Should Doctors Have Guns?

Nurses General Nursing

Published

The author, a doctor, makes the case that in our climate of daily random violence and desperate drug addicts, a doctor would be wise to have a gun in his office. He brings up the example of emergency rooms having metal detectors and bullet proof glass because shootings have actually occurred there. So he asks:

Would you not see a doctor if you knew he had a gun in his office?

To those who would fear ....... I ask you this, why would a doctor having a gun bother you? Do you live in fear that your physician is trying to kill you? I mean if he really wanted you dead, he could stab you with a scalpel or inject you with something lethal. He could do so with the tools of his profession in a much more efficient manner than with a gun.

http://brainblogger.com/2008/05/09/should-doctors-have-guns/

The ER episode situation has happened a few times where I've worked too. Sometimes life is just one big drama!

As they say- truth IS stranger than fiction....

I think ER docs should carry pre-filled syringes of potassium chloride holstered like a bandolier around their chests! Ready to go at a moment's notice :devil:

ROFL!!! :lol2::devil::bowingpur :lol2:

Definately less messy... :D

There is a difference between feeling safe and actually being safe.

A gun can make a person feel safe. Why not save the money you would spend on a gun to use for first months rent and moving costs to a safer area.

I'd rather use the money for the gun and range time to increase my gun useage skills so that if/when I DO need to use it- I am comfortable doing so. Like it or not- living and working in a "safe/nice" area doesn't mean you are somehow safe from violence.

Specializes in Geriatrics.
I'm not particularly "anti gun", but it's ridiculous to be packing a gun to work in a clinic. Frankly, I'd refuse to live or work in such a violent and unprotected area. I don't care to live or work in such a place.

What if every citizen was packing a gun? I think that's a bad idea. Let's say everyone chose to do this. Would you feel safer? I wouldn't. I think people would end up shooting each other more. People would lose their tempers and a certain percentage would pull their guns. You'd be living in anarchy.

If every citizen was packing a gun, it would make the "NON_LAW ABIDING" citizens think twice before attacking. There are many laws in place for gun licencing & safety, they need to be completely enforced. Most gun owners are careful of thier right to carry, it's one of the rights given us in the constitution. Saddly, due to those who chose to break laws and endanger the rest of us, there is an outcry to restrict or remove that right. So what will happen if guns are removed from the hands of law adiding citizens?? Simple, the only ones who will have guns will be the ones who never followed the law to begin with. I also have a "Licence to Care & a Licence to Carry". I've never shot anyone in anger or otherwise. If the Dr feels his life is endanger, and he has gone through all LEGAL avenues for protection to no avail, then yes he has the right to carry & protect himself. Personally, I'd leave the job/area where I felt unsafe.

Specializes in Med/Surg, ICU, ER, Peds ER-CPEN.

If my doc needed to keep a gun in his desk then he either needs to switch locations or I need to switch doctors lol But in all fairness if they feel that threatened they deserve to have the right the same as everyone else, a scalpel isn't going to deter a drug addict in need of a fix, a gun barrel however and they might think twice

Don't think a doctor should have a gun in his office or carry one into a hospital where he is seeing patients. I have no objection to concealed carry laws but I think the doctor should keep it a personal issue and not bring it into his professional life. Patients don't reasonably expect to be threatened by their physician. There was a physician in a hospital where I worked who brought a gun to the hospital and staff became aware of it. He lost his hospital privileges. As I know the situation which brought him to that point which was all over the local news I think he did have real safety issues for himself and understand it from that point. Don't have a clue what alternatives would have been available to him but if a physician feels he is threatened by his patients so often that he has to bring a gun to the office seems like it is time to move your practice.

Specializes in LTC, assisted living, med-surg, psych.
I have an RN license, and I also have a concealed weapon permit. I'm licensed to care, and I'm licensed to carry. I think you can figure out how I feel on this issue.

I like the way you put that. Count me in!:yeah:

I like the way you put that. Count me in!:yeah:

Count me in too. :up:

steph

When I was in Austin, TX I had a bumper sticker made that said: "Road Rage? (in red) I've got your cure" No one ever even honked at me after that! The lady at the shop that made them asked for a couple...and showed me the pistol she was packing, lol!

Now there's a good bumper sticker!

What has happened in America that some parts of the nation are too dangerous to live or work in without carrying a gun?

I'll tell you: Drugs, promiscuity, breakdown of the family, degeneration of the culture, violence saturated media, welfare culture, lack of discipline in schools, coddling of youth, divorce, materialism gone rampant, loss of religious faith, debasement of women.

So there were NO violent areas of America BEFORE this?

Wrong. Violence has ALWAYS been a part of American culture.

Most of what you list is mostly based in religion and quite frankly has NOTHING to do with the prevalence of violence.

Violence is and always has been at the forefront of practically every culture.

Drugs- Always been around in one form or another.

Promiscuity- Has NOTHING to do with this. Has ALWAYS been around.

Breakdown of the family - I can go with that one.

Degeneration of culture - There is NO SUCH THING. Culture always changes.

Violence Saturated Media - Red Herring. No link between either has been established except in the minds of religious folks. Violence is EVERYWHERE in the real world.

Lack of discipline/Coddling - I'll agree with those

Divorce- I find divorce to be good. No point i putting up with the nonsense in the past. Times change. We have to get used to it. Divorce is better than years of suffering.

Materialism gone rampant- Has always been here.

Loss of religious faith- This is just silly. Religion has caused the MOST violence in recorded history.

Debasement of women-This I agree with.

Better to have a gun and never need it than need a gun and not have one.

Specializes in Med Surg, ER, OR.

if they have a gun, then i want a tazer to make my pts comply with their meds. Also good to teach those pts who 'love' their call lights a good, old-fashioned lesson

if they have a gun, then i want a tazer to make my pts comply with their meds. Also good to teach those pts who 'love' their call lights a good, old-fashioned lesson

I love this!!!

+ Add a Comment