As if it wasn’t enough, the negative comments about NPs are rather excessive, particularly from Reddit groups and forums like StudentDoctor, where medical students, resident physicians, and even attending physicians rant and complain about “mid-level” scope creeping. They post horror stories of misdiagnosed aneurysm, peritonitis, and ectopic pregnancies. I’ve even seen one Reddit user that devotes his entire account to creating fictional tales of an NP, he portrays the NP in a satirical and sarcastic manner, magnifying their medical mistakes.

The pressure to succeed and do well is real. Firstly for my future patients, for I wish not to hurt anyone under my care. Secondly, I do not wish to appear as a fraud. I do feel like a fraud, like how in the world am I entrusted with this responsibility? Don’t get me wrong, I will never pretend to know something I do not know! 
 

Lastly, maintaining full time employment whilst going to school. I know plenty of nurses that work FT and do NP school. The thing is that I’m extremely concerned with dedicating as much time as possible into my studies. Full time employment with school is stressing me out. I don’t have a family or anyone to support, so quitting is very tempting. The only thing I’m afraid of losing are my benefits. ☹️

Featured Replies

47 minutes ago, VaniCCRN said:

the negative comments about NPs are rather excessive, particularly from Reddit groups and forums like StudentDoctor, where medical students, resident physicians, and even attending physicians rant and complain about “mid-level” scope creeping.

What were you expecting? In Middle school, you have guys in the locker room making up stories about the girls. This Reddit Forum is the same as the Middle school locker room. The only difference is they don't care if the girls hear them. They are threatened by NPs because you are invading on their turf and they don't like it. 

A few responses I have based on your concerns:

1. I can give plenty of horror stories where an MD made mistakes or missed a diagnosis and the heroic nurses save the day. It goes both ways.

2. Truth be told, being an NP is a major Responsibility. I would be terrified of YOU if you weren't scared of the implications. 

3. Are you doing school full time? If so, maybe do college part time? 

Hi OP - that is why I dropped out of midwifery school one year into it (hi Frontier class 80, if anyone is out there!). I realized my anxiety was too great for the responsibility of being a practitioner. So I switched tracks and went into leadership. Lots of responsibilities, but mostly not the life or death kinds. 

There is nothing wrong with having goals since you were very young. If you go along and find that what you thought you wanted isn't what you want now, you are allowed to pivot to something else. 

People grow and change and get to know themselves better. If you would be happier with a lesser burden of responsibility, maybe it is time to re-evaluate your goals and see what you really want.

Remind the guy making fun of midlevels misdiagnosing pts that a physician must agree with and sign off on the midlevel’s assessment and tx, so the MD missed it also!

6 hours ago, VaniCCRN said:

This semester has been a reality check, as I dive into the world of physical assessments, proper documentation, differential diagnoses, and proper clinical reasoning. I’m truly stressed and scared.

 

6 hours ago, VaniCCRN said:

As if it wasn’t enough, the negative comments about NPs are rather excessive, particularly from Reddit groups and forums like StudentDoctor, where medical students, resident physicians, and even attending physicians rant and complain about “mid-level” scope creeping.

You probably aren't stressed and scared because of SDN or Reddit. Maybe....just maybe....what's a little freakish is the set-up of graduate nursing education for something as serious as the provider role. People love to get defensive about it but it doesn't even pass the smell test and it is going to catch up with us. It's easy to mock because it's easy to mock; That isn't the problem of people who call it out, it's the problem of people who accept and defend it. Just because some people find it stressful to study, raise a family and work full-time (in a different role) all at the same time doesn't mean the preparation is rigorous.

I wouldn't hesitate to reduce work hours and every other responsibility as much as possible in order to commit time to studying if you decide to continue on this path.

21 minutes ago, T-Bird78 said:

Remind the guy making fun of midlevels misdiagnosing pts that a physician must agree with and sign off on the midlevel’s assessment and tx, so the MD missed it also!

Not always, not all states require an MD sign off, as NPs have independent practice

1 hour ago, T-Bird78 said:

Remind the guy making fun of midlevels misdiagnosing pts that a physician must agree with and sign off on the midlevel’s assessment and tx, so the MD missed it also!

Not necessarily- depends on the state. In many states, NPs practice independently. There is no physician “sign off”.

  • Experts
9 hours ago, VaniCCRN said:

As if it wasn’t enough, the negative comments about NPs are rather excessive, particularly from Reddit groups and forums like StudentDoctor, where medical students, resident physicians, and even attending physicians rant and complain about “mid-level” scope creeping. They post horror stories of misdiagnosed aneurysm, peritonitis, and ectopic pregnancies. I’ve even seen one Reddit user that devotes his entire account to creating fictional tales of an NP, he portrays the NP in a satirical and sarcastic manner, magnifying their medical mistakes.

This is more reflective of them than any nurse. Can you say, "Projection"? There isn't a physician on the planet who hasn't missed a serious diagnosis: search and sign up for the excellent Med Mal Insights blog online (they also print submissions from nurses!). God knows there's plenty of opportunities to see mocking of med students, residents, and "even attendings" online and on TV/video.

"Mid-level" is a pejorative term. For some reason these folks like PAs better than NPs, even though in many states NPs can practice independently and PAs never can. Well, wups, maybe that's why. YOu don't need to pay any more attention to that, or their opinion, than you do to the jerk who says "Only a nurse, only follows MD orders."

You know more than you think, you will learn more as you practice (just like they do), and you will be more present for your patients than they ever will. That's why you do what you're doing, isn't it? Research shows you'll have higher pt satisfaction, fewer hospital readmits, and lower costs than physicians (and that's the other big threat: follow the money) for the bulk of family practice/PCP case load: COPD, CHF, DM, and the like. Chill out. YOu can do this.

  • Experts

I wouldn't check the Reddit anymore.

Consider going part-time for the time of Master's program. You will most likely have to pay more for health insurance compared to full time, but it's doable.

Best of luck! If being a provider is what you always wanted, with enough determination, you will get there.

8 hours ago, RN-to- BSN said:

I wouldn't check the Reddit anymore.

This. What I can say is that at both the clinic where I work, and the one where I’m a patient, the MDs and the APRNs have a really good working relationship. Both parties understand their roles and the different skills they bring to patient care. Nobody is in a pissing contest about who is better— they are different roles. Reddit is for angry people. If it makes you feel terrible to read it, DON’T. 

  • Guides

I wanted to chime in on a few things here because I think it’s important for you abs your socialization into a new role. 
 

1. I think it is important to acknowledge from the beginning that you are moving from a place where you have developed competency and expertise through years of work experience into a role where you will be starting fresh. Being an expert nurse only qualifies you to be a novice NP. There is no skipping steps, you need to rebuild that competency and expertise with experience in practice. I often see NP students that are experienced RNs putting far too much pressure on themselves to know everything from the start. It’s OK to be a student again and simply learn. There is a mantra of fake-it until-you-make-it in NP school; I make students dump that at the door because it creates stress and it ruins your learning experience in the clinical setting for sure. 

2. We all make mistakes. We all misdiagnose. Some doctors enjoy pointing out when NPs do this but the truth is, if they are in practice, they’ve made the same errors. If they don’t think they have, they not only aren’t good providers they are dangerous ones. Self-reflecting practice is the hallmark of a good provider; it can be anxiety producing for students/novice providers because it means we actively look for our mistakes, but overtime the anxiety goes away and we are left with being able to accept our mistakes and grow from them. Remember there are lots of illnesses that you will come across as a PCP that have an average time-to-diagnosis of 5-10-15 years! 
 

3. Primary care is far too broad to know everything; there isn’t a provider on the planet that knows it all in-depth. I tell patients frequently “ I don’t know”; the art of medicine is being able to create a plan from that! The MOST important thing a PCP can do, and it’s simple, is identify normal from abnormal. If you can do this simple thing (and the longer you practice the less simple it gets) you will have a solid foundation to grow on.

4. I may take some flack here but I am a firm believer that you are making an investment in yourself in a new career; working FT and doing NP student part time is not the ideal way to build a strong foundation. Would you rather see a PCP that  did their education and training as their second priority? On the flip side, would you want an RN taking care of you that was focused on trying to learn something different? It’s a big investment of your money and time, make the most of it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Add a Comment

Currently Reading 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.