HANDWASHING: Male hospital staff lax

Nurses Activism

Published

http://www.reutershealth.com/frame2/eline.html

Male hospital staff lax on handwashing: study

NEW YORK, Jan 16 (Reuters Health) - Studies have found that men are less strict about handwashing than women are, and new research suggests that the cleanliness gender gap extends to the medical profession.

Australian researchers found that in their institution's critical care unit, male healthcare workers washed their hands one-third less often than female workers did after contact with an invasive instrument or a patient's skin, blood or "excretions."

But the sex difference was not seen across all the professions, according to Thea van de Mortel and colleagues at Southern Cross University in Lismore.

Male and female nurses had similarly high handwashing rates after patient contact. As for doctors, women washed their hands 88% of the time, compared with just 54% among men. Female ward workers washed up nearly twice as often their male counterparts, and female radiographers practiced hand hygiene more often than males, the report indicates.

Physical therapists were the most vigilant of all. Both men and women washed their hands after every patient contact observed in the study, according to findings published in a recent issue of the American Journal of Infection Control.

Handwashing is a basic way to limit the spread of germs in any environment. A number of studies in the general population have shown that women and girls are more likely than men and boys to wash their hands in a germ-filled situation, such as after using the bathroom, the researchers point out.

The authors note that these results follow that trend, with the exception of nurses and physical therapists. And they speculate that "cultural" differences among the health professions might explain the various handwashing practices.

"Pinpointing how these cultural differences arise may provide a means of boosting handwashing frequency," van de Mortel and colleagues write.

Handwashing in the study was assessed by "covert" observers from the staff. They followed the handwashing practices of 156 men and 93 women across all hospital shifts, for 3 months.

SOURCE: American Journal of Infection Control 2001;29:395-399.

--------------------

WE nurses have known this for years! HOW can we break this poor habit???????

Both times; before and after you go. Especially after, and especially before. Try to keep your hands germ free at all times, because they are your most used instraments as a health worker.:)

I wash when i come into the bathroom, and on my way out. And often I wipe my hands and carry the PAPER towel with me, closing the faucet and opening the doors with it as my barrier to those two obvious noscomial points.

Well I always wash before and after and use a paper towel to turn off the water and open the door. Our infection control team has found that the door handles are the most contaminated area in there.

And as far as the technique you grab your waist band kinda far out over thigh area pull down until the equipment comes out ,relax and go then you can even shake the with the wasit band if you must. the simply raise your wasit band and you are done, ta da. by grabbing far enough out and from the outside you dont gran any part that touched mister happy. hope that helps for you curious folk.

How did we get this far with our dirty hands.............

bobbi

Specializes in NICU.

While I was typing my earlier post, my fiance walked in and read over my shoulder. He then went ahead and demonstrated Mario's described technique, including the wigglying on tippy toes at the end. While I could pretty much picture it from the description, the demonstration is kinda funny.

Just wanted to point out for all the guys getting defensive here, that, according to the article NRSKaren posted, male nurses have handwashing rates equivalent to female nurses. It's just all the other male healthcare workers in the hospital who are bad, dirty, icky boys. ;)

This thread keeps making me think of that scene in Lethal Weapon 3, when Lorna Cole (Rene Russo) follows Riggs (Mel Gibson) into the guys' bathroom and they proceed to have a discussion while he whizzes, shakes off, and zips up, all with his back to the camera. He finally turns to agree with her and attempts to shake hands. She looks down at his unwashed appendage (not THAT one--his hand,you perverts!), smirks, and says pointedly, "Wash your hands, Riggs," before turning and walking out of the bathroom.

My point? Um...I forget, exactly. Something about Mel Gibson having a nice butt, I think...

Hi colleagues... naughteeee. LOL. I have to admit that in my personal experiences as working around and with mostly male physicians in the hospital setting, I've only notice two in my entire career that either washed their hands before going in the patient's room, while in the patient's room or after coming out of the room. I've seen many a doctor walk in a room with blatant isolation signs all over the place as if germs can't touch them and they don't carry them.

Specializes in ER, ICU, L&D, OR.

Sounds like a bunch of male bashing to me. Coupled with some weird thinking, Definitely more than I wanted to hear.

Ive been around a long time, cants say where ive seen men wash their hands less than women,or doctors of either gender. particularly in todays enviroment where you are exposed to everything continously.

YUCK

Thomas

Specializes in ER.

OK so some guys think they can go without touching any critical body parts, but the first question that came to my mind was that their aim must be awful- and who gets to clean THAT up?

Aim!! What's up with that? Urinating in the standing position for a guy is NOT like throwing a basketball, or something, where you hafta aim. This is absurd;) Do you aim your hands into your face when you drink a glass of juice? It's adduction, right? ;) Well, for us guys, it automatic abduction.:)

Perhaps women stereotype all men (sweeping generalizations) based on Mel Gibson movies. :roll

LOL @ Stargazer!

This all makes it sound as if male genitals are the filthiest thing around. Relatively, genitals are probably cleaner than hands even AFTER they've been washed.

I REALLY wanna say something naughty here, but know it would be edited.....DAMN!

I'm afraid I have to agree with mjamesRN. My hands touch doorknobs, money, and everything else, while my...well, never mind. Anyway, as far as bathroom habits, I wash my hands after, use paper towels to turn off the water and open the door. In public bathrooms, if the toilet or urinal isn't an automatic flusher, I use my foot or elbow to flush. Does anyone here do that? Needless to say it's my elbow for the urinal. If I tried to use my foot, I'd wind up in the E.R.!

:chuckle So, Mario, you've never seen the results of a male's bad aim? I didn't there was anyone who hasn't! I just figured there are an awful lot of men with either bad eyesight, or really shaky hands!

+ Add a Comment