who is better trained(clincals) adn or bsn

  1. 0
    i have heard conflicting stories about adn being more trained than a bsn. i thought to myself: if asn are more trained how is it that bsn are the ones who are prefered in hiring.

  2. Enjoy this?

    Join thousands and get our weekly Nursing Insights newsletter with the hottest, discussions, articles, and toons.

  3. 12 Comments...

  4. 0
    This is dependent upon the particular programs being compared at any given point in time.
  5. 1
    I agree that it depends upon the individual school, not whether it is an ADN or BSN program. There are clinically strong and clinically weak ADN programs and the same for BSN programs. You can't make blanket assumptions just based on the type of program.
    Spidey's mom likes this.
  6. 1
    I agree it depends on where your clinicals are and the amount of things the clinical site allows the student to do.
    RNDreamer likes this.
  7. 2
    I agree it all depends on the program. Frankly having been in all 3 Diploma is definitely first in getting skills. I did not finish that one for personal reasons.

    I went right to a BS program and felt we stood around more than participated. Then after I got married I dropped out for 9 years and went to an associate program. 3 courses tough as nails-8 hours a day 4 days a week clinical- classes sometimes til 6 at night. I was ready to ride when I graduated.

    So that's 3 programs out of the bazillion out there;it's like comparing apples, pecans and pvc pipe. You have to investigate before you start to find out how many clinical hours you need-and how many skills you can get in those hours.
    Joie_de_vivre and Jessy_RN like this.
  8. 3
    There is no way to answer this question. It depends upon variables that cannot be assessed here: the schools, instructor, clinical sites, and student attitude and effort.
    Joie_de_vivre, cmh05, and RNDreamer like this.
  9. 0
    maybe my question should be do u actually get hands on experience in clincals if you pursue a bsn?
  10. 2
    Quote from mee9mee9
    maybe my question should be do u actually get hands on experience in clincals if you pursue a bsn?
    Yes, you do; you'll place Foleys, initiate IVs, give meds, learn charting, do assessments, etc etc... with a 2-year program that's done in 4 semesters (5 if you do an LPN exit); with a 4-year BSN program, it's spread out more. If you want more hands-on training, know your stuff before you show up to clinicals; be ready to volunteer to assist with placing a chest tube, remove staples, do an IV push... whatever might happen. If you show aptitude and are willing to be the first to try something, your instructor will likely take notice and let you do more. I can't tell you how many times at the start of clinicals my instructor would pop her head into a room and go "Anyone want to d/c an epidural?" and the students would look nervously at each other and wait for someone else to volunteer. Get the basics down (sterile procedures, how to admin different types of injections, etc) from your book and be the first to jump on whatever opportunities your instructor provides.
    Joie_de_vivre and cmh05 like this.
  11. 0
    Quote from mee9mee9
    maybe my question should be do u actually get hands on experience in clincals if you pursue a bsn?
    It depends on the program. My BS program is a three year program, so we have three years of clinicals. I've forgotten the exact number, but we have in excess of 1,500 clinical hours.

    I've received plenty of "hands-on" experience.
  12. 1
    It depends alot on the program like everyone has said. In general it depends on what your trained to do. Clinical skill focused on a little more in associate level. Management, academic is pushed more in BSN. You can't really answer which trains you better, you need to differentiate what it is you want to be trained for. My program had very little clinical training. I didn't know what working as a nurse was until after graduation, but I sure could write a paper about it, lol.
    Joie_de_vivre likes this.

Nursing Jobs in every specialty and state. Visit today and Create Job Alerts, Manage Your Resume, and Apply for Jobs.