Patient Complaints In Spite of Good Care

Nurses General Nursing

Published

Hello all! Recently a patient complained to his aunt that his night nurse "didn't care about me". This was a confused patient, admitted for flu-like symptoms, fever, etc. I noticed the patient was very angry by the morning, but did not feel as though he had been neglected by any means, he had been fluffed and puffed, brought anything he requested in the way of drinks, etc., and auntie had been taken care of as well, by given free access to the patient outside of regular visiting hours, offered drinks and snacks, pillow and blankets etc. I informed the supervisor that he had complained, and thought no more of it. Long story short, my director called me in and suspended me for "not taking care of the patient." In report, I was told a different story about the patient than what was reflected, but I documented everything I had been told regarding the plan of care for the patient, and documented everything that was done. I felt my suspension displayed a true lack of support for nursing staff, and I resigned. I have always had excellent reviews from my patients, peers and supervisors wherever I have worked. I felt hurt and humilated that this happened, and that any patient can wreak havoc on an unsuspecting nurse. However, I am happy to be "out" from under this particular manager, who, of course has a string of credentials, but no heart for her staff. I am only one of a stream of nurses to resign since she came on board a year ago. If any one has been through this and has advice for me, I would love to hear a word of encouragement. I also would like to stop having feelings of anger toward the director. After all, perhaps she did me a favor.

vivere:crying2:

Specializes in Management, Emergency, Psych, Med Surg.

You know, some managers just don't know how to manage their way out of a paper bag. Now there may be other issues here that we don't know about. But when I used to get patient complaints I used to at least talk to the staff member and get their side of the story, or even before that, ask some of the other staff how it was going with that particular patient and family. Usually I would go talk to them myself so I could assess for myself if they were crazy or not. Some people are going to complain no matter what you do. You could be walking on water and they would not be happy. So who knows. But I think suspension is extreme. In one hospital where I used to work, we had a customer service class. If we had someone who needed communication help, we sent them to the customer service training class. Sometimes it helped, sometimes not.

Specializes in Staff nurse.
You know, some managers just don't know how to manage their way out of a paper bag. Now there may be other issues here that we don't know about. But when I used to get patient complaints I used to at least talk to the staff member and get their side of the story, or even before that, ask some of the other staff how it was going with that particular patient and family. Usually I would go talk to them myself so I could assess for myself if they were crazy or not. Some people are going to complain no matter what you do. You could be walking on water and they would not be happy. So who knows. But I think suspension is extreme. In one hospital where I used to work, we had a customer service class. If we had someone who needed communication help, we sent them to the customer service training class. Sometimes it helped, sometimes not.

Could we maybe have a class for patients and their visitors on Hospital Etiquitte; What to expect; What NOT to expect; your rights as a patient; your Responsibilities as a patient; your role as a visitor?

Maybe a short film on what the nurse does: get new admit: access; do new orders; IV & tests; meds; waiting for pharm to enter meds; interruptions in nursing (codes, falls, fire alarms etc). This is not making excuses...some people really thing that each patient has his/her own nurse. I've heard comments like "I want to go back to ICU, the service there is better"...

Specializes in Rehab, Infection, LTC.

omg we work for the same woman!

Specializes in ICU.
Your manager is a moron. Consider this a blessing in disguise.

LOL Thank you. I am considering it as a blessing and although I miss my co-workers, I am now relieved about the ending. I am still concerned about the pay cut, but got rid of my boyfriend also, so I will actually end up just fine. Lots of changes going on, and I am glad about it. Thanks for your support.

memento vivere:redbeathe

Specializes in ICU.
omg we work for the same woman!

LOL....i don't think so...but its crazy to think that just because someone has an advanced degree, they can move into management and do a good job. my manager had no clue. She loved to talk about how she loves ICU nursing, but she hadn't taken care of patients in YEARS! (thank the Lord)

Specializes in ortho, hospice volunteer, psych,.

patients and visitors do complain for some pretty dippy reasons sometimes. i'm so sorry about your situation. is there an appeals process?

the two strangest (i think) complaints lodged against me were:

1. i refused to cut up a piece of chicken into small bite-sized pieces:eek: for an able bodied 16 year old male, whose arm and hand worked just fine, thank you. complaint was by his over protective mother.

2. i polished my nursing shoes but did not polish the laces or put in new ones.:banghead: that complaint was from

a charge nurse who had been a nurse in wwii and korea.

good luck!

kathy

sharpeimom:paw::paw:

my gosh, is it me or do all the whackos end up in nsg??

viv, it sounds like a lot is going on with you.

wishing you strength, faith and peace on your journey now and always.

leslie

Specializes in Rodeo Nursing (Neuro).

The thing about being dumped by a mean, ugly girlfriend (I suppose it's similar for boyfriends) is that you are bound to wonder, at some point, Gee, if she didn't want me, how big a loser must I be? But within a few weeks, all you are is glad to be out of it.

Same with crappy jobs. Besides, you resigned, so you dumped them.

Good for you.

It's a good thing you resigned, suspensions are typically followed by termination. Unfair? Sure, but it sounds like you're the scapegoat. Anyway, good riddance! You don't want to work for a fruitcake/terror like her.

Best wishes,

DeLana

Agreed. And you have the support of all of us on this board. We have all been there, and it could have been any one of us. Some people are just unhappy, and will complain in order to bring others down with them to their level. I am glad you resigned, it is not worth it to let others determine that you have lesser worth.

vivere, that just stinks. don't let it get you down. you know in your heart that you provided excellent care to your patient.

your manager can...well, what kathy griffin says.

wait, your EX-manager!

i hope you will find a workplace where you're appreciated.:heartbeat

You said that you are one of many to resign. That says to me that it is an 'it's either you or me' attitude & you are one of many that become the scapegoat under this manager. It is a shame; but, there are many places like this. Hoping someday, somewhere, someone, will realize the problem lies with the management and not the worker in the pit.

Sometimes managers are brought in to "clean house" if a unit has a record of complaints, etc. Not saying that this is the case here, because it doesn't sound like it.

A number of people leaving after a regime change isn't all that unusual. If the new folks leave then it's a different animal.

Unfortunately, many places--and not just in health care--don't give supervisors much if any training on how to supervise and manage.

+ Add a Comment