"You dont look like a Susan Brown" (long)

Nurses General Nursing

Published

I want to know how other people would react.....Am I over reacting?

Not too long ago, my nursing dept got a new health manager due to the expected retirement of the existing health manager. The nurse who was about to retire has a name that does not sound ethnic, (Please do not blast me) just say its Susan Brown. She stayed on to train the new health manager before officially retiring....

Another nurse and I needed needed to get certified in CPR, and Mrs "Susan" gave me her corporate card to pay for the class. Ok. Here's what really burned my tail. The new manager, told me she was nervous about me using Susan's corporate card, because I dont "look" like a Susan Brown!!!!! I felt my face turn red, and I said....Well, my name is Cynthia Johnson, what do I look like my name is, Maria Gonzales? To explain a little bit more, I am half mexican and half black. I look very ethnic. I was very hurt and furious at the same time. I have never been made to feel like that before. Am I over reacting? Would any body else taken this to be a prejudiced statement?

Well, about a month later....the new nurse manager was suspended for sending a racist email through the company email network. The email was called...."I am white and proud" and was horrible. It stated how unfair it was to have an all black college like spellman or moorehouse, but if white people wanted an all white college, it was considered racist. Or, why was it ok for black gansters to promote violence against white cops, but it was unacceptable for white cops to beat "n----rs! I dont even want to repeat some of what the email said.

The new nurse manager was suspended for three days. We then had to have a meeting with her, to listen to how sorry she was, and that she was not a racist, that she just wanted people to "ponder" some of the ideas in the email. She asked us if we thought she was racist, and that she believed she never acted that way. I told her that she did, when she told me I didnt look like a "Susan Brown". I told her that I have never felt so humiliated, and that she made me "realize" my differences as far as ethnicity goes. I asked her to look at me, and tell me what she saw. Did she see someone who made a 4.0 in nursing school, someone who was named an All State Academic Scholar, or did she see a minority female who didnt "look" like a Susan Brown? She couldnt answer.

Thanks for listening.

people can be so dumb. My niece has a friend who was born and raised in the USA but her parents are from Columbia. They have a latin name. The friend was exempt from taking Spanish in high school because it was assumed she knew the language. WRONG. A friend of mine is from South Africa. She is white, but likes to refer to herself as African-American just to watch reactions. She really is African-American but ---- oh well, the point is beware of stereotyping.

Specializes in Med/Surg, Geriatrics.
mutter mumble she gives the rest of us white folks a bad name grumble grouse....

No she doesn't. Her stupidity is all her own. I would say that she has a short future in nursing but she's a manager already????? So who knows....

No she doesn't. Her stupidity is all her own.

I'm kidding, Sharon.

Specializes in Med-Surg/Tele, ER.

No, you are not overreacting. I think your institution underreacted to your supervisor's obvious racist beliefs. It's clear to me she certainly didn't learn anything from the (miniscule) suspension, as evidenced by her total denial in the meeting with you and your co-workers. I am so sick of this kind of response to racism. It makes me sick.

I'm glad you stood-up to her in the meeting. I wish your institution responded better to this - they're contributing to an already racist system.

Specializes in Staff nurse.

You seem to be the fair-minded and kind person I would like as a co-worker. Sure it hurts to hear such a comment...but remember not everyone thinks like that. AND you were brave enough to say at the meeting how humiliating it was for you (the susan brown comment). And you were professional about it. God bless.

i share my disbelief and repulsion, along with everyone else.

it is also incredulous that she only got a 3-day suspension.

if this were me, i would be documenting every little direct and indirect remark she may happen to make in the future.

she is not to be trusted, ever.

in the event she ever sues the facility, she will definitely play the race card.

i'm sorry you experienced this.

wishing you the best of everything.

leslie

Specializes in Med/Surg, Geriatrics.
I'm kidding, Sharon.

:kiss Okay.

Specializes in ob/gyn med /surg.

cyndi that nurse manager is so insulting.you handled her well.. i cannot believe she had the nerve to send out that email to coworkers or anyone for that matter. is she still working there? i don't know how she could show her face in public. maybe she won't last long now and you will get a new manager soon. she caused alot of hard feeling amongst the staff... and no you weren't over reacting.

Specializes in Cardiac Telemetry, Emergency, SAFE.

Cyndi, I too am sorry that this happened. I know too well how racism affects people (myself included,I am Puertorican), and this is one of the only things that causes an uncontrollable rage in me when I realize how stupid people can still be....

Take care! I would do what a PP suggested and keep a log of any future events....Nothing comes out of us that isnt in us..She obviously still didnt understand she was wrong if she was only trying to share "her point of view" and still denied her true feelings after her suspension...

it is easy to take a look and already judge somebody. some people would meet a person, have a 30 second, hi, how are you kinda chat, and already have a whole system of biased and prejudiced perception forming in their mind. it is sad and wrong.

i am asian, and live in an area, where there is a lot of native american population. i look native: black hair, brown eyes, dark skin. last week at a store i was getting a movie or something....the clerk takes my check card....checks my name ....re-checks it....goes, and gets his supervisor...me: "what is the problem? clerk: "is this your card? me..."um...yes, it is.

clerk, still holding my card away from me, asked me for my id. i produced it. without looking at me, he goes "what tribe?

me: "excuse me?

- i said what tribe

- oh...you mean indian tribe. i am not of native american origin. umm...i am asian. ... why???

- "loudly, to his supervisor" she is not native.

he returns my card. no explanation. nothing. it took me 25 minutes to get a movie i would usually get in 30 seconds. leaving, i overheard his supervisor telling him "yep, always check, if they are native, get id, get tribal id, make sure it's their credit card. those people ....""""

so, just based on the color of my skin, and my hair they made a judgement. i was not wearing dirty clothes, or reeking of alcohol, or acting suspicious, so they would have a reason to think that it is not my card.

i am not against native american clubs...or asian community support centers...or irish american women club....whatever enriches your life - go for it. we just need to realize that this life is great because there is so many different people, who make this life exciting, and interesting, diverse.

Specializes in CCU,ICU,ER retired.

How sad those kind of people are. I have never understood bigotry. My dad was a dixieland Jazz musician and there were many many people in our house having a good time and playing wonderful music. One time when I was aroun 7-8 yrs old I was told that a couple of my friends would not be coming to a slumber party because my dad played the devil's voodoo music and we let black people in our house I didn't understand why until my wonderful dad explained it to me. I have to say I thought it was more sad than angry. I still love to hear my dad play I thought it had always sounded more like God than the devil.

+ Add a Comment