Does how much money we make and benefits really matter

Nurses General Nursing

Published

....or am I dreaming? The question is pretty self explanatory. As an example, just the other day, I had a co-worker refuse a request from a resident and the director, to take on that resident and give her a shower that morning. Instead of listening to the med-tech from the previous shift, and the rest of the staff, that she was being asked to take on another resident, she complained about having two showers and her load that morning. She said it is my responsibility for that resident and I had to deal with it. To top it off I had a coworker, (who was my partner on the floor) come in late without notifying the rest of the community. Therefore we were short staffed, I had 6 showers because we were not sure my partner was to arrive at that time.

She knew I needed the help, but seemed to care less. The other caregiver was standing there. Eventually nothing came about and I just went and did the shower, because Iwas so frustrated. I told them I have never showered this resident. The resident knew that as well, and was upset when I told her that the person she requested refused to give her a shower. Eventually push came to shove because call lights were going off like mad. That one caregiver who refused to shower and help me out, kept calling on the walkie, that I have calls going off and wondering why I was not there. I told her I was giving that one shower. Eventually, the third caregiver came down to help. Finally..the fourth caregiver showed up an hour late.

This job paid $10.00 an hour with decent benefits. I have been in jobs that paid more and for some reason they were more willing. Is it me, or not.. I hope it is me..:)

Specializes in Case mgmt., rehab, (CRRN), LTC & psych.
Less initiative from staff? Less help too?
I can only speak based on my personal experiences. As I've previously mentioned, I work at a specialty hospital that has a low, uncompetitive wage grid. The quality nurses and aides leave for greener pastures and higher pay once a better opportunity comes along, while the bottom-of-the-barrel staff stick around year after year.
Specializes in Pediatric Pulmonology and Allergy.

I don't really think there is a strong correlation between pay and benefits, and work ethic. At every pay level you will find enthusiastic workers and lazy workers, and that goes from housekeepers to nurse's aides to RN's, APN's and MD's. Also, once you're getting paid at a certain level you get acclimated to getting paid on that level and you tend to look at what other people on a similar job level are getting paid -- so if you are making $100k a year you're comparing yourself to the person making $120k, not to the person making $20k.

Yes generally speaking any lousy (my words, I don't mean just nursing) job with low pay is not going to get a lot of enthusiastic exuberant workers.

However someone with intelligence and foresight will give their best effort in any job knowing it is a stepping stone to better jobs. Work in a lousy place 6 +months then apply with confidence for a better job.

Specializes in Pedi.
I can only speak based on my personal experiences. As I've previously mentioned, I work at a specialty hospital that has a low, uncompetitive wage grid. The quality nurses and aides leave for greener pastures and higher pay once a better opportunity comes along, while the bottom-of-the-barrel staff stick around year after year.

I agree. You get what you pay for, more or less. Quality employees are not going to stick around forever at a job that's not paying them well when a better opportunity comes along.

Specializes in Critical Care; Cardiac; Professional Development.

Work ethic seems to carry across regardless of pay rate. I know techs who bust their butt every single shift and those who don't. I know nurses who are the same. That being said, as mentioned above, those who know they can make more money elsewhere WILL go elsewhere. This talent bleed is very evident in my hospital.

The fact is, if you don't feel the job pays enough to DO the job, for goodness sake don't take the job. The patients and your co-workers are counting on you to DO. YOUR. JOB. Period.

And nobody should EVER tell a patient that someone has refused to deal with them. Unprofessional and frankly hurtful/unkind to the patient. The conflicts between staff have no place in patient care, ever. I am shocked anyone would tell a resident that.

Specializes in Family Nurse Practitioner.

Some of the hardest working people I know don't make much money. I found this to be an offensive question. Lazy people come with every type of pay check in every tax bracket.

Specializes in Pediatrics, Emergency, Trauma.
Work ethic seems to carry across regardless of pay rate. I know techs who bust their butt every single shift and those who don't. I know nurses who are the same. That being said, as mentioned above, those who know they can make more money elsewhere WILL go elsewhere. This talent bleed is very evident in my hospital.

The fact is, if you don't feel the job pays enough to DO the job, for goodness sake don't take the job. The patients and your co-workers are counting on you to DO. YOUR. JOB. Period.

And nobody should EVER tell a patient that someone has refused to deal with them. Unprofessional and frankly hurtful/unkind to the patient. The conflicts between staff have no place in patient care, ever. I am shocked anyone would tell a resident that.

^Well Said. :yes:

Specializes in Pediatric Pulmonology and Allergy.
Some of the hardest working people I know don't make much money. I found this to be an offensive question. Lazy people come with every type of pay check in every tax bracket.

Actually, the people in the lower pay rungs do most of the work that keeps society running from day to day.

I once read an article where someone made an observation that the CEO can take an extended 2 month vacation and you wouldn't realize he was gone, but if the housekeeper is off one day you feel it right away.

Specializes in Med/Surg/ICU/Stepdown.

I could be wrong, and since I'm not near the computer, I can't find a study to directly support this but ... isn't there a correlation between compensation and work performance?

Specializes in UR/PA, Hematology/Oncology, Med Surg, Psych.

I don't believe that pay wage is directly related to job performance, but I do feel that the job market plays a role. When jobs are plentiful (generally low wage labor has a larger pool of available jobs and more lateral employee movement; housekeeping, Target, Walmart, Burger King, McDonalds, etc) SOME individuals may not give their all. But when jobs are scarce, people become nervous of losing their position and are willing to go 'the extra mile.' JMHO

+ Add a Comment