Murse, The new scrubs insult to nursing

Nurses General Nursing

Published

I had to vent about this,

First I did so on my blog, link to it is at the bottom of the page, http://www.nilepoc.com

I subsequently have done a search on the term, and found that typically it means male purse. Only on the show it equals male nurse.

Here is what I had to say, what do you have to say. I may actually write to the show about it.

anyway, thanks for letting my rant.

I once again am upset with the way Hollywood portrays nursing. (The first occurrence was when I saw "Meet the Parents") Particularly in the way they handle male nursing. Did you catch last week's episode of scrubs? (I know, I shouldn't be watching TV, but hey everyone deserves breaks) If you did, and you are a male nurse, you now know your new title.

MURSE

You read that correctly, as if it weren't bad enough to be in a profession named after the act of feeding an infant, along comes this. I am angry, for many reasons, the least of which is that term, but I digress. I guess in some ways, I should not be surprised. It is hard for me to think of a single show that paints a positive picture of nursing, or gives it some modicum of respect. Usually the only people showing any respect for nurses, are either related to one, or have spent undue amounts of time in or around hospitals as patients, or as family members of patients. More often than not though, you are apt to see the Doctor lauded, and the nurse put down, or ignored all together.

Is Hollywood unaware of the shortage currently threatening the ability of hospitals to even operate? Are they also aware that much funnier things happen in the world of nursing? Granted, poop stories portrayed on the small screen are not going to do nursing a whole lot of good either, but at least they don't denigrate the individuals who actually work as nurses.

Strong character development would not be hard to accomplish, with plots that were not detrimental to nurses would also be easy to write. So far, ER has come the closest to presenting good nurse role models in my mind. However they occasionally tread into the worship the doctor mode, but then you usually get to see the same doctor humbled quite nicely in a later episode.

Why the diatribe? Well, I am realizing that I am entering into a field, where I will gain a much-needed shot of autonomy in my practice, and also a jump in the respect I will receive while practicing. Conversely I also will have to deal with the public's perception of what nurses are, as well as describe what I am. I have every ambition of keeping my head up and proclaiming my nursehood. But I can at the same time see that it would be pretty easy to fall into complacency and just meld into the woodwork, when time came to tell someone what I do. "Oh, I work in Anesthesia", and hope that they assume you are a doctor, and move on to another topic. Currently, I stop and spend the time to educate the person I am talking to. But, what do you say when someone responds with, "Well that must have been quite a compliment to be thought of as a Doctor"? Or some other asinine comment. I usually correct them, and say that "no it is not a compliment", and then go on to tell them why that is. I wonder how many other professions go through this? BTW I know women who have the same thoughts, actually the compliment above was given to a female nurse.

Anyway, I am going to leave this hanging for now, and go write something for a grade, and not an audience.

Love the ANA letter, particuarly the last paragraph.

I can't even begin to remember how many lay people have asked me if I 'm involved romantically with a doctor, and then are not only surprized that I'm not, but have no interest in the idea. Yes, there are a few residents at my hospital who have caught my attention, but it's hardly the reason I'm in nursing. But apparently that's the public's perception of nurses - we're doe-eyed whenever an MD is on the unit. :rolleyes:

Specializes in Specializes in L/D, newborn, GYN, LTC, Dialysis.

I am SO sick of TV maligning careers like nursing. Sicker still that the American public buys so much of the crap TV and the media feed them as "gospel". However I am So very glad the ANA is "ON IT" in this case. It's time SOMEONE spoke up.....whenever insulting things like this occur in TV and Media, we all need to flood them w/similar correspondence, if nothing else, to show them we as professionals will NOT take it "lying down". GOOD FOR THE ANA!

Too late for those of you in other time zones--but tonight's episode of JAG is described by TV Guide as "a tribute to Navy nurses. The cast play different characters in a story set during the Battle of Iwo Jima, where a wounded Marine and a Navy nurse (David James Elliott, Catherine Bell) fall in love aboard a ship."

Well, I'm going to be busy watching Buffy and taping American Idol while flipping over to Gilmore Girls during commercials, but if somebody else on the West Coast wants to watch this and report back--

I'm sure it'll be gag-inducing. :p

I love the show, and keep in mind that it is a comedy. It portrays every profession in a negative light (doctors, administrators). I will continue to love it, whether they say murse or not. I am a lot more concerned about safe staffing levels and such than the use of a made up word on a sit com. Flame away.

Specializes in Corrections, Psych, Med-Surg.

Anyone watching TV deserves whatever they see, IMHO. Take it for what it usually is (junk) and leave it behind when the set is turned off. It's like getting upset about comic books. If you don't like this stuff, don't watch or read it.

Specializes in Med-Surg Nursing.
Originally posted by fergus51

I love the show, and keep in mind that it is a comedy. It portrays every profession in a negative light (doctors, administrators). I will continue to love it, whether they say murse or not. I am a lot more concerned about safe staffing levels and such than the use of a made up word on a sit com. Flame away.

Couldn't agree with you more fergus! I love Scrubs and watched the episode and didn't take offense at it whatsoever. I'm a female and when I heard murse it reminded me of SMURF for whatever reason.

Kelly:)

I realize that Scrubs is supposed to be humorous---indeed that's my problem with the show and its treatment of nursing in last week's episode. The bedpan jokes, male nurse jokes etc have been around a long time. The predictable and time worn antics gave the show a noticably dated aura which I found more boring than offensive. Judging by their ratings success, I would guess mine is the minority opinion but I think Scrubs stinks. Were it not for its favorable time slot, I would never watch.

granted this is TV....etc...and WE as nurses know the TRUTH and should just let it go......well, the public doesn't know the reality of nursing and l believe this to be one of the many consequences contributing to the woes in our career. l can't even begin to estimate how many times l have been asked "is it like ER?" or "They don't do that on ER"....or some other version of comparing reality to TV.....some of this from intelligent ppl....of which there is another profound shortage.....anyway, it is not the misrepresentation in the name of entertainment that is the sole problem with TV image of nursing.....it's the lack of balance of adequate professional reflections of nursing.....there is absolutely NOTHING on TV that l can think of that portrays the reality of nursing....and considering the way the public at large believes TV to be reality, l think this is a huge detriment to our profession..........LR

Specializes in Anesthesia.

I don't know. I can see where it may be upsetting to some for nurses to be portrayed in this way on tv, but the only ones that really bother me is when I'm flipping through the tv guide on digital cable and a Mediao titled "Hot and Heavy Nurses" or something equally depraved comes up. Those really bug me....like some Mediao queen is really smart enough to do my job......

At any rate, I would encourage anyone who is so inclined to send an email to NBC. Let them know how you feel about it, and make sure to tell them that you'll be sending emails to their advertisers and boycotting their products. Believe it or not, that stuff really works. I color myself proud for contributing to Bill Maher's (Politically Incorrect host) timely departure (after his bad comments following Sept 11th) with my flaming email.

Lou

Convicted of placenta previa & serving time on couch arrest ~ Day 34

Specializes in Med/Surg, Geriatrics.

I don't care for Scrubs either, it is way too silly for me and what you guys are describing doesn't surprise me one bit. What does disturb me is not only the negative portrayal of nurses in the media but our near invisibility. If you watch shows like "Trauma: Life in the ER" or many of the reality based TV shows that are shown on Discovery Health or TLC, of which I do enjoy for the most part, you would be misled into believing that the hospitals are run strictly by the doctors and that they are the primary caregivers of these patients while the nurses are insignificant participants in the care of most patients. It's very frustrating to watch.

On a positive note, I did watch a special on A&E(my favorite channel) about preemies and it was very positive and realistic about the role the NICU nurses played in the care of those infants. It featured actual interviews with the nurses who provided the care(not administration types), it showed how knowledgeable and skilled they all were and there was no doubt that they were vital participants in the care of those infants. Unfortunately, it was the exception and not the rule.

Originally posted by Stargazer

Well, I'm going to be busy watching Buffy and taping American Idol while flipping over to Gilmore Girls during commercials, but if somebody else on the West Coast wants to watch this and report back--

Dood... TIVO something. :D

Maybe we should all e-mail Fox and ask for a reality series...Nursezilla anyone?

+ Add a Comment