Is It Too Demeaning to be a CNA?

Nurses Nurse Beth

Published

Dear Nurse Beth,

Changing Careers.
So my question is in two folds?

1) I barely have a science background maybe a little algebra but basically both my bachelors and Masters is in the communications filled. Now I am thinking of switching careers because I just feel nursing is a really rewarding career and I get to help people which I love. I guess my question is how hard will it be for somebody like me who has never been taught the sciences?
2) I am also thinking of starting in the health field by becoming a CNA.. is this a good idea or is it too demeaning (like I have been told it is)?


Dear Changing Careers,

You are already accomplished, and the studying part should be doable for you. You will have to take pre-requisites, which include chemistry, physiology, and anatomy. They are challenging classes in that you have to study, but nothing you can't do if you're determined.

Your belief that being a CNA is demeaning is a huge concern, though. It's understandable you have no idea about the healthcare field since you've had no exposure, but we work as a team. Doctors, nurses, assistants- all of us.

But having no understanding of the roles or prior experience is no excuse for believing CNA work is demeaning. It's a privilege to care for sick people, protect their dignity, make them comfortable and clean.

Yes, my advice to you is to work as a CNA. Whatever romanticized and unrealistic filters you are seeing through now will change, I guarantee it. One tip- when you land your CNA job, don't tell any co-workers how you really feel.

Best wishes,

Nurse Beth

Author, "Your Last Nursing Class: How to Land Your First Nursing Job"...and your next!

3 minutes ago, Crash_Cart said:

To my knowledge, EMT's are trained to work calls from an ambulance and CNA's work with patients in a hospital.

I recently took a BLS class and the trainer is an EMT who told me that after getting her EMT she worked as an emergency room tech in the ED at the local children's hospital. I have also seen many postings for positions at my local hospitals that PCT's can be either CNA's or EMT's. It also seems to me that most often CNA's work in nursing homes. Aside from the difference of where one works, what difference in job functions would make one more useful for a career in nursing? What is missing from being exposed to "nursing" as you said?

Specializes in ER OR LTC Code Blue Trauma Dog.
1 hour ago, Crash_Cart said:

Good luck.

I don’t know if it’s your intent, but you are coming off as rather rude. I’m asking so if I would greatly benefit from being a CNA as opposed to an EMT I can know that before entering into a program for either of those.

2 hours ago, Crash_Cart said:

To my knowledge, EMT's are trained to work calls from an ambulance and CNA's work with patients in a hospital.

The Emergency Room where I work hires EMTs as techs too.

CNA here. If you think CNA work is demeaning, you have no idea how important CNAs actually are, especially in SNFs (skilled nursing facilities). I don't know what care facilities are like in other states, but at SNFs where I live CNAs are the eyes/ears/boots on the ground and care facilities would literally not run without us. Our work is the farthest thing from glamorous, but as Nurse Beth stated - it is absolutely an honor to care for those who are sick and dying. Some days are amazing. Some days are hard and frustrating. But you will learn so much.

Specializes in ER OR LTC Code Blue Trauma Dog.
55 minutes ago, beekee said:

The Emergency Room where I work hires EMTs as techs too.

Regardless where they might work, EMT's are trained to be first responders.

Their training consists of learning how to drive an ambulance, respond to 911 calls, operate two way radio equipment, extricate patients from motor vehicles, apply emergency equipment such as MAST pants, thomas splints, cervical collars, spinal boards, interpret EKG's, use cardiac monitors etc etc etc.

However, that still doesn't mean EMT's are trained to provide any bedside patient care like a CNA ("Nursing Assistant") does. EMT's are simply not trained to work with patients in a hospital nursing unit environment.

Spin it any way you want, but they just aren't and the idea that anyone would gain a nursing education from becoming an EMT first responder is flawed thinking. Please reconsider this approach.

Specializes in Geriatrics, Dialysis.

It is not in the very least little bit demeaning to be a CNA. Quite the opposite in fact. Caring for those who can't care for themselves is an honorable job. What it isn't however is a high paying job. Unless you are in a fairly low income profession for somebody with a Masters degree it will a serious cut in pay for you. If you decide to go down that path before starting nursing while I highly recommend it you will probably be looking at some decent adjustments in lifestyle just to make ends meet. I would suggest before you commit to this idea that you crunch some numbers and make sure you can afford to.

10 hours ago, kbrn2002 said:

It is not in the very least little bit demeaning to be a CNA. Quite the opposite in fact. Caring for those who can't care for themselves is an honorable job. What it isn't however is a high paying job. Unless you are in a fairly low income profession for somebody with a Masters degree it will a serious cut in pay for you. If you decide to go down that path before starting nursing while I highly recommend it you will probably be looking at some decent adjustments in lifestyle just to make ends meet. I would suggest before you commit to this idea that you crunch some numbers and make sure you can afford to.

I know I mentioned having my masters degree, so I don't know if this was directed towards my comments which I realize is steering this thread away from the OP. I'm already barely getting by with my master's degree because I'm not working in my field. I currently work 3 jobs (1 full-time, 2 part-time) and because of all the debt I've accumulated in earning my previous degrees, it's just not enough. I get that being a CNA doesn't pay well and certainly doesn't pay what a CNA deserves. I come from working in education/social services so I'm very much used to not being paid well. I also know that for my sanity, staying in a slightly better paying job that is completely unfulfilling is not helping me either.

I have read through what has been written and it is obvious that being a CNA does not really appeal to you. So I believe if you become a CNA you will get burned out fast. I suggest that you look into the EMT, or CMA programs.

Specializes in Critical Care; Cardiac; Professional Development.

EMT isn't going to get you what you are looking for, if being exposed to nursing is the goal. Generally they can be hired to be an ER technician, but they don't get hired elsewhere in the hospital and exposure to nursing in general will be minimal unless you get one of those coveted ER jobs.

Which is better, being an EMT and getting healthcare experience or sitting in an office, staring at computer, being taunted by talking to students who are out there doing what I'm itching to do?

+ Add a Comment