Getting "points back" on a test
- 2Feb 19 by adnstudent44So we have one professor this semester who will go over our exams with us after we have all taken it, and often will sometimes decide to give points back to students if the choice they picked "made sense" or if she realizes she didn't give us the information she'll give the whole class the question. However I have found that it is usually the same students who often can "debate" a question enough to get the points for a question they got incorrect, while other students often do not get points back. I often get the "difficult" questions correct so when the teacher gives the points back, my grade doesn't change much.
My question is this: is it worth it for me to ask the professor why she gives points back when some students complain about a question when others dont? I get frustrated because I usually get Bs or As while some students get lower Bs and Cs to begin with but end up with the same grade as me or better after they get these "points back" on questions I studied hard to get right the first time I took the test. I feel like I almost get cheated out of having a better grade. I don't want my classmates to hate me though, or for my professor to get annoyed at me.
Also, a lot of times the choice they get "points" back for will have killed a patient....I don't understand how they can get points back for an answer that would have killed a patient in real life, while other students try to get points back for a question they got wrong but whose "incorrect" answer wouldn't have killed a patient.
Should I just keep my head down and be happy with my grades? If i sound like a spoil sport I'm sorry, its just been really frustrating for me lately....
- 5Feb 19 by ckh23You might suggest statistical analysis to your teacher. I'm in grad school now and that is how they determine if extra points will be awarded or if certain questions will be thrown out. However, that usually involves half of the class getting a question incorrect which leads the professor that either the question is worded poorly or there may have been more than one correct answer. You should also bring up these concerns to your professor in private and see what he/she says.
- 0Feb 19 by adnstudent44well my professor has brought up that she looks at that, but there have been times where half the class gets it wrong and she says i understand you guys didn't understand blank, but i still think you should have it marked wrong; which I totally understand. Its when theres 4 out of 20 or just 6, and its always the same people, that get the points- that I get frustrated. Or how the answer they put would kill a patient. I don't understand the thinking behind that. Usually if half the class gets it wrong, its because of something easily explainable or a misunderstanding, its never an answer that would cause a patient death- or if it is- its one of those times she says shes going to keep it incorrect.
- 9Feb 19 by GrnTeaI had a class of students like that once.I used to teach review sessions, optional, not during class time. Sometimes people came, sometimes they didn't. But there was major whining about throwing out questions and so forth afterwards. I once lost a little cool and said that if these people put half the effort into studying that they put into calculating their GPA to the fourth decimal place to figure out how many questions they needed thrown out to pass with a 74 (!) we wouldn't be listening to this.
Don't worry about them. Your grade is not affected by theirs. And look on the bright side: If you think you've got a good rationale to have an extra point awarded to you, it sounds like you'd get it.
- 0Feb 19 by springchick1Quote from adnstudent44Normally the questions that you get points back for are the difficult questions. If you've already gotten the question right, you've already been awarded a point for it. Why should you get another one?I often get the "difficult" questions correct so when the teacher gives the points back, my grade doesn't change much.
- 1Feb 19 by EverlineAs others have said here, we get points back based on stats of how many students got the question wrong. We are not allowed to debate the questions or get points back by showing where something is in the textbook. Our tests are computerized and we get our grade as soon as we finish the test, at which point we can look at the test answers and rationales. There is no discussion or debate. Usually a few days later our grades will be adjusted if the stats show a question should be thrown out.
I can understand why you would be bothered by what is going on. I probably would be too. But I have to agree with others that you should just concentrate on your own grades and don't bother yourself with what is going on with these other students debating and getting points. In the end, it won't mean anything to you. Do your best and press on.
- 2Feb 19 by SWM2009I had an instructor who would give points even for responses that were not correct if the student could give a persuasive argument. These were NCLEX type exams where the goal was to select the BEST answer but if you argued your way through a wrong answer the instructor gave you the point. However, she would remind students that if the question came up again in the comprehensive final then they'd better select the answer that was actually correct ...yeah
I did not make a fuss over it. I did the work, passed the class and moved on.