My Reasons For Avoiding The Acute Care Hospital

Some nurses have never worked one day inside a traditional acute care hospital during the entire length of their nursing careers. How could this possibly happen? While I cannot speak for other nurses, I will provide an answer to the question that multiple people have asked: "Why don't you want to work at a major hospital?" Nurses General Nursing Article

I've been asked the same question by members of allnurses.com, real-life coworkers, and even some of my own family members: "Why aren't you interested in working at a major hospital?"

My relatively short nursing career consists of experience in long term care, rehabilitation (acute and sub-acute), and psych. For the past two and a half years I've been employed at a small specialty hospital that provides acute rehabilitation services, and to be honest, I think it's wonderful when a patient discharges to home with the ability to walk and talk when he was bedridden and unable to speak just two weeks ago.

My career is about to traverse into a new chapter when I enter the realm of developmental disabilities nursing starting next week. Twelve years ago, when I was 19 years old, I was employed as a direct care staff member and caregiver at a group home in a residential area that housed six developmentally disabled clients. I mostly enjoyed working with this particular patient population and will be thrilled to finally work as a nurse in this specialty.

Meanwhile, let's venture back to the original question. . .Why do I not want to work at a major hospital? Honest introspection is a major part of my career decision. In addition, my experiences while attending clinical rotations during nursing school at multiple hospitals in two different states cemented my choice to avoid acute care like the plague, especially after seeing how appallingly the nurses were being treated. After much painstaking self-reflection, I realize that an acute care hospital job is not for me. Some people would interject and say, "Well, you'll never know unless you try it!"

To be perfectly blunt, I know my personality is not compatible with acute care. I'm a mellow type B girl who does not like responding to codes. I dislike dealing with changes in condition. I detest taking off orders that constantly change on the whim of the doctor, nurse practitioner, or physician's assistant. I cannot stand constantly performing procedural skills such as IV starts, Foley catheter insertions, nasogastric tube drops, or blood draws. I despise having to drop what I'm doing to address a stat order. I do not look forward to constant interaction with physicians, families, dietary staff, visitors, RT, and other people.

I hate the liability involved with acute care. I do not enjoy the idea of not knowing exactly what I'm going to walk into. I do not like making decisions NOW, and in acute care the nurse must make decisions NOW. Acute care involves a pace with which I'm not comfortable. I'm not an adrenaline junkie. My preferences include low acuity patients, low liability, minimal stress, and the same old routine. I know that several years of acute care hospital experience would be vastly beneficial to my career as a nurse. After all, you don't know what you don't know. However, if I would likely be unhappy during those years, why follow through with it? If I could steer clear of the acute care hospital for the remainder of my career, I'd be content.

Some uninformed people insist that real nursing only takes place inside the walls of the acute care hospital setting. People can think whatever they darn well please. As long as I'm happy, secure, and comfortable with the work I'm doing, that's all that matters to me. Patients outside the hospital setting need nurses, too.

You totally renewed my faith in the nursing field with that article!!! I myself am a relatively new nurse (will be three years post boards this August), and I feel I could have written that article as well!!! I bounced around different fields post college, but after earning my degree in developmental disabilities, I took a job as a caregiver for a group home of about 12 senior's with varying types of MR/psychiatric and behavioral issues. After about a year there, I was put in a class to be a "medication associate"...and that is where the bug hit. After getting married, moving to Pa, and working in an assisted living facility for 3 years, I decided to go back to nursing school...I was ready, mature, and knew this is what I wanted (and my company paid the WHOLE thing, included my liscence and boards).

But long story semi short, I work in a locked down alzheimers/dementia unit. 80 residents all with varying stages but all diagnosed Alzheimers, including a handful on hospice services. It's assisted living...so we are not even close to even being at a skilled level (though...that is the direction we are heading with some new admits!!) but anyway...If I had a nickel for every person who scoffed at me, who told me that I was "throwing away my career"...I wouldn't have to work anymore!!! Here's the long and short of it...I'm happy!!! I did the whole surgery/catheters/blood draw "ohhh this is super cool" stuff in nursing school. If I have never have to flush a line or do PICC line care again, am I going to regret it for the rest of my life?? No. What I would regret is time with my residents. I have 80 grandmoms and grandpaps who may not recognize me everyday....but get me thru my day with a hug and and I Love You. yeah, i have the crazy families who get on my nerves...but the time to bond with them to the point that I had a family bring me thanksgiving dinner after finding out I couldn't travel home to see my family on the holiday. I work for a smallish company but that has great pay, amazzzing benefits, and GUARANTEED every other weekend and every other holiday off....yeah. In healthcare. On most nights I have two MA's to cover the med cart so I can get charting and what not done..and actually oversee the care of my patients (imagine that!!!)

So I agree with the article...It takes all type of nurses to make the world go round!!!

Specializes in Clinical Research, Outpt Women's Health.

It has been 20 years since I graduated nursing school. I had worked the previous 10 years prior to becoming a nurse in hospitals. I am thrilled to have missed out on the whole acute care thing.

The future of healthcare is moving away from inpatient acute care and more toward outpatient procedures and home health. And as healthcare changes and evolves, nursing schools really need to stop pushing acute care nursing so hard. I think that's why so many new grads come out of school thinking they have to work in a hospital.

Specializes in family practice and school nursing.

worked 1 year in med surg, then 15 yrs in family practice, and now 11 yrs as a school nurse. Much prefer family practice and school nursing.

When I was in nursing school all I wanted to do get licensed and apply for acute care positions. Now that I am working in acute care all I can think about is how to advance my career beyond what I am doing now. I like my back, knees, and sanity but I also feel pressure to maintain an acute care position for future opportunities. In your case, I don't believe acute care experience is necessary for WHNP or FNP (which I looking into) so don't be like me and beat yourself up.

Specializes in ER.

I can't disagree with this sentiment. I was an EMT before becoming an RN and I have to say I can't believe all the drama the joint commission brings to bedside nursing. For example, the drama with the glucometer. Its over the top!

More and more, I think about leaving for grad school and a private practice where I eat lunch, work at a steady pace and don't have someone "watching me" all the time, whether it be handwashing or chart auditing.

Specializes in critical care, ER, health policy.

The commuter:

What a shame that so many RN's feel the same way about acute care.

The bigger question is, in my mind, what are we going to do about it????

We must all be related. This is sooo me as well.

I like acute care nursing, but I don't like the way the hospital is being run.

I don't like the cutting back of resources while simultaneously increasing documentation requirements. I don't like the emphasis on patient satisfaction scores. I don't like words like "Quality Service Initiative", and I especially despise "Excellence", because they come out of the mouths of the very people who are cutting the resources while increasing the workload, who have no earthly idea what it is like for us on the floor. I don't like managers who behave as cheerleaders for the administration instead of going to bat for the staff on the floor. I don't like being treated badly by patients and visitors for deficiencies in care despite the fact that I have been working non-stop without a break doing the best I can.

These are the reasons I got out of acute care. If and when the pendulum ever swings back the other way again, where patient loads and acuities are appropriate, where the expectations of what we can get done in one shift are realistic, where we are given the resources that we need in order to be able to provide safe patient care, and where the title of "Nurse" does NOT equal "Maid", then I might go back.

You described my feelings perfectly. This is a factor in my indecision on whether to take that refresher class and get my license renewed. I do not want to work in a hospital ever again. My personality is like yours. Thanks for putting into words what so many of us feel.

I get what you're saying.

I happen to love the hands on procedures you dislike, and don't "mind" codes...especially when they are successful, but what most resonates with me in your post is the massive coordinating of PT/OT/ST/MD's/NP's/PA's/Dietary/ordersordersorders ad infinitum. It seems like if the inter-departmental flow breaks down at any point, it falls on the RN's shoulders.

From admit to discharge, the RN is responsible for making sure every fikcnig jot and tiddle has come together in a tidy package.

Acute care RN's, especially in larger hospitals, are the master coordinators. Somewhere in there they might have a moment or two to look after the actual patient and throw some meds at them.

This is one of the really cool things about the Nursing profession; there is something for just about everybody who wants to pursue and achieve. My preference lies more with critical care, but I have a ton of respect for those who choose to excel in Rehab and long term care. Every Nursing specialty is just that... a specialty, and it's all good. :)