Minorities feel cheated in health care

Nurses Safety

Published

http://www.msnbc.com/news/970053.asp?cp1=1

Minorities feel cheated in health care

Study: Blacks, Hispanics say medical treatment is not equal

WASHINGTON, Sept. 22-U.S. blacks and Hispanics feel they get worse health care than their white compatriots, according to a study published Monday-a feeling supported by scientific evidence.

THE STUDY, published in the journal Health Affairs, finds that blacks and Hispanics are up to three times more likely than whites to feel that minorities receive a lower level of care.

Just one in five whites felt minorities got shortchanged, the survey, done by the Harvard University Forums on Health, Health Affairs, The New America Foundation, and other groups, found.

"The poll findings show a persistent feeling among minorities that the care they are getting is not equal to that of whites," Dr. David Blumenthal, director of Harvard's Interfaculty Program on Health Systems Improvement, said in a statement.

"Inequality in medical access and treatment is a problem for many Americans that can no longer be ignored."

In 2002 the Institute of Medicine reported that members of racial and ethnic minorities are given lower quality health care than whites even when make as much money and carry the same insurance.

The Institute, an independent body that advises Congress and the federal government, suggested that deliberate or unconscious bias by doctors and other health care providers may worsen the problem.

The survey by Lake Snell Perry & Associates involved 806 adults and was weighted to include extra numbers of blacks and Hispanics.

Those surveyed felt that cultural and language barriers were most to blame for the disparities while more than half felt doctors and nurses treat minority patients differently than white patients.

© 2003 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.

Specializes in 5 yrs OR, ASU Pre-Op 2 yr. ER.
Originally posted by cheerfuldoer

.

There's always somebody better off than the next person. Even the poorest person has something someone poorer than himself/herself doesn't have...even if it's a dirty winter coat, or a dirty pair of shoes they may have found in someone's trashcan.

I remember being little and Mom driving around after Christmas in the ritzy neighborhoods (typically some old clothes were out on the curb when they got new ones), and this was my clothes to last for the year (thank god we did get the money for new underwear and socks though). Makes you appreciate (and protective) or everything new that you ever get.

I always get a bit upset when I hear the back and forth of a thread gone racial.

I'm sure there are many of us who have experienced some sort of prejudice and a lot of it remains fresh in our minds.

I like Renee's idea of spreading a bit of kindness.

-Russell

Specializes in 5 yrs OR, ASU Pre-Op 2 yr. ER.
Originally posted by Rustyhammer

I always get a bit upset when I hear the back and forth of a thread gone racial.

I'm sure there are many of us who have experienced some sort of prejudice and a lot of it remains fresh in our minds.

I like Renee's idea of spreading a bit of kindness.

-Russell

Agreed.

Originally posted by Rustyhammer

I always get a bit upset when I hear the back and forth of a thread gone racial.

I'm sure there are many of us who have experienced some sort of prejudice and a lot of it remains fresh in our minds.

I like Renee's idea of spreading a bit of kindness.

-Russell

I agree. Sorry about the above post. It came on a day where everything all day long had been about this race or that race and the comments just rubbed me the wrong way. We should be compassionate to all NO MATTER WHAT. I agree with Renee, spread love and kindness.

This isn't to anyone in particular, but sometimes it rubs me the wrong way when people expect me to get over "racial issues." Most of you only think of racial issues when there is a thread or something on the news, but I live this every day. I hated going to school everyday because my college was in a little town and I knew that I was most likely going to get stopped by the police for no apparent reason. Have any of you had to call the police to get the police who stopped you to quit harassing you. Have you ever had to comfort a friend who was just refused service because she was there with her white husband. Well I have, so forgive me if I can't just forget about it and pretend like we live in a colorblind society. Contrary to what this post probably sounds like, I'm not bitter. But, I won't pretend that I live in a mystical magical world full of love. I can't afford to.

Oh, how tired I am of the victim mentality. And I can't even escape it on a nursing forum. :eek:

I'm glad that people are open to discussing different issues on this forum. Yes, it may be that many others perceive discussing racial issues as a dead horse that gets repeatedly beaten. For many people in this great nation that dead horse is alive and kicking. It's a reality.

Specializes in Case Management, Home Health, UM.
Originally posted by sjoe

People with a victim mentality will always believe they are getting the short end of the stick, no matter what the situation actually is. This kind of whining is always easier than taking responsibility for oneself.

Thank you!

Honestly, and I'm just being honest here, the only racial issue I see is: the people who perceive themselves as victims, actually victimizing themselves. They are very defensive, and seem to be looking for reasons to feel cheated. The victim attitude is written all over them. They almost seem to be saying "I feel inadequate, so you better not treat me that way!" I have friends of all races. But I also encounter a lot of minorities who act as if they expect to be discriminated against from the word go. I see this in the hospital all the time. I just want to be a good nurse to a patient, and I instantly get "the attitude" just because I'm white and they're not. Hm, maybe I'm the one being discriminated against....... :rolleyes:

Never said anyone was better, what i DID say is that i have a problem with ppl who are able-bodied, non working, and mooching, in other words. (taken from post written by lpb2b2004)

lpn2b2004 - the first post that i responded to referred to your experience with a women who was WORKING and pulled a muscle. next you changed your words to those written above. so is the problem with a working person or a non-working person? also, let's remember there is a lot of unemployment in this country. the country is full of the able-bodied who cannot find a job. it is tight for everyone. just be glad you are working and doing something positive for yourself. it is wonderful you are able to. but have compassion for those who do not have the same opportunities. :cool:

Specializes in ICU.

i think minorities everywhere feel cheated in healthcare and to a certain extent they are. we have a free hospital system that sets out not to discriminate - then why are the folliwing facts still with us

how bad is aboriginal health?

many aboriginal health problems begin even before birth and form part of a cyclical pattern affecting our health. our babies are twice as likely to be of low birth weight, to die or fail to thrive. low birth weight, poor diets and poor environmental conditions retard our children's growth and lower their immunity to infectious conditions and kidney disease. access to renal dialysis is problematic with the number of aborigines on renal dialysis doubling every two years.

aboriginal peoples die 15-20 years younger than the australian population, with

23 times the average death rate from infections of the kidney,

12-17 times the average for diabetes (one of the highest rates in the world) and

3-5 times the death rate from chronic respiratory disease.

we are 10 times more likely to suffer blindness than the general population, largely because of corneal scarring from trachoma or unoperated cataract and, increasingly, from diabetes.

we are twice as likely to be admitted to hospital, usually so ill that we need to stay longer - mainly for dialysis, pregnancy and childbirth complications, respiratory and digestive diseases and injury. we suffer higher than average rates for mental disorders, alcohol and other drug related conditions, circulatory diseases, nervous system disorders, skin diseases and infectious and parasitic diseases. these conditions reach an acute stage because of lack of early attention - either because services are not available, or because they are inaccessible to aborigines and torres strait islanders.

taken from:- http://www.atsic.gov.au/issues/disadvantage/health/background_briefing.asp#how%20bad%20is%20aboriginal%20health?

and this is in a country with free health care. i have to share with everyone a quote from that same page

social justice is not primarily a matter of the relief of suffering. it is a matter of the fulfilment of a responsibility.

first report of the former aboriginal and torres strait islander social justice commissioner, mick dodson.

Gwenith, are you sure they didn't just cut and paste that from a Canadian report?;) It is exactly what you'd see here as well... i think people need to get off the race issue and look at the needs issue. Those most at risk need to be treated, and if that means a certain ethnic group, then so what? Deal with it.

+ Add a Comment