Published
Anyone see the story regarding the school nurse who thought one of the students had a routine stomach virus when the teacher summoned her only to discover the kid was showing signs of a stroke?In interviews she is quoted as saying she thought he was "fixin' to die".Discuss.Me first-color me appalled......
It's so funny that the majority of you disagree.The members of this board have slammed posters for spelling and grammar to the point that they left.And to call me names because I hold a differing opinion just proves your own ignorance.
There's a difference between spelling and grammar errors and local dialect. I also fail to see any posts calling you names.
I did read the story,I also know that terms such as "fixin' to die" "circling the drain" etc.I also know it is "regional".My point is it makes her sound ignorant.We nurses continue to strive to be recognized as professionals.I would th ok no anyone with even a minimum of education would put their best foot forward during an interview and use proper English.I guess it's my issue.
THis comment makes you sound intolerant and prejudiced. People have different lingusitic characteristics depending on where they live. Because something is southern or spoken by mostly poor or minority communities, it doesn't mean the thinking behind the comment is ignorant. YOU are ignorant for not understanding that language is just a symbolic expression of underlying thought. All of our thoughts are the same, our language we use to express that thought may be different and just because it isnt generally accepted by northern, white anglo saxon, English speakers, doesn't make it ignorant. Tuck your prejudice back in, its showing.
I do wish that when an RN is interviewed by a news outlet, he/she would attempt to speak in a polished and professional manner. Don't use slang. Don't give God all the credit. That boy lived because you were highly educated, competent, and professional.I admit I felt the same as the OP when I read the article: 'this is why people think nurses are dumb' 'this will hurt the professional image that we're trying to portray'
I understand that 'fixin to' is perfectly normal verbage in parts of this fine nation. I don't think someone is dumb for using regional dialect.
I think it's dumb to give an interview to a news outlet using regional dialect, especially when you are being identified as an RN.
Regional dialect = how people speak. It's not something you turn on and off for different audiences.
Perhaps if I'm ever interviewed, I'll speak with a British accent so as not to embarrass my fellows.
I did read the story,I also know that terms such as "fixin' to die" "circling the drain" etc.I also know it is "regional".My point is it makes her sound ignorant.We nurses continue to strive to be recognized as professionals.I would th ok no anyone with even a minimum of education would put their best foot forward during an interview and use proper English.
If you're hoping for nurses to be recognized as professionals, how about not denigrating one of your quick-witted, critical-thinking colleagues for using a (perfectly understandable, regional) turn of phrase while recounting how she diagnosed a child's life-threatening condition on her own and saved him. You might as well criticize her crisp white cap for being askew while she called EMS. Heavens.
I guess it's my issue.
Yes.
It's so funny that the majority of you disagree.The members of this board have slammed posters for spelling and grammar to the point that they left.And to call me names because I hold a differing opinion just proves your own ignorance.I stand by my opinion.I would not say to a family member "your dad is circling the drain" or " fixin'to die".I would not report it to a physician,I would not use it publicly especially during an interview.
Let's talk about " cultural awareness".It is a regional colloqialism. No place for it in this context in my opinion.Thanks for yours,no need to call me names.
If you're going to tear people apart, at least have proper grammar, punctuation & syntax. I believe it looks tacky & unintelligent to be posting about how one nurse spoke to a news outlet but you can't put a proper sentence together. Kinda hypocritical, don't you think?
The irony of complaining about the public perception of a colleague's professionalism in using an extremely common colloquialism in an interview explaining to laypeople what happened (do you think the audience would have understood what she was saying if she said "I took one look at the child and immediately noticed he was rapidly decompensating- his prognosis seemed grim"?) while using almost incoherently poor spelling, grammar, and punctuation, is... profound.
Conqueror+, BSN, RN
1,457 Posts
Um, what is wrong with being a hick ? I take exception to that generalization. I'm fixin to post about it on Facebook.