The Wisdom of Lurking

Published

We've all seen the new poster whose very first post is one lambasting the more established members of the forum for lack of compassion to patients, students or new nurses, for eating our young” or for bullying. One recent memorable thread included the header I Have A Bone To Pick With You”, and unfortunately was closed before I had the chance to respond to it. Nevertheless, it was entertaining, and I've wondered what happened to the original poster. Perhaps the only way to recover from a fiasco like that is to close down the profile and start again with a new user name.

While it is your absolute right to post in whatever (however stupid) manner you choose, certain topics, buzzwords and titles are likely to earn you a good deal LESS respect that you think you deserve. Perhaps less than you might actually deserve. If your inaugural post (or any one of your first 10) is entitled Why do Nurses Eat Their Young?”, I'm Surrounded By Mean Old Biter Nurses” or Nurses Are Mean And Nasty,” I can almost guarantee that you're going to be lambasted by more established members of the AN community — unless you're lucky enough that your thread gets shut down immediately. Apologizing for the post and declaring that you now see the error of your ways isn't going to get you much slack, either as new members log on, read that first post and immediately respond. Most of us don't read the entire thread before responding. I think it's more fun to type out my first reaction, then read what everyone else has to say.

Lurking for a week or more will give you an opportunity to observe the hot button” issues and determine that perhaps starting your membership with a thread inquiring why nurses aren't delighted to have students helping them” or doing all of their work” isn't going to win you fans outside of the nursing student forums. It will give you some insight on which forum to use when asking someone to do your homework for you. (You HAVE caught on, haven't you, that we won't do your homework for you? That doesn't make us mean haters. That makes us professionals who want to have other professionals working with us in the future.) If you're new to the internet, perhaps lurking will give you some insight on using all caps or underlining, italicizing AND bolding those comments about how everyone is MEAN to you isn't going to endear you to other posters.

If you lurk for awhile, you may begin to understand thread drift” and know that once you put something out there, it's out there. People will comment on it, both positively and negatively, and you as a commenter on the thread (or even an original poster) will have no control over the direction of the thread once it's posted. That's how we get threads about red jello and white chocolate.

Lurking may make clear the inadvisability of writing a post stating that the only reason you don't get along with your coworkers is that they're all so jealous of your extreme youth and extraordinary beauty, and besides they're all a bunch of ugly old hags.

On second thought, what am I saying! If everyone were to lurk for awhile before their first post, it would cut down immeasurably on those entertaining, gotta have popcorn” threads!

Specializes in Oncology; medical specialty website.
This thread, and many of the comments, are puzzling to me. I have always felt that this forum is clique-ish and there are certain posters that always rally around each other. So what if someone is not a "seasoned poster," or "valued member?" You guys certainly do take yourselves very seriously, don't you? I thought becoming an RN was a noteworthy accomplishment, but I guess one needs to be a "valued member" of AN to be really important.

I don't think anyone is saying that. My take on this is just that many times it helps to get the feel of a site before jumping in with all four feet. There have been several posts recently by brand new members. Lambasting everyone on a thread that, up to that point, had been highly entertaining. (Please pause while I play taps for the dearly departed "Mockery of Nursing" thread).

Nurses from all backgrounds can make vital contributions, and they need not be crusty.

Specializes in Oncology; medical specialty website.

LOL..that is what I was going to say.

This thread, and many of the comments, are puzzling to me. I have always felt that this forum is clique-ish and there are certain posters that always rally around each other. So what if someone is not a "seasoned poster," or "valued member?" You guys certainly do take yourselves very seriously, don't you? I thought becoming an RN was a noteworthy accomplishment, but I guess one needs to be a "valued member" of AN to be really important.

There clearly are cliques here, not just one but more. These people have good advice when you get beyond the childishness. It really comes down to if you are okay wading through the nonsense to get to the quality info.

But, the greater majority of folks here are not in cliques and have no personal need to be "special" on the internet full of anonymous people.

One issue I do wish to point out is that there is a big difference between cliques and groups of people who have formed internet friendships. They are not one in the same. A clique will support another clique member even when it makes them both/all look silly, friends will laugh and have long running jokes. Cliques probably won't get that statement but those with internet friendships will.

Just my personal opinion from my 20+ years on the internet, clique members usually don't appear to have great social skills in real time. But on line they can be anything, play any role, and do those behaviors with like minded people. Others that also do not have great social skills.

I think in the end you just have to ignore the weirdnesses of people and see if they have anything to offer you. If not, just move on to the next post.

Lurking to see the "tone" of the board...maybe. But maybe not. That implies you are okay with others dictating what you write or "else". That has never been okay with me.

Again, cliques and internet friendships, two very different groups of people and that does seem to be an issue that is easily confused with the limitations of internet writing. (No tone of voice, facial expressions, etc.)

Specializes in Psychiatric Nursing.

Defying gravity, thanks for making my morning!

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
Suggesting one uses the search feature is not meant to resurrect new threads, but to find threads where the question has already been asked and answered ad nauseum.

I personally don't mind if someone posts on a thread that's a few months old, to add more information, a different angle, or to ask a question.

But really, what's the point of bumping up a 5-year-old thread?

Well, that ghost thread is still going after six years. But in general, I agree with you.

I have been creepily lurking here for the past several months (yes, that is me in the figurative bushes)!

I am finishing up my pre-reqs, and then will be applying to nursing school. I am your friendly neighborhood lurker so that I can soak up as much knowledge as I can in the meantime - not to mention, it's also pretty motivating. I can't wait until I can proudly state that I am a nurse and then eat baby nurses, myself! (I hope for some ice-cream flavored ones - kidding kidding).

Seriously though, there has been so much information that I have learned from lurking here... I am really glad this place exists. I promise I won't ever ask you guys to do my homework, or "why am I not being placed on first shift without weekends? Scandalous!", or even talk about how "I failed a class because my Professor is a giant Sucky McSuckerson who is out to get me because I am SuperStudent".

I will probably keep creepily lurking about, however, as I feel this has been really helpful.

~ Newbie

I have been creepily lurking here for the past several months (yes, that is me in the figurative bushes)!

I am finishing up my pre-reqs, and then will be applying to nursing school. I am your friendly neighborhood lurker so that I can soak up as much knowledge as I can in the meantime - not to mention, it's also pretty motivating. I can't wait until I can proudly state that I am a nurse and then eat baby nurses, myself! (I hope for some ice-cream flavored ones - kidding kidding).

Seriously though, there has been so much information that I have learned from lurking here... I am really glad this place exists. I promise I won't ever ask you guys to do my homework, or "why am I not being placed on first shift without weekends? Scandalous!", or even talk about how "I failed a class because my Professor is a giant Sucky McSuckerson who is out to get me because I am SuperStudent".

I will probably keep creepily lurking about, however, as I feel this has been really helpful.

~ Newbie

Hey, I like you.

+ Join the Discussion