LPNs Often Fare Better Than Some Degree Earners

During my four years as an LPN, I did financially better than many of the people who earned baccalaureate degrees in humanities-type majors such as American literature, art, English, philosophy, sociology, classics, linguistics, and theater. While their BA degrees exuded more prestige than my lowly nursing license, I typically earned more money and struggled less than them. Nurses LPN/LVN Article

Updated:  

Some readers might be aware that a college bubble is forming in the United States. Since so many people in this day and age have earned college degrees when compared to previous generations, the value of having one has decreased in the employment market. Graduation from college or university no longer paves the road to good income, success, or the easy life. This is evidenced by the numerous college graduates who are unemployed or underemployed during this economic climate.

I worked as a licensed practical nurse (LPN) from 2006 until 2010 and did reasonably well during those years. No one is ever going to become rich by working as an LPN, but a comfortable life with decent income and middle class comforts are definitely within reach if you do not squander whatever money you earn. My 12-month diploma of vocational nursing and LPN license enabled me to earn a decent income, buy a newer construction house, park two vehicles in the driveway, amass a five-figure nest egg, save for retirement, and avoid living from paycheck to paycheck. By the way, I was accomplishing these things as a single female in my mid-twenties with no spouse or significant other.

I feel that practical education, hands-on job training, and the learning of trades have all been pushed to the wayside. Politicians, educators, and many parents are encouraging all young people to go to college without much regard to the chosen major or concentration. According to Cohan (2012), half of freshly minted college graduates are unemployed or underemployed. And the story does not stop there, because many grads are underemployed in jobs that do not require degrees. Young adults with bachelor's degrees are increasingly scraping by in lower-wage jobs-waiter or waitress, bartender, retail clerk or receptionist, for example-and that's confounding their hopes a degree would pay off despite higher tuition and mounting student loans (USA Today, 2012).

Many of the university graduates who have earned baccalaureate degrees in art history, classics, philosophy, humanities, religious studies, liberal arts, psychology, sociology, women's studies, literature, human ecology, sculpture, fashion design, or any number of majors and concentrations are not faring that well in today's super competitive job market. The ones who do manage to find jobs must contend with very low pay and minimal career mobility. Also, many people who have attained postgraduate education, such as masters and doctorate degrees, in these types of majors are not exactly doing well.

According to Cohan (2012), those with majors "in zoology, anthropology, philosophy, art history and humanities" don't stand much of a chance of getting jobs requiring a college degree. However, according to the BLS, the median annual wage of licensed practical and licensed vocational nurses was $40,380 in May 2010, and LPN employment is expected to grow faster than the national average.

By no means am I bashing higher education, since it instills a broader view of the world and inculcates critical thought. However, many young people are blindly pursuing educational pathways without an end plan or goal in sight. It is so sad to read about individuals with nearly six figures in student loan debt who must work low-paying jobs in the service industry to make their staggering monthly payments.

Stand proud, LPNs. Your licensure will eventually lead to a middle-income job and a path to a respectable life, if it has not already. While the bachelor of arts or masters degree tends to carry more prestige in society than a career certificate and practical nursing license, you will typically earn more money and struggle less than people who did not select their majors wisely. In summary, LPNs often fare better than some degree earners.

 

I dont regret my 18,000 BS in Sociology. I was able, and still remain able to find employment- that I don't think I could find without a degree. Sure, I rarely ever see jobs that require degrees in Sociology. But the point is to have a degree. In anything. And people will give you a second look. I'd rather have a Bachelors, than not have one. I also think "going away to college" is an experience that I wouldn't have got, had I just gone to LPN school from the start. I lived on my own, balanced a checkbook, learned things about myself and other people. Sounds corny, but it was worth 18,000- to me. Yet, I still have to pay $200 a month for 8 more years for my "experience". So yeah, there are drawbacks. :lol2:

That said, I'm excited to see what my future as a LPN holds for me. I don't think I would have ended up here, if not for my oppurtunity to work in a group home and see what nurses did.

Specializes in Forensic Psych.
A very real and unfortunate drawback to some technical fields is that it requires manual labor. My friend's husband, the plumber, can no longer continue in his trade now that he's in his forties because his knees are shot from all the crouching in tight places. The money may be good, but it's hard on the body! Something to consider when going to a trade in your twenties...what shape can you expect to be in by middle age from all the strain on the body.

I agree with this. My step father has been a welder for 30 years and his body is wearing out. Fortunately, he owns his own business so he was able to hire in someone to do it for him. Many good paying manual labor careers have paths that lead to less physical work. A good friend of mine spent about 10 years doing commercial hazmat clean up and moved up into a 6 figure office job with the company with nothing more than a good head on his shoulders and networking.

My mother, an RN is not longer practicing thanks to the strain on HER body at 53. A few years ago she injured her back and had to have surgery and can't work bedside any more. So I wouldn't exclude nursing from the "manual labor" category.

The same can be said for bedside nursing being hard on one's body due to its very physical nature. Many nurses who enter this profession during their youth end up entering middle age with chronic back problems, stress on the joints, repetitive motion injuries, rotator cuff issues, and so forth.

Our very own Nursing With Disabilities forum is filled with these nurses who are now worn down after practicing at the bedside for decades.

To some, the logical solution would be, "Earn your BSN or MSN and look for a desk job." However, many of these nurses already have nursing education at the baccalaureate (BSN) level, and the number of less physical 'desk jobs' is finitely limited. There can only be so many chiefs to overlook the Indians.

I definitely agree! And, I also consider nursing a skilled trade as well.

Actually, I think manual labor keeps people in good shape. Moving furniture helped build my muscles. It's many office/computer workers who seem pretty flabby and weak to me.

With good body mechanics, I suppose lifting furniture would produce body building effects. I'm thinking more of the trades that require you to twist your body out of shape to fit in tight places (like plumbing etc). Good paying trades while young that take a toll on the body with the years. These trades aren't really aerobic or body building...and many in these professions are just as flabby as your average office worker who sits at a desk. Besides, lifting furniture isn't a trained technical degree in my neck of the woods.

Specializes in HIV, Psych, GI, Hepatology, Research.

This is inspiring and we need more inspiration as LPNs. Too many people bash us and I'm tired of it. I would never dare look down upon someone due to their occupation/career. As an LPN I've never had so many people treat me like I'm a nobody. Truth be told this is the best position I've ever had in my life. Yes I am going for my RN. Do I feel that makes me less of a nurse as a LPN, no. I may not have the same scope of practice but it's almost like comparing a doctor to a surgeon in my opinion.

As a LPN I do not live paycheck to paycheck. I have 2 savings accounts (when I never even had one before). I have a brand new car, a huge apartment, I have 2 children who have everything they need and want, I spoil myself with things that I could not before. Point being- My family does just fine on my income as a LPN.

To reiterate the point of this post even more is the fact that one HUGE reason I'm going on to do the LPN to RN bridge is because I've already spent so much time and money on all of the pre requisites needed for the program. If I don't finish then I will have those loans to pay back with nothing to show for it.

I dont think having a degree makes you a better nurse, sorry to my dear lectures, yea i do have a Bachelor degree 4 years later, however i also have studied at other istitutions not at university level and funny enough i get paid more than in my nursing degree , but again the specialty i choose is a male dominant career hence the wages reflect that too. i am starting on 120 thousand year.

Specializes in Critical Care, Med-Surg, Psych, Geri, LTC, Tele,.

Dang commuter! You say some great stuff at the right time!! I start lvn school on Monday and hope for the things you mentioned!!! Thanks!!

Specializes in Case mgmt., rehab, (CRRN), LTC & psych.
Dang commuter! You say some great stuff at the right time!! I start lvn school on Monday and hope for the things you mentioned!!! Thanks!!
I checked your profile and see that you are located in Northern CA, which (unfortunately) has one of the worst nursing job markets in the entire country due to the economic slump.

I'm only being realistic when I say that you are going to need to be ultra creative, think outside the box, and network like crazy in order to find LVN employment in that part of the state. Things are so saturated in Northern CA that some LVN graduates from the class of 2009, 2010, and 2011 have not found their first nursing jobs yet.

I have my history degree. and definately agree, Lpns make MORE MONEY. I am a proud carrier of a bachelors in History that doesn't pay the bills. My Lpn license pays the bills. I will never regret getting that bachelors(army paid for that anyways!) NEVER. But am forever grateful I have nursing skills that NOONE can take away from me. And it is nice to be able to pay my rent on time!

One of my friends has her masters in 15th century French art...

She sells jewelry at a local store for $7.50/hr.

Exactly what kind of high paying job she thought she would get with that degree is beyond me.

Once she said to me, "You are just an LPN! Why do you get paid so much? I have my masters!!"

Uh, yeah,

An Rn with her masters..yes someone like that SHOULD and does get paid more. Completely understandable.

An art history major in an esoteric subject? Of course I am going to get paid more. Supply and demand. Supply and demand.

She has applied to numerous museums...but I am sure there are plenty of art history applicants behind her. I am not an expert but I am going to assume that there are very few positions in comparison to all the art history majors applying.

But if I have question about 15th century French art, I shall ask my friend!

Great article and right on time. I just finished my packet in hopes of getting into practical nursing school. I initially went to college immediately after high school because that was what my parents wanted. I didn't fill out one college app. My parents did them. I tried going into the military but my father cried and pitched a real fit about it. If I had it to do over though I would have either started LPN school right out of high school or went for the military. I dated a guy with 3 degrees and he has no work experience whatsoever. Needless to say he has a really hard time finding work anywhere. I recommended he complete his paralegal studies and work part time while in school but he feels that is "beneathe him" as a law student. Like someone else said, people need to start looking at education as more than just a trophy and a means to look down on those who have chosen different paths. Are we not all in this world togther? Degrees, diplomas, and certificates are stepping stones to a better life. However, the piece of paper in and of itself is not enough anymore. Experience is priceless and will definitely score you a second look too. I plan to use the prereqs I completed in the beginning of my college career later to get my BSN but I definitely think I am much wiser regarding how I want to continue my educational pursuits and avoid drowning in college debt. Thank you again for the article!

Yikes, a *masters* in 15th century French art?? I'm sorry, but the fact that such a major even exists show how out of touch academia is with the real world...

I have a BA in Political Science. I am thankful to have the degree but so far it has done nothing for me. I was not able to get a job with my degree. I finally went to LPN school for 1 year and then I was able to find a job making nearly $20/hour. I am currently in a LPN-BSN program. My point is just having a bachelors degree is not always going to land you a job. Sometimes you have to change your perspective and explore other options that you may have shot down in the past. When you open your mind up to other options you might just stumble into the path you should have taken in the first place.