Not Criminally Responsible

Nursing Students Student Assist

Published

  1. Should an individual with a mental health disorder be found Criminally Responsible?

    • 5
      Yes
    • 1
      No

6 members have participated

Hi all,

I'm new to this site so correct me if I'm posting this in the wrong section. I'm a first year psychiatric nursing student and I have a term paper coming up. The topic is that individuals diagnosed with a mental health disorder who have committed a crime should be found Not Criminally Responsible. I am having trouble writing this paper and any thoughts or opinions would be extremely helpful. Thanks! :up:

Up Vote Up Vote ×

Too many variables for there to be a yes/no answer to your question. For one thing, "mental health disorder" can mean anything from mild depression or anxiety to intractable psychosis.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Med/Surg, Ortho, ASC.

Do you have any thoughts or ideas yourself? As a first year nursing student, your primary job is not just to write your papers, but also to learn how to research and develop your own ideas.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Med/Surg, Ortho, ASC.

P.s. What do you mean by saying you're a psych nursing student? Nursing students don't specialize in school.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Critical Care.

The portion of those "diagnosed with a mental health disorder" that are truly unable to tell right from wrong is very small, so no, I don't think it would be appropriate or respectful to those with mental health disorders to say that none of them know right from wrong and therefore shouldn't be held responsible for crimes they commit.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in OR, Nursing Professional Development.
P.s. What do you mean by saying you're a psych nursing student? Nursing students don't specialize in school.

Poster is from British Columbia in Canada, where nurses can specialize into psychiatric nursing programs. CRPNBC

Agree that this is in no way a simple yes/no question.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
P.s. What do you mean by saying you're a psych nursing student? Nursing students don't specialize in school.

OP is in Canada (where they do have specialized psych nursing degrees).

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Education.

OP, this sounds more like a paper that wants your opinion...let me put on a writing teacher's hat for a few minutes.

So, do you think they should be held criminally responsible or not?

Now that you've answered that question, time to start your research. What reliable sources (tip: start with your textbooks) can you find to back up your opinion? Look at the sources that your textbook authors used. Are you able to find those writings and use them? Now go online. Google Scholar is an excellent place to start the internet searching. Ovid, PubMed...your school librarians can help you with that, as well.

As part of an opinion paper, you will want to acknowledge the other side. Spare a paragraph or two for that.

Now, maybe you really can't decide one way or the other. So what is your opinion?

Is this your first paper as a university student? There are so many tips and tricks out there that it will take too long for me to go through them all. If your school offers writing tutors, then they will be a good resource for you to use.

One final question. Did you take any sort of academic writing class?

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Complex pedi to LTC/SA & now a manager.
P.s. What do you mean by saying you're a psych nursing student? Nursing students don't specialize in school.

They do in Canada and the UK

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in ED, Pedi Vasc access, Paramedic serving 6 towns.

I would go online to your library's website and look for online journal articles. You are not going to right a legitimate paper based on peoples online opinions!

Annie

Up Vote Up Vote ×

@tyler start your paper with the Canadian legal definition of 'not criminally responsible on account of a mental disorder' .

Up Vote Up Vote ×

Thank you all for the feedback. This definitely isn't my first essay as a uni student. What my opinion is and what I'm aruguing is that if an individual is diagnosed with a mental health disorder they should be found NOT criminally responsible. I have read through some academic articles and what I'm finding in common to support my argument is how prisons/jails worsen symptoms of mental illness and individuals would receive better/proper treatment in a hospital rather than behind bars. Should I save my last paragraph to explain the other side of the argument?

Up Vote Up Vote ×
+ Add a Comment