TV shows and movies that are ruined, because you know better - page 4
by HollyHobby 18,313 Views | 68 Comments
So many TV shows and movies take place, at least in part, in a medical setting. When you're a nurse, you automatically notice the severe errors in the scenery, which ruins the show. Or maybe it's just me. I was watching the... Read More
- 3Mar 29, '10 by zamboniI have just discovered what is my new favorite-of-all-time show..."24". We're watching the back seasons on DVD while keeping up with the current (and sadly, last) season. I am so happy to report that in an older episode, Jack Bauer finds an unconscious person (trying not to spoil here), and performs a picture perfect assessment, followed by proper CPR (proper by AHA standards in the early 2000s). When he's trying to keep someone alive that's been shot or stabbed, he uses direct pressure and pressure points (while screaming at them to give up what they know!). It was hysterical, because when he did the CPR, my boyfriend (who always cringes, waiting on my critique) looked over at me...I simply smiled and nodded. They "worked a code" in a clinic that was fairly spot on, although they gave up kinda quickly (in their defense, if I was working that code on someone with that much trauma, I would have bailed out too). I even predicted the intra-cardiac Epi dose before they did it...and given the situation, it's probably exactly what I would have done in real life (should I ever find myself in that ridiculous a situation...).
It makes me happy that a show that uses any reality as a loose definition would go to the trouble to do simple little things like that right. And even though Jack survives being shot, stabbed, tortured, electrocuted, beaten, crashes, radiation exposure and bio-weapon exposure...I believe that would probably happen in real life too. Him doing proper CPR was probably the hottest thing I've ever seen on TV.
- 0Mar 30, '10 by Bill E. RubinQuote from RADIATIONRN2BEJust like "House" where the team does brain surgery, open heart surgery, medical diagnoses and management, oncology, etc, etc.I always crack up when shows like Mercy (I know, I know, it is an awful show about nurses) has one physician who seems to specialize in everything. I work in oncology and I was mad that they had the crazy physician prescribe chemo for one patient while also treating a girl who had an STD down the hall and another neuro patient next door.
And there are only three nurses who seem to always work the same shifts and who always have weekends free. I admit to liking Mercy, even though it's inaccurate. I also understand in the name of entertainment that it's easier to follow a smaller number of characters and to make the plots interesting, the types of situations these characters experience is made ridiculously diverse. Still, it makes me chuckle.
- 0Mar 30, '10 by RADIATION_RNI agree cityhawk, as much as the inaccuracies of Mercy bug me so much, I have gotten into it. I just wish they wouldn't have made Chloe a "new" nurse with a masters degree. I would think someone with a masters degree in nursing wouldn't seem so naive about everything. It's like she went through all that schooling with no clinicals! hehe!
- 2Mar 30, '10 by CT PixieWatched Nurse Jackie last night..both Jackie and Zoe had to use their stethescope..both did so..putting the ear pieces in the WRONG way. Before I could even yell out (like I always do..its a pet peeve of mine) "TURN THEM AROUND..!!" My husband (non-medical..in all ways) shouts out "Jeeze, turn them around, they are backwards" I nearly spit out my water!
- 3Apr 14, '10 by niteniteOne of the things that also drives me nuts is when you hear ventilator sounds and the camera pans over and the pt just has a cannula and a couple of IV's.
Also, can't forget pt's who've been in comas forever who still somehow have perfect makeup and hair
- 0Apr 16, '10 by jmwsinpcDon't even get me stated on Grey's Anatomy and the MASS amounts of things that I scream at the TV on every episode. BTW, this show was voted as the WORST show on TV for prortrayals or nurses and nursing. Wonder why? When was the last time you saw a bunch of surgery interns take vital signs and do I/O's? LOL
Where are the nurses? Oh wait, they are in the closet having sex with the docs or they are striking outside. Other than that, you don't see them. SICKENING. BTW...WHERE ARE ALL THE CNA'S???? THEY DON"T EXIST!!!!!
The first Army Wives this past week, when the nurse gave D's son the pills in the hospital ,and he was baker acted? The nurse watching didn't even look up! The nurse with his meds didn't check to make sure he had actually taken the pills and not cheeked them(which of course, he did). STUPID!!! THAT WOULD NEVER BE ALLOWED! DUH! You always check the cheeks and under the tongue. You make sure. And no way would the sitter nurse be not watching the kid and texting in the corner. Sheesh. I work as a CNA in Ortho/Neuro. I am pre- LPN. My fiancee is a CNA as well as an RN student and we both work PRN at a mental hospital when we need extra hours. We would SO get fired and loose our CNA licenses for that. Rediculous.
- 1Apr 16, '10 by talaxandraQuote from HollyHobbyOMG - that drives me the most nuts, that an entire film premise is based on an easily checked, massively wrong 'fact'.Oh, and remember the movie Flatliners? The premise was these medical students (or whoever) would put each other into a deathlike state, then debifrillate them back to life- from asystole. You don't shock asystole!
A film-making former friend asked me to act as medical adviser for a script he was writing. He included defibrillating an asystolic girl - when I read it (while having my hair done) I literally said aloud, "No! Nooooooooooo!" I gave him alternatives, including having a character say "It could be fine VF..." but he was adamant that she wouldn't really be dead (and therefore brought back to life) unless she was DC reverted. So I withdrew permission for my name to be included as an adviser.
And in the 1994 Russell Cowe/Jack Thompson film The Sum of Us there's a scene where dad's in hospital after a stroke - the camera pans across the (ridiculously enormous) ICU room past the ventilator to the (bed rails lowered) bed, where dad has... nasal prongs in situ. Which promptly broke my willing suspension of disbelief, along with that of every other nurse and doctor in the cinema. WHich was a particular shame as it was a hospital find raising event
- 1May 7, '10 by dandk1997RNI LOVE watching House (seriously, who doesn't love an angst ridden bad boy who can play piano?) but it makes me crazy. I can not STAND IT when those doctors do every single procedure the patient needs. AS IF! It also really, REALLY bugs me when they mispronounce medical terminology.
My husband, who happens to be a tv producer, keeps telling me I need to deal with the "suspension of disbelief," which just makes me even crazier.
- 1May 12, '10 by HollyHobbyEven on "real" medical shows, like Trauma: life in the ER, I get p***** off. I'm an ICU nurse. In these shows, the patient spends a bit of time in the ER and then CT and then surgery, then the next thing you know, he's recovering and ready to go home.
What happened to the two or four or ten weeks the patient spent in the ICU? What about the ICU nurses who worked their hinders off trying to save the guy? Not to mention the physical therapists, dieticians, CNAs, etc etc.
It's like this person came in horribly injured, but thanks to the ER staff (and they deserve credit of course, but not ALL the credit) the patient is on his way home. The ER nurse may spend maybe a few hours with that patient, the ER doc may spend an hour total, but the ICU nurse spends weeks or MONTHS with the patient. But the ER doctor (who is often snappish and rude) gets all the credit for saving the life.
It just gets my undies in a bundle.