TV shows and movies that are ruined, because you know better

Published

So many TV shows and movies take place, at least in part, in a medical setting. When you're a nurse, you automatically notice the severe errors in the scenery, which ruins the show. Or maybe it's just me.

I was watching the very first episode of ER (as a rerun, this is fairly recently) where the nurse- what was her name? I'm getting old- OD'd and was brought into the ER on a stretcher. I jumped off the couch and started shouting, "Chest tubes?!? She has two Atrium chest tubes there. For a drug overdose???"

It seems like the directors of these shows assume that the more medical-looking stuff they throw in there, the more realistic it will seem.

On TV, the "patient" almost always has his O2 cannula on incorrectly. And I can't count how many times I've seen the actor-patient surrounded by medical equipment that is totally irrelevant to his illness. Oh, there's a vent nearby, and some vent tubing on the bed, for no apparent reason. Sometimes you'll see an EKG monitor in the background and the rhythm displayed there totally doesn't match what's going on with the "patient". (Many times, it's a fatal rhythm, but the patient is alert and talking.)

And the IV pumps/ bags etc... It's all wrong, all wrong, and I can't stand it.

Also, I'm a huge Stephen King fan, but in two of his books he has patients who are on ventilators who suddenly wake up and start talking... with the ventilator still in place. (The Dead Zone, and Desperation.)

It also chaps my ### when the nurse is wearing whites, with a skimpy white skirt, with a white nurse's cap... in a modern day setting. (If the movie is taking place in 1970, that's different, but I'm talking about shows set in modern times.) Inevitably, if the nurse says anything at all, it is something stupid.

Has anyone else been irritated or enraged by things like this? Or am I just over the edge?

I do not watch medical shows.. I can remember watching different (old) drama shows and the 'nurses' are always shown getting off work, getting into their cars and gosh if they don't have on their little white caps. When I wore a cap it was not allowed to wear them out of the hospital. And why would you want to?? Also the poor victim dies and everyone rushes up and someone says 'he's dead'. No CPR, no call 911. Just 'he's dead', then the police show up. I watched a Clint Eastwood movie, he'd had a heart transplant, his surgeon was furious because he had a fever, did blood work, in the exam room, no gloves, no sterile procedure, visitor in the room walking around, and showed the cath going into the new heart. Maybe now we know why he had fever...

Specializes in Psych (25 years), Medical (15 years).

In the movie "Mud", the ER sent home a 14 y/o boy treated for a snake bite while still unconscious.

Of course, had the ER not​ sent the boy to his houseboat home, Matthew McConaughey (Mud) wouldn't have been able to visit the boy, the Bad Guys set out to kill Mud couldn't have tracked him down, and Sam Shepard could not have picked off the Bad Guys from across the river!

In some circumstances, the plot supersedes keeping a Patient for observation after treatment for a life-threatening trauma!

Specializes in Psych (25 years), Medical (15 years).
My favorite was one time on Greys, I think it was Arizona, told a patient they had "psoriasis" of the liver

Oh no!

Specializes in Psych (25 years), Medical (15 years).
I had a doctor in real life that actually came in and did all his own vital signs!! I was about 20 then and I was astonished!! That doctor is still around and has too full of a load of patients to take anymore. He was great he was a doctor for all the right reasons. What a gem.

Few and far between, littlelimabean!

When I worked in OR about 25 years ago, the Surgeon, Dr. M, would stay around and help clean up afterwards!

Thereafter, I worked in a little rural 19 bed Hospital, in ER and Med/Surg, with Dr. C. He was a GP, an ERP, a Surgeon, and even did the anesthesia for the other town Physician during surgeries, Dr. P.!

I currently work with a Nurse Extern from that town and he informed me that that Dr. C has since retired.

However, Dr. P still practices. The Nurse Extern told a story where a Patient had to help Dr. P stand up after a routine exam!

+ Join the Discussion