Forced to resign, new grad with only 1 year of experinece.

Nurses General Nursing

Published

I find myself today some how discourage and with a low spirit, I would like to know the opinion and hear experiences from either new grads or more experience nurses about my story.

I was hired exactly one year ago as a New Grad at the ER in a local hospital. We all new grads were hired with a $5000 contract for 3 years. This contract involved educational training for New Grad ER nurses, This will include a preceptors and a Regional ER course. Well at the time and as a New grad looking for a new experience and any job that came across the ER sounded great, and 3 years contract really did not felt like much.

Well my journey started, I was trying to get use to be called the orientee, because this was the way all our coworkers were referring to us.

Well one day after a couple of week of orientations and lots of CE courses online required by the hospital, our manager said to us the ER course will start next week, but we have to make an addendum to your contract, is not going to be $5000 anymore now is $7500, I was forced to sign it at that point. We all sign it . The ER regional course was 4 or 5 weeks and it was useless, poor teachers nothing ER related really broad and vague. It was like assisting to one of those fast track NCLEX courses, basic stuff but nothing that I didn't knew already from nursing school. I really felt robbed, but again I needed a job and I was still excited about ER. We were suppose to have a ONE preceptor to follow through what you were learning, not many and who ever was willing to take you that day. This is what happened, I had multiple preceptors, some good, some hate to have an orientee and some just care less about teaching you. I completed my 6 month review with clean record :-) I even call dad , I am good I passed my probation period clean with clean record. that was a huge relieve, up to that point all my managers and directors were being some how nice to me. Well things change, once you are on your own with no preceptor, I was oriented during day shift for 3 months and now I was sent to nights. That was a major change for me, keeping in mind I had never ever work a night shift in my life, but that was my agreement and I was willing to fulfill it.

I was hired in March and I managed to keep up my new grad record clean, until season started, most of the techs were either fired or left, I see many nurses leave but I really didn't get involved, I was there to earn my living not to gossip around.

December 31th I was called for the first time to my managers office, I had gave another patient papers mixed with the packet the doctor handled me to discharge this patient, and I mislabeled a blood tube. I was being written up for the first time, my manager didn't look or acted as nice as before, she was rough, mean and really not understanding. I assumed my fault, but I accept my personality is sometimes talkative and I said I am not sure I gave those papers to the patient, because this is the case many times where the charge nurses give discharges or doctors do and then you have to sign on them, and ER is really busy things like this are hard to remember. But I guess I should just assume my fault and leave that office. Well I managed to just say I am sorry I will pay more attention to detail, this was what they counsel me about, attention to detail. Well after that I felt they were watching me, I was so sad and anxious not to make any mistakes that I feel the more careful I was the more clumsy I was becoming. I was called one more time to the office, A Retired Nurse who came to my ER almost at change of shift placed a complaint that she was never place in the monitor, and also I had place a urine sample in the same bag with the tubes, this according to the lab contaminates specimen and she made me withdraw the labs again. I gained a second write up. I appeal the monitor case because it was charted, but manager said patient was a reliable source and eve though I had patient for less than 30 minutes and even if I gave bedside report and it was documented in my chart, it wasn't valid and I had to keep the write up. I did not appeal this write up not until I received the 3rd write up.

The third write up happened last week march, we are talking of 3 write ups in a matter of 3 months. The last write up that caused me a suspension was about my biggest fault, I entered the medication list of one of my patients into another patients chart. They found out when the patient went to the floor and the nurse wrote me up, I have no excuse the ER has been to explosion level and my anxiety because I knew this was going to happened, my charge nurses being of no help, no techs in the ER , many normal factors of the ER.. no Excuse I am making stupid mistakes. I was told by my managers who were very aggressive in front of the ER director in this write up appeal meeting, We are seeing a pattern here you are not having attention to detail and also you don't accept your blames. They also told me that one more error and I will be fired. What should I do? Is this a good time to resign and take a deep breath before making more mistakes? Is my manager going to give bad references about me once I start looking for a job? I really feel stupid for making all this rookie mistakes :-(, mostly because my manager has told me I don't belong in the hospital world.

I am scared of resigning, but I am more afraid of being fired, how to handle this and leave with my head up ?

Specializes in Emergency, Telemetry, Transplant.
what makes you think I'm not aware of the charge nurse role? just as a curiosity, unless play with their phones is in their job descriptions I don't think I'm wrong.

My comeback would be that if you are so certain of what the charge nurse is or is not doing, then you are spending way too much time focusing on the charge nurse. Given your OP, maybe you should decrease your focus on the charge, and focus more on your practice as an ED nurse.

Specializes in Emergency, Telemetry, Transplant.
I don't see why you anger towards me

I can't speak for others, but I am not angry. However, it was quite unprofessional to criticize your charge nurses like that. I'm guessing that if I took 10 snapshots of your day, if they were the wrong 10 snapshots, I might get the idea that you just sit around and don't properly care for your patients. Yet, you are taking a few snapshots of the charge nurses' days and assume that they don't do anything. Until you actually work shifts as charge, you have no right to judge the charge nurse on what they do or not.

As to how this relates to the OP, it seems like you are making excuses. Your mistakes were the result of a bad course, bad charge nurses, bad supervisors, a bad NM, etc. I sincerely hope you are able to introspective and a make a plan for what you need to do to become a better nurse.

For the record, I think resigning is a bad idea, IMHO.

Specializes in Nurse Leader specializing in Labor & Delivery.
is not the criticism is the Approach used, you for example approached it very well, in this post no bullying was used,.

First, nobody in this thread has bullied you. Your perception of people not sugar-coating their words as the same as bullying could be part of the problem.

Secondly, please use the quote button so we can tell to whom your comments are directed.

I also agree that you should not resign, unless you want to be stuck with paying back $7,500 to the hospital. If they fire you, it nulls the contract and you would not have to pay it back.

That happened to my husband as a new grad - 2 months into his brand new job on Med/Tele, everyone quickly realized that floor nursing was not his forte (and he is a fabulous nurse and very successful, but not floor nurse material - which also means that you could be a fabulous nurse in some other area). They fired him, and then told him he needs to pay back the sign-on and relocation bonus. And he said "Um, no. You fired me. I owe you nothing. And my attorney agrees." They never mentioned it again.

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
I'm of the impression that English is not the OP's native language and there may be some communication issues that need to be resolved between her and her managers.

In addition, there may be some cultural mismatch. A manager who is addressing you about a serious error is not going to be as "nice" and friendly as she was when she was interviewing you for a job. It wasn't about "crushing you." It was about making sure you understood the ramifications of your error. If you continued to be talkative as she was counseling you, it may have appeared as if you "didn't get it."

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
I have to disagree. I believe in the ER, a year is still a new grad.

A year is a novice nurse, but the freshness is off the bloom. Not a new grad.

Specializes in Psych, Addictions, SOL (Student of Life).

Contracts can be broken for all kinds of reasons so it pays to read the fine print. I never sign any contract on the spot . I take it home and read it. If they don't want to allow that I'm pretty sure there's something buried in the fine print they don't want me to see. If they insist I will sign and add under duress to my signature.

Hppy

@QuietRiot, it is a big deal. Although she is a new nurse, she is not a new grad. This is not about titles, but more about how she sees herself. Self assessment is important when it comes to improvement; and when someone places themselves in a category beneath the level of where they should be, it says a lot about how that individual views themselves.

I'm not saying she's seasoned or experienced. She's very much new, but management is expecting her to function as a novice at this point, not a new grad. And she will be expected to function as such in future jobs too.

1. IF 1yr or less = new grad...then having 1yr of experience puts you at the tail end of the new grad category.

2. In none of your previous post did you mention the reason for nit picking/zooming in on her referring to herself as a new-grad..when you magnify small minuscule references it's best to tie it back to the overall picture.

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
I don't see why you anger towards me, yes I made a mistake I am not saying I didn't at all I did and I feel bad about it. But I also come accross with many people with your same attitude, always judgemental, angry and with a arrogant personality, also I want some tips on how to not let that affect me ?, I am a very sweet,positive, healthy and friendly person, not use to people constantly attacking you. Why it feels like I see this picture in many nurses? is this the way I'm going to become in few years?

I haven't seen anyone on this thread displaying anger toward you, but it IS frustrating that you don't seem to "get it." This mistakes are yours, not the charge nurse's, and clearly you don't understand the charge role. That is always frustrating to charge nurses when you then complain about what they're doing or not doing. If you are always running behind and needing help, it isn't up to the charge nurse to rescue you. It's up to you to figure out how to keep up.

Now for you to start insulting posters with whom you disagree is a very unappealing tactic, and I can see how THAT would get you into trouble in the workplace. That "I come across many people with your same attitude, always judgemental, angry and with an arrogant personality" statement probably riled up many people who would otherwise have been on your side. Judging from what we've seen here, you probably have difficulty getting along with your co-workers.

An employee who is well-liked can "get away with" much larger errors -- because management is willing to work with an employee they like. An employee they don't like will get fired or disciplined much more readily. From the attitude displayed here, you aren't going to be well liked. It may be a cultural thing to see yourself as "sweet, positive, healthy and friendly" while seeing your colleagues as "judgemental, angry and arrogant", but you're in the US now, working with Americans and not just Americans but ER nurses who tend to have strong personalities. It's on YOU to adjust to your environment, not your environment to adjust to you.

And you didn't make a mistake. You made SEVERAL mistakes in a short period of time, and it's coming out that you've made even more mistakes you didn't mention in the first place. Maybe the ER isn't for you, but you are not going to find a nursing job where everyone is sweet and positive while you rack up mistake after mistake.

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
I would try another department maybe....ER may be a bit much for some new grads. Idk, just by reading your post, it sounds like a bit much for you. Personally, I look at nursing as a way for me to work towards my strengths and not my weaknesses. I'm stronger at following orders and caring out plans and I KNOW this. So I KNOW ER, critical care and cardiac are NOT areas for me. ;-) I work well with doctors and adult patients....so I gravitate towards those environments (LTC, internal medicine). While in nursing school now, I think more of my strengths are delegation and management of care. So when I pass my nclex RN I will look for maybe an ADON position or nurse manager. It's great for new grads to jump in head first if that's their desire...BUT we all must know when we began to jeopardize our patients. Because it's not about us, it's about them!

#MyOpinion Be blessed!

I wish you luck finding an ADON or nurse manager job right out of the box.

Specializes in Med/Surg, Ortho, ASC.
I wish you luck finding an ADON or nurse manager job right out of the box.

Unfortunately, he/she may find it all too easy to find such a position these days. Seems to me that LTC's & LTAC's are hiring more & more new grads simply because they don't know what they don't know and are willing to step off the cliff way more eagerly than someone with experience.

Now that is definitely a COB, jaded opinion as to the "why would they hire a new grad?" question, but it's definitely happening.

Specializes in Oncology; medical specialty website.
Unfortunately, he/she may find it all too easy to find such a position these days. Seems to me that LTC's & LTAC's are hiring more & more new grads simply because they don't know what they don't know and are willing to step off the cliff way more eagerly than someone with experience.

Now that is definitely a COB, jaded opinion as to the "why would they hire a new grad?" question, but it's definitely happening.

It's not a "COB, jaded opinion." It's an opinion based on what would be best for the patients and employees. A brand new, "wet behind the ears nurse," does not bring the experience necessary to successfully and safely run a department, let alone an entire LTC/LTAC or SNF.

Specializes in Mental Health Nursing.

Sorry, my phone doesn't have the quote feature so I have to do it manually.

Quote from QuietRiot

1. IF 1yr or less = new grad...then having 1yr of experience puts you at the tail end of the new grad category.*

2. In none of your previous post did you mention the reason for nit picking/zooming in on her referring to herself as a new-grad..when you magnify small minuscule references it's best to tie it back to the overall picture.

I already made my point and tied it to the big picture. I can't help if you didn't get it. Out of everything I said, YOU chose to only focus on a small segment.

+ Add a Comment