The Hotel Phenomenon

Since when did flat screen TVs, overstuffed arm chairs, a multi-page food menu, and an almost concierge service become a major focus in modern day hospitals? Patient satisfaction IS a must, but I feel as if priorities are off considering there often isn’t enough equipment, OR HANDS, to go around. Which is most important?

Updated:  

It's 0700 and the night shift is scrambling to give report as us day-shifters struggle in with our coffee breath and slightly askew hair. Part of the way through the patient history of the terrible triad (coronary artery disease, diabetes, COPD...) I hear through the grapevine that not one, but BOTH of our CNAs have called out. My ears perk up like a hunting dog and I scramble. I interrupt my own report in order to find the best-working COW (computer on wheels) and a fully functioning dynamap. Of which I sadly realized was nowhere to be found. It makes for a terrible time post cardiac cath if all the MP-5s are claimed and there are no dynamaps equipped with all of the appropriate fixings (temperature, blood pressure, oxygen monitor). Needless to say, I felt as though I was drowning before the day had truly started. As report finished and we had rounded in each room, I could see the gleaming flat screen TV, the arm-chair full of overstuffed pillows, toiletries strewn about the room, and our 6-page menu stuck to the floor in some sort of goo. The manual blood pressure cuff on the wall was either falling off, missing parts, or not there at all and the thermometers on the walls wouldn't turn on. We were operating at a 5 to 1 flex ratio with patients post cardiac procedures, on a multitude of drips, BiPAPs buzzing, and rapid responses flooding in.

Where did this money come from?!

I am no expert in funds when it comes to profit and not for profit hospitals. My father always corrects me on the rant of "where did this money come from?!" "Where did THAT money come from?!" (He would tell me that it's from a different allocated fund). To be completely honest, I am sure that it does. What I would like to know is when did flat-screen TVs with more than just local cable and overstuffed armchairs become more important than an extra doppler on the unit? Or maybe an extra staff member?

A Shift In Healthcare

There has been a shift in healthcare in the last couple of decades (even the last hundreds of years). I sit and talk with my grandmother often who was a nurse when they sterilized the baby bottles in the NICU and had steel bedpans for the adults. Then, thermometers were made of glass (eek! mercury) and there were visiting hours. She explains the vast differences between the times on many accounts, and seems perplexed with "the way things are going".

In truth, there are many things that we are doing right. What I think is a good reminder to patients and their families is that we are at work to help heal and to help give comfort. Sometimes this means that you are going to miss your 2100 showing of "Blue Bloods" (though I do love a good mustache)! It's not that we don't want people to feel safe, comforted with mutual trust but we ALL do want to do a great job. Personally, I want to have the opportunity to catch your sepsis before your blood pressure tanks and your organs start to shut down. Is that so much to ask?

I know that nurses have difficulty allocating their time with the increased pressure from patient flow coordinators to "treat and get them out" or to address multiple social concerns and battles between family members. It's not for lack of trying. As a floor nurse, I get more calls about a TV not working, anger at not being able to have a diet with salt, frustration that someone forgot their iPhone cord and their phone is dead, or that the internet is terribly patchy and they can't watch Netflix. Like I said before, how do we fix the idea that hospitals are not hotels but rather places of healing that warrant a focused approach on labs, tests, assessment, addressing a plan of care, holistic approaches to care and outpatient follow up? Where is the line drawn?

In the past year I've had patients elope for cigarettes who've had NSTEMIs, invited friends to visit at the bedside to give heroin or cocaine IV through a PICC line (by barring the door, mind you), and get in a full-on yelling match with nurses because we sent a patient for an ultrasound and they missed "The Price is Right".

It is a difficult line for each one of us to walk. Communication is always key, but sometimes words can fail. I've explained on multiple accounts why we do the things we do, and how our number ONE priority is patient care and prevention. At times that trumps an extra lounger in your room, or me refusing you to have take-out when you are going for an EGD in the morning.

Do Patient Satisfaction Scores Improve?

Always in the back of my mind, I want to know when (if it hasn't already happened) will our interventions of prioritizing register in our patient satisfaction scores? Is there a differentiation between patients being dissatisfied with their stay due to things in the hospital's control, or rather that they didn't get to maintain their normal routines that warranted a hospital stay that likened a Hilton experience?

I don't write any of these things to accuse patients in any way or to declare that our duties as nurses do not include ADLs and kindness in our daily care. But the chatter continues between nursing professionals of the staffing shortages, equipment issues, and the stress of meeting expectations that seem to be near impossible to fulfill.

Where do we go from here? Where is the line? What is our place?

Should the nurses get surveys concerning how their hospital allocates funds and writes up scopes of practice? Should there be a public service announcement video for each patient and their family upon arrival notifying them of the hospital's roles in patient care and what their satisfaction surveys really mean for healthcare?

I know that this article is loaded with multiple issues, it is difficult to stay on task when one thing reflects another. But with all that said, the issues facing us today ARE focused on money, are reflected by patient satisfaction surveys and are loaded with resources dwindling and the expectations rising. So, my friends, what do we do next?

Here's my thought OP.

If one were to look at any administrator's home, there you would more than likely find big screens, interior designed concepts, and a fridge full of imported, organic yummies.

If you were to look in the average nurses home, although there may be some lovely things here and there, any number could be considered well loved and worn. With a fridge full of (for those of us who are a little bit type A) leftovers for quick suppers at 8pm.

In any administrators home, focus could be on "are the appetizers ready for my dinner party" and the average nurse "I hope someone filled and started the dishwasher"

In other words, administrators want to reflect lovely state of the art items that are going to make a patient make the facility money. Then they can receive their sometimes outrageous salaries, as they are marketing a brand.

Nurses, on the other hand, just want some HELP, equipment that actually WORKS, and patient focus to be on healing and highest functional level.

Why in the world would a patient want to leave cushy digs with people at their beck and call?

Until one has a top tier administrator that has actually been a bedside nurse and hires middle managers that have also been bedside nurses and who have the authority and say so in hiring enough help as well as being sure there's enough working clinical equipment, the trend of facilities that are like theme part accommodations will unfortunately continue.

I don't think we can compare a nursing job with a Starbuck job. They are both important but nurse job is more stressful because you are dealing with people lives. I personally believe that the line should be drawn about what certain things. Giving coffee , juice and ice cream to patient when you have a nurses aide and 6 to7 patient in the hospital is almost impossible. We want to do all those things to make the patient comfortable but sometimes it is difficult. Not having equipment is one of the big things but yet we have flat screen TV with multiple channel, room service with a menu. No thermometer, no BP cuff. Patient comes with the GI bleed, NG tube is place, but it takes a nurse an hour to find a wall suctioning device. The list goes on but yet we have unnecessary equipment for the beauty of the room.

bmegne said:
I don't think we can compare a nursing job with a Starbuck job. They are both important but nurse job is more stressful because you are dealing with people lives. I personally believe that the line should be drawn about what certain things. Giving coffee , juice and ice cream to patient when you have a nurses aide and 6 to7 patient in the hospital is almost impossible. We want to do all those things to make the patient comfortable but sometimes it is difficult. Not having equipment is one of the big things but yet we have flat screen TV with multiple channel, room service with a menu. No thermometer, no BP cuff. Patient comes with the GI bleed, NG tube is place, but it takes a nurse an hour to find a wall suctioning device. The list goes on but yet we have unnecessary equipment for the beauty of the room.

I'm so sorry you're in that situation--that just sounds unsafe. I'm kind of surprised that the Joint Commission would allow an organization to function without essential safety equipment.

bmegne said:
I don't think we can compare a nursing job with a Starbuck job. They are both important but nurse job is more stressful because you are dealing with people lives. I personally believe that the line should be drawn about what certain things. Giving coffee , juice and ice cream to patient when you have a nurses aide and 6 to7 patient in the hospital is almost impossible. We want to do all those things to make the patient comfortable but sometimes it is difficult. Not having equipment is one of the big things but yet we have flat screen TV with multiple channel, room service with a menu. No thermometer, no BP cuff. Patient comes with the GI bleed, NG tube is place, but it takes a nurse an hour to find a wall suctioning device. The list goes on but yet we have unnecessary equipment for the beauty of the room.

Customers were being compared, not nurses and baristas. ie if the school principal can have a fit in the drive thru imagine the fit thrown when there is some real stress.

What I said..

Quote
As far as unreasonable demands, in this society where I bet even a nurse has reacted to an imperfect latte (my daughter works at a coffee house, all walks of life have meltdowns over their custom drink not meeting expectations) I can see why people become unreasonable where the stress is higher than the drive thru. We are not ever going to go back to being satisfied with the 50's hospital environment. People just don't shut off their customer service expectations because they're inside hospital walls.

3rd poster who has misrepresented what I wrote.

Specializes in ICU.
Croweater said:
Your analogy between your daughter's job at Starbucks and a busy nurse is bogus. Nursing staff are highly trained individuals with responsibilities which is could land them in court if they make an error. I doubt if your daughter would be sued for a dodgy cup of coffee. Times have changed from when I started nursing in the 1970s, patients are much older, sicker, technology has exploded, staffing numbers reduced - yet expectations of nursing staff has remained the same. Only now, families believe that the hospital is an extension of their home and the nurses exist to serve their needs as well with an increasing level of hostility towards nursing staff from families that was not so evident years ago. People are in hospital because they are ill and need treatment unavailable at home. Expecting a nurse to wait until their tv programme has finished and generally treating nursing staff as an interruption to their social media activity is a reflection of the lack of manners exhibited by many people these days.

I will have to respectfully disagree with this. I worked in retail management for many years. You would not believe the stuff people do and say and threaten you with. One time a guy threatened to sue me for being racist. The reason I was deemed a racist you might ask? He wanted to buy a weight set and a weight bench. He wanted a discount because he was buying two items. I said I'm sorry but I'm not giving you a discount on that, these items are already on sale. He told me that if he was white, I would do it. I told him it didn't matter what color he was, I wasn't allowed to do it. He actually went and got the head of the NAACP to come back with him to the store. I was then threatened with a lawsuit, in which I promptly gave him our corporate number. He ended up with a discount and I was so mad.

Another guy threatened me that he was going to have me fired and was trying to come over the gun counter at me. Yes, the gun counter. The reason, you may wonder? He was trying to buy a shotgun. Federal law requires me to call the FBI for a background check. Sometimes, they would do a hold for anywhere from 15 minutes to 72 hours while they do a more indepth check. I'm not privy to any information as to why. I was not allowed to sell him the gun at that point. He then wanted someone else to buy the gun for him at that moment which is illegal and considered a straw purchase. He got so mad and was screaming and yelling at me and threatening me. I didn't have security to help him out. I finally had to call the police and he left. Not before telling me he was going to get me. I was scared to go to my car at night for months. That was stressful.

I also had a handgun pointed at me, while a young guy stole an entire rack on Nike sweatshirts and ran out of the store. Also stressful.

I get the point of several people saying it can't possibly be as stressful because we have people's lives in our hands. One of the reasons I won't go back to retail is I was tired of being yelled at for the most ridiculous things. Things that don't matter in life.

But, make no mistake, people lose their marbles all the time over anything. Those three stories are just a few of what I encountered over the years. Just a small fraction. People are serious about their coffee these days. I don't know why, it sounds silly, but they are. Or they have other crap going on in their lives and a wrong coffee order was the straw that broke the camel's back. I honestly think people should have to work in fast food or retail for a year of their lives to get an idea of what society can be like. It's not pretty.

That was not a good comparison at all. We can't compare life and food.

Specializes in ICU.
bmegne said:
That was not a good comparison at all. We can't compare life and food.

Why can't you? It is extremely stressful dealing with angry people. People want to sue you for absolutely everything these days. People will stand there and tell you they are going to have you fired for something that wasn't even your fault. When your family is depending on your job and people are constantly threatening you and calling you incompetent and other things, it is stressful. As I stated, people lose their marbles over the silliest things.

Everyone on the planet thinks they their job is the most stressful job ever. And no one understands how stressful their particular job is. And I know that being a nurse has it's own kind of stress, but in every job there is stress. I dated a guy who's job it was to ensure that all of the medical devices that were being produced in a company were sterile. He was a quality control. That could be an issue of life or death if an unsterile medical device made it's way into surgery. He took his stress to the extreme though. He worked about 30-35 hours a week and got paid very well. He was allowed to be late if he wanted, and he could leave early for appts and such. He basically made his own schedule. But he had people coming at him all day when he was in there and I'm sure it was stressful. Just as a man threatening to come after me because I couldn't sell him a gun was stressful. I was worried about my own life. Each and every job comes with it's own stress. It's all about how the individual deals with that stress.

Specializes in Med/Surg, Onc., Palliative/Hospice, CPU.

For my earlier post-- Anger from the patients/their families.. Thanks for that-- I was a bit general. ;)

Everything said here is true, and more! Response to the situation by management is to "make sure we maintain our patient/family satisfaction scores!" And we wonder why young RNs chose not to work at the bedside, and "old timers" are counting the days till retirement!!

bmegne said:
That was not a good comparison at all. We can't compare life and food.

But isn't that EXACTLY what administration does?!

Starbucks employees get min. wage, have orders screamed at them from a million directions, and I am quite sure it is NOT a "regular coffee" order....it is a two thumbs up and a half twist blend. Hot coffee drinks thrown at one, on one's feet for hours and hours....not my idea of a remote fun time. And if the customer is not"delighted" and the coffee put out is not what comes in monetarily, then the person loses their job.

Hospitals are business. The customer is always right. That they are also ill is irrelevant. Administration could care less if they are ill. They do, however, frown upon actually killing someone (if only for the lawsuit). Every questionnaire on which reimbursements are based is about their theme park esque experience. As opposed to "I was so sick, and the nurses made me well" it is "they were so rude to my Auntie Mary that I was outraged" (and if one is well enough to be outraged, they are well enough to be discharged.

Anyways....because this is a brand, a business, and a money maker....yup, there is a huge similarity between a hospital and a starbucks....only starbucks tend to be quite loyal to the employees that are loyal to their company. And seem to promote from within....we could use THOSE concepts in th health care industry. Heaven knows we use theme park analogy.

The first thing that popped out at me was the term "COW" for computer on wheels. We used to have cows but a patient overheard the word "COW", assumed we were talking about her and complained. Our 600+ bed hospital now use "WOWS", workstations on wheels. This sort of illustrates, to me, how pandering and ridiculous things have become. Never mind our Level one trauma certification, robotic assisted surgeries, lifesaving antibiotics, blood we hang, 60 minutes max door to Cath lab times, world-class neurosurgeons, pain specialist team, etc..people complain that our coffee isn't that great, they can't smoke, we cannot tell them exactly when each hospitalist an specialist will round,we don't feed free meals to visitors, on and on. It's insane. I'm a friendly compassionate and highly competent nurse, but sometimes the things that patients, and by extension TPTB care about is really out of control. The shift needs to get back to saving lives, a safe environment, healing, not trivial nonsense that boosts our satisfaction numbers. I am assuming this is more prevalent in the U.S., where we have turned into a bunch of entitled crybabies. The line needs to be drawn.

Specializes in ER.

About 18 months ago I had a pt trigger-happy on his call bell, because he wanted me to call the TV company and complain because the Steve Harvey Show was interrupted to give a newsflash that Nelson Mandela had died.

Seriously wanted me to stop what I was doing and make the call.

The hotel thing has just gone too far. When exactly did common sense become illegal? :no: