My Reasons For Avoiding The Acute Care Hospital

Some nurses have never worked one day inside a traditional acute care hospital during the entire length of their nursing careers. How could this possibly happen? While I cannot speak for other nurses, I will provide an answer to the question that multiple people have asked: "Why don't you want to work at a major hospital?" Nurses General Nursing Article

I've been asked the same question by members of allnurses.com, real-life coworkers, and even some of my own family members: "Why aren't you interested in working at a major hospital?"

My relatively short nursing career consists of experience in long term care, rehabilitation (acute and sub-acute), and psych. For the past two and a half years I've been employed at a small specialty hospital that provides acute rehabilitation services, and to be honest, I think it's wonderful when a patient discharges to home with the ability to walk and talk when he was bedridden and unable to speak just two weeks ago.

My career is about to traverse into a new chapter when I enter the realm of developmental disabilities nursing starting next week. Twelve years ago, when I was 19 years old, I was employed as a direct care staff member and caregiver at a group home in a residential area that housed six developmentally disabled clients. I mostly enjoyed working with this particular patient population and will be thrilled to finally work as a nurse in this specialty.

Meanwhile, let's venture back to the original question. . .Why do I not want to work at a major hospital? Honest introspection is a major part of my career decision. In addition, my experiences while attending clinical rotations during nursing school at multiple hospitals in two different states cemented my choice to avoid acute care like the plague, especially after seeing how appallingly the nurses were being treated. After much painstaking self-reflection, I realize that an acute care hospital job is not for me. Some people would interject and say, "Well, you'll never know unless you try it!"

To be perfectly blunt, I know my personality is not compatible with acute care. I'm a mellow type B girl who does not like responding to codes. I dislike dealing with changes in condition. I detest taking off orders that constantly change on the whim of the doctor, nurse practitioner, or physician's assistant. I cannot stand constantly performing procedural skills such as IV starts, Foley catheter insertions, nasogastric tube drops, or blood draws. I despise having to drop what I'm doing to address a stat order. I do not look forward to constant interaction with physicians, families, dietary staff, visitors, RT, and other people.

I hate the liability involved with acute care. I do not enjoy the idea of not knowing exactly what I'm going to walk into. I do not like making decisions NOW, and in acute care the nurse must make decisions NOW. Acute care involves a pace with which I'm not comfortable. I'm not an adrenaline junkie. My preferences include low acuity patients, low liability, minimal stress, and the same old routine. I know that several years of acute care hospital experience would be vastly beneficial to my career as a nurse. After all, you don't know what you don't know. However, if I would likely be unhappy during those years, why follow through with it? If I could steer clear of the acute care hospital for the remainder of my career, I'd be content.

Some uninformed people insist that real nursing only takes place inside the walls of the acute care hospital setting. People can think whatever they darn well please. As long as I'm happy, secure, and comfortable with the work I'm doing, that's all that matters to me. Patients outside the hospital setting need nurses, too.

I wonder if part of the reason people are so adamant about new nurses needing to start out in med/surg and get that golden year of experience is because it's what they did...and what everyone told them to do...and what their professors had to do...etc, etc. I'm not saying it's always the case, because I'm sure there are people who chose to take the med/surg route when they had the opportunity to go straight into their specialty, but I think some people start out in med/surg because it's the only option available. So, instead of saying, "I couldn't get a job as a new grad in the specialty I want," they say, "I really wanted to start out in med/surg and get some experience."

I struggled with whether or not I should start out in med/surg even though I really wanted to do psych. I KNEW I wanted to do psych and that I would hate med/surg because I worked med/surg as an intern. Still, I had so many people say, "You should really get a year in med/surg as an RN," that it made me question my choices.

Ultimately, I chose to go with the job I've always wanted. I was talking to a nurse who works in psych about this very thing before I decided and she said, "I can't imagine getting paid what I get paid here (at the psych facility) to work on med/surg." I agreed. I worked on med/surg before, even though the role was different, I knew it would be almost constant high stress, very physically demanding, and I remember so many nurses saying, "I feel like my license is always on the line."

Who knows. Maybe one day I'll regret not getting that golden year of med/surg experience, but right now I highly doubt it. I don't think any nursing job is totally stress free, but mine is pretty laid back. I live in one of the lowest paid areas in the country and I don't feel as over worked and underpaid as many of my peers do. I dunno if I like my job because it's low stress, or if it's low stress because I like my job. Either way, I'm certain if I would've stayed in med/surg or anything like it (which was my plan as an intern) I would be completely miserable and burned out.

Specializes in Acute Care Psych, DNP Student.

To be perfectly blunt, I know my personality is not compatible with acute care. I’m a mellow type B girl who does not like responding to codes. I dislike dealing with changes in condition. I detest taking off orders that constantly change on the whim of the doctor, nurse practitioner, or physician‘s assistant. I cannot stand constantly performing procedural skills such as IV starts, Foley catheter insertions, nasogastric tube drops, or blood draws. I despise having to drop what I'm doing to address a stat order. I do not look forward to constant interaction with physicians, families, dietary staff, visitors, RT, and other people.

Some uninformed people insist that real nursing only takes place inside the walls of the acute care hospital setting. People can think whatever they darn well please. As long as I’m happy, secure, and comfortable with the work I’m doing, that’s all that matters to me. Patients outside the hospital setting need nurses, too.

What's interesting to me is the variation of practice within different nursing environments.

When I graduated from nursing school I consciously rejected acute care employment for many of the reasons you listed. I took a job at a correctional facility and found myself doing all of what you listed above - but without the backup a hospital provides. Many of our nurses at the prison went to the local hospital because they said the pace was too much at the prison. They liked med/surg at the local hospital because they said the pace of work was better. A couple joked they could "rest" in med/surg compared to our prison jobs.

Now I work acute care psych and find this hospital job is nothing compared to my previous non-hospital job.

I really don't care about uniformed nurses who think real nursing takes place inside a hospital - their narrow scopes and perceptions don't concern me.

Specializes in LTC and School Health.

Commuter- You have done it again.... Put my feelings into an article. I was told to start off in a hospital because "that is the right thing to do" as a new grad. Even though I had previous LPN experience prior to becoming a RN, I had a really hard time adjusting to the hosptial setting.

Stat orders, codes, critical labs, call lights, all memebers of the disciplinary team, rounding, and etc. It was overwhelming. I think I'm a mixture of A and B personality, mostly b though.

During my time in ICU, I thought this was just normal new grad blues but I was wrong. Working in ICU nearly drove me into an early grave. I was drinking wine almost 3-4 times a week, taking ativan, and just really really depressed. Ofcourse my co-workers didn't help with creating a hostile environment. I came to the realization that this specialty and type of nursing is NOT for me and doesn't fit my personality.

To test my theory, I interviewed and shawdowed at another ICU and felt the same way.

I typically like a routine with an occassional code to keep me on my toes. In ICU, I felt like I was putting out fires all day long. I have an offer pending for the ER, my husband tells me I shouldn't take the job because he knows my personality does not fit one of the ER. I agree with him, however I need a job.

I'm praying I get into PP or NBN. I think I would be excel in that area.

Specializes in LTC and School Health.

I'm tired of ER,ICU nurses thanking they are God. I used to hear my ICU co-workers put down every single specialty in the hospital. I would get so offended. Specialities are not a one size fits all. Everyone has their own unique gifts and talents that contributes to every area of nursing.

I'm tired of ER,ICU nurses thanking they are God. I used to hear my ICU co-workers put down every single specialty in the hospital. I would get so offended. Specialities are not a one size fits all. Everyone has their own unique gifts and talents that contributes to every area of nursing.

That's so weird. I don't get it. There are a few specialties I would never, ever want to work in but I really don't think about them at all...much less put down the people who work in them. That's just...odd.

That's so weird. I don't get it. There are a few specialties I would never, ever want to work in but I really don't think about them at all...much less put down the people who work in them. That's just...odd.

I don't understand, either. I know there are many specialties/settings in which I wouldn't want to work simply because I know I would not be a good fit.

I think every nurse has a specific calling. For example, one of my nursing friends says that she couldn't handle the ED, while I state I couldn't handle rehab nursing. But I believe we are where we both need to be to be the best nurses we can be. It is too bad that acute care seems to be glorified, but I really am grateful for all of you nurses who do the less "notorious" specialties. Nursing is an art and a science across the board, no matter where you practice or who receives your care.

Glad I'm not the only one to think this. I always dreaded my Med-Surg clinicals and thought "If this is where I have to be a nurse, I'm not sure I want to be a nurse." Then, I realized that I don't have to, well, unless it's my only choice. It's probably not that bad, but the patient load variances between various hospitals and units frighten me because there is always that chance that I never know how many patients I might have for the day. However, I would pick it over ICU, even though ICU has less patients. ICU is way too much. ER too. Slower paces, I say! However, I ultimately settled on OR being my specialty of choice. Go figure. I definitely appreciate the "one patient at a time" approach.

Specializes in Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation.

@ TheCommuter

Totally inspired by your experience as a 19 year old working in a disabled persons' facility and enjoyed reading your thread! I somewhat share that experience. A year ago I got a hourly job as a tutor at my community college while I was talking my GE's, but it was for the disabled students programs & services. Well actually, my technical title is Student Assistant III but my job consisted of tutoring disabled students (physically or mentally; severe or not) in all educational subjects and working with acquired brained injury (or ABI) students on memory programs. Not only was it AND still is (I'm still currently working there) a great experience in a different environment, I've come to admire both the people and the care takers. I'm currently a new nursing student (I start this coming spring); however, I do want to become a psychiatric nurse in the distant future, but I definitely see myself as a nurse in the psychiatric or disabled field. I DO want to head straight into ICU when I finished nursing school since I also work in the ICU/CCU as a lift team technician (or mobility technician) and I love the "thrill" and "adrenaline" and there is always something new every day :)

Just thought I'd share my experience as well hehe.

Specializes in Med Surg - Renal.

Great discussion of career choices.

In the end, you don't owe anyone an explanation for doing the work you enjoy doing.

Specializes in Med/Surg,Cardiac.

I've had ICU nurses tell me that they couldn't imagine the stress of taking 8 patients on the floor. Simultaneously I have nurses who are terrible if ever pulled to the units. I have found that I'm not sure where my passion is yet, but I've been blessed with a job where I love my coworkers and get to float around frequently and experience new specialties. I love talking to other nurses and hearing about where they've been and what specialties were their favorites.

I have worked at 2 major hospitals in my area and they have been the worst jobs I have had as a RN. We need to listen more to ourselves and not to other people's opinions of what we should do. I have been guilty of this in the past and they were bad experiences. Great thread to read.

I applaud you for your choice and for standing up for it. I wish you well and find fulfillment in what you do as a nurse.