The Hotel Phenomenon

Since when did flat screen TVs, overstuffed arm chairs, a multi-page food menu, and an almost concierge service become a major focus in modern day hospitals? Patient satisfaction IS a must, but I feel as if priorities are off considering there often isn’t enough equipment, OR HANDS, to go around. Which is most important?

Updated:  

It's 0700 and the night shift is scrambling to give report as us day-shifters struggle in with our coffee breath and slightly askew hair. Part of the way through the patient history of the terrible triad (coronary artery disease, diabetes, COPD...) I hear through the grapevine that not one, but BOTH of our CNAs have called out. My ears perk up like a hunting dog and I scramble. I interrupt my own report in order to find the best-working COW (computer on wheels) and a fully functioning dynamap. Of which I sadly realized was nowhere to be found. It makes for a terrible time post cardiac cath if all the MP-5s are claimed and there are no dynamaps equipped with all of the appropriate fixings (temperature, blood pressure, oxygen monitor). Needless to say, I felt as though I was drowning before the day had truly started. As report finished and we had rounded in each room, I could see the gleaming flat screen TV, the arm-chair full of overstuffed pillows, toiletries strewn about the room, and our 6-page menu stuck to the floor in some sort of goo. The manual blood pressure cuff on the wall was either falling off, missing parts, or not there at all and the thermometers on the walls wouldn't turn on. We were operating at a 5 to 1 flex ratio with patients post cardiac procedures, on a multitude of drips, BiPAPs buzzing, and rapid responses flooding in.

Where did this money come from?!

I am no expert in funds when it comes to profit and not for profit hospitals. My father always corrects me on the rant of "where did this money come from?!" "Where did THAT money come from?!" (He would tell me that it's from a different allocated fund). To be completely honest, I am sure that it does. What I would like to know is when did flat-screen TVs with more than just local cable and overstuffed armchairs become more important than an extra doppler on the unit? Or maybe an extra staff member?

A Shift In Healthcare

There has been a shift in healthcare in the last couple of decades (even the last hundreds of years). I sit and talk with my grandmother often who was a nurse when they sterilized the baby bottles in the NICU and had steel bedpans for the adults. Then, thermometers were made of glass (eek! mercury) and there were visiting hours. She explains the vast differences between the times on many accounts, and seems perplexed with "the way things are going".

In truth, there are many things that we are doing right. What I think is a good reminder to patients and their families is that we are at work to help heal and to help give comfort. Sometimes this means that you are going to miss your 2100 showing of "Blue Bloods" (though I do love a good mustache)! It's not that we don't want people to feel safe, comforted with mutual trust but we ALL do want to do a great job. Personally, I want to have the opportunity to catch your sepsis before your blood pressure tanks and your organs start to shut down. Is that so much to ask?

I know that nurses have difficulty allocating their time with the increased pressure from patient flow coordinators to "treat and get them out" or to address multiple social concerns and battles between family members. It's not for lack of trying. As a floor nurse, I get more calls about a TV not working, anger at not being able to have a diet with salt, frustration that someone forgot their iPhone cord and their phone is dead, or that the internet is terribly patchy and they can't watch Netflix. Like I said before, how do we fix the idea that hospitals are not hotels but rather places of healing that warrant a focused approach on labs, tests, assessment, addressing a plan of care, holistic approaches to care and outpatient follow up? Where is the line drawn?

In the past year I've had patients elope for cigarettes who've had NSTEMIs, invited friends to visit at the bedside to give heroin or cocaine IV through a PICC line (by barring the door, mind you), and get in a full-on yelling match with nurses because we sent a patient for an ultrasound and they missed "The Price is Right".

It is a difficult line for each one of us to walk. Communication is always key, but sometimes words can fail. I've explained on multiple accounts why we do the things we do, and how our number ONE priority is patient care and prevention. At times that trumps an extra lounger in your room, or me refusing you to have take-out when you are going for an EGD in the morning.

Do Patient Satisfaction Scores Improve?

Always in the back of my mind, I want to know when (if it hasn't already happened) will our interventions of prioritizing register in our patient satisfaction scores? Is there a differentiation between patients being dissatisfied with their stay due to things in the hospital's control, or rather that they didn't get to maintain their normal routines that warranted a hospital stay that likened a Hilton experience?

I don't write any of these things to accuse patients in any way or to declare that our duties as nurses do not include ADLs and kindness in our daily care. But the chatter continues between nursing professionals of the staffing shortages, equipment issues, and the stress of meeting expectations that seem to be near impossible to fulfill.

Where do we go from here? Where is the line? What is our place?

Should the nurses get surveys concerning how their hospital allocates funds and writes up scopes of practice? Should there be a public service announcement video for each patient and their family upon arrival notifying them of the hospital's roles in patient care and what their satisfaction surveys really mean for healthcare?

I know that this article is loaded with multiple issues, it is difficult to stay on task when one thing reflects another. But with all that said, the issues facing us today ARE focused on money, are reflected by patient satisfaction surveys and are loaded with resources dwindling and the expectations rising. So, my friends, what do we do next?

Your analogy between your daughter's job at Starbucks and a busy nurse is bogus. Nursing staff are highly trained individuals with responsibilities which is could land them in court if they make an error. I doubt if your daughter would be sued for a dodgy cup of coffee. Times have changed from when I started nursing in the 1970s, patients are much older, sicker, technology has exploded, staffing numbers reduced - yet expectations of nursing staff has remained the same. Only now, families believe that the hospital is an extension of their home and the nurses exist to serve their needs as well with an increasing level of hostility towards nursing staff from families that was not so evident years ago. People are in hospital because they are ill and need treatment unavailable at home. Expecting a nurse to wait until their tv programme has finished and generally treating nursing staff as an interruption to their social media activity is a reflection of the lack of manners exhibited by many people these days.

Specializes in Med/Surg, Gyn, Pospartum & Psych.

I had a patient preparing to be discharged a few months ago. I can't remember her exact diagnosis but it wasn't a chronic condition that required frequent hospitalization. What I do remember is her saying that this was the least "nice" vacation she had ever taken in our hospital. Huh?? I suspect it was related to the fact we have been running at capacity for literally months and she didn't get a nice private room this time (not lucky enough to be put in isolation). I really did get the impression that this was her version of a vacation...lay in bed all day, room service for meals, and nursing staff to wait hand and food on her while her family callled and doted on her.

I am getting disturbed by the number of admits who do not need in patient nursing care that are ending up on our floor. It is almost like some of the patients are "professional patients" ... and I am not talking about those with diagnosed chronic conditions that have flare ups but rather the vague diagnoses that I am suspecting probably should have a psych consult along with a PT/OT consult. I have been caring for a "fever of unknown origin" patient for several days who has yet to have a temperature over 99.5 on this stay...EVEN at admission. She spent 2 weeks with us and returned on her two week home anniversary...ironically, same room. She won't let us weigh her because she "has too much water weight" and trust me, she isn't the 120-130 lbs that she declared at admission (she isn't overweight either though).

We also had a patient who was definitely ill but refused most treatment for two weeks. She dictated when and which medications she was going to take. Expected us to stand in her room while she went to the bathroom (took about 20 minutes) and when assisting her into bed, she told us exactly what parts of her body we could touch. I went in to do a dressing change and she announced her son had done it....and I didn't need to touch it (how do I chart that?). She told a new nurse (fresh grad) that it was her "responsibility as a nurse" to rub her back for 30 minutes when her back hurt at 4am. LOL. Can I say she told me that she didn't need her cholesterol medication because she was managing it "with her diet" AS she ate fried chicken out of a fast food box her son had brought her.

I also had a 30 year old woman throw a hissy fit over dietary not allowing her to order bacon for breakfast when her diet was "cardiac". For some reason, she thought I had the power to change the diet order. She said couldn't eat anything else because only bacon sounded good. I simply told her to talk to her doctor when he/she came through later in the day....but she still whined that breakfast would be over by then.

Croweater said:
Your analogy between your daughter's job at Starbucks and a busy nurse is bogus. Nursing staff are highly trained individuals with responsibilities which is could land them in court if they make an error. I doubt if your daughter would be sued for a dodgy cup of coffee. Times have changed from when I started nursing in the 1970s, patients are much older, sicker, technology has exploded, staffing numbers reduced - yet expectations of nursing staff has remained the same. Only now, families believe that the hospital is an extension of their home and the nurses exist to serve their needs as well with an increasing level of hostility towards nursing staff from families that was not so evident years ago. People are in hospital because they are ill and need treatment unavailable at home. Expecting a nurse to wait until their tv programme has finished and generally treating nursing staff as an interruption to their social media activity is a reflection of the lack of manners exhibited by many people these days.

You missed the whole point.

The analogy wasn't between nurses and baristas (seriously?). It was about our attitudes towards customer service in general and the outrageous expectations we've developed, from our $$ coffee to healthcare service, it doesn't just shut off when we're admitted to your unit.

There are articles and news reports on electronics and social media dependence, I would think some of these behaviors could be related and that the consequence is coming out even while an inpatient.

I've had middle aged and older patients literally reach for their ringing cell phone when I'm in the middle of a procedure, it's like they cannot not answer their phones. I've had to say, Hey, hold still! as I'm drawing blood or changing a PICC dressing. I don't believe they do it out of rudeness or disrespect.

Oh goodness AutumnApple, I would have been absolutely livid! I feel like society in general needs to be educated. Right after you take your constitution test in high school, you get handed a hospital etiquette test :sarcastic: Seriously though, the general problem seems to be that people do not have the proper definition of what a hospital is and what it's goals are.

"We're very sorry your shoes were destroyed. Good thing you're ALIVE so that you can buy another pair. I hear ghosts don't get to buy shoes."

I think it should be our job to educate patients about what is best for them, and if they do not do it, chart that the patient refuses, and send them home. Healthcare is not a right to people who do not want to follow best practice.

Specializes in Med/Surg, Onc., Palliative/Hospice, CPU.

Your stories are blowing my mind! I thought I had a pretty good collection, but man! Keep up the comments, I am sitting to read multiple times a day everyone-- Thank you! You are giving me much food for thought. Does anyone else feel as though they are strong in the workplace, standing up for the right thing, but then find themselves derailed when you have been told that in being honest that your customer service is poor? (I've heard this on multiple occasions, mind you-- which is why I feel inclined to ask!)

Specializes in Med/Surg, Gyn, Pospartum & Psych.
synaptic said:
I think it should be our job to educate patients about what is best for them, and if they do not do it, chart that the patient refuses, and send them home. Healthcare is not a right to people who do not want to follow best practice.

Now we better be careful on this one....what is "best" for a patient might only be an opinion of what WE believe is best for them. We are not living in their skin. This is no different that realizing what is best for a patient with an infection might actually harm their kidneys or liver...so while we BELIEVE that something is best considering the options...someone else might rather risk dying of the infection over living with dialysis for the remainder of their lives. It isn't our place to dictate the best decision....just to let them know what rules exist IF they want to receive our help. They don't get to dictate their diet IF they want to be treated under the plan we suggest and recommend. IF they want that ultrasound of their kidneys done while getting in-patient care, it will be done on OUR schedule not at their convenience.

Specializes in SICU, trauma, neuro.
Jacqueline.Damm said:
Does anyone else feel as though they are strong in the workplace, standing up for the right thing, but then find themselves derailed when you have been told that in being honest that your customer service is poor? (I've heard this on multiple occasions, mind you-- which is why I feel inclined to ask!)

I'm not sure I understand the question. Let's take my example of the woman who asked for a hospital gown and toiletries for her sister, and became angry when I told her we're not able to do that. The sister told the pt, "ask her to speak to a supervisor. She's just a nurse."

Do you mean when we're met w/ anger from the pt/family?

I ignored the "just a nurse" comment, and assured them that I would get my supervisor. I immediately went to my charge RN, told him what happened and that they are asking for a supervisor. He promptly went to them and advised them that I was accurate that we are not permitted to give supplies to family (I'll also clarify that this wasn't a rule-breaking situation. She'd been admitted to the ICU postop for observation, was rock stable and transferred to the floor the next a.m.) They ranted for a minute, and he said "I wish it was different, but this is how it is. If you want to speak to my boss, her name is [her name.] She will be here in the morning."

No, I didn't get rattled by their anger.

Or do you mean, told by our superiors that our customer service is poor? In 12.5 years of nursing, I have never once been told my customer service was poor. Not once.

And I've never pandered to nonsense.

Specializes in ED; Med Surg.

What I don't understand...if you come to the hospital, are admitted and refuse: antibiotics, ambulation, PT/OT, dictate to me when your labs will be drawn...etc. etc. etc.

WHY did you seek medical attention? I support wholeheartedly your right to refuse but don't take a bed from someone who needs it and our help.

blackribbon said:
I am getting disturbed by the number of admits who do not need in patient nursing care that are ending up on our floor.

I have the opposite issue. I work in a SNF/LTC and we get way too many admits who would've still been in the hospital even five years ago.

Specializes in Med/Surg, Gyn, Pospartum & Psych.
Izzy11 said:
I have the opposite issue. I work in a SNF/LTC and we get way too many admits who would've still been in the hospital even five years ago.

I actually was referring to people who will walk out of the hospital and head straight to the restaurant to get the food we would not allow them to eat while being so "nauseated" and crippled by pain...not those that need skilled nursing. Some may just need a good caregiver but not inpatient hospital care.