Hospital Workers Suspended for Peeking at George Clooney's Medical Info - page 2
... Read More
Oct 10, '07Occupation: Nursing Professional Development + Academic Faculty Specialty: 38 year(s) of experience in Nursing Professional Development ; Joined: Sep '02; Posts: 13,545; Likes: 25,365I agree with the punishment -- and hope that nurses and nursing groups support that punishment publically. Behavior like this jeopardizes the health of celebreties who may hesitate to seek the health care they out of fear of public disclosure. It also makes us all look really bad.
Throw the book at them -- and make sure the public is told that we don't support that type of behavior.
Oct 10, '07Occupation: allnurses Asst Community Manager, APRN Specialty: 25 year(s) of experience in Nephrology, Cardiology, ER, ICU ; From: US ; Joined: Apr '00; Posts: 53,485; Likes: 26,440The penalty fit the crime. It is expected that when you enter the hospital, info will be passed out on a need to know basis only. Everyone deserves the same right to privacy; be they a co-worker, a neighbor, family friend, or celebrity.
Oct 10, '07Specialty: Trauma ICU,ER,ACLS/BLS instructor ; Joined: Jul '07; Posts: 395; Likes: 293Quote from traumaRUsThe penalty fit the crime. It is expected that when you enter the hospital, info will be passed out on a need to know basis only. Everyone deserves the same right to privacy; be they a co-worker, a neighbor, family friend, or celebrity.
Oct 10, '07Joined: Sep '05; Posts: 217; Likes: 234Quote from traumaRUsCouldn't have been said better!The penalty fit the crime. It is expected that when you enter the hospital, info will be passed out on a need to know basis only. Everyone deserves the same right to privacy; be they a co-worker, a neighbor, family friend, or celebrity.
Oct 10, '07Joined: May '07; Posts: 311; Likes: 291Their punishment could have been much worse.
They could have been fired plus had some kind of charges
pressed against them.
Oct 10, '07Occupation: RN Specialty: ob/gyn med /surg ; From: US ; Joined: Mar '07; Posts: 2,399; Likes: 1,754dr's were suspended too... wow.. the heck with the records .. i would go see george... who cares about his CT scan.. i want to see him... what a hunk.. i don't know why they didn't john doe him on admit.. we have had a couple famous people and they come in as john doe.
Oct 10, '07Occupation: RN-i (RETIRED) Specialty: ORTHOPAEDICS-CERTIFIED SINCE 89 ; From: US ; Joined: May '00; Posts: 14,479; Likes: 2,298True violation. ButIMHO a large pay cut/even a drop in "rank" for x number of days/months/years might make others aware you can't get away with this.
Confronted by stares from your peers has a great censure value.
Oct 10, '07Joined: Dec '02; Posts: 41,761; Likes: 48,081I agree, throw the book at them.
I brought this issue up at a recent orientation at my new job regarding computer access to patient records. I asked if a nurse can look at any patient's records, not just the nurse's own patients. The answer is yes, but they are not supposed to.
I had a "friend" who worked at this hospital before I did but at the same time that I had my baby. She told me that she looked up my records and read the delivery report.
There is no safeguard . . except getting caught and getting in trouble.
Oct 10, '07Occupation: Stay at home mother and student Joined: Jan '07; Posts: 1,088; Likes: 280:yeahthat:Quote from zenmanWhy didn't they just peek at George?
Oct 10, '07Occupation: cardiovascular nurse Specialty: 12 year(s) of experience in ccu cardiovascular ; Joined: Oct '03; Posts: 645; Likes: 233They really should have been fired, the staff knew better. How many times is hippa drilled into our heads about patient rights and confidentiality. I saw the interview and i think he was really nice about the whole situation.
Oct 10, '07Joined: Jul '03; Posts: 2,937; Likes: 2,386In regard to whether or not "confidentiality" was breached, it might be that a breach in confidentiality is being defined as a health professional passing on information that had been given to them with the understanding that it wasn't to be shared publicly. Thus, a person sneaking a look at a medical record is a violation of policy and a breach of patient privacy (as in information being kept private) but wouldn't be considered a breach of confidentiality. If the health personnel looked at the records and then shared confidential information (eg patient was treated for an STD) with another (patient's wife, a tabloid) that would be a breach of confidentiality. Just a thought.Last edit by jjjoy on Oct 10, '07
Oct 10, '07Joined: Nov '06; Posts: 20,715; Likes: 23,950Hmmmm. Look at George or look at his records? I think I know which I'd pick!
In all seriousness, as tempting as it may be, nobody is worth losing my job. And it's his (or anybody else's) right as a patient to not have everybody & their brother looking at their stuff.
A few years back, while working at a community health center, someone came up with the great idea of combining medical and dental records for the migrant farmworker patients that would be visiting us for a season only. Another nurse and I fought it because people working on someone's teeth have no need to know if she has been recently treated for a vaginal yeast infection or something similar. We fought it, and eventually, we won. That's only remotely related to George Clooney's medical record, but the point is that EVERYBODY'S stuff is private and should be kept that way.
Oct 10, '07Joined: Apr '00; Posts: 24,611; Likes: 35,450i'm surprised they only got suspensions.
to me, it is clearly a terminable offense.
what were these people thinking????
dang, i love george as well.
but i'd much rather love him outside of the hospital, when he's healed, able and willing.