Nurse Charged with killing patients

World International

Published

http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/articles/10475064?source=Evening%20Standard

Nurse 'tried to kill patients'

By Valentine Low, Evening Standard

28 April 2004

A hospital nurse was so obsessed with "ruthless efficiency" that she tried to kill four elderly patients to free their beds, a court heard today.

Barbara Salisbury was even heard urging one patient "give in, it's time to go", as she administered an overdose, prosecuting barrister Robin Spencer QC told the jury at Chester Crown Court.

Determined to get patients off her ward quickly - alive or dead - she "overstepped the line between humane nursing and callous dispatch", taking it upon herself to hasten the death of the four very ill patients at Leighton Hospital, Crewe, Mr Spencer said.

Salisbury, 47, from Pontybodkin, north Wales, who was working as a ward sister, denies four counts of attempted murder against Reuben Thompson, 81, Frank Owen, 92, James Byrne, 76, and Frances May Taylor, 88. The alleged offences took place between 1999 and 2001.

Mr Spencer said Salisbury tried to kill Mr Byrne and Mrs Taylor by "unnecessary and inappropriate" administration of diamorphine.

The court heard she was seen repeatedly pressing the booster button on the device delivering the drug to Mr Byrne and telling him: "Give in, it's time to go."

Mr Spencer said Salisbury tried to kill Mr Owen and Mr Thompson by lying them on their backs to drown in their own secretions. In Mr Owen's case, she told a fellow nurse: "With any luck his lungs will fill with fluid and he will die."

Salisbury was reported to police by other nurses at the hospital. Mr Spencer told the jury: " Barbara Salisbury arrogated to herself the right to decide when [patients] should die.

"She does not suggest these were attempts at mercy killing. The allegations, she says, are quite simply untrue."

He added: "If the patient could be made well enough to be discharged she would aim for that, if not she would hasten death. One way or another she wanted these patients off her ward." The trial continues.

Specializes in MS Home Health.

:chair:

renerian

Hmm. I can't help but wonder like Gwenith if this nurses' words were perhaps spoken in a moment of frustration (or typical nurses' sick humor) and things are being blown out of proportion due to vindictiveness. Hope she gets a chance to defend herself fairly.

When someone is dying slowly, our human response may be to wish to hasten the inevitable demise or provide the least suffering possible...this doesn't make us killers. We also become frustrated at family that 'won't let loved ones go', and with patients who are still full codes when they are obviously failing and terminal. This doesn't make us cold hearted necessarily,. We are humans with our own feelings.

To me the sensationalism in this story is suspect and I hope clear thinking people investigate this. I've been a victim of vindictive game players in our profession, and tactics are recognizable in this story to those of us who have observed it firsthand.

Specializes in Registered Nurse.
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/articles/10475064?source=Evening%20Standard

Nurse 'tried to kill patients'

By Valentine Low, Evening Standard

28 April 2004

A hospital nurse was so obsessed with "ruthless efficiency" that she tried to kill four elderly patients to free their beds, a court heard today.

.

Talk about brainwashed! :rolleyes:

she must not have as much paperwork for admits and discharges as we have!

Specializes in IMCU/Telemetry.
A similar case happened here in Australia - only it turned out to be gossip and sheer nastiness from co-workers. New RN in a small country town had trodden on some feet of some of the more self-important Enrolled Nurses. They were used to doing things a certain way - she would not let them - next thing she is up on murder charges.

Gwenith, what was the end result. I take it that she got off with it, but what was done about the nurses filing a false claim.

The Barbara Salisbury case seems like a chain of errors to me, things were going wrong for a while but nobody did anything about, don't get me wrong, no proportion of blame should be put on anyone other than Barbara Salisbury, but if the chain of errors can be stopped early things don't have to go so far. Yet again, the profession of nursing is in the spotlight because of this awful situation. What a shame that the papers can't find a story everyday about how wonderful the hugh majority of nurses are!!!!

Specializes in Renal, Haemo and Peritoneal.

Does anyone have a link to this story?

I have been reading this thread and it seems as though a lot of you are jumping to conclusions about this nurse.

Gwenith and Mattsmom81 could be disturbingly accurate about what has happened.

I have been following this case through the media coverage both nationally and locally to that area.

I understand from this that there was a ward battle going on, one of the key witnesses in the case actually admitted in court that he has lied on his police statement in which he accused this nurse of laying a patient flat to die.. as it turns out she was not even on shift when the alleged offence occured... you tell me thats not vindictiveness.

I understand that all the patients were either DNR or were in for TLC only.

In the two cases she has been convicted of the drugs were prescribed by doctors and was the minimal starting doses of diamorphine... I dont know about elsewhere in the world but here there has to be two people to administor diamorphine and each one is accountable for that administration. In the NMC code of conduct it says that each nurse is accountable for their own actions and to say that another member of staff pushed you into giving the drug is no form of defence... yet this is what is reported to have happened in court.. nurses were saying she bullied them... well sorry thats no defence as far as I am concerned... they are just as liable as her and should be serving this sentance with her.

Also in the media coverage it has said that no nurses reported what they see to be attempts at killing patients, to anyone at the time it happened.... whatever happened to clinical incident forms?... or speaking to managers... the whole thing stinks of bullying, and bullying which has gone to the extremes.

Why has this nurse been jailed? what has she done wrong?

Specializes in Renal, Haemo and Peritoneal.
i am going to be an expert witness for an upcoming trial and in search of articles about "dealing with alzhemers /mental patients. anyone know wher i can find these articles?

thanks for your help

put this search into google,

journals alzheimer's elderly demented

for as old and cynical that i am, i am still paradoxically SO naive and gullible...and i have been the recipient of vindictiveness yet i still just never seem to 'get it'....i retract my original post on this thread with entirely different perspective.

The Barbara Salisbury case seems like a chain of errors to me, things were going wrong for a while but nobody did anything about, don't get me wrong, no proportion of blame should be put on anyone other than Barbara Salisbury, but if the chain of errors can be stopped early things don't have to go so far. Yet again, the profession of nursing is in the spotlight because of this awful situation. What a shame that the papers can't find a story everyday about how wonderful the hugh majority of nurses are!!!![/Q

Anyway the other vindictive nurses could be lying and she could be totally innocent?? Why not get to know ALL the facts before you make a judgement on one of your own nurses. Any wonder with collegues like you she is where she is!!!!:imbar

+ Add a Comment