Facilities are firing seasoned, higher paid nurses and utilizing younger less experienced nurses. This cost-cutting measure is putting patients at risk, working nursing and support staff to the point of exhaustion, and causing staff to leave the profession.
Updated:
This article was written by a member on allnurses. Due to the controversial and emotionally charged nature of the article, the member wanted the topic out in the open so nurses could discuss it. Because she is afraid of retribution if any of her hospital administrative staff should read this article and link it back to her, we offered to publish it for her anonymously. Please add your comments regarding this issue negatively impacting nurses and the healthcare system.
I am an experienced nurse that has watched many of my very talented colleagues leave the bedside due to the changes that have taken place in healthcare as of late. I have seen staff cut to the minimum, while patient acuity and nurse to patient ratios increase. I have seen support staff break down in tears because they have not been able to do their jobs properly. I have seen staff pushed to their breaking point, all the while administration stays in their offices, or in the meetings, determining yet more ways they can cut our resources. I see your salaries raised to ridiculous amounts, while we are denied cost of living increases, housekeeping is cut at night, and our benefits cost more, while the services are decreased.
I see our retirement cut while at the same time, the amount matched continues to be diminished or non-existent.
I see ways in which we are constantly blamed for declining patient satisfaction, increased patient falls, late medication administration, all the while we are asked to do more with less. I have seen you fire experienced staff and hire less experienced, cheaper, staff. I have seen that new staff break down because they have no resources, no experience to draw from and I have seen patients suffer from that inexperience. I have seen codes increase, inappropriate admissions to floors, transfers to higher levels of care, all because no one was there initially to advocate for a higher level of care for the patient, to begin with.
I still see you in your office. I do not see you on the floor. I see you with your graphs, your pie charts, your questions about readmission rates when I had already advocated for that patient to stay longer but was simply laughed off by doctors and not supported by you. Yet, somehow, I need to be on a committee to fix the problem.
I am now required to work extra shifts, because staff are getting sick due to stress, or leaving completely because they are tired of dealing with things. I see you develop a culture of fear, where our jobs are at stake and threatened at every turn. Yet, you still look to me for solutions.
"How can we do more with what we have?" I am asked.
My answer: There is no way to do more. We are at our limit. You are losing nurses as fast as you are gaining them, at a time when we need to be building up our profession when the baby boomers are just starting to become a factor in our healthcare environment.
My answer to this is simple. It is time to get real and start valuing your employees. If you want to be reimbursed for patient satisfaction, increase your services. Staff departments with what they need - enough nurses, enough aids, monitor techs, secretaries, ED techs, whatever. Then you will see positive results. Falls will decrease. Medication errors will decrease and medications will be given on time. Patients will get the treatment they deserve and patient satisfaction scores will improve. Your reimbursement will improve and you will stop losing money. Everyone wins: most importantly, the patients.
We need to stop the assembly-line mentality of medicine and return to the service mentality.
Yes, we are a business. But any business that has ever done well has not done well by decreasing the services to people or by mistreating its staff. Otherwise, healthcare facilities are going to see more of the same and suffer more financial penalties, less high-quality staff, and patients will suffer.
I was talking with several of my colleagues just the other day. All of us had many years of experience. Many had been at the bedside for over 20+ years. Many are leaving the bedside due to the unsafe conditions they are seeing. They just don't want to be a part of it. Perhaps this does not scare you, but it should. You must not be a patient yet.
For a follow-up article, please go to Nurses Fight Back! Why Some Hospitals are Despicable
Hospitals Firing Seasoned Nurses_ Nurses FIGHT Back! _ allnurses.pdf
SatkinsRN said:I've worked in hospitals for over 20 years now. I've noticed (in my limited experience) that hospitals that are owned by Fortune 500 companies, whose primary reason for existence is to make money for their shareholders, simply SUCK! The equipment is shoddy, they do not value having an educated nursing workforce, nurses have little voice in the governance of the facility, and nurses are literally worked like dogs-except that most compassionate people will actually let a dog drink some water, eat some food, and have time to "do their business." I'm curious to know...what are other nurses' experience with for-profit versus not-for-profit facilities? I've recently started working at a catholic hospital. Although I'm only in my third week there, I've been exceedingly impressed with their thorough orientation process, and exceptional hospital education department.
Opposite experience here. Catholic non profit magnet hospital was an absolute nightmare, for profit non magnet hospital was far far better in ratios, support staff, nurse involvement, clinical ladders etc.
sistrmoon said:I worked in Texas at a non-profit Magnet hospital. It had horrible ratios, nearly zero support staff, and was dreadfully unsafe. I knew about Safe Harbor but nearly none of my coworkers did. I know of no one who ever utilized it. It triggers a mandatory JCHAO visit. We were already receiving those as well as Magnet stamped! I have great doubt safe harbor does much of anything except maybe target you for retaliation. It sounds great in theory. I now work in NY at a for-profit non-Magnet hospital. Nothing like Safe Harbor exists here. Never have more than 6 patients, and way more support staff. Things still suck, but it's a spa compared to my previous hospital.
I am glad you found a better place to work. I was just talking about Magnet designation recently - I know that our local hospital that is Magnet designated is ridiculously understaffed and unsafe right now, but the Level 1 that is not Magnet is much better. I am not sure Magnet means as much as it did when I first encountered it in 2006. Sad!
Secretperson said:Please stop and think about this:
If computer programmers from the 1970's never stayed current on the progression of technology,regardless of how good they were, how relevant do you think they would be today with a high end laptop pc or MAC? The basics of programming remain the same, yet much more is expected for a lot less, and when almost any computer owner can now do what an older programmer used to do, how does the older programmer create worth?
That's an interesting example. I worked in the IT industry before becoming a nurse and there are many very well paid successful people in that industry who don't even have a college degree. You seem to be touting more formal education as the means to increase our worth. Really not certain that it follows and the IT industry is a prime example.
Talking to nursing leaders and administrators is pointless. I know, I am a victim of being forced to leave a position I loved. Take it to the public. Stories like this need to be published in every large and small newspapers, and issues need to be aired on big time talk shows who are serious in calling out corporate leaders to demand change
Regarding public education, this is true.....except that the media and the government are skilled at sending propaganda and mixed messages to deliberately confuse the public. Look at all the articles discussing the "nursing shortage", when in fact the reality is a shortage of jobs. The public still believes that nurses can find jobs anywhere, anytime. I have friends and acquaintances who continue to be shocked when I enlighten them.
Then, you have multiple postings across various sites for nurses, but on closer inspection they are temp, casual or job shares. Many of the postings are an illusion, no intention to ever fill them. In addition, there have been numerous campaigns by health authorities advertising the need for nurses, while these same entities are quietly downsizing and laying workers off.
Even the meetings that managers attend are confusing, filled with double-speak. On one hand, we are told to cut all costs, but in that same meeting, we discuss how to improve patient care. Are you kidding me??!!
I'm not sure what the answer is. Perhaps mass picketing by nurses, except that anyone involved would lose their job and be blacklisted.
I have to throw in here how disappointed I am in the nursing leadership that had rare moment in the national spotlight with the Ebola crisis. I read several media statements & saw many interviews on CNN & MSNBC, etc. with various "spokespersons" and "leadership" of various nurse organizations.
Not ONE of them had any fire, any anger, ANY passion. They all had personalities of cantaloupes. Soft spoken, inoffensive, bland. I distinctly remember watching some of these women and being APPALLED! At how banal and limp they were. I was screaming at the TV, "come ON!!! Nurses NEED you to show some HEAT! Some CONTROVERSY! Some ANGER! This is your MOMENT!!"
Part of the reason we can't get a leg up is because we have no powerful, centralized leadership promoting reform for us with ANY kind of fury or commitment!!!!
mclennan said:I have to throw in here how disappointed I am in the nursing leadership that had rare moment in the national spotlight with the Ebola crisis. I read several media statements & saw many interviews on CNN & MSNBC, etc. with various "spokespersons" and "leadership" of various nurse organizations.Not ONE of them had any fire, any anger, ANY passion. They all had personalities of cantaloupes. Soft spoken, inoffensive, bland. I distinctly remember watching some of these women and being APPALLED! At how banal and limp they were. I was screaming at the TV, "come ON! Nurses NEED you to show some HEAT! Some CONTROVERSY! Some ANGER! This is your MOMENT!!"
Part of the reason we can't get a leg up is because we have no powerful, centralized leadership promoting reform for us with ANY kind of fury or commitment!!
I agree...to a point.
If anyone who was speaking out passionately and continues to is the NNU.
They continue to fight for proper patient ratios, safety/ proper PPE in light of the Ebola outbreak, and have never stopped.
They have also lobbied against repealing the rule in the ACA that mandates full-time job is 30+ hours/week to qualify for benefits; they really have always been full speed ahead in terms of the rights for nurses; it is up to US to be well knowledgable in who is speaking up for us, even locally and nationally, even if they don't have a chapter in the state, there are still organizations that are out there; NNU is one of the forefront people out there; and there is no cost to join and be a supporter.
joanna73 said:Regarding public education, this is true.....except that the media and the government are skilled at sending propaganda and mixed messages to deliberately confuse the public. Look at all the articles discussing the "nursing shortage", when in fact the reality is a shortage of jobs. The public still believes that nurses can find jobs anywhere, anytime. I have friends and acquaintances who continue to be shocked when I enlighten them.
That's all true, but can be looked at another way. There IS a nursing shortage - of nurses at the bedside all due to the posted-but-unfilled vacancies we've talked about. And our cause isn't helped by all those lovely letters to the editor praising the excellent care the writer or a family member received at one of our hospitals. The writer doesn't know that the wonderful nurse who cared for him or his wife missed lunch, hadn't been to the bathroom since just before leaving the house that day, had 5, 7 or 10 other patients s/he provided the same level of care to and then stayed an hour after the shift ended without pay to tie up the charting - just like EVERY other day! I've had so many discussions with friends and family members who comment on me getting home so late from work with questions like, "Well, why don't you just leave at 7 o'clock? and still haven't managed to gain understanding that we can't "just leave".
joanna73 said:Then, you have multiple postings across various sites for nurses, but on closer inspection they are temp, casual or job shares. Many of the postings are an illusion, no intention to ever fill them. In addition, there have been numerous campaigns by health authorities advertising the need for nurses, while these same entities are quietly downsizing and laying workers off.
SO true!! It always really frosts me when I see my employer advertising in national and even international nursing journals for nurses, and proclaiming how wonderful it is to work here, how flexible their lives can be if they just hitch their wagons to our star. All lies.
joanna73 said:Even the meetings that managers attend are confusing, filled with double-speak. On one hand, we are told to cut all costs, but in that same meeting, we discuss how to improve patient care. Are you kidding me??!!
We can't afford to hire more staff but we can pay somebody to do daily hand hygiene audits. We can't afford to hire new staff but we can buy an already-obsolete blood dispenser that has been sitting unused for 8 months already. We can't afford to hire more staff but we can stockpile computers in a warehouse so long that their warranties and support contracts expire, then roll them out with the new new EHR. We can't afford to hire new staff but we can waste millions of dollars worth of drugs to make patient care more safe. Oh so many examples.
joanna73 said:I'm not sure what the answer is. Perhaps mass picketing by nurses, except that anyone involved would lose their job and be blacklisted.
Or arrested and fined, since it's against the law for nurses to strike here.
mclennan said:I have to throw in here how disappointed I am in the nursing leadership that had rare moment in the national spotlight with the Ebola crisis. I read several media statements & saw many interviews on CNN & MSNBC, etc. with various "spokespersons" and "leadership" of various nurse organizations.Not ONE of them had any fire, any anger, ANY passion. They all had personalities of cantaloupes. Soft spoken, inoffensive, bland. I distinctly remember watching some of these women and being APPALLED! At how banal and limp they were. I was screaming at the TV, "come ON! Nurses NEED you to show some HEAT! Some CONTROVERSY! Some ANGER! This is your MOMENT!!"
Part of the reason we can't get a leg up is because we have no powerful, centralized leadership promoting reform for us with ANY kind of fury or commitment!!
That could never be said about the president of the Canadian Federation of Nurses' Unions. There is no more passionate, articulate and fearless leader than she is. The national director of nursing practice and client advocacy for NNU is no slouch either. I've heard both these women speak, the former a number of times, and can vouch for their fire. But they need support.
There's a forum here called Collective Bargaining/Nursing Union. The forum is full of threads and posts that are virulently and stridently opposed to any collective action. One thread, running to 30 pages now, is called Top 10 Reasons Against Unions. The degree of ignorance some posters display when discussing this topic is startling. Their minds are so closed that not even dynamite could open them. Some key phrases from the thread: Unions are evil. Their executives are in it for the power and the money. They're all corrupt. They're only valuable for coal miners and auto workers. Nurses have to much self-respect to join a union. It's impossible to fire a union member, no matter how bad they are. Unions just take my money but don't provide me with any value for it. I could go on and on. There will always be those dissenters and unless you can be sure the yea-sayers outnumber them, any attempt to organize will fail.
I never used to think unions were all that much good. In fact, I thought they were quite bad - thanks, Mom... Then I became a nurse. I was forced to take a job with a nursing agency that provided home nursing and facility staff relief so that I could pay my bills. The things that happened to me while on that job quickly pointed out how wrong I was. Things like being put in charge of an entire nursing home at night with no warning that was what I would be doing. (I was the only RN, with 1 LPN and 6 CNAs for a building with 120 beds.) Things like doing a shift with an adolescent with a degenerative neurological disorder which required me to clean the bathroom, do laundry and wash floors in addition to patient care - then be paid as an LPN because that's who they usually sent in. Things like being threatened with firing if I called a home health patient's physician to report my concern that the kid was dying. And I had no protection. I'm very thankful now for the support of my union, whether their work has a personal impact on me or not. Having seen how far they go to protect members from a variety of trumped-up charges, they will have my undying respect.
spiderslap said:Below is a very informative article regarding the mindset of hospital admin
Sad! Very Sad. It doesn't surprise me though, since hospitals already mistreat nurses, why would they treat Dr's any better once they are employees for the corporation. Of course they would use the same tactics they use on us to control them and keep their wages down. These type of tactics are why I would never want to work in management. I have no desire to let greed and money be so important that I would mistreat and manipulate others. I do believe a strong union is the way to go like the NNU. I'm very impressed with what they have accomplished. The ANA is too conservative and too pro hospital for me. Maybe one day Dr's will unionize too now that so many of them have been forced from private practice into working for hospitals and insurance companies!
brandy1017 said:Sad! Very Sad. It doesn't surprise me though, since hospitals already mistreat nurses, why would they treat Dr's any better once they are employees for the corporation. Of course they would use the same tactics they use on us to control them and keep their wages down. These type of tactics are why I would never want to work in management. I have no desire to let greed and money be so important that I would mistreat and manipulate others. I do believe a strong union is the way to go like the NNU. I'm very impressed with what they have accomplished. The ANA is too conservative and too pro hospital for me. Maybe one day Dr's will unionize too now that so many of them have been forced from private practice into working for hospitals and insurance companies!
In my area, there is a Doctor's union; when a local hospital's nurse went on strike, they were at the picket lines in support of them, people honked by in support.
This particular union works closely with this nurses union on a unified front.
sistrmoon, BSN, RN
842 Posts
I worked in Texas at a non-profit Magnet hospital. It had horrible ratios, nearly zero support staff, and was dreadfully unsafe. I knew about Safe Harbor but nearly none of my coworkers did. I know of no one who ever utilized it. It triggers a mandatory JCHAO visit. We were already receiving those as well as Magnet stamped! I have great doubt safe harbor does much of anything except maybe target you for retaliation. It sounds great in theory. I now work in NY at a for-profit non-Magnet hospital. Nothing like Safe Harbor exists here. Never have more than 6 patients, and way more support staff. Things still suck, but it's a spa compared to my previous hospital.