I've noticed something on these boards...

World International

Published

Disclaimer: This is not to bash US nurses at all, you're all great. Love your work.

OK. After reading through a lot of these threads, especially the ones titled things like "Nurses eat their young", I have noticed that American nurses in general seem to be very competitive with each other and almost perpetuate this "eating their young" thing by going in with a defensive attitude. In many of the threads, nurses are frustrated by colleagues who have no respect for teamwork or 'mateship'. Now, I don't profess to have much experience at all. I have worked as an AIN for a month, and been a student for two years. I have found every single nurse I've met to be helpful and cooperative. There are certainly some who could use a few more communication classes, but all in all there have been no major problems.

It could just be me. I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt. I also go in to a ward with the assumption that everyone will be nice, and I make sure I appear enthusiastic and helpful. When I don't understand or know something, I ask before it becomes a problem.

Do you think that this is a difference in Australian *nursing* culture specifically, or Australian culture in general? Or have I been extremely lucky?

i have found one big difference between aussie and american nurses and im stuggling to say what i want as i know my post will get edited and then it will be a free for all on my ar$e, so im just going to say it....... alot of american nurses (that ive seen post on here) have no sense of humor and are really anal. now it might be due to the patient ratios you guys have but alot of you need to learn to take the pi$$ out of yourself and not be so up tight,...... let the belting commence, ill even make it easy for you guys and grab my ankles

No one is going to take such a sweeping generalization so seriously Froghair. You can come out from under your rock now, no one is going to be angry at your post.

its not a generalization it just goes back to people sometimes percieve how they are differently to how they actually come across. yes im out from under the rock i did have to sleep at some stage. maybe youve just been around to many poms noahm to see this...... and yes i have a ton of american friends none are nurses though. so my post wasnt intended to "american bash" thats just how i see what i read on here. we aussies and yanks are alike but in so many ways we are so different if that makes any sense

Specializes in Med-Surg, Trauma, Ortho, Neuro, Cardiac.
its not a generalization it just goes back to people sometimes percieve how they are differently to how they actually come across........ thats just how i see what i read on here.

My point, and I'll say it again, is you can't judge a culture of nurses by what you read on a message board.

Nurses here too are quick to judge. 50 nurses on a unit, and one bully, so someone comes here and say "why are nurses so catty??? Why do nurses eat their young?". The reader in another country might judge the whole lot and that's not fair.

The US is a big country and nursing even differs from one part of the states to the other.

If we're anal it's because of lawyers and people suing and this organization called JACHO.

I'll get off my soapbox, because I will be the first to admit that nursing this US isn't pretty. I don't have rose colored glasses on.

My point, and I'll say it again, is you can't judge a culture of nurses by what you read on a message board.

Nurses here too are quick to judge. 50 nurses on a unit, and one bully, so someone comes here and say "why are nurses so catty??? Why do nurses eat their young?". The reader in another country might judge the whole lot and that's not fair.

The US is a big country and nursing even differs from one part of the states to the other.

If we're anal it's because of lawyers and people suing and this organization called JACHO.

I'll get off my soapbox, because I will be the first to admit that nursing this US isn't pretty. I don't have rose colored glasses on.

i think you hit it on the head with the law suits i hope australia never gets as bad as you guys have it.

It's hard to imagine a culture of rough looking, steaking eating, beer drinking, crocodile hunters producing nurses that are team players that don't eat their young.

j/k. Stereotypes are wrong. hehehe

That is so hilarious! but yet so true about stereotypes LMAO

Specializes in 5 yrs OR, ASU Pre-Op 2 yr. ER.
My point, and I'll say it again, is you can't judge a culture of nurses by what you read on a message board.

Nurses here too are quick to judge. 50 nurses on a unit, and one bully, so someone comes here and say "why are nurses so catty??? Why do nurses eat their young?". The reader in another country might judge the whole lot and that's not fair.

The US is a big country and nursing even differs from one part of the states to the other.

If we're anal it's because of lawyers and people suing and this organization called JACHO.

I'll get off my soapbox, because I will be the first to admit that nursing this US isn't pretty. I don't have rose colored glasses on.

Thank you, well said. I would have replied to the words you were addressing, but then again, somehow, i would have probably been reinforcing the non-humor, anal stereotyping. :rolleyes:

It is my opinion that American culture as a whole, is very competative. Not limited to the nursing profession. I have beaucoup friends in the tech industry & hear frequent stories of people undermining their co-worker to make oneself look good.

I don't think that being competative in and of itself is a bad thing (but do think that deviance is).

Yes, we eat our young and we are especially fond of foreign travelers. I haven't had a good Aussie meal in a long time so if you are planning on coming to the states may I recommend CA?

Specializes in Med/Surg/Ortho/HH/Radiology-Now Retired.
yes, we eat our young and we are especially fond of foreign travelers. i haven't had a good aussie meal in a long time so if you are planning on coming to the states may i recommend ca?

hahaha! cardiac, i am coming, soon!!! lol but, i have to tell ya, i'd be tough eatin' meat, mate! lol tasty maybe, but bloody tough! lol.

hi

i'm a newly qualified nurse in the Uk and i have found that 'eating their young' happens here to.

i found it was the older nurses who did not like the younger students who are now taking Diplomas and Degrees and they may have felt threatened by them. i personally have been asked by a ward manager that because i have a degree did i think i was better than her (my first ever clinical placement).

but also the areas where they are short staffed and stressed are also prone to this.

as to the Aussie culture i would to nurse there and try it for myself!

+ Add a Comment