Nursing Is No Longer Worth It

Nurses are treated like expendable pieces of meat that are readily replaced like a disposable dead battery. Covid-19 is the straw that has finally broken the camel's back for me and now I'm ready to leave nursing completely. You only live once in this life. If you happen to discover this article and you're considering a career in nursing, I would urge you to turn around and look elsewhere. Nurses COVID News

Updated:  

I'd Like To Tell You A Story

I've been a member of Allnurses for nearly a decade. It's a little surreal to contemplate that amount of time but I vividly recall writing posts in the pre-nursing students section pleading for help in Anatomy and Physiology.

A decade! Time really flies.

Given my involvement in this forum over the years, I created this new username to remain anonymous and to speak freely about my opinions and feelings about nursing.

In the beginning, nursing was an exciting, interesting, and thrilling career. As a student, I would spend extra hours delving into extra readings about A&P and care plans. I would tutor students and help anyone that I could. I even volunteered in a local hospital to get more exposure.

I was addicted to the idea of becoming a nurse!

As a newly minted nurse, I loved connecting the pathophysiological dots at the bedside and helping the providers make well-informed decisions by providing them with valuable assessments and up-to-date patient data.

I've worked in many specialties over the past 7 years but my primary focus has been pulmonary step down. I've traveled all over the country and worked in a variety of hospital systems big and small.

I've helped save lives through rapid responses, code blues, administered vital medications and important treatments. I've teamed up with fellow nurses to help them catch up on meds or other tasks, then find ourselves at a local diner for an early morning post-shift breakfast.

Those are the best!

I've also experienced a significant amount of pain and agony. I've seen more patients die than a I care to count. I've listened to hearts stop. I've seen heart die on monitors. I've watched people take their last breath completely and utterly alone in this world.

I've laughed, cried, and been stunned. A host of emotions over the years.

When I was done working acute care, I transitioned to ambulatory nursing and started triaging patients in a variety of specialty clinics. This was a weird shift because I thought ambulatory nursing where were lazy nurses go or older nurses go to finish out their career. I found that outpatient nurses were just as hard but simply in a different way.

I even found myself in a nursing supervisor position where I currently reside. Something I never would have thought I would have found myself in. I even tried to talk my boss out of it when she first approached me about it because I thought to myself, "You must be crazy! Why would you consider me?" I am grateful for the opportunity ultimately.

Something Has Changed

There was a time where I absolutely loved the nursing profession and my place in it. But, something changed along the way. Burn out? I have my doubts it's that simple. This feels more definitive than the insidiousness of Burn out. This feels more permanent than burn out.

Over the past couple years, I've really questioned my place in nursing. Is this profession for me? Was it ever? Is it worth it anymore? I think Covid 19 really pushed me over the edge and was the straw that finally broke the camel's back.

Here's The Bottom Line To Me

  • If I had to do it over again, I would not choose nursing as a profession.
  • Nursing is no longer a profession that is worth pursuing and if a person would ask, I would recommend they choose something else.
  • While there was a time when the love of the patient was what did it for me, ultimately, at this time in my life, nursing is no longer worth it because we are completely undervalued, underpaid, underappreciated, and understaffed.
  • We are forced into dangerous scenarios with massive liability with compensation that doesn't match the risk we take as professionals and individuals.

Hospitals Just Do Not Care

While they give the facade of caring, healthcare organizations and hospitals ultimately don't care about you and your well being as a professional nurse.

Hospitals don't want quality. They want the appearance of quality but in actuality they want quantity. They want more with less in even lesser time. More patients. More calls. More responsibilities. More liability for you. More destruction on your physical and emotional well being. You are treated like a disposable piece of equipment with a short shelf life.

And, when it comes down to it, your professional and personal butt is totally on the line and if you screw up, there will be every effort to blame you, avoid organizational liability, and throw you under the bus.

Don't ever believe your hospital is there to back you. Consider yourself fortunate if you happen to find a manager that will stick their neck out for you and back you when the **** really hits the fan.

The PPE Crisis We're Facing Is Unbelievable

It's shocking to me that our hospital "leaders" didn't have the wisdom or foresight to have massive stockpiles in place. Now, nurses and providers are force to buy PPE on-line (impossible currently), wear the same PPE over and over, or not have any at all. This is a clear example of the failure of leadership all over the country and the clear lack of consideration for the front line worker's safety. Of course, nurses aren't the only one feeling this pain.

Nurses Are Severely Undervalued And Underpaid

We take massive liability when we're administering medications and implementing the plan of care. Yet, where's the pay? When you try to negotiate your pay with HR, you're going to get a giant middle finger. Organizations have standardized pay scales and there is zero room for negotiation. Nurses have zero pull when it comes to pay negotiation.

My theory about pay is that nurses are a cost to the healthcare system. You are not a financial asset like a provider who has billable treatments and procedures. We don't bring in revenue to the organization. Therefore, nurses don't have negotiation power. Yet, we're somehow sooo "valuable?"

Don't buy us pizza, baked goods, and crappy nurse's day prizes. Give us better pay and better benefits. That is the way to create loyalty. Yes, nursing is also about providing a service to the patient but if you're a valuable, highly trained, highly skilled, and highly knowledgeable professional, you should be paid adequately. Period.

Here's a current representation of the pay issue. I'm seeing travel nursing contracts for $4,000-$8000 per week in some parts of the country. That's crazy money! The organization I presently work for is "volun-telling" ambulatory staff to either "go acute care or use PTO/unpaid leave." However, when these staff to go in-patient, they don't receive temporary differentials or hazard pay.

Furthermore, the acute care nurses taking care of Covid patients aren't receiving hazard pay either even though they are reusing PPE and taking care of dangerous patient populations. So we're going to pay travel nurses six figures? But, when you force nurses back into acute care or not adequately pay acute care nurses, that's supposed to be okay? Think again.

Nursing Isn't Worth It Because Of The Liability

I've traveled in certain locations where nurses were taking care of 10 patients at night on an acute cardiac unit.

Unbelievable. Talk about liability.

I'm not going to go into it now but if you practice nursing without professional , you're basically having unprotected sex but expecting not to get pregnant.

Why do you think providers have professional ? Yes, nurses get sued to and remember what I said above about hospitals throwing nurses under the bus? It's literally pennies a day for peace of mind. If you have any valuables or assets in your life you wouldn't want to be taken away, you need professional liability insurance.

Nurses Are Part Of The Problem As Well

The nursing culture is full of malignant toxicity, backstabbing, and bullying people. It's vial and toxic and incredibly hard thrive in.

I have rarely seen a unit or clinic act in a cohesive, team-based manner. My professional career has only been in nursing so I'm not sure how other professions are. However, most places I have been to, have been the same.

There are many nurses that bring their contagious negativity to the bedside and to the clinics. It's distracting and disturbing to be around and it has taken a toll on myself and I know it has on others around me. I'm speaking in generalities of course because not ALL nurses are like this but it's fairly common. Just spend a half a day on a nursing unit and you'll quickly notice who those problematic people are.

I once had hope for the nursing profession that someday they would come together and help change it for the better. There's what, about 3 million nurses in the country? That's a lot of voices. We're too busy bickering amongst ourselves to ever truly come together and create meaningful change.

Bickering, backstabbing, and bullying is easy. Coming together with a cohesive voice to promote real change in the nursing profession is hard and it will never happen in my opinion.

I guess I could go on and on about the failings of the nursing profession but I'll leave you with this:

Quote

Nurses are treated as expendable pieces of meat that are readily replaced like a disposable dead battery. You are severely under paid for the skills and knowledge you bring to the table. Hospitals don't give a crap about your well being even though they say the do.

Nursing Is No Longer About The Art Of Nursing

  • It's about the numbers.
  • The output.
  • Doing more with less in less time.
  • The satisfaction scores.

You only live once in this life. If you happen to discover this article and you're considering nursing, I would urge you to turn around and look elsewhere.

Nursing isn't worth the risk and the personal effects it has on your life.

Specializes in Critical care, tele, Medical-Surgical.

An article written by a woman with a Masters in poetry and who teaches English. Despite the title, she is not a nurse.

What I Wish Someone Told Me BEFORE Becoming a Registered Nurse

We all think we know what an RN does, based on TV shows or our real-life interactions at hospitals or doctor’s offices. But what goes on behind the scenes? Is nursing school worth it once you’re on the other side?

What is it like to be a nurse? It’s not easy to get a clear picture of this career without speaking to those who’ve walked the walk. So to help, we rounded up nursing experts to tell you what they wish they’d known BEFORE becoming an RN.

Read their advice and find out a few lessons they learned along the way...

https://www.rasmussen.edu/degrees/nursing/blog/what-I-wish-someone-told-me-before-becoming-registered-nurse/

Specializes in Critical care, tele, Medical-Surgical.

Deborah Burger R.N. president of the National Nurses Union NNU-California Nurses Association knows NURSING IS WORTH IT! She is a working nurse.

In this interview she talks about the crisis in the healthcare system and the fight of the NNU-CNA to defend nurses, healthcare workers and the public. She also discusses the lowering of standards by the CDC on the re-use of masks, the retaliation and bullying of nurses and the role of the hospitals & big Pharma.

She reports on how other countries have successfully defended their nurses and front line healthcare workers as well as their populations. With 40 million unemployed in the United States and a likely 25% in California she discusses the growing need for medicare for all and how the structure of the privately run healthcare system prevents the United States from properly protecting the people of the United States. This interview was done by WorkWeek host Steve Zeltzer on 5/22/20. The director of National Nurses United NNU on the lack of PPE during the pandemic: ‘This is just out of control’

So worrying after reading this article. As as a newly registered nurse, I wish to know more of what experiences you've gone through to be this discouraged. I'm sure we all don't go through the exact same experiences though.

On 4/14/2020 at 8:44 AM, A Hit With The Ladies said:

Have you considered treating those healthcare organizations as expendable as well? We live in a capitalist country where everyone's worth and value is determined by their market value they provide for an organization.

It doesn't matter if you're a nurse or not. You'll see the identical patterns among attorneys in Biglaw, among physicians in giant hospital networks and group practices, among engineers in corporate offices (ever heard of Dilbert comics?), among computer scientists/software engineers at the big tech companies, and most other educated professions.

Your job is and always will be "just a job". If you make your nursing career your identity, then suppose your state board of nursing took away your nursing license - who are you, then?

Create value in the marketplace and leverage yourself.

Again, some uncommon common ground with AHWTL. You have the power to do whatever you want to do and to leverage your skills.

If I were starting out again, and the profession was like it is today, I would look into other options besides nursing. I don't view (and never have viewed) being a nurse as my "calling." But what initially drew me to nursing and made me want to be a nurse, has become so diluted by so much..that it seems "the heart of nursing" has gotten lost along the way.

Nursing has provided a lot for me over the years.. a lot of opportunity, education, job stability.. especially now, with the uncertainty of so much, I am grateful to be employed. I am also grateful it is not in a hospital setting and relieved that I recently declined an offer to return to a hospital position (which had nothing to do w/Covid per se, it was how the hospital was handling Covid).

I'm not interested in going into debt to go back to school for another career nor am I in a position to just not work, so I've moved into a job that while not perfect, doesn't have a lot of the issues many on this thread have referenced. It's a job where I can provide for my family, with little stress and can still do a little good for someone and I'm OK with that..

Specializes in retired LTC.

Peachpit - I'm envious as I believe so many other readers prob are too.

Glad that you were able to find something that works for you. Esp in these times and when one starts to think 'retirement' in the not too far off distant future.

Continued good luck to you.

Excellent analysis and responses, sisters and brothers. We nurses often start our missions in the institutions. But what if Nurses were in charge (again, like 100 yrs ago)? After 35 years in, I've thought about a nurse-run hospital and what that could do for our communities. Chief Nurse (not CEO or CNO). CNAs, not "PCTs"; adequate staffing for patients; good pay; a healing environment, no 5G. Miracle? Delusional? What if every RN, calculatedly and in solidarity, walked out of the hospital and returned as independent contractors? I couldn't take institutions anymore 7 yrs ago and am providing pt advocacy as a sole proprietress, to keep folks healthy and out of the hospital.

Specializes in retired LTC.

SOMETHING happened to healthcare about 20 - 25 some years ago. It moved out of the pt-focused delivery care system to one that was just driven by money. And it was run by those who just crunch the money numbers.

Sadly, salaries (and supplies) are the biggest cost for facilities, so where better to apply Draconian, stringent measures to economize by focusing to crimp down on staff. Nurses were DE-PROFESSIONALIZED. We lost our 'edge' in the change and now suffer the extreme consequences.

I'm relieved that it's been over for me for some time. Nursing was no longer worth it.

On 7/9/2020 at 2:46 AM, Daniel Baneni said:

It is quite ironic to see supposedly seasoned nurses complaining here and discouraging new nurses. No one should take their cues from someone complaining on how he/she was treated. No profession is short of complainers and nursing is no exception. It is your responsibility (as a new nurse) to tread your own path and you will be surprised how different your course might be. Avoid groupthink. No one will ever tell you their negative sides because they are blind to them. This is expected. There are always two sides of a story and every new nurse reading this thread must keep that in mind. In either case, it is not like there are thousands of good options (besides nursing) out there anyway.

You give some good advice to avoid groupthink and to tread one's own path. Another's course might be different than what is presented here in this OP, or they might end up 20 years down the road saying I wish I would have listened. It's really hard to tell because all of our individual personalities and life experiences are unique to who we are.

People don't talk about their difficulties in nursing for the purpose of discouraging newer nurses any more than people report positive experiences for the purpose of fooling newer nurses and making them think everything is sunshine and rainbows.

It's okay for people to discuss their experiences in this profession, which are always going to be on a continuum ranging from uber-positive to downright disgust and everything in-between.

This is one of those topics where what *I* don't understand is why people often defend nursing as if it is a personal insult when another nurse says that nursing isn't what they thought it would be, they hate it, or it is "no longer worth it." That's fine - it is their opinion about their experience. It doesn't insult me if people love nursing or if they hate it; it has nothing to do with me.

The other thing we have to understand is that there's nursing (the profession, the philosophies, the provision of care and the meeting of needs) and then there's working as a nurse employee. Much of the disappointments we read have to do with the employee aspect and work environment of many nurses and are not as much about tearing down the idea of caring for others or nursing itself.

Specializes in retired LTC.
1 hour ago, JKL33 said:

The other thing we have to understand is that there's nursing (the profession, the philosophies, the provision of care and the meeting of needs) and then there's working as a nurse employee. Much of the disappointments we read have to do with the employee aspect and work environment of many nurses and are not as much about tearing down the idea of caring for others or nursing itself.

Great point differentiating the 2 diverse aspects!. I TRULY miss the nursing CARING part - it was soooo hard for me to turn off that 'nurse' part of me when I was hospitalized several times recently. I 'kept an eye' on my roommates as it became evident that there were times someone needed to do so. My 'nursing' background just doesn't turn itself off! The staff was EXCELLENT - there couldn't be any better staff anywhere, I believe. But they were spread just so thin/thick. I miss THAT part of nursing - knowing that I could make an impact on someone's health & well-being.

When I worked, I could go home at shift end knowing that no one was experiencing unaddressed pain; no one's blood sugar bottomed out perilously low; dressings were intact; pts peed when they should have; all my gtubes & IVs were patent & on-time; no resp distress pts who all had their neb tx and were well positioned up in bed. THAT WAS GOOD!! Nursing WAS worth it.

But still I went home frazzled that I was running late to 'count off'. Just not enough time to finish up with 'supervisor' things (perish I should have overtime!) Staffing would be short - I couldn't get anyone to come in. So my shift would have some 'special duties' before they left. NOT GOOD! Nursing was no longer worth it. And that was becoming the norm more shifts than not. Time to give it up!

Sadly, too many folk are entering nsg expecting the CARING' aspects of nsg. Not really aware of the business/fiduciary side of health care that dictates how their jobs will really function. I guess that it all comes down to IDEAL versus REAL. And the REAL also includes working 365/24/7, vacation request denials, bad weather travel, UN-extended orientation periods for some with trouble adapting to their glamorous 'dream' passion unit jobs, pandemic coverage, etc.

And more upsetting is the realization that this is REALITY about to set in as in REALITY ORIENTATION for mant like a mule-kick in the head.

I hold that this REAL vs IDEAL approach is what directs many of us re our responses. Some of us take the more REAL road as versus the IDEAL road. It does us as 'experienced' ones and 'newbies/wannabes' GROSS DISSERVICE be less than honest. It just seems that in today's work environment, the honesty & reality is more the norm when advice is requested.

Specializes in Psychiatry / Hospital Administration.
On 4/14/2020 at 8:27 AM, AnonymousSuper said:

There are many nurses that bring their contagious negativity

This is a passionate post for many here and rightly so, it probably should be since most nurses see their role as both a privilege and a responsibility to serve other humans when they are vulnerable. I cannot imagine a world without nurses to sit at the side of another human vulnerable and suffering. It shouldn't be about the money, and or risk if you're in the field for the right reason(s). All I could ask is that you re-evaluate your position and bow out respectfully. Quietly. It seems all too easy to for you to advocate to have nurses join your opinion, but fail to see the essence of what Florence Nightingale sacrificed for during the risk of death and disease in a war of pathogens (let's remember that Florence didn't have to work at all!). The oath is there to serve, and serving requires sacrifice. Much of which circumstances are out of our control. For those that are nurses for the right cause, there is no need to support - they just get it.

I applaud the author of the OP for taking a stance and advocating your perspective. You must have known that you would elicit responses that agree and disagree. Rather than spending energy this way, perhaps advocate through your local government representative, or join a lobby to help influence real change. It's hard to see that this work here is merely more than a vent. If it is to help aspirants from helping others in need, that's not the selflessness that we seek in nurses. Only the strong need apply.

As a Nurse Leader, I would want you to know there are good leaders out there that suffer too. Great leaders stay the course and do not give up. We silently absorb the negativity and re-channel it in the form of education (like here). We want to provide everything that you ask for. And we know that if we did, the likelihood of supply would zero out faster than we could resupply - 100% reality. What would you have organizations do when they only have, and or can get so much supply?

When I was working the first night we received Covid pt's, the nurses were so upset - understandably. I knew then what I know now - that this unpredictable, and unwanted pathogen is going to require us to communicate like never before, staying in touch for hourly updates, and getting creative with little to no resources. What I also knew was that we were human and we needed each other's support. So, I provided the human caring for my staff the way I do for my patients - after all, we will navigate this biological war together.

Why do I have any particular weight to make an opinion? I work in both private and municipal spheres, and both roles are highly respected in the community. I've always been a person of service and I completely understand that duty and honor are not something that one is compensated for with money. It's one or the other - never both. For the most respected profession in the world, it cannot be about money. Just as many posts have stated, war brings unpredictable chaos, and lots of it. We do not win wars by gathering others in opinion and going home for a better job. We join together and fight with numbers. It's about team.

To be completely empathetic, I do understand the OP opinion. But at the same time, our philosophies on duty, sacrifice, and privilege to serve others couldn't be more far apart.

Thank you for the opportunity to reply to your post. I had a very rough shift supporting my nurses today in all the challenges we worked on together. And the advocating for the profession still continues despite my fatigue. I wish the OP author well in whatever profession suites you better. I'm happy that you were able to serve others for as long as you could. Be well and thank you for your service sincerely.

I very much appreciate and respect your post. As a manager I’m sure you’re doing what you can. Unfortunately, I think you know, helping/supporting and actually performing the duties of a nurse are two different things. The responsibility always stops at the nurse charged with that patient’s care. I don’t think it’s the actual idea of nursing that’s the issue, it’s the job conditions. The push and pull, the constant pressure from those above nurses to put as much on nursing staff as possible, dismiss concerns of staff and make them feel they should shut up and do their jobs; it is, in fact, a very oppressive environment. I wouldn’t being lying if I told you I have been informed multiple times over the years by my manger that if I don’t like something, there’s the door; for one of you I have 2 people applying.

Recently, before covid, my unit was being asked to do something that we were very uncomfortable with, as well as not oriented to, and my manager was having meeting after meeting with us, really exerting pressure and when someone asked if we, the staff, could be fired for not complying, my manager stated “I don’t know, maybe I’ll get fired.” Then went on to state that her yearly bonus was already in jeopardy if she couldn’t get us to comply. (Ask me if I care.)

So, while I love helping people, and I think many of us carry this in our hearts, we are mostly kind hearted and giving which allows us to be manipulated, threatened and bullied on the regular by so many different disciplines and management in hospitals. It’s actually a sad state of affairs. Personally, stories of wanting to get in a car accident on the way to work, crying before a shift, just hating going to work, I think these are signs of a toxic environment that nurses are unable to enact changes to. I don’t fit the role very well, I’m quite an abrupt person who my manager describes as a straight shooter, I say things to co workers without thinking and it’s more fact stating and not malicious, yet, these co workers take things personally, so they are quite delicate people who easily become taken advantage of; this is why there is such an oppressive environment, the type of people attracted to nursing are good hearted people.

It’s like going to parochial school.