Murse, The new scrubs insult to nursing

Nurses General Nursing

Published

I had to vent about this,

First I did so on my blog, link to it is at the bottom of the page, http://www.nilepoc.com

I subsequently have done a search on the term, and found that typically it means male purse. Only on the show it equals male nurse.

Here is what I had to say, what do you have to say. I may actually write to the show about it.

anyway, thanks for letting my rant.

I once again am upset with the way Hollywood portrays nursing. (The first occurrence was when I saw "Meet the Parents") Particularly in the way they handle male nursing. Did you catch last week's episode of scrubs? (I know, I shouldn't be watching TV, but hey everyone deserves breaks) If you did, and you are a male nurse, you now know your new title.

MURSE

You read that correctly, as if it weren't bad enough to be in a profession named after the act of feeding an infant, along comes this. I am angry, for many reasons, the least of which is that term, but I digress. I guess in some ways, I should not be surprised. It is hard for me to think of a single show that paints a positive picture of nursing, or gives it some modicum of respect. Usually the only people showing any respect for nurses, are either related to one, or have spent undue amounts of time in or around hospitals as patients, or as family members of patients. More often than not though, you are apt to see the Doctor lauded, and the nurse put down, or ignored all together.

Is Hollywood unaware of the shortage currently threatening the ability of hospitals to even operate? Are they also aware that much funnier things happen in the world of nursing? Granted, poop stories portrayed on the small screen are not going to do nursing a whole lot of good either, but at least they don't denigrate the individuals who actually work as nurses.

Strong character development would not be hard to accomplish, with plots that were not detrimental to nurses would also be easy to write. So far, ER has come the closest to presenting good nurse role models in my mind. However they occasionally tread into the worship the doctor mode, but then you usually get to see the same doctor humbled quite nicely in a later episode.

Why the diatribe? Well, I am realizing that I am entering into a field, where I will gain a much-needed shot of autonomy in my practice, and also a jump in the respect I will receive while practicing. Conversely I also will have to deal with the public's perception of what nurses are, as well as describe what I am. I have every ambition of keeping my head up and proclaiming my nursehood. But I can at the same time see that it would be pretty easy to fall into complacency and just meld into the woodwork, when time came to tell someone what I do. "Oh, I work in Anesthesia", and hope that they assume you are a doctor, and move on to another topic. Currently, I stop and spend the time to educate the person I am talking to. But, what do you say when someone responds with, "Well that must have been quite a compliment to be thought of as a Doctor"? Or some other asinine comment. I usually correct them, and say that "no it is not a compliment", and then go on to tell them why that is. I wonder how many other professions go through this? BTW I know women who have the same thoughts, actually the compliment above was given to a female nurse.

Anyway, I am going to leave this hanging for now, and go write something for a grade, and not an audience.

Originally posted by delirium

Dood... TIVO something. :D

Hee. I'm sure it'll come to that eventually. I tend to resist new technology as long as possible. Hell, I don't even have a DVD player, except on my computer. :D
Originally posted by Stargazer

Hee. I'm sure it'll come to that eventually. I tend to resist new technology as long as possible. Hell, I don't even have a DVD player, except on my computer. :D

Heck, I still have problems with the VCR! Luckily, I have children to program it for me.

I understand everyone's concerns here, but we have to remember Scrubs is a comedy. So, what about all of the images tv has given us with the male doctor screwing the nurse in the utility closet. Doesn't that offend our profession too?

At any rate, the tv show I am most concerned with is the HBO "hit" Oz. If any show portrays nurses/nursing in a bad light it would be that show. In fact, the latest episode shows one nurse over medicating an inmate in the infirmary just so she can hold a pillow over his face to asphyxiate him. In another segment the same nurse hears an inmate is being transfered to the infirmary from death row and states, "Okay, but I'm putting him in restraints." If you knew this character you would wonder why she would ever say that, because this character/inmate is mentally handicapped and really isn't all that dangerous. Later, they show this same inmate trying to get someone's attention so he can get up to go have a BM. All of the nurses ignore him, and finally one walks over, annoyed to all hell, and says, "What do you want?" When she sees he was inct. she says, "Oh Great! Not again." I mean really, sometimes I think that on a REALLY bad day, but I would never say that out loud.

If there is anyone we should be annoyed with it should be this show and HBO. Granted they are playing inmates, but do the nurses on the show have to act like inmates too? If we are going to start a "war" with the entertainment business, let's do it all the way and not half assed!

I checked and this episode (#52, season 6) is no longer running currently on "regular" cable. Contact them at 212-512-1208 or go to: http://www.hbo.com/corpinfo/contactus.shtml

I would like to start by saying that Scrubs is probably my favorite TV show at the moment. After all, my husband is a resident and I'm in nursing school. The way they portrayed the situation of the male nurse was fairly realistic. It showed how most people do react to male nurses, but was successful in allowing that character to express his pride of being a nurse and being an individual.

Another thing: The nurses on that show, while kind of stereotypical, are usually portrayed in a positive light. For example, when Turk (the surgical resident dating Carla, the nurse) brought Carla an application for Nurse Practitioner School, the show allowed her to explain to him that she liked being a nurse. The other nurses are generally shown as strong and knowledgable professionals.

+ Add a Comment