Published
No, it doesn't.I managed a 3.77 during my ADN program... I graduated with a 4.0 from my RN-to-BSN program. Doesn't mean I'm a better nurse.
On the other hand, it's likely that if you tracked the progress of 5,000 graduates with 3.8's and compared it with the progress of 5,000 graduates with 2.8's that you would find statistically significant higher performance in the former group compared with the latter.
I've always felt that a few tenths of a point didn't make much difference -- and schools vary so much in their level of difficulty that it is hard to compare a student from one school with a student from another school. However, having worked in Staff Development for years and worked with hundreds of new grads, I do believe that the better students generally outperform the poor ones.
There are exceptions of course, but in general, I have found that the knowledge and skills mastered by the better students gives them an advantage in the workplace. Even more important, whatever abilities they had in school to succeed (natural intelligence, work ethic, lack of distractions, whatever) often help them succeed in the next phase of their career.
But of course ... there are exceptions. In particular, sometimes the VERY intelligent new grads have trouble adapting to the work environment where their superior intellectual skills are less of an advantage to them. In the workplace, you are evaluated more on what you do than what you know ... and sometimes, those students don't do as much or as well as a "B" student or "A-" student with the drive to work hard.
I guess I would wonder as an employer if the family/other obligations situation was a hindrance in school, why would it suddenly NOT be a hindrance on the job? If one had trouble juggling all of that in school and it affected one's grades, it is likely to still be an issue that may affect work performance as well. As someone hiring, that is what I would hear.
There are a lot of us who manage a higher GPA while juggling family, work and other obligations. I agree with the above that high GPA doesn't mean having the luxury of nothing else to do. It doesn't necessarily mean being a better nurse, but it IS a quantifiable way to measure performance in the face of lack of other means to do so.
Some schools are easy as heck...some are not. Sometimes ur a genius and other times ur just lucky. I know ppl that would miss a test and make it up with the help of a friend with the answers...so is your GPA higher, well yea! On the other hand, I know some with 2 pregnancies and a photograhic memory who have had the content/material b4 and aced everything. I agree that its a way to find your cream of the crop but cream of the crop in reading and regurgin content doesnt always equal cream of the crop in patient care...just a lil food for thought : )
the gpa question got me as well! i had a phone interview and one of the first questions she asked me was "why isn't your gpa higher?" seriously?! i was so caught off guard, and i didn't know how to answer that question! here is the truth: i have a 3.16 gpa and i was working about 16-20hrs a week. but still, even without working, i think a 3.16 gpa is damn good! my program was not easy by any means! i am not sure how many other nursing schools do this, but we needed a 75% for a 'c', an 83% for a 'b' and 92% for an 'a'. i studied hard and worked my butt off! unfortunately, because of the grading system, i ended up with two 82% c's and one 91% b. now, how do i explain all that without sounding defensive or like i am making excuses! anyone have any good advice as to how i can answer that question next time?
it really is too bad that you can't really take into account how difficult your nursing program is, because that definately does make a huge difference when it comes to your GPA. my program is probably one of the tougher ones out there, because to get an A you need a 95%! honestly that makes me mad because it's not like nursing classes aren't hard enough, but they have to set the percentage at a freakin 95% which is seriously impossible to get in some classes. luckily i still have a pretty good GPA. it'd be nice if the employers who ask for GPAs could somehow take that into account.
In a tight job market the employers hold all of the cards. As another poster stated, the GPA thing may be a tool to shrink the enormous amount of applications received for the limited positions available. New nursing school saying: C=RN, A=employed RN, it is what the market bears unfortunately.
G
Music in My Heart
1 Article; 4,111 Posts