Gasp! An uninsured Nurse (rant)

Nurses Activism

Published

I visited a Dermatologist today to check out a painful spot that had developed on my lip. It came up in conversation with his assisstant that I was a nurse. She glanced at my chart and remarked "I see you dont have insurance, and you're a nurse? How can that be? Surely you realize how important insurance is." My response "I dont buy into the insurance business and Im prepared to take the finacial risks that that may entail". She rolled her eyes and went on about her business. This is not the first time Ive caught flack for being a nurse and not having medical insurance, as if my involvement in the healthcare field should somehow guarantee that I be excluded from the millions of Americans living without health insurance.

The truth is, my employer does not offer coverage for part-time employees (which I choose to be due to family obligations). I could be added on to my husbands work policy on which he carries himself and our daughter but at a price of over $700 a month (heck he would practically be working for just insurance!). I could get my own policy to the tune of $150 a month and pay outrageous copays for every visit and Rx. But Ive found that barring any major emergency/Dx that Im coming out much better NOT having insurance. The dermatologist gave me a discount for paying cash so my bill was only $60 (an insurance copay would have been $70). When I get sick I go to urgent care where they also give cash discounts, I pay $86 whereas hubby and baby have an urgent care copay of $200. I go to the health dept for my yearly GYN visit and BC pills to the tune of $90 (as based on my income) whereas when I had insurance I paid $35 per visit plus $25 a month for Rx. Im saving a ton of money not being insured. Now I know that if anything major comes up Ill have a ton of bills to pay out of pocket, but thats why they make payment plans. I just cant justify paying $1800 a year for a healthcare discount program (i.e. Insurance)

And just because Im a nurse does not mean I should have to have insurance!

Specializes in Med/Surg.
I would be willing to bet that the majority of nurses in the US do not have health insurance.

What do you base that on?

Specializes in Pediatric/Adolescent, Med-Surg.
I would be willing to bet that the majority of nurses in the US do not have health insurance.

What are you basing this on?

Specializes in Med/Surg.

I agree with the poster that said that your husband's insurance plan sounds far from ideal. $200 for urgent care?!? On my insurance plan (through the hospital I work at) its $35, ER $100, any hospitalization $100. While I am young and have no health problems I recently landed in the ER. Did not need to be hospitalized, had some lab tests, EKG, US the usual and my bill was over $8500. Very glad out of that I was responsible only for $100 (my copay). Have you thought about maybe working full time and your husband cutting back for the family obligations? In my situation my husband and I agreed that this was by far the better plan for our family.

My husband was never sick a day in his life. Until he got a tumor...

6 months of chemo was $22,000 a month. A 20% copay was $4,400 a month. Add on radiation treatments, a major surgery, medicines, etc. even with insurance, our out of pocket expenses were astronomical. Thank God my husband was very successful in his career and we had the money.

If you never get sick, I'm sure you'll feel very satisfied about your risky philosophy. If you get cancer or some other catastrophic illness, I imagine you will look back on your cavalier attitude with regret. There is no "payment plan" that will assuage the financial devastation of a cancer diagnosis. But it seems you don't realize the true potential consequences of your attitude or you are in denial about the fact that serious illness can happen to ANYONE, regardless of previous health status.

But hey, it's your life and only you (and your family) will pay the consequences if your little gamble doesn't go well.

Good luck-you're going to need it. I'm sincere when I say I hope you enjoy good health and happiness.

Specializes in NICU, ER, OR.

You dont "buy" into the insurance business, but you let your usband pay 700 per month for a rob job policy? that certainly sounds like your buying into it to me... please explain how this makes sense to you.... is it just so you can work part time? im not being sarcastic.... im really confused... 700 per month is acceptable to you? its alot of money, even for a good plan......

i have blue cross blue shield. i pay 80 dollars pr month, i have no deductible, and i have a 20 dollar copay, 25 for specialists. most RX's ar under 10, most are 4 bucks. i had an emergency cholycystectomy, i paid nothing besides h food my husband brought me from a restaurant the next day.... i mean not even a parking fee i had to pay.... so, ummm i am guarding THIS WITH MY LIFE. Because I know it could very well depend on it. Beleive me, I would love to work pt, but not at the detriment of financial security of my family. and another thing to consider..god forbid you or anyone in your family has a life threatening illness... do you really think you will get top notch care?do you know how many times i have heard, from docs "should we get a scan? answer: nah, no insurance, we will watch it"........

Specializes in CDI Supervisor; Formerly NICU.

But hey, it's your life and only you (and your family) will pay the consequences if your little gamble doesn't go well.

Well, not really. When it does happen, and she can't afford the payments of thousands or dollars, she'll default and everyone else will absorb her debt through increased cost of healthcare.

Specializes in MDS/Office.

Optimist....I understand where you're coming from....

My Health Insurance is "more than doubling" next year!

Health Care Workers who can't afford Health Care....Criminal! :(

I agree with the poster that said that your husband's insurance plan sounds far from ideal. $200 for urgent care?!? On my insurance plan (through the hospital I work at) its $35, ER $100, any hospitalization $100. While I am young and have no health problems I recently landed in the ER. Did not need to be hospitalized, had some lab tests, EKG, US the usual and my bill was over $8500. Very glad out of that I was responsible only for $100 (my copay). Have you thought about maybe working full time and your husband cutting back for the family obligations? In my situation my husband and I agreed that this was by far the better plan for our family.

Wow, where do you work? I work in a hospital and have Blue Cross/Blue Shield and I can only afford the HSA with $3000/$6000 deductible. Consider yourself very fortunate!

To the OP, you very well should consider yourself lucky also. No way would I want to take the chance of not having insurance in the case of a serious illness, major car accident etc. Who knows when something like that may happen? I don't even want to think of having to pay on a hospital bill for the rest of my life.

Well, not really. When it does happen, and she can't afford the payments of thousands or dollars, she'll default and everyone else will absorb her debt through increased cost of healthcare.

True, the public at large will absorb some of it, but she is not indigent; she will surely feel the hurt of a huge medical expense. They will come after her.

I had a friend in nursing school who was uninsured. Athletic, young, healthy...until she got leukemia. She got treatment at the county hospital. It was NOT the treatment you or I would hope for or would receive as insured patients. She still had to pay more than she could spare for treatment. She died broke and broken, after immeasurable suffering. Now, she may have died had she been insured, but I can guarantee she would have had better care if she had been insured. She said as much many times during her ordeal. This is not something to take lightly.

Optimist....I understand where you're coming from....

My Health Insurance is "more than doubling" next year!

Health Care Workers who can't afford Health Care....Criminal! :(

Well, the OP never said she couldn't afford it. She said she wasn't willing to pay $1800 a year for insurance.

When you are an unemployed nurse that isn't any different than any other unemployed person who can't afford insurance. Health insurance is a luxury that many employed people can't afford. I would invite anybody making such comments to buy a policy for me.

You obviously have the right to not carry insurance. :)

I wasn't expecting to end up in the hospital for 6 weeks last year, with a bill of 330,000.00+....I'm on Medicare, and was eligible for SOME help with co-pays. The year of prescriptions specific for the kind of cancer I have is > $5500/month. Without part D I'd be dead.

I hope that when you decide to go to work full-time, if you do, you'll reconsider the possibilities you see as a nurse- and hear about in all sorts of places. The stories that end up on the news that say how many people were injured in some tragic event never say how bad the injuries are- and how many end up needing longterm care. :twocents:

I understand the short term cost-effectiveness. And hope that it continues to work for you :)

+ Add a Comment