Is night shift healthier for some people?

Nurses General Nursing

Published

So I work days, which as a new RN can be difficult to get. I've worked a bit over a year.

We're a busy floor. I am typically out late, between 4:30 - 5pm (supposed to be 7 - 330 shift). I usually am unable to get a lunch, so either don't eat, or eat worse than I'd like to when I get home. I usually get VERY hungry before bed, but try to avoid eating right before bed. I usually scarf down some breakfast. I never used to eat breakfast because it made me sick (nausea) but I would just be so hungry from not eating all day, so I made myself.

Any who I've read through many topics here that state how unhealthy night shift can be on the body. I'm very health conscious. I feel like days isn't that healthy because of my eating habits. But will nights really increase my risk of hypertension/cancer/diabetes/weight gain/ etc??

I'm only asking because I feel like I may be more nocturnal. For one I can eventually fall asleep whenever. But even on my days off when I wake at about 9am I want to take a nap by noon. I have a VERY hard time going to sleep before 2 am or so.

I start to become really energized late in the evening like 8pm or so. I have an *extremely* hard time waking up in the morning. Even if I had 8 to 9 hours of sleep. I have to drag myself out of bed and am often sleepy until noon. Also the most stressful things for me on days - dealing with doctors, families, and lack of teamwork - is minimal on nights.

I did a night shift once before and it was fine for me. But it was only one shift.

Thoughts/experience?

If working nightshift helps you achieve a better work/life balance, or reduces your stress levels, then it is healthier for you, despite some of the drawbacks. It takes a while to accustom and you need to take your rest seriously but it can be managed and can lead to a healthy happy life.

Specializes in geriatrics.

Nights depends on the person. I work permanent nights. I try to keep the same schedule on my nights off and I say no to trading or picking up day shifts.

Sometimes I need melatonin or gravol to sleep, but mostly I'm fine. I also eat healthy meals and exercise. All of these elements are crucial.

Specializes in Med/Surg.

I could not work days. When I work nights, I am able to eat a healthy meal before work, pack a healthy meal and healthy snacks to take with me, and eat a healthy meal before bed in the morning when I get off. On days, I don't eat breakfast (can't wake up early enough) and never have time to pack a lunch. I am much healthier on nights.

Specializes in CICU.
Specializes in LTC/SNF.

I am a night owl by nature. On extended "vacation" time when I have nowhere to be, my body naturally gravitates towards a more nocturnal schedule. The problems for me occur when, as previous posters have stated, I try to switch back and forth between being awake during the day and at night. I am still working on training my husband that waking me up at 1300 to go to lunch together is like me coming in and jumping on the bed at 0100 while he is sleeping and demanding that he wake up. I also feel more tired and fatigued when they jack up my schedule by making me work a 12 alternating with one day off. I feel much better when I work 3 straight 12's and have 4 off. I sleep less now that I work nights, but I used to take hours to fall asleep sometimes, then I would oversleep on weekends. Now I fall straight to sleep after work, and I sleep a good and consistent 6-8 hours per day. I have actually lost 10 lbs in the 2 months since I started working nights since I am more inclined to snack during the day, well, now I am sleeping at that time. For me, I feel healthier and happier on nights. They could not pay me enough to work days, too much craziness and stress.

Caveat: this was the topic of my MSN thesis, and several ongoing research projects I am involved in.

There is strong evidence that people are GENETICALLY 'larks' (morning people) or 'owls' (evening/ night people). From your natural tendencies, it sounds like you are an 'owl' and might do well on night shift.

And yes, it is true that night shift workers have an increased RISK of diabetes, heart disease, stroke, hypertension, cancer, obesity and accidental death.

I'm wondering of those risks are higher with night shift workers who are not "natural" owls but larks.

Specializes in Surgical/MedSurg/Oncology/Hospice.

I've been an RN for 4 years now, originally starting off on the 3p-11p shift...that wasn't for me, I never saw my school-age children and getting errands/chores done was difficult. I transferred to a 12hr day shift position after 6 months...for a newer RN that's like hitting the jackpot, right? NOT for me! :no: I needed more sleep to be able to drag my rear out of bed at 5am, but had trouble 'winding down' and getting to sleep before midnight. The chaotic frenzy of all that goes along with day shift, along with the learning curve that newer RN's are constantly trying to keep ahead of, had me seriously doubting my ability to continue in this career.

Six months into the day shift job I had an opportunity to transfer (all of these moves were lateral transfers within one health system, maintaining my seniority) to my dream unit, but it was the midnight shift...I was doubtful, nervous about the shift change, but decided to take the plunge. That was the BEST decision I've made in my career so far. While the night shift has its down falls, I LOVE working nights: no management hovering, dealing primarily with either House Officers or Surgical Resident and not the entire alphabet soup of specialties, no case management rounds in the middle of med pass, no fighting for a (functioning) computer at the nurses station or the wall-a-roos, a tighter-knit relationship with my MN coworkers, a much more laid back mentality...and I can easily function competently on 5-ish hours of sleep if needed and do not 'hit the wall' of exhaustion like I used to on day shift.

While I can't speak for all of the potential health-risks associated with shift work, for me it has meant significantly less stress, more sleep (as I maintain my nocturnal routine even on days off) and even more time with my family, as my kids are teens now who tend to gravitate toward my schedule, at least during summer-break;). I don't plan on leaving my 12 hr midnight shifts unless hell freezes over...why work a shift I hate for less money?! :uhoh3:

Specializes in pediatrics; PICU; NICU.

I've been working nights for almost 38 years. When I got married 6 years ago, I took a day job so my hubby & I would work the same hours. Big mistake for me! I could not sleep at night, wanted to sleep all day when I was at work, & felt generally ill the whole time. I only lasted a month & begged to go back to nights. Once back on nights, I was fine again. I'll never try that again!

Specializes in geriatrics.

Like many others, I worked day shift for years (non nursing) and I always struggled to force myself to sleep before midnight. Even if I had been at work all day and tired, I'd naturally want to be up by the time 2030 came around.

Try going to work on four hours sleep for months on end. Rotating shifts though are the worst, because your system never really knows when to sleep and that's all too common for nursing.

I doubt I'll work permanent nights forever, but rotating shifts are definitely out. I need a set schedule.

Specializes in NICU, ICU, PICU, Academia.
I'm wondering of those risks are higher with night shift workers who are not "natural" owls but larks.

That exact hypothesis is the focus of some current research. I think it is entirely plausible.

I've been working night shift for 1.5 years now and I recently did my physical and bloodwork. Welp, it came back low in Vitamin D and that my urine showed I was dehydrated. Thank Lord, my TSH, T4 levels and thyroid US were normal. I've been feeling quite sluggish at work and stressed lately. I know in the long run the night shift is not practical for me. For now, I'm taking supplements and getting out in the sun * I live in the Sunshine State , lol* and drinking plenty of water.

Specializes in Prior military RN/current ICU RN..

Where did i criticize anything? You are the one giving out information not me. I was asking for facts. Are you sayong if i find somethong on google it is always true? Anyone who claims to KNOW something as always true then i expect evidence

Is that wrong? Chill out

+ Add a Comment