Critical Thinking

Critical thinking is an intellectual process which uses one's clinical skills to guide one's patient care. Clinical decisons that need to be based on a logical thinking process. How can one learn critical thinking and put that into practice? Nurses Announcements Archive Article

Critical thinkers want to be clear. They want to be logical. Nurses want to be accurate and precise in their practice. It is safe practice and in a patient's best interest.

So how does one become a critical thinker? A nurse needs to learn how to be fair and actively listening to their patients. Newer nurses would benefit from a mentor. Someone who's practice they admire, and who they can observe and learn from. Nurses benefit from leading with their heads, and not their hearts.

For every action, there's a reaction. So to critically think, a nurse must be systematic in the practice of assessment. A good assessment starts with getting as much information that you can and in a perfect world, from the patient. Sometimes, that is just not feasible. And depending on the unit on which you work, not possible. So a good head to toe is paramount to good critical thinking skills.

Always, always follow your facility policy. And always be sure that first and foremost, your patient's heart is beating and they are breathing. Otherwise, here's a good run down on an assessment, which can only enhance critical thinking.

So literally, start at the head. Are they alert, oriented, do they have any bruising or head lacs? Can they speak, swallow? What's going on with the neck? JVD? Can they shrug their shoulders? Raise their arms? What is their grips like? Skin color, condition, temperature? Do they have good cap refill? What is their blood pressure? Are they breathing well? RR? Labored? Equal chest rise and fall? Listen to their heart. Are they at a regular rate and rythym? While you are there take an apical pulse. Are you hearing and feeling the same thing?

Listen to each lobe of the lung, both sides. What do the lungs sound like? Look at the skin conditon of the back.

Is the patient urinating and having BM's? Regularly? What kind of sounds do you hear in the abdomen, each quad? Is their any tenderness? Where? Look at the sacral area of the back. What is the skin condition?

Does the patient have any swelling of the legs or feet? Do they have any discoloration? What is the cap refill like in the toes? Do they have good sensation? Do they move, walk, walk with an appliance? Frequent falls?

Finally, what is their home life like? Do they live alone? Are they scared? Are they being hurt? Do they have any services in place? Do they need any services in place? Do they need an alternate level of care? Do they, or the family that lives with them, need any specialized teaching to maintain function?

In order to critically think well, all of the information that a nurse needs to make an informed report to the MD and/or other disciplines needs to start with a through and good assessment. You need to be aware of what the goal of the patient is to make reasoned thought a reality for the end goal of the highest level of function for your patient.

Specializes in PACU, presurgical testing.

I read a quotation recently on the back of a book on critical thinking: "You see what you know." No way around it; this is true. As a new grad, there is so much I don't see because I don't know to look for it. Every day I learn new things that get added to the knowledge bank, which helps me to see these things in the future, but it's a gradual process.

It's also hard to know what's important (and to whom). Sometimes I find that when I "critically think" about an issue and talk to someone in the department or one of the docs, it's not really a big deal to them. Better not to assume, as a previous poster said.

I am a firm believer in CT and it saves lives.

My question is this: How do we expect nurses to hold space for CT when we let them work in clunky processes?

I asked nurses on this forum how many times a shift they find themselves spending 10 minutes looking for equipment, information, keys etc and it is staggering that most of them spent triple that amount of time hunting and gathering items for patient care.

I did the math and worked out that if 12 nurses spent 10 minutes on one ward in one day, in a hospital of 20 wards just looking for stuff it equated to 400 hours of time spent away from the patient bedside. It's frustrating and does not empower our nurses. It certainly is not conducive to having space to think critically about your patients.

I'm not saying that CT is not an important skill - it is vital! There is value in making sure that the nurse can first get to spend more time with the patient to be able to do the head to toe assessment and put clinical signs together.

Perhaps its time to link these two together - time at the bedside & CT - and make them of equal importance for patient safety.

Specializes in Cardiothoracic ICU.

"Always, always follow your facility policy." Unfortunately policy at my hospital has taken critical thinking out of the nurses scope of practice.

"Always, always follow your facility policy." Unfortunately policy at my hospital has taken critical thinking out of the nurses scope of practice.

In the posts of some regular posters, critical thinking is not in the L.P.N. scope of practice and is a result of their education. They forget that it's a lifeskill.

See, now my problem with the excerpts you quoted here is they're just so..... dry. Unrelateable and jargon-filled to the point of being impenetrable. That third quote, for example, is rendered almost meaningless by it's own inaccessible language. The content is all true and of value, but that's useless if the reader is coma-inducing bored three words in.

Well, then, let's try it again. I didn't see jargon or inaccessible big words, but hey. In the eye of the beholder, I guess. Ot maybe a life skill, whatever that is.

Break it down into phrases and you'll see it's not so hard.

"Critical thinking is

the ability to recognize problems

and raise questions,

gather evidence to support answers and solutions,

evaluate alternative solutions,

and communicate effectively with others

to implement solutions for the best possible outcomes."

Was that really so hard?

You will note that it is not merely collecting information from a comprehensive examination, which appeared to be the main thrust of the OP. I will grant you that it's not as simplistic as many people take it to be-- I can see that the vast majority of posters here really don't have a good understanding of all the parts of critical thinking. That is almost certain to be the major problem with trying to get nurses to use it. Simpler language cannot, alas for your assumption, reduce critical thinking down to fewer parts than these.

Recognizing problems -- that's the "AD" of ADPIE-- assess/analyze and diagnose (yes, nursing diagnosis...where did I just see posted that someone hadn't done that for seven years since she graduated? Yeah.)

Gathering evidence to support answers/solutions to the problems-- that's evidence-based practice in action. How many people really do that?

Evaluating alternatives-- well, you need a decent education to know what they might be in the first place. Then you make a conscious evaluation.

Effective communication -- IMHO, saying a piece is about critical thinking and then going off on the specifics of physical assessment is not evidence of this.

"Always, always follow your facility policy." Unfortunately policy at my hospital has taken critical thinking out of the nurses scope of practice.

I see your point with all of the "smart pumps" and "customer service scripts" and "key terms" and the list goes on and on....

And it has been in my particular scope in my state to be able to effectively think critically. It is a life skill, and an important part of keeping your patient at a level compatible with end goal.

Even with all of those things listed above, it is important to listen to your patient, report to whomever you need to, advocate always.

Well, then, let's try it again. I didn't see jargon or inaccessible big words, but hey. In the eye of the beholder, I guess. Ot maybe a life skill, whatever that is.

I wasn't trying to be offensive or stand-offish. It was just that the quotes you cited reminded me about an interesting article I'd read in the online NYT about how the majority of academic writing fails to speak to it's readers. Althogh full of information, it fails to really convey that information, because most readers are in trouble a couple sentences in. Not because it's over their head, or has big words, but because it's obtuse. It lacks flow. The reader shouldn't have to work that hard to get through a paragraph.

Only reason I said anything is because I had just read that article, and it was on my mind.

IMHO, saying a piece is about critical thinking and then going off on the specifics of physical assessment is not evidence of this.

Yeah... that did throw me off. I kept waiting for the meat.

In any case, the article is appreciated for creating a jumping off point from where we can expand on the concept of critical thinking.

Yeah... that did throw me off. I kept waiting for the meat.

In any case, the article is appreciated for creating a jumping off point from where we can expand on the concept of critical thinking.

And that was my intent. Critical thinking in nursing begins, in my opinion, with a really good and through assessment.

And critical thinking is a concept that one can only learn and be astute in with time and practice. No critical thinking is effective if you have no clue what you are dealing with. And a good assessment is how those thought processess form.

Terrific article describing the critical thinking that goes along with physical assessment, which is the springboard of all other care relating to the patient. That's why we do the physical assessments before anything else. I wouldn't want to "get the meds out of the way", no matter what time is scheduled on the MAR, before evaluating whether the meds are appropriate at this time, ie bp meds when the bp is low, skin clammy and pale, pt with n/v, etc. Critical thinking means you don't leave your brain at the house. I am not an automaton, I am a nurse. I use all 5 senses, and then my 6th when I can't put a finger on it, but something is just not right with a pt. It was a surprise to me as a new nurse, 22 yrs ago, how seldom I got to have that "Ta-daa" moment of "fixing" a pt. I thought I wasn't doing it right. A more experienced mentor explained that critical thinking, and nursing process, are fluid...going on all the time about all pts at once. It's not a checklist, and you never get to say "done with that one...next!" until death or discharge. "Remember", she said, "only the dumb ones never ask questions..."

Great article!! :)

Specializes in retired from healthcare.

"You don't leave your brain at the house."

More importantly, you do not let staff members, patients or visitors take your brain out of gear. Health workers are not flunkies that have to cater to high and mighty authority figures.

Don't leave your heart and soul "at the house" either.