Smoking among Nurses is hypocritical.

Published

I don't believe the number of Nurses that continue to smoke, despite the constant flow of patients that have numerous problems associated with smoking. Furthermore, it is very hypocritical for anyone, DR. or Nurse to be advising patients about proper lifestyle changes. I often get these reasons when I am confronted by a smoker.

#1) It is my right to smoke and I don't feel anyone has the right to tell me otherwise.

Smoking has nothing to do with rights. Smoking is clearly an invasion into the rights of those who do not smoke. Perhaps we should remember the children who have their rights removed by breathing smoke from parents/relatives. And we should have the right to speak out against smoking as there is NO BENEFIT whatsoever. Furthermore smoking drives up health care costs for everyone, regardless if they smoke or not. Talk about rights.

#2) We all are going to die of something someday. Oh well!

With this attitude, you definately shouldn't be in the health care field, especially Nursing. Nursing is all about getting the patient better. What would you do if you overheard a doctor tell his/her patient that it is ok to continue in the bad habits, because they will die someday of something. How ridiculous!

#3) I can't quit!

Why not? You started somehow. You had to smoke several times without actually liking it to be able to acquire the "taste" which led to addicition. Any addiction can be broke if YOU choose to do so. You can quit if you chose to quit. But you have opted for the "I can't quit" excuse because frankly you don't want to quit.

#4) The air we breathe is already polluted, so what makes the difference?

Oh, about $3-4 per pack. I agree that the quality of air is not very good due to various reasons, but to pay hard earned $ to further pollution and to further deteriorate your health is totally asinine. Doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

Why do people start smoking?

#1) Social status

#2) Exposed all his/her life as family/friends smoked.

#3) Peer pressure

If someone wants to classify smoking as an "addiction," I'm cool with that. However ...

When anything is named as an addiction, there are always those who decide that the "addicts" must be "treated." Whether they want to be treated, or not.

"Addiction" is a whole complex of physical and psychological parameters, and much of our substance abuse (from tobacco to white sugar) can be technically called "addictions." Maybe just continue calling it a bad habit?

Jim Huffman, RN

Maybe I speak out strongly when I say smoking is an addiction, but I am a former smoker, and when I quit I went through physical and mental withdrawal. I still crave a cigarette every now and then, especially when the going gets tough.

I used to say that "smoking is a crutch, but hey I'd rather use the crutch than limp." That was when I was a smoker.

Now I say, let's find out why you need that crutch.

To me the difference between a bad habit and an addiction, is that the habit has no severe consequences to your physical/psychological/mental health that you are aware of, while an addiction does.

I'm not trying to be argumentative, it's just my opinion.

I don't believe the number of Nurses that continue to smoke, despite the constant flow of patients that have numerous problems associated with smoking. Furthermore, it is very hypocritical for anyone, DR. or Nurse to be advising patients about proper lifestyle changes. I often get these reasons when I am confronted by a smoker.

#1) It is my right to smoke and I don't feel anyone has the right to tell me otherwise.

Smoking has nothing to do with rights. Smoking is clearly an invasion into the rights of those who do not smoke. Perhaps we should remember the children who have their rights removed by breathing smoke from parents/relatives. And we should have the right to speak out against smoking as there is NO BENEFIT whatsoever. Furthermore smoking drives up health care costs for everyone, regardless if they smoke or not. Talk about rights.

#2) We all are going to die of something someday. Oh well!

With this attitude, you definately shouldn't be in the health care field, especially Nursing. Nursing is all about getting the patient better. What would you do if you overheard a doctor tell his/her patient that it is ok to continue in the bad habits, because they will die someday of something. How ridiculous!

#3) I can't quit!

Why not? You started somehow. You had to smoke several times without actually liking it to be able to acquire the "taste" which led to addicition. Any addiction can be broke if YOU choose to do so. You can quit if you chose to quit. But you have opted for the "I can't quit" excuse because frankly you don't want to quit.

#4) The air we breathe is already polluted, so what makes the difference?

Oh, about $3-4 per pack. I agree that the quality of air is not very good due to various reasons, but to pay hard earned $ to further pollution and to further deteriorate your health is totally asinine. Doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

Why do people start smoking?

#1) Social status

#2) Exposed all his/her life as family/friends smoked.

#3) Peer pressure

i don't smoke, but i do like ice cream. :rotfl:

do you like a burger tom? how about a beer? do you enjoy a cold one? perhaps you like an iced tea or a cola instead? sugar will kill you ya know. along with fat and booze.

here's a clue tom: there are more overweight nurses than smoking nurses. so now what do you say?

I'm calling the SPCA! :p

:chuckle

Nicotine IS addictive.

Specializes in Nursing Assistant/ Army Medic, LVN.

Nicotine isn't addictive????

HMMM................

............But I'm sure YOU know best. :rolleyes:

Specializes in PeriOp, ICU, PICU, NICU.

This is too hot too handle type of topic. I am not a smoker but that is my personal choice. If someone else chooses whether in the medical field or not is their business. I cannot change the world and I am not perfect to try to change others. I live my life one day at a time, and if I don't like something I just look the other way and avoid any complications.

This is too hot too handle type of topic. I am not a smoker but that is my personal choice. If someone else chooses whether in the medical field or not is their business. I cannot change the world and I am not perfect to try to change others. I live my life one day at a time, and if I don't like something I just look the other way and avoid any complications.

Yes it is and it is so hot, he won't respond. But I do see he is a new student and I congratulate him on that. But he might want to be a little careful with the "know it all, better then the" kind of attitude, that got one person kicked out of our program.

One other thing, this site is for Nurses and Nursing students to help one another. You might have just burnt a bridge or 2 or 3 or maybe even 4. :o Good luck with your studying.

P.S. I actually wrote that nurses would be the best choice to make a public service announcement, not that they should have to. Also, you wrote "I don't think so, it is our duty to inform and educate patients of good health practices even if we don't practice them ourselves." Isn't that a form of hypocracy? Doesn't that prove the OP's point? HMMM.....

UM, I don't think it's hypocritcal if it's part of our job description. As I SAID, it would be inappropriate NOT to say anything. EDUCATING and INFORMING is different than preaching at someone. If I tell the patient, "anyone that smokes doesn't care about themselves and is a very stupid individual" I'd say that is hypocritical, but INFORMING them about health risks and what it is doing to them is not.... So NO, it does not prove the OPs point... in my opinion.

~Crystal

Specializes in Telemetry, ICU, Psych.
UM, I don't think it's hypocritcal if it's part of our job description. As I SAID, it would be inappropriate NOT to say anything. EDUCATING and INFORMING is different than preaching at someone. If I tell the patient, "anyone that smokes doesn't care about themselves and is a very stupid individual" I'd say that is hypocritical, but INFORMING them about health risks and what it is doing to them is no.... So NO, it does not prove the OPs poing... in my opinion.

~Crystal

Crystal,

Thanks for expressing your opinion. I have expressed my thoughts, you have expressed yours. Let's give the rest of the folks a chance to speak up. Once again, thanks for the discourse.

BTW, I noticed that your are an LPN. Are you currently in an RN program? I (hopefully), start one this december, then I'll work for two months and transfer to an ADN program. I have a couple of ???'s for you, but - if you don't mind - I'll send a PM. Let me know if it's OK.

CrazyPremed

Crystal,

Thanks for expressing your opinion. I have expressed my thoughts, you have expressed yours. Let's give the rest of the folks a chance to speak up. Once again, thanks for the discourse.

BTW, I noticed that your are an LPN. Are you currently in an RN program? I (hopefully), start one this december, then I'll work for two months and transfer to an ADN program. I have a couple of ???'s for you, but - if you don't mind - I'll send a PM. Let me know if it's OK.

CrazyPremed

Hey, thanks for your thoughts too, everyone is entitled to their own opinion right? Right. Yes, I am currently an LPN, and I just started the RN (ASN)program... last monday. When I'm done with that I plan to transfer to a BSN program... hopefully. Well, feel free to PM me anytime! Talk to you later.

~Crystal

I don't believe the number of Nurses that continue to smoke, despite the constant flow of patients that have numerous problems associated with smoking. Furthermore, it is very hypocritical for anyone, DR. or Nurse to be advising patients about proper lifestyle changes. I often get these reasons when I am confronted by a smoker.

#1) It is my right to smoke and I don't feel anyone has the right to tell me otherwise.

Smoking has nothing to do with rights. Smoking is clearly an invasion into the rights of those who do not smoke. Perhaps we should remember the children who have their rights removed by breathing smoke from parents/relatives. And we should have the right to speak out against smoking as there is NO BENEFIT whatsoever. Furthermore smoking drives up health care costs for everyone, regardless if they smoke or not. Talk about rights.

#2) We all are going to die of something someday. Oh well!

With this attitude, you definately shouldn't be in the health care field, especially Nursing. Nursing is all about getting the patient better. What would you do if you overheard a doctor tell his/her patient that it is ok to continue in the bad habits, because they will die someday of something. How ridiculous!

#3) I can't quit!

Why not? You started somehow. You had to smoke several times without actually liking it to be able to acquire the "taste" which led to addicition. Any addiction can be broke if YOU choose to do so. You can quit if you chose to quit. But you have opted for the "I can't quit" excuse because frankly you don't want to quit.

#4) The air we breathe is already polluted, so what makes the difference?

Oh, about $3-4 per pack. I agree that the quality of air is not very good due to various reasons, but to pay hard earned $ to further pollution and to further deteriorate your health is totally asinine. Doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

Why do people start smoking?

#1) Social status

#2) Exposed all his/her life as family/friends smoked.

#3) Peer pressure

SO YOU DONT HAVE ANY BAD HABITS?

ARE YOU OVERWEIGHT (COMPULSIVE EATER MAYBE)? THAT DRIVES UP HEALTH CARE,THATS HYPOCRITICAL IF YOURE TEACHING YOUR PTS. ABOUT A HEALTHY LIFESTYLE,AND ABOUT INVASION OF RIGHTS OF PEOPLE WHO DONT SMOKE,THATS WHY THERES SMOKING AREAS ,JUST DONT GO BY THE SMOKING AREAS.TRUST ME ITS EASY TO START SMOKING BUT HARD AS H*LL TO QUIT.MOST OF THE TIME I ENJOY SMOKING AND I WILL NOT QUIT JUST B/C IM A NURSE. SORRY HONEY!!!!

just wondering what brought this diatribe on?....

I believe it would be hypocritical to take the Nightingale Pledge and not inform people of the benefits of quitting things that are damaging their health. Being a nurse does not put you on trial, you are not a "leader", you are a care giver and it is your job to provide care. Part of care is teaching and educating. I personally believe every nurse should educate about better health practices, but let's look on the flip side of this.

How would the OP want to discourage smoking? by saying that people who smoke are bad, by making some crude remark... As a smoker I would be highly offended if a health care person confronted me about my smoking in a rude way, with his attitude. I would much rather be informed by someone who looked at me non judgementally and kind of floated the information by me than someone who made me feel like a worthless idiot for smoking.

+ Join the Discussion