Lifestyle Discrimination

Nurses Activism

Published

Should lifestyle discrimination be legal ? With the rising cost of healthcare, companies are looking for ways to save money. Across the US, many companies, including hospitals, are refusing to hire employees who's lifestyle is deemed to be high risk.

Users of tobacco, though perfectly legal, are being told that they aren't entitled to have a job because they smoke or chew tobacco. And many supporters of this new type of discrimination are living very high risk lifestyles themselves. Although they may not yet be aware, companies know when they've stumbled on to something that increases their profits. Eventually, many other groups will be added to the list of unacceptable lifestyles, including those who are over-weight, drink alcohol, poor eating habits, etc. And with advancements in genetic testing and lifestyle screening, the practice of refusing to hire, refusing to insure, or denying many of the opportunities that were once equally available to all, might very well be the way of things to come in America.

How bad does the discrimination have to get before people will begin to recognize it for what it truly is, and take action to stop it?

Specializes in ER, ICU.

Should lifestyle discrimination be legal ?

I wouldn't call it discrimination, but yes, when it is a proven health hazard. Smoking and obesity are both bad for your health. As nurses, we are educated on how to teach clients the benefits of a healthy lifestyle. Ethically, we should model those behaviors. As an employer I would choose the employee who modeled healthy behaviors over the one who did not. It is also proven that people who smoke or are obese use more health care dollars. Employers have the right to try and cut costs by avoiding high cost employees.

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
Should lifestyle discrimination be legal ?

I wouldn't call it discrimination, but yes, when it is a proven health hazard. Smoking and obesity are both bad for your health. As nurses, we are educated on how to teach clients the benefits of a healthy lifestyle. Ethically, we should model those behaviors. As an employer I would choose the employee who modeled healthy behaviors over the one who did not. It is also proven that people who smoke or are obese use more health care dollars. Employers have the right to try and cut costs by avoiding high cost employees.

Whether or not you would call it discrimination, that's what it IS. And if you think you can tell by looking at a nurse whether or not she/he models healthy behaviors, you are sadly mistaken.

Specializes in Critical Care,Recovery, ED.

Agree that it is discrimination. It also doesn't decrease health care costs overall. It just shifts the costs from an individual employer, thus increasing THEIR profit margin, to society was a whole. Whether it be to some other employer (competitor) or to governmental programs the societal costs will still be there.

Should lifestyle discrimination be legal ?

I wouldn't call it discrimination, but yes, when it is a proven health hazard. Smoking and obesity are both bad for your health. As nurses, we are educated on how to teach clients the benefits of a healthy lifestyle. Ethically, we should model those behaviors. As an employer I would choose the employee who modeled healthy behaviors over the one who did not. It is also proven that people who smoke or are obese use more health care dollars. Employers have the right to try and cut costs by avoiding high cost employees.

I wish there was a Frowny Face Dislike Post button. I'd be clicking the heck out of it on this. This is utter nonsense. What you would call it doesn't matter, because it IS discrimination. There are so many things wrong with your post, I am tired just thinking about rebutting your points.

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
I wish there was a Frowny Face Dislike Post button. I'd be clicking the heck out of it on this. This is utter nonsense. What you would call it doesn't matter, because it IS discrimination. There are so many things wrong with your post, I am tired just thinking about rebutting your points.

Yes, yes! I want a frowny face! It is sad how many nurses want to throw their colleagues under the bus in the name of "healthy lifestyle"!

No offense but I love how as I was reading your comment about not being a "chicken little", I looked up at your username "delicate flower" lmao

Specializes in Critical Care.

I think nurses are being mistaken for airline stewardesses or hostesses, that we have to look a certain way to do the job or what I like to call stepford nurses! We're paid for our nursing skills not for our looks, but hey if they can get two for one they will do it! An elegant stepford nurse who will play along with whatever "script" is given!

I am 45, overweight, and a smoker. I work 40 hours a week, and I very rarely miss time from work. Perhaps, one or two days a year, if that. I can't even remember when I went to the doctor last. I am not on any medication, so I have never had to use my health insurance for anything. (Knock on wood) I am trying to lose weight, and work out at least an hour every afternoon, when I get home. I am eating healthier and seeing progress. I actually am more active and eat healthier, then some of my younger, thinner coworkers. Although I am a smoker, I actually take less breaks during my shift, then my non-smoking coworkers do. I take my 30 minute lunch break and that is it. I guess what I'm trying to say is that you can't judge someone, just by looking at them, and think that they are costing a company more money, when that obviously isn't always the case.

In my place of employment, the highest cost to the health insurance, and the ones who miss the most time, are the ones who are pregnant. Not the middle aged, overweight, smokers, like myself. I work with many twenty-something year old females, and I am not exaggerating, when I say that somebody is always pregnant.

Do I think that companies should only hire people past the child-bearing years? Absolutely not! I was just trying to prove a point, that I think discrimination on any level is bad. Whether it be age, weight, or anything else. As long as the employee is competent and hardworking, then that is all that really matters. Because if you start denying this person or that person employment for whatever reason, then where does it end? I was just trying to show that (at least in the place where I work) it's the younger, non-smoking people that are using the health insurance more then the older, overweight, smoking, ones.

No offense but I love how as I was reading your comment about not being a "chicken little", I looked up at your username "delicate flower" lmao

Err, OK. They actually not the same thing at all. When I think of a chicken little, "the sky is falling!," I see a very frazzled person, freaking out, running around getting everyone around the fired up about some kind of nebulous calamity that either doesn't exist, or is blown way out of proportion.

For me, Delicate Flower refers to the fact that I am gentle, sensitive, and vulnerable. I internalize a lot of what goes on around me. My feelings are hurt easily, but because of that I have high regard for the feelings of others. I am introspective, and yet I am almost always calm - at least on the exterior. So I really meant it when I said I am not a chicken little.

I wanted to say no offense taken, but it did hurt my feelings a little, to be honest. :)

I would also like to add that pregnant nurses are the worst to work with, "Oh I cant take that patient. Oh i cant turn my patient." If you can't physically do the job, its time to go on short term disability.

+ Add a Comment