Defunding the Police: Win /Win Situation Or Recipe for Disaster?

Defunding the police, entails cutting down services to the police and diverting them to social services such as housing, employment, is this the solution or are there deeper extenuating circumstances such as lack of family structures, lack of fathers and mentors or revolving vicious cycle of poverty.

Updated:  

Violence is rampant across low-income black neighborhoods across the nation as police have withdrawn from their communities. Within inner cities, street violence is reaching historic proportions and the perpetrators are as young as ten in Chicago. Chicago and New York city have seen high rates of homicides and crimes under the disguise of Black Lives Matter. Answers to rampant violence will be found within the communities suffering from the crisis.  Fathers and Mentors Wanted!

Fatherless societies since slavery throughout the twenty-first century!

We need to know where we come from in order to move forward. Deep rooted in slavery times, the effects of such are still affecting the black community. Some might say, slavery occurred four hundred years ago or whatever, why are you bringing this up. Yes, fellow nurses, history put a dent in the black society, as such, we cannot keep putting band aids, and not treating the cause, a spade is a spade, let’s talk.

Slavery occurred when blacks were stolen from their mother countries and brought to America and other European countries. Once they landed, they were stripped of their identity, forced to change names and not practice their traditions. Once stripped of their identity, families were separated and not allowed to live together (Comer). The living and working conditions in the plantations impeded the formation of stable families adhering to the nuclear model slavery may have negatively influenced family formation and sexual mores among blacks (Williams). The slave trade, with the frequent division of family members, has represented a further factor in impeding the formation of stable families adhering to the nuclear model.

Black men were forced to have children they could not claim as family nor provide for, and expected to watch their children being sold as property (Caldwell & White). The Black father enslaved was helpless and required to accept his fate without resistance or concern. It is arguable that centuries of this patterning have helped render him invisible today (Caldwell & White). The tendency to matrifocal was strengthened by laws mandating that the children of slave women would also be slaves and prohibiting free men to intermarry with slave women (Stampp). Depriving black males of both authority and responsibility also led to a marginal role for black husbands and fathers within the household, resulting in the reinforcement of the single-mother family model (Stampp). The alleged inadequacy of the slave father and husband, the absence of male ‘models’ for young slave children to emulate, the prevalence of the father’s personality has persisted to modern day post slavery.  Black children are indeed more likely to reside with a single parent female headship. When families are broken, there is lack of growth and development as noted by Erick Erickson theory of development (Mcleod).

Growth and Development: Erick Erickson

Erickson theorized that developing children identify the traits, habits and ideas from people around them (McLeod). As a result, children develop a sense of competence, confidence, adequacy, efficacy and a sense of worthwhile and belonging. Some black families are poor, have inadequate housing, inadequate healthcare. Parents living under severe economic hardships are unable to give their children child bearing experiences that promote adequate self-regulation. Development is hampered and interferes with self-control, ability to concentrate, learn and manage social environment.

According to Erickson, the challenges of stages not successfully completed may be expected to return as problems in the future “arrested development” (McLeod). If fathers and mentors are lacking in the black community, where children are not taught or told that they matter at an early age results in the behavior mentioned above. Looting, not respecting self and others, black on black crime because lack of instilling of values at an early age. Unless, the black community starts loving and respecting themselves, providing emotional support to children, defunding the police is only a band aid to their issues. It has to start with them because of arrested development, they need police in their communities. Resources of course should be channeled into education, housing and other needs, but this has to be resolved first.

Generative fathering takes into account the dynamic nature of parenting. It requires that adult African American men commit to participating in the lifespan of children as an obligation for cultural and community continuity (Caldwell & White).

‘’I was lucky to have parents, teachers and mentors who’d fed me with a consistent, simple message: You Matter!" (Michelle Obama).   

Resources    

Racism and African American adolescent development (Comer, J.P)

Generative fathering: Challenges to Black masculinity and identity. Black fathers: An invisible presence in America (Caldwell, L.D., & White, J.L.)

Erik Erikson (McLeod, S.)

Becoming (Obama, M.)

The Peculiar Institution: Slavery in the Ante-Bellum South (Stampp, K.A.)

Help me to find my people: The African American search for family lost in slavery (Williams, H.A.)

Specializes in Private Duty Pediatrics.
2 hours ago, subee said:

I can agree to this stand alone statement and it applies to all races.  Single parenthood for so many is a one way on ramp to a life time of poverty.  Raising kids without any help in a chaotic environment always leads to trauma and hardship that get passed on to the next generation.  It's difficult to nurture a child when you are poor and stressed  and probably didn't get good parenting yourself.

Three ways to poverty: drop out of high school, have no marketable skills (so no job), and become a single parent. 

Often, these are from poor choices, but sometimes it just happens, as when the father is sent to prison. (Not necessarily the mother's fault.)

But is it true that lack of role models or fathers can lead to psychological issues that manifest in different ways as adults?

 

Some say the title is baseless, first of all it has been on the news, second,  my concern is the family structure has to be rectified in black communities in order to move forward. Charity begins at home. 

Specializes in Private Duty Pediatrics.

How do we go about rectifying the family structure in Black communities? 
What are your thoughts?

First and foremost, family structure is important. Kids need to hear that they matter and that they have to work hard to get to their destination. Even if poor, a gentle loving home can calm the mind, once the mind is balanced, these kids can be stirred in the right direction. Angry children will turn into angry adults. When they don't attain anything in terms of education, etc. and better jobs, they resent everyone, even authority and go on rampages if given a chance!

Specializes in NICU, PICU, Transport, L&D, Hospice.
1 hour ago, simba and mufasa said:

First and foremost, family structure is important. Kids need to hear that they matter and that they have to work hard to get to their destination. Even if poor, a gentle loving home can calm the mind, once the mind is balanced, these kids can be stirred in the right direction. Angry children will turn into angry adults. When they don't attain anything in terms of education, etc. and better jobs, they resent everyone, even authority and go on rampages if given a chance!

Perhaps with a defunded police fewer black men will be wrongfully incarcerated or murdered by police...thus resulting in more intact families. 

Specializes in Private Duty Pediatrics.
22 minutes ago, toomuchbaloney said:

Perhaps with a defunded police fewer black men will be wrongfully incarcerated or murdered by police...thus resulting in more intact families. 

Fewer sent to prison has to help.

Specializes in CRNA, Finally retired.
15 hours ago, simba and mufasa said:

First and foremost, family structure is important. Kids need to hear that they matter and that they have to work hard to get to their destination. Even if poor, a gentle loving home can calm the mind, once the mind is balanced, these kids can be stirred in the right direction. Angry children will turn into angry adults. When they don't attain anything in terms of education, etc. and better jobs, they resent everyone, even authority and go on rampages if given a chance!

Gentile poverty is disappearing and in it's place is extreme poverty and extreme wealth.  a "gentle" loving family isn't poverty because the parents aren't angry or addled or addicted and can behave like loving parents.  At some point, though, love isn't enough.  I see many parents in family court who love their children but are just hapless and incapable of providing stabile housing, etc.  Maybe instead of paying people to have kids, we should be rewarding young men and women for not having kids, staying in school, etc.  

Specializes in Critical care, tele, Medical-Surgical.

 This family picture was taken in 1942. Two of the girls are cousins of the daughters and sons of the parents. The two older 'boys' were away in the military. I never met the parents, who died in their fifties probably due to poor health care for low income negros in Mississippi at the time. 

All the kids finished high school. One earned a college degree. ALL left Mississippi as young adults worked and/or owned a business, bought a house, and sent most of the children to college. A very important person is not in the picture. Uncle John, brother of the mother in the photo, worked for a White doctor, saved his money, and opened a laundromat in Detroit. Married with no children he bought new shoes, coats, and school supplies for his nieces and nephews. I have been married to one of them for 53 years. I love them all as much as I do my own sisters.

I KNOW they were loving parents because I know their children. They talk about "Mama and Daddy" with love just as I talk about my deceased loved ones.

FAMILY_PICTURE.jpg?width=1920&height=108

This photo is the parents when my husband's mother was pregnant with him:       Dora_Alphonso_.jpg?width=1920&height=108

Can you recognize those kids in these recent photos?       

EPSON016_(6).JPG?width=1920&height=1080&
Brother_sister.JPG?width=1920&height=108

Specializes in CRNA, Finally retired.
16 hours ago, herring_RN said:

 This family picture was taken in 1942. Two of the girls are cousins of the daughters and sons of the parents. The two older 'boys' were away in the military. I never met the parents, who probably died in their fifties due to poor health care for low income negros in Mississippi at the time. 

All the kids finished high school. One earned a college degree. ALL left Mississippi as young adults worked and/or owned a business, bought a house, and sent most of the children to college. A very important person is not in the picture. Uncle John, brother of the mother in the photo, worked for a White doctor, saved his money, and opened a laundromat in Detroit. Married with no children he bought new shoes, coats, and school supplies for his nieces and nephews. I have been married to one of them for 53 years. I love them all as much as I do my own sisters.

I KNOW they were loving parents because I know their children. The talk about "Mama and Daddy" with love just as I talk about my deceased loved ones.

FAMILY_PICTURE.jpg?width=1920&height=108

This photo is the parents when my husband's mother was pregnant with him:       Dora_Alphonso_.jpg?width=1920&height=108

Can you recognize those kids in these recent photos?       

EPSON016_(6).JPG?width=1920&height=1080&
Brother_sister.JPG?width=1920&height=108

Two parent family.  They can do almost anything.  One set of foster parents I worked with on a case added 5 foster kids from two two separate "families" to their own 3 kids.  Only one working parent and they have made it work and are my heroes.  However, for people born in 1942, IMHO raising kids was easier - not all the violence and distractions of the digital age.  If all these kids were raised by a single parent, IMHO, the ending would be different.  Thank you for sharing some "good news" with us.  You got lucky to get them.

Specializes in Vents, Telemetry, Home Care, Home infusion.

Camden NJ, across the Delaware River from me disbanded it's police force in 2013 due to corruption, open air drug markets and extreme poverty in the city.  Local physician started tracking frequent flyer hospital patients to get them resources to stabilize their health.

Outcome here:

42%  crime reduction + "community-oriented policing," which prizes partnership and problem-solving over violence and punishment.

https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/09/us/disband-police-camden-new-jersey-trnd/index.html

 

Re Camdens  "Frequent Flyers"  -to decrease emergency calls...

The Camden (N.J.) Coalition of Healthcare Providers created its "hotspotting" care coordination program more than a decade ago to help lower costs and readmissions among patients with extremely high healthcare utilization. The program connects patients with social workers and nurses to coordinate outpatient care after a hospital discharge. While the program was first launched in New Jersey, it has since gained widespread attention and expanded nationally.  Study found doesn't significantly cut readmission rates

Specializes in Critical care, tele, Medical-Surgical.
8 minutes ago, NRSKarenRN said:

Camden NJ, across the Delaware River from me disbanded it's police force in 2013 due to corruption, open air drug markets and extreme poverty in the city.  Local physician started tracking frequent flyer hospital patients to get them resources to stabilize their health.

Outcome here:

42%  crime reduction + "community-oriented policing," which prizes partnership and problem-solving over violence and punishment.

https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/09/us/disband-police-camden-new-jersey-trnd/index.html

 

Re Camdens  "Frequent Flyers"  -to decrease emergency calls...

The Camden (N.J.) Coalition of Healthcare Providers created its "hotspotting" care coordination program more than a decade ago to help lower costs and readmissions among patients with extremely high healthcare utilization. The program connects patients with social workers and nurses to coordinate outpatient care after a hospital discharge. While the program was first launched in New Jersey, it has since gained widespread attention and expanded nationally.  Study found doesn't significantly cut readmission rates

Thank you Karen. This is a hopeful article. It seems to be better in Camden. I hope it works out well in Minneapolis.