Need a vent -- disabled parking

Nurses Disabilities

Published

Sorry this is a little long and unwieldy.

You know I don't look, at first, like I have any kind of disability or limitations. I work very hard to maintain my posture and not limp or stoop. Now, I do have a disabled parking permit. Have done for years. Some woman in my class saw that I parked in disabled and has taken it upon herself to start making smart orificed remarks in front of me such as:

that isn't parking for mentally disabled

you shouldn't be parking there you don't look disabled

Not only that, she has drawn the attention of my entire class to this by suggesting to other people in the class that I am using someone else's disable permit (they have mentioned it to me).

So last night I am walking to my car with a friend from class (who happens to know about my condition and how it affects me). This woman tags along and when we stop at my car -- I just knew she was going to say something -- I wish I had lagged behind to avoid a confrontation. Then off she goes..."do you mind if I ask why you park there?". Finally the woman is direct! Now, frankly I do mind that she knows. So I just said, "I have a disability that qualifies me for a disabled parking permit". Then she makes the same remark, "It's not for mentally disabled ya' know". I confess I nearly lost the plot.

So I asked if she was suggesting that I was parking there illegally. She starts going on about some friend of hers that uses someone else's parking permit (or something like that) and how it "isn't right". I lit up like a Christmas tree. Essentially I told her that I was sick of her assassinating my character amongst our classmates by suggesting this and that the remarks about being"mentally disabled" weren't funny, but mean and upsetting. I also invited her to take my permit number, lift the phone and call the Dept. of Transportation to report me -- if she really felt that I was doing this illegally or the shut up about it...permanently.

Then I got in my car and burst into tears -- like a big baby. I hate letting people upset me like that!

This had been brewing for weeks since she first saw me parking at clinical and now I am embarrassed that I lost it -- I feel incredibly defensive. From the first time I met this woman I was wary of her (she has a remark for everything). She is not the sort of person I would do anything but keep at arms length. The problem is we are a small class and an even smaller clinical group. Even before she made the remarks about parking I seemed to be in her sights -- 1st day in skills lab she called me retarded because I couldn't find her brachial pulse (so we were off to a great start).

I have never been the thin skinned sort. In fact quite the opposite. I don't mind joking around with people or even sending myself up. What I do know is when someone is joking versus being unpleasant. Thus far I have worked really hard to ignore her jibes in class. What I find odd is she always makes these remarks in front of other people. When we have been one-on-one she never says anything unpleasant.

I have fairly severe arthritis affecting my spine, sacroiliac, shoulders and hips -- thankfully not peripheral joints. I've had it since I was 18 yo (some 20+ years). Apart from a great deal of chronic pain and perpetual fatigue you would never know I had anything wrong with me unless you observed me quite closely -- e.g. I've lost nearly all ROM in my neck.

Generally speaking I don't divulge this information classmates at NS or employers. I consider it private and no one's business. I keep myself as healthy as I can and have learned a multitude of strategies to manage pain so I rarely need to take a narcotic for pain (they kill the pain but I can't stand how they affect me otherwise).

I am not ashamed of the condition but I am VERY aware of how people judge well in advance of obtaining information and I am well aware that in our relatively small community, where I intend to work as a nurse, this sort of info can affect job prospects. I know it shouldn't but we all know it can and does.

Still I feel like an orifice. I have three more semesters of this woman. My heart sank when we were assigned the same clinical. Seriously I just want to be completely ignored by her. I am sure class today will be a complete treat.

Specializes in Geriatrics, Cath Lab, Cardiology,Neuro.

First of all if she continues to harrass you, something needs to be done. Second she shows no compassion to be a nurse. She will eventually come across people in your shoes, the scary thing is that she might say the same hurtful things. Also she needs to look up the word retarded. That word is the most misused word in the English language. I had a similar situation when I was training to be a Medical Assistant. This classmate of mine is a single mom of 3 kids, her ex-husband is going to jail for doing something to her (that's all she told me, she wont go into details, but I assume it was bad enough that the judge wants him put away). Her oldest son has Asperger's and a seizure disorder, and she gets SSI for his medical needs. She works as a CNA at the local nursing home, but still it is not enough to support the kids so she gets assistance from the state. Well one day she had no choice but to bring the kids in (it was their school vacation week, and she couldnt get a sitter till later). We had computer class, and she had the kids on seperate computers. Well several of my severely judgemental classmates started making remarks under their breath. "she is frauding the system" "the reason why she knows so much about financial aid is because she goes to school to get the money", "her kid doesnt need SSI, he is fine", etc..... Then there was a discussion in one of our classes about Medicare and Medicaid which fired up the comments again about my classmate. It got to the point that our instructor mentioned Medicare is for the elderly....and DISABLED and you will come across that on clinical. Some people are insensitive!

Specializes in IMCU.

I just wanted to thank you all for your responses. I was pretty upset about all of this. I won't do anything more about it because I like a peaceful life. So far she hasn't done anything else directed at me. It is a pity that I kind of remain on high alert in her presence -- I hate it actually.

She is in my clinical section...yay...not. Only 1 more year to go though.

Again thanks.

Specializes in ER, PACU, Med-Surg, Hospice, LTC.

People are ignorant.

I am not sure where the belief that a person with a Disabled Paring placard has to look "disabled". Sadly, a lot of people do indeed believe this.

If you are requried to do any type of reports/speeches for class, pick this as a topic.

It would certainly enlighten a lot of narrow-minded people out there.

Specializes in IMCU.
People are ignorant.

I am not sure where the belief that a person with a Disabled Paring placard has to look "disabled". Sadly, a lot of people do indeed believe this.

If you are requried to do any type of reports/speeches for class, pick this as a topic.

It would certainly enlighten a lot of narrow-minded people out there.

I agree! I have twice been stopped by police and had my card and identity verified when I have parked places. One police officer said "you don't look disabled".

Interesting. One of the students in my nursing class got a disabled placard and told me the only reason she got it was to get better parking at the school. She said she otherwise never used disabled parking. I can't say that I felt one way or the other about what she did. As far as I was concerned at the time, I had thought that it was pretty ingenious of her to use her ability to obtain the permit to her advantage. After all, whatever the criteria were, she met them. I agree that you should make every effort to complain to the school authorities about this person's behavior if she bothers you again. You have a right to have a harassment free educational experience.

Specializes in Geriatrics, Cath Lab, Cardiology,Neuro.

There are many people out there who have "hidden disabilities". These people don't need a wheelchair or crutches, but may suffer from a condition that limits them. There are people who have chronic, debilitating conditions and they don't show they are suffering.

Specializes in ICU, psych, corrections.

I wanted to say I empathize with you. My husband is rated as 20% disabled from his time in the Army and although he doesn't look handicapped, his knees cause him problems from time to time (he's had 5 ACL surgeries). He's also got several badly herniated discs from jumping out of helicopters and landing "funny". :idea: He has a handicap placard but doesn't use it 90% of the time. The times he does? When we are at a big amusement park like Disneyland, etc and he knows that walking around the park all day long is going to cause him to limp by the of the day. He also used it when he was going to school at the university because the closest parking spots available were easily 1/2 mile away, some more than that. Do I think less of him for using the placard on those occasions? No, because all the other times when he could use it, he doesn't "feel right" about doing so. He's got a fairly high pain tolerance level and would rather walk from a regular parking spot to the store, etc. on most days.

I have rheumatoid arthritis but am not considered disabled (thank God it's mild to moderate RA and Celebrex controls the majority of the pain and swelling). I don't look like I'm in pain; neither does my husband. So when he does use the placard and we park in a handicapped spot, people will occasionally make disparaging remarks. We got into a screaming match one day with an older couple because they loudly proclaimed that my husband was "defrauding" the system by using a handicapped spot when he clearly wasn't handicapped. And when my husband politely responded that he was a disabled vet, the guy yelled at him to "prove it". I was taken aback at their attitude and how rude they were. Worst, our three kids were sitting there, staring at this man berating their dad and wondering why the grown-ups were acting like that. :rolleyes:

There have been times when the remarks made by others have gotten so bad, my husband has just about thrown away his placard and said "never again. I'll just park in regular spots, regardless of how I'm feeling or hurting". I'm sorry this happened to you and I agree this student has no business being IN your business. My heart goes out to you.

Specializes in Med Surg, ICU, home&pub health, pvt duty.

:twocents: I understand your situation. I have scholiosis and need double hip replacement. At times I cannot walk without a walker or cane. Other times, I am able to walk without aid but cannot walk far. I have a handicapped parking placcard. When I have a good day, I take a regular spot but on the other days I have to park in the handicapped spot.

Here in Los Angeles we have had police officers watch the handicapped parking placard users and if they feel the person is not handicapped or using someone elses placard, they will issue a ticket and you have to prove you are handicapped and it is your placard.

There was a TV story about people taking it upon them selves to report those parking in handciapped spaces with placards. What I have problems with is that sometimes a person's disability is not obvious--especially if they have taken pain meds or it is a heart problem.

Specializes in Nephrology, Cardiology, ER, ICU.

Golly - I'm just thankful I don't have to use a handicapped placard - what awful treatment some of you have received.

I'm so sorry.

Specializes in Infusion Nursing, Home Health Infusion.

I understand...I just got one.....b/c of a chronic problem that I have had for a long time...if I am one my feet too long and too many days in a row.....I have pain...can someone always see that NO!!!!! when I can walk far..... I do......other days I can not without suffering......these are just ignorant peope that think you have to be in a w/c or missing a limb to be disabled...I say DO NOT ENGAGE........DO NOT EVEN RESPOND...Ignorance does not deserve a response....thank GOD for men like your husband!!! I hope he uses it every time he needs it!!!!

Specializes in ob high risk, labor and delivery, postp.

i have a spinal condition (too many things to go into detail) but it means than the only position that i'm reasonably comfortable in is reclining..i have pain meds ( a fentanyl patch continuously as narcotics for breakthrough pain), i don't go out much but i do have a handicapped placard, and yes i have had the same reaction, although most people just give me dirty looks, while some say things loudly enough for me to hear like "she shouldn't be parking there" and worse..thank goodness though none have confronted me..i have had to become conscious of waiting until i have left a parking area BEFORE i leave a parking area..since by law you are not supposed to drive with the placard still affixed to the rearview mirror, i would get in m car and then drive off...now i wait because before people used to even beep at me and give me dirty looks when i was backing out of the spot..its ironic because even my own sister was talking about being at disney world and how people "who didn't even look disabled" were going around in wheelchairs and getting right onto the rides through a disability access...i told her "well people could say the same about me",,,the thing is that i won't even go to a park like that...some don't make any allowances..and i would really need than to be able to accomadate my disability..even with all my meds..i can't tolerate being up and about for even 4 hours..so i would need to be able to have quick transportation and get right onto rides and stuff with my family although many rides i wouldn't be able to tolerate at all..Anyway..try to get a thicker skin (although i agree that this person was wrong and doesn't have the compassion needed to be a good nurse so the school should know about her treatment of you) but in nursing you need to be able to tolerate a lot of abuse because you are constantly having to deal with problems with docs, family members and patients who are only thinking about their problem and not all the things you are doing! Good luck to you..hope you are now in a different clinical group!

Specializes in LTC.
i have a spinal condition (too many things to go into detail) but it means than the only position that i'm reasonably comfortable in is reclining..i have pain meds ( a fentanyl patch continuously as narcotics for breakthrough pain), i don't go out much but i do have a handicapped placard, and yes i have had the same reaction, although most people just give me dirty looks, while some say things loudly enough for me to hear like "she shouldn't be parking there" and worse..thank goodness though none have confronted me..i have had to become conscious of waiting until i have left a parking area BEFORE i leave a parking area..since by law you are not supposed to drive with the placard still affixed to the rearview mirror, i would get in m car and then drive off...now i wait because before people used to even beep at me and give me dirty looks when i was backing out of the spot..its ironic because even my own sister was talking about being at disney world and how people "who didn't even look disabled" were going around in wheelchairs and getting right onto the rides through a disability access...i told her "well people could say the same about me",,,the thing is that i won't even go to a park like that...some don't make any allowances..and i would really need than to be able to accomadate my disability..even with all my meds..i can't tolerate being up and about for even 4 hours..so i would need to be able to have quick transportation and get right onto rides and stuff with my family although many rides i wouldn't be able to tolerate at all..Anyway..try to get a thicker skin (although i agree that this person was wrong and doesn't have the compassion needed to be a good nurse so the school should know about her treatment of you) but in nursing you need to be able to tolerate a lot of abuse because you are constantly having to deal with problems with docs, family members and patients who are only thinking about their problem and not all the things you are doing! Good luck to you..hope you are now in a different clinical group!

Sadly, there are those out there who either outright fake disabilities or have very slight disabilities and milk them for all they're worth. About 10 years ago, I was at Disneyland with my family on Christmas Day; busiest day of the year. My brother (who is one of the nicest guys in the world...I know I'm biased, LOL) was walking slightly ahead of a woman who was riding one of those Rascal type scooters. She ran straight into him, hitting his foot! He turned and said something like "Whoops...sorry about that!" (Again, SHE ran into HIM). She replied "*** dammit, can't you see I'm in a cart?!?" I about lost it. I told her "I don't care what your problem is; how would you like security to know that you are going around hitting people?!?". A bystander who saw the incident told me that she had overheard other people complaining that there was a woman in a scooter riding around running into people. Honestly! Some people's kids. It's wretched people like her who make it so hard for others with true disabilities. :down:

P.S. Not to say this woman did not have a disability; I have no clue about that, not knowing her. My point is just that behavior like that is not acceptable no matter what the circumstance.

+ Add a Comment