Nursing: Not A Recession-Proof Career

The media, some institutions of higher learning, and many members of the public heartily believe that the nursing profession is immune to economic downturns. Contrary to popular beliefs, nursing is quite vulnerable when economic times change for the worse. The intended purpose of this article is to dispel the popular myth that nursing is recession-proof. Nurses General Nursing Article

Contrary to widely held beliefs, nursing is certainly NOT the recession-proof career that many entities have seemingly made it out to be.

During the recession of the early 1990s, some nurses in certain regions of the United States had remained unemployed for six months or longer as they attempted to secure employment. Newly graduated nurses were hit the hardest, but many local employment markets were brutal toward the more experienced nurses, too. The severe nursing glut of the early 1990s had persisted well into the middle 1990s before easing sometime during the late 1990s.

During the Great Recession of the late 2000s, patients avoided having elective surgeries in droves because they were fearful of taking the time away from work that was needed for full recovery, which resulted in a low census on certain units in acute care hospitals. When the census is low at hospitals, fewer nurses are needed to keep these floors operational.

More people than usual become unemployed during sluggish economic times and, as a result, lose their health insurance benefits. Since healthcare is prohibitively expensive, uninsured people are definitely not inclined to seek it unless their health problems have progressed into unavoidable emergencies. In addition, the medical bills of uninsured patients tend to go unpaid, which means less cash flow for healthcare facilities. Numerous hospitals are providing plenty of charity care in this day and age.

Although it is an accurate statement that nursing jobs can never be outsourced, always remember that nurses can be "insourced" by recruiting foreign nurses to work at the most desperate hospitals in the U.S. In fact, a hospital in the desolate border town of Pecos, Texas, is currently willing to sponsor nurses from abroad. These nurses are less likely to whine about working evenings, nights, weekends, and holidays because they are earning more money in the U.S. than they ever would in their country of origin.

Masses of part-time nurses accept full-time positions during economic recessions to keep their households afloat when a breadwinner spouse loses his or her job without notice. Plenty of retired nurses have been reactivating their nursing licenses and since 2008, and are returning to the nursing workforce due to the escalating costs of food and fuel combined with the effects of retirement funds that have dwindled in value.

Another noteworthy issue is the aggressive expansion of nursing program slots over the past few years. Moreover, multiple new schools of nursing have opened their doors to willing applicants in recent years, especially at the private for-profit trade schools. These two factors have resulted in a recent increase in newly graduated nurses in local job markets. A significant number of these new nurses have grappled with unemployment and underemployment for more than one year because their local job markets cannot absorb them all.

The aforementioned ideas are just some food for thought. While these occurrences might not apply to your specific region or the part of the world where you live, these things are surely happening in many cities and towns across the United States.

commuter- keep up the good work

I'm trying to do my part in busting this pervasive myth by spreading the word. If every unemployed or underemployed nurse spreads the word, then perhaps the clueless public would 'catch a clue.'

I was just laid off due to the sale of my department.

Let's just say that despite my ten years of service and twenty years of experience, or rather I should say because of, the hospital was not exactly enthusiastic about reabsorbing me into another department.

The unemployment office here in town told me that they've seen an alarming number of laid-off RN's hit their doors in the last two years which is something they've never seen before.

Specializes in Case mgmt., rehab, (CRRN), LTC & psych.
I was just laid off due to the sale of my department.

Let's just say that despite my ten years of service and twenty years of experience, or rather I should say because of, the hospital was not exactly enthusiastic about reabsorbing me into another department.

The unemployment office here in town told me that they've seen an alarming number of laid-off RN's hit their doors in the last two years which is something they've never seen before.

The internet is filled with many sob stories and anecdotal evidence of seasoned, older, experienced nurses being terminated and replaced with less-experienced nurses who can be paid significantly less money.

However, the corporations who engage in these deplorable hiring practices would never admit that they terminated an older nurse's employment due to federally protected issues such as age. These same folks would also never admit to shedding expensive labor to make room for cheaper labor.

This situation is so sad and despicable. I am sorry that you were laid off, and I certainly hope that this situation ends with a silver lining that benefits you. Good luck to you!

The internet is filled with many sob stories and anecdotal evidence of seasoned, older, experienced nurses being terminated and replaced with less-experienced nurses who can be paid significantly less money.

However, the corporations who engage in these deplorable hiring practices would never admit that they terminated an older nurse's employment due to federally protected issues such as age. These same folks would also never admit to shedding expensive labor to make room for cheaper labor.

This situation is so sad and despicable. I am sorry that you were laid off, and I certainly hope that this situation ends with a silver lining that benefits you. Good luck to you!

The problem is in getting past the anecdotal in a way that reflects an accurate picture.

But as you said, the corporate machine has built-in firing and layoff practices that are damned near impossible to trace/track as to the true motive.

We've only seen the tip of the iceberg, and the available data has not caught up with current trends/stats of unemployment. In my state, the number of new grads cranked out each year has doubled over the last eight years, thanks to a decade-long (and still going strong), multi-entity, concerted effort increasing enrollment in nursing schools... to the tune of millions of taxpayer dollars.

As a side note, one of our local hospitals just laid off fifteen medical transcriptionists. Their jobs were shipped to India.

Specializes in Prior military RN/current ICU RN..

The key is to be FLEXIBLE. I graduated BSN program in '07. I did 2 years med/surg..and psych since then. The thing I did is I MOVED. I went to Wyoming! They were hiring like mad. I got my experience and then moved to Maine to do psych. If you are willing to move you can fine areas in the country where they really need nurses. I know older nurses maybe can't do this, but I advise students to be open to moving. Even for a year or two. Get some experience then places are more likely to hire you. Worked for me!

Specializes in Case mgmt., rehab, (CRRN), LTC & psych.
The key is to be FLEXIBLE. I graduated BSN program in '07. I did 2 years med/surg..and psych since then. The thing I did is I MOVED. I went to Wyoming! They were hiring like mad. I got my experience and then moved to Maine to do psych. If you are willing to move you can fine areas in the country where they really need nurses. I know older nurses maybe can't do this, but I advise students to be open to moving. Even for a year or two. Get some experience then places are more likely to hire you. Worked for me!

I also relocated to another state for more job opportunities.

However, many people cannot or will not move due to personal preferences, lack of relocation money, being enmeshed with extended family members, lack of openness to new experiences, or feeling deep emotional ties to the area in which they currently live.

Many people are what I refer to as 'location-stable.' They will stay in places in the face of a lack of opportunity (high unemployment rates, dismal local job market, declining local economy, etc.). Instead of migrating elsewhere, location-stable people would rather wait things out and hope that the jobs return to their geographic area.

Update on my lay-off.

As some here know, I'm not an "old nurse" in age-years, but since I started young, I'm an old nurse in "nurse years" meaning...nearer the top of the pay scale.

After the sale of my department and the ensuing layoff, the hospital was as I've said, "not enthusiastic" about keeping me on board in another department even though as they said, my patient care was "excellent."

The nursing market is rapidly changing, obviously due to many socioeconomic factors and trends that if you aren't aware of, you should be. Most of it is profit driven.These changes imho are permanent and will continue.

Nurses, are becoming appliances in an increasingly WalMart'ed system of health care delivery.

So, after being laid off I went to task on making lemonade out of lemons: After a LOT of research, I was awarded full Training Benefits from the State. I submitted huge amounts of statistical RN employment data, current employment trends and projections, education requirement projections (see the IOM/tri-council reports) and rationales. I may very well be the first ADN-RN to not only succeed here, but to apply at all.

I told the colleges' admission counselor, "don't be surprised if I'm not the first of many to cross your desk."

Good luck and best wishes to all...it's tough out there.

Specializes in Case mgmt., rehab, (CRRN), LTC & psych.
Update on my lay-off.

As some here know, I'm not an "old nurse" in age-years, but since I started young, I'm an old nurse in "nurse years" meaning...nearer the top of the pay scale.

Thank you for the update.

BTW, my workplace has an absolutely horrid wage grid for both new and experienced nurses alike. The wage grid starts at $23 hourly for new grad RNs and cuts off at $34 for the most experienced RNs. This is in a major metropolitan area with several million people.

One of my coworkers has 23 years of nursing experience and earns a whopping $30 hourly. Another coworker has 40+ years of experience and earns $34 per hour. I personally think that seasoned nurses with many years of experience need to be paid much more than the peanuts that these two women earn.

Guttercat, what are you going to do with the benefits? Are you leaving nursing - would be silly if you stayed now that you can get out...