Do Female Docs Provide Better Care to Their Hospitalized Patients Than Male Counterparts?

Nurses General Nursing

Published

According to Medicare data analysis, "elderly hospital patients seen by female internists were less likely to die or be readmitted in the short run than those treated by male physicians."

The results of a study approved by the Harvard Medical School Institutional review Board and published in JAMA today show "the advantages associated with female physicians persisted across eight common medical conditions and across patients' severity of illness".

"There is evidence in the primary care setting suggesting that, compared with male physicians, female physicians are more likely to practice evidence-based medicine, perform as well or better on standardized examinations, and provide more patient-centered care. Patients of female primary care physicians also experience fewer emergency department visits compared with patients of male primary care physicians."

What do you think female doctors do differently than male doctors?

Do you have a preference for the gender of your physician(s)? If so, what is this preference based on?

For more about this study, please go to:

Comparison of Hospital Mortality and Readmission Rates for Medicare Patients Treated by Male vs Female Physicians

Specializes in Hospice, corrections, psychiatry, rehab, LTC.

Speaking from personal experience, the best physician I have ever had was a female. So was the worst one.

Women are usually socialized differently than men, which may account for some of the differences in how they generally treat others.

Specializes in Peds, Med-Surg, Disaster Nsg, Parish Nsg.

An interview with 2 of the physicians involved in this study has been added to the OP.

Specializes in Critical Care, Med-Surg, Psych, Geri, LTC, Tele,.

In most cases I do not have a preference for the gender of my physicians. However, I prefer female counselors and psychotherapists.

Oh my goodness, Commuter! I was thinking the same thing!!

I wonder what some of the posters here would say about the fact that while the vast majority of healthcare is dominated by women, men tend to be promoted faster and take a higher percentage of leadership roles, especially in the executive level. I am sure that this must mean that women are not as intelligent as men or maybe just do not have the biological capacity to be good leaders.

Is it OK yet in this thread to say that I prefer Asian physicians since they are obviously much more intelligent since medical schools have to discriminate against them to prevent Asians from dominating medical schools? Acceptance rates being a skewed as much as 22.5% for Asian and 81.0% for Blacks for the same GPA and MCAT score.

Short answer: no. I have seen really no difference. I know many docs male and female who are good. I also know many male and female docs who should not be allowed near a hospital. It's about personality, compassion, and heart. Why not go further with this study. Where the doctors black, white, Korean, Indian, Chinese, Vietnamese, Jamaican, etc?

Specializes in Psychiatry, Community, Nurse Manager, hospice.

I'm a woman. And I'm not surprised that we do this better. We do lots of things better. But it's not cool to rub it in. And it really isn't useful information, since both sexes should have equal opportunity in every field.

We wouldn't like it if studies were being published that men are better at stuff. We would hate that. It might be used to justify discrimination and it would just be plain ole sexist.

So let's stop.

Are we talking gender or sex? Are we talking about learned or innate behaviors?

I'm kidding, I really don't care. Humans being good humans to each other is all I care about.

Be a good person.

Specializes in ICU.

My answer to the thread question is NO..

Reminds me of this meme!

I'm not really one to generalise based on sex, however, as a male nurse, I can definitely say that women do a much better job at SHOWING compassion. As someone who considers himself to be a great nurse, I often see my female counterparts exhibiting such kindness and compassion and I don't really see that with our male nurses. I think we can be a bit more direct and to the point, why women, their maternalistic instincts are truly evident in the care they provide. That is not to say male nurses don't provide equal care. It's just different care.

I think in my experience, this is the same for physicians. I work with an pulmonary intensivist who is just absolutely amazing and competent- especially with end of life issues and patients just love him. While I have an IM doc who has really poor bedside manner and patients despise him- however, he is a genius and still provides great care. And ultimately, I work with this one female Neurologist and female Stroke-Neuro NP who are absolutely phenomenal and amazingly compassionate. They truly get to know their patients and provide excellent care and makes me feel very proud to be on their team.

You provided some statistics and I'm a science guy so I'm inclined to believe the stats- my guess is women tend to be more maternalistic- certain things keep them up at night more than men so maybe they truly go out of their way to make sure the patient gets excellent care and thus they can sleep better at night! I do have to say I have worked with some pretty awesome doctors, men and women but my favourite physicians happen to be women- they treat me with kindness and value my opinion while also spending quality time with their patients instead of just a quick lung auscultation and chart review.

I think that the osteopathic training may have something to do with it as well.

I have noticed a difference in their approaches both as a patient and a nurse. You raise yet another good point.

+ Add a Comment