Betrayed by Management

Updated:   Published

Hello Nurse Beth,

I am in need of your support and expert opinion. For the past two years I have been a staff nurse on a very busy med/surg unit. This past May I graduated with my BSN. We tragically lost our evening nurse manager to an automobile accident on May 30th, and management offered me the position. It was a privilege and an honor for them to have chosen me and I gracefully accepted the unofficial position. Due to the sensitivity of the matter they did not post and interview for it until about 3 weeks ago.

As you can imagine, transitioning from floor nurse to manager was not an easy task. I gave it my all, self taught by reading, researching, and gained lots of experience by doing. The evening shift is a challenging one, but gave it my all and did my best- my teammates were rooting for me. I have a great rapport with the unit as well as the entire “Planetree” community and departments within the organization.

In a nutshell, the organization decided to hire a candidate that they thought was more qualified for the position. I am discouraged because I believe I earned and deserved that position. I am now left with the offer to continue until the new manager starts and goes through hospital orientation, as well as orienting with me in the position, (which will take us through the next 6 weeks) or I can return to the 36 hr , 3 12’s I had initially (they were saving my spot). I am torn and don’t know how to handle it. Part of me tells me it wasn’t meant to be, and to swallow my pride, because I understand that when one door closes another one opens. How I handle this will be a true testament- at the same time I feel betrayed. This is a time sensitive matter . Please advise 

Dear Betrayed,

You really stepped up for them and gave them your best. It's natural to feel a range of emotions when this happens. Feeling betrayed and even used is understandable.

But the thing is, it's business, and it's not personal. The best thing for you to do, career-wise, is stay on in the temp position until the new manager is trained. Help her to be a success with your inside knowledge. You will gain an ally, not to mention you'll be doing the right thing.

I saw the identical thing happen on a MedSurg floor, and the interim nurse manager, who I'll call Chelsea, was passed over for an outside applicant. The outside applicant lasted a little over a year, and guess who became the manager again- on her own floor? Right, the interim. She's held the position for 5 years now and is held in high esteem. By that I mean she is always being selected to work on new initiatives.

To all appearances, Chelsea was gracious and took the high road throughout the whole experience. If she had given in to negative feelings, she never would have been promoted in the long run.

Chances are, you will get your chance, it's just not your time right this minute... You learned a lot and that you won't lose.

You are so right, your behavior now is a testament-and an opportunity to rise above and be professional.

Best wishes,

Nurse Beth

Specializes in Geriatrics, Dialysis.

I disagree heartily with the advice to stay on, train the new manger in the job OP expected to and was led to believe she would receive and then happily go back to the previous floor position. Plus be grateful for the experience? No thanks. 

If the stars align there will be another job for a different employer with a start date that makes training her own immediate supervisor before what now feels like a demotion an impossibility.  Heck if OP can line up that new job I wouldn't blame her at all if it becomes impossible to stay on long enough to train the new hire in what she feels should have been her job even if it means taking some well deserved time off between jobs! 

I'm a little salty about this situation because a similar thing happened to me and I did exactly that. I found another job with the added bonus of better pay and benefits. Just be sure to never badmouth your current employer, don't ever admit to leaving just because you were passed up for the position and obviously give your employer a proper notice before leaving. 

Specializes in Medical, surgical, geriatric, rehabilitation, tvn.

Dear colleague,

I am sure  you did not even think at first what’s for you ? Anything written your temporary managing the ward?possibility you can be a candidate ?but you grab it and why not your one of the senior, Then you have you have given your utmost, .is it unfair ? 
Did you ever think of a full on management responsibilities Protocol an d guidelines ....can you handle bureaucracy.

Well it was not given to you as you fill in only a part of it, when the time comes you’ll be able to realise what I’m saying then you are ready.

I am sure most of the colleagues senior and good experience will agree that so many managers shouldn’t be one. 
If you think you want to handle this responsibility and this is your calling, think again. 
 

1 hour ago, kbrn2002 said:

Heck if OP can line up that new job I wouldn't blame her at all if it becomes impossible to stay on long enough to train the new hire in what she feels should have been her job even if it means taking some well deserved time off between jobs! 

I thought that too, even as I was calling the "train your replacement" move classy.

It's also perfectly classy to make good decisions for oneself, take care not to burn bridges, and go about one's life in a positive manner even if that doesn't involve doing exactly what other people wish you would do after they have independently made their own decisions.

Specializes in retired LTC.

kbrn2002 - I luv you!  You wholeheartedly agree with my take on the situation and said it so clearly! And JKL33 is on board too. And others.

Sad that we COBs are out of tolerance for these cheap shots by upper admin 'manglement' that take advantage of good nurse employees, esp the 'team players'. It's been way too long  and enough is enough.

There's a current member here who has very similar adamant views, altho that poster's recommendations may be a bit too extreme for my tastes.

to delia - welcome to AN. It's freq a suggestion to new members that you consider using anonymous screen names. Everybody & anybody reads this open site, and you don't want to be noticed.

Specializes in Acute Rehab, STR, Med/Surg, SDS.

To my fellow RN’s......

I have read each and every one of your responses carefully and  considered it all. I appreciate all of your advice and am grateful for all your support- you all made very valid points and your experiences are noteworthy. 

Nurse Beth- thank you for your advice, I have decided to do just that. I must say I absolutely love both the hospital as well as my co-workers and have no intentions of leaving just yet. I will rise above and remain in this position until necessary, definitely update my resume, and then eventually resume my position as floor nurse . I have no doubt that this was a stepping stone, and eventually something will come along that is meant to be- until then, I will continue to do what I love, and do it well :)

OGRNBSN

5 hours ago, Olga Giotopulos said:

I must say I absolutely love both the hospital as well as my co-workers and have no intentions of leaving just yet. I will rise above and remain in this position until necessary, definitely update my resume, and then eventually resume my position as floor nurse

I support you. ?? Having a workplace that you love and wonderful coworkers is not something to throw away lightly or out of a sense of revenge or temporary hurt feelings.

I am in favor of people thinking these things through and making the decision that feels right to them from a position of personal strength, rather than ever feeling duty-bound (by nursing) to respond in a particular way after others have already made their decisions. A decision you make proactively, positively and from a position of strength is pretty much a good one in my book and given your mindset this situation is bound to lead to even more personal growth. Likely professional, too.

Best of luck to you.

Specializes in Critical Care; Cardiac; Professional Development.

If that is your real name, you may wish to change it to something more anonymous.

Specializes in retired LTC.

to OG - to add to the PP, I am also STRONGLY recommending your change your screen name, and do it quickly. There is NO privacy on social media, and for this site here, everybody & anybody, incl employers, read it, unbeknownst. Anonymity is your friend.

The mods can help you.

OP, please check your inbox - I sent a message.

On 11/4/2020 at 12:49 AM, OGRNBSN said:

To my fellow RN’s......

I have read each and every one of your responses carefully and  considered it all. I appreciate all of your advice and am grateful for all your support- you all made very valid points and your experiences are noteworthy. 

Nurse Beth- thank you for your advice, I have decided to do just that. I must say I absolutely love both the hospital as well as my co-workers and have no intentions of leaving just yet. I will rise above and remain in this position until necessary, definitely update my resume, and then eventually resume my position as floor nurse . I have no doubt that this was a stepping stone, and eventually something will come along that is meant to be- until then, I will continue to do what I love, and do it well ?

OGRNBSN

Word to the wise, change your profile photo if that is truly your picture. It might seem like an innocuous thing on an online forum, but I would be remiss to think that all the eyes that peruse these spheres are for altruistic purposes. Nonetheless, take my word of caution with a grain of salt. I am just a cynical nurse hehe. 

+ Join the Discussion