My Reasons For Avoiding The Acute Care Hospital

Some nurses have never worked one day inside a traditional acute care hospital during the entire length of their nursing careers. How could this possibly happen? While I cannot speak for other nurses, I will provide an answer to the question that multiple people have asked: "Why don't you want to work at a major hospital?" Nurses General Nursing Article

I've been asked the same question by members of allnurses.com, real-life coworkers, and even some of my own family members: "Why aren't you interested in working at a major hospital?"

My relatively short nursing career consists of experience in long term care, rehabilitation (acute and sub-acute), and psych. For the past two and a half years I've been employed at a small specialty hospital that provides acute rehabilitation services, and to be honest, I think it's wonderful when a patient discharges to home with the ability to walk and talk when he was bedridden and unable to speak just two weeks ago.

My career is about to traverse into a new chapter when I enter the realm of developmental disabilities nursing starting next week. Twelve years ago, when I was 19 years old, I was employed as a direct care staff member and caregiver at a group home in a residential area that housed six developmentally disabled clients. I mostly enjoyed working with this particular patient population and will be thrilled to finally work as a nurse in this specialty.

Meanwhile, let's venture back to the original question. . .Why do I not want to work at a major hospital? Honest introspection is a major part of my career decision. In addition, my experiences while attending clinical rotations during nursing school at multiple hospitals in two different states cemented my choice to avoid acute care like the plague, especially after seeing how appallingly the nurses were being treated. After much painstaking self-reflection, I realize that an acute care hospital job is not for me. Some people would interject and say, "Well, you'll never know unless you try it!"

To be perfectly blunt, I know my personality is not compatible with acute care. I'm a mellow type B girl who does not like responding to codes. I dislike dealing with changes in condition. I detest taking off orders that constantly change on the whim of the doctor, nurse practitioner, or physician's assistant. I cannot stand constantly performing procedural skills such as IV starts, Foley catheter insertions, nasogastric tube drops, or blood draws. I despise having to drop what I'm doing to address a stat order. I do not look forward to constant interaction with physicians, families, dietary staff, visitors, RT, and other people.

I hate the liability involved with acute care. I do not enjoy the idea of not knowing exactly what I'm going to walk into. I do not like making decisions NOW, and in acute care the nurse must make decisions NOW. Acute care involves a pace with which I'm not comfortable. I'm not an adrenaline junkie. My preferences include low acuity patients, low liability, minimal stress, and the same old routine. I know that several years of acute care hospital experience would be vastly beneficial to my career as a nurse. After all, you don't know what you don't know. However, if I would likely be unhappy during those years, why follow through with it? If I could steer clear of the acute care hospital for the remainder of my career, I'd be content.

Some uninformed people insist that real nursing only takes place inside the walls of the acute care hospital setting. People can think whatever they darn well please. As long as I'm happy, secure, and comfortable with the work I'm doing, that's all that matters to me. Patients outside the hospital setting need nurses, too.

When I started critical care, I was fascinatd by ABGs, ECGs, EEGs, labs, vents; to the extent that I would awake before the alarm. I could not wait to get to the hospital and continue learning.

I worked in California in a pulmonary ICU during the first wave of AIDS (1984/85). A few of the nurses on my unit refused to care for AIDS patients. (I think, at the time, it was called GRID or another acronym.) Some of the nurses were pregnant so I didn't blame them. We were all in the dark about the disease.

I did not refuse to care for AIDS patients. I met amazing men with wonderful histories and stories to tell. I wept when they passed.

We nurses drew our own ABG's when the patient was too fragile for an A-line.

One of my patients was a young woman (19) who was stabbed during a fight with another woman over a boyfriend. She developed ARDS and was on a vent for weeks. She recovered. We made that happen for her.

There were Swan-Ganz (PA line) insertions at the bedside. I admired the doctors so much.

When I worked in that unit, the nurse/patient ratio was 1:2.

Specializes in maternal child, public/community health.

I too have not worked in acute care. Could I? Yes and I could be good at it but I knew before I went to nursing school that I wanted to do maternal-child public health. I wanted time to do health teaching and to have long-term relationships with my patients. I got the "you really need to do a couple years of med-surg" from instructors and other nurses. Their rationale was that it taught you skills you would not learn in other jobs. When I asked if aspiring acute care nurses needed to do public health, rehab, long-term care etc to develop skills they wouldn't learn in acute care, they usually just looked at me like I was weird. I told them, "No nurse can know it all. There is too much information and care is too complex. If you are a cardiac nurse, you develop that skill and knowledge but do not know maternal-child or peds. You develop a skill set in whatever nursing job you do. You can't know or do it all." I was 51 when I graduated. I did not want to waste a couple years doing a job I did not like. After 9 months in a peds clinic, I got my ideal job in public health working with pregnant and parenting teens - exactly what I wanted to do. I have autonomy, do lots of teaching, face unexpected challenges daily and my job is never boring. Is it easier than acute? NO! It is just hard in different ways but I love it. Some nurses with hospital experience try it and find it is not a good fit for them - they may not like being without backup, going into strangers homes in not great areas of town or they miss the adrenaline rush. The great thing about nursing is you can find an area that fits you. I appreciate all the great acute care nurses I know. I'm just not one of them.

Might I regret done the road that I did not do acute care? Maybe but I for sure I absolutely would regret spending time doing acute care. Am I a "real nurse"? Yes. I use the nursing process every day. I don't give meds but I do a lot of teaching. I advocate for my patients when they are not receiving the care they deserve and need. I educate about a wide variety of subjects - not just the teen mom but other family members as well. I am a real nurse and I love what I do. I hope those of you who don't love your job can find one that is a good fit for you.

Specializes in Palliative.

Around here, public health is the position to covet. One usually has to have years of seniority to get into it. In nursing school our entire program was geared toward community nursing. Public health nurses are also on a higher pay scale than other nurses. We got the distinct feeling that while we would have to do our time in acute, if we really wanted to be on the forefront of nursing we should go into community as soon as possible.

That said, new nurses are usually encouraged to start in acute, if not to stay there. The prevailing logic is that with a couple of years of acute experience, a young nurse has more options because she has a skill base on which to draw that she wouldn't if she only worked LTC. And I certainly saw the reality of that in the LTC facility I worked in. RNs basically do nothing but paper work and a number of them were afraid to work elsewhere because they felt their lack of skills. Some pick up shifts in acute just to keep skills current. So it's more about taking advantage of options rather than saying this type of nursing is superior. I do know there is a real distaste for LTC in general however.

Agreed that the non-stop parade of other disciplines, families etc is the worst thing about working acute, however working nights on a less acute unit helps with some of the issues. That said, I've been told many times that nursing in general is completely unsuited to my personality (I come up in myers-briggs as an INTP--all the career advice says the worst job an INTP could do is caregiving--a list of all the things INTPs are utter crap at basically describes nursing). All through nursing school I was struck by the fact that people like me should not be nurses. But it turns out doing things I'm not naturally good at has been an incredibly valuable growing experience. And that's the other side of things, it is possible to learn a lot by doing the things that are uncomfortable and don't come easily.

That said, the field I would never work in is psych. I hated that with every fibre of my being and was lucky to even pass the clinical. It was my lowest mark in nursing school. I think it's great that some nurses love psych however because it means I don't have to ever work there ever.

Wow, I wish I would have found this post before I'd worked at a hospital.

This sounds just like me in a nutshell! It's nice to hear my own thoughts being echoed and validated.

Specializes in OB/GYN,PHN, Family Planning.

I can echo the same comments. I worked in L&D right after graduating from nursing school because I felt I needed the acute hospital experience. For the past 9 years I have been a PHN and LOVE it -would NEVER go back to hospital nursing. I am currently a RN manager for a public health/family planning clinic and finishing my Masters in Nursing with focus in PH. "Real" nurses don't just work in hospitals.

Thank you so much for this article. I always enjoy hearing from you!! I am a second career nurse who realized in my last semester of nursing school that acute care just wasn't for me. It was almost impossible for new grad ADNs to get hospital jobs here where I live anyway, so I was very lucky to get a job in corrections, which I really loved. Currently I am working PRN in corrections and PDN for a special-needs child. What a great variety, huh? Not as much money as I could possibly make if I had gotten that acute care experience, but I recently told a friend that at my stage of life I wanted work that enhanced my life, not shortened it. I know that acute care would drive me (or God forbid, someone else!!) to an early grave. If I was younger I know I would have wanted that acute care experience and I felt really bad about missing out on it for a while. Just recently though I realized I have grown into being a confident, competent nurse in my own specialties and possibly even have strengths that the nurses being run ragged in the hospital haven't had a chance to develop. Thanks again for your article.

So...as a GN with a valid RN license, uninterested in hospital work...where do I find an employer? It seems that "golden year" for floor nursing if not 2 is the ticket to moving out of the acute care setting and into a specialty.

Even wound care centers want nurses with at least 2 years so it seems from the job listings I've read.

I want the oppertunity to assess patients and provide care but the nurse to patient ratios combined with the pace of the hospital setting is not conducive to me and I don't think it's really safe for the patient or my license.

Any suggestions are welcome.

I'm very interested in PH...but that floor experience...can I get into PH without acute care setting experience?

I've been a nurse for 10 years Always working Med. Surg. & Acute care settings. I must say I do understand where you are coming from after reading your article & respect your honesty about your feelings for this type of nursing. It does not make you less of a nurse & you are SO right about the fact that nurseing does not take place only in the walls of a acute care setting. You are so right about what you said & do NOT let anyone make you feel less just because your not into adrenaline rush settings. Me personally , I do not like routine & I work so much better stressed & under pressure. I"ve floated in hospitals all of my nursing career & that is what I love. Always different & never knowing what I'm walking into. Constantly learning & experiencing new & different things & people. It is definitely my calling & I truly love it & this type work is not work to me , it is such a joy. We are all different & the medical field requires many different people & personalities for all that is has to offer. You are just as important as us adreniline junkies !

I've been asked the same question by members of Allnurses.com, real-life coworkers, and even some of my own family members: "Why aren't you interested in working at a major hospital?"

My relatively short nursing career consists of experience in long term care, rehabilitation (acute and sub-acute), and psych. For the past two and a half years I've been employed at a small specialty hospital that provides acute rehabilitation services, and to be honest, I think it's wonderful when a patient discharges to home with the ability to walk and talk when he was bedridden and unable to speak just two weeks ago.

My career is about to traverse into a new chapter when I enter the realm of developmental disabilities nursing starting next week. Twelve years ago, when I was 19 years old, I was employed as a direct care staff member and caregiver at a group home in a residential area that housed six developmentally disabled clients. I mostly enjoyed working with this particular patient population and will be thrilled to finally work as a nurse in this specialty.

Meanwhile, let's venture back to the original question. . .Why do I not want to work at a major hospital? Honest introspection is a major part of my career decision. In addition, my experiences while attending clinical rotations during nursing school at multiple hospitals in two different states cemented my choice to avoid acute care like the plague, especially after seeing how appallingly the nurses were being treated. After much painstaking self-reflection, I realize that an acute care hospital job is not for me. Some people would interject and say, "Well, you'll never know unless you try it!"

To be perfectly blunt, I know my personality is not compatible with acute care. I'm a mellow type B girl who does not like responding to codes. I dislike dealing with changes in condition. I detest taking off orders that constantly change on the whim of the doctor, nurse practitioner, or physician's assistant. I cannot stand constantly performing procedural skills such as IV starts, Foley catheter insertions, nasogastric tube drops, or blood draws. I despise having to drop what I'm doing to address a stat order. I do not look forward to constant interaction with physicians, families, dietary staff, visitors, RT, and other people.

I hate the liability involved with acute care. I do not enjoy the idea of not knowing exactly what I'm going to walk into. I do not like making decisions NOW, and in acute care the nurse must make decisions NOW. Acute care involves a pace with which I'm not comfortable. I'm not an adrenaline junkie. My preferences include low acuity patients, low liability, minimal stress, and the same old routine. I know that several years of acute care hospital experience would be vastly beneficial to my career as a nurse. After all, you don't know what you don't know. However, if I would likely be unhappy during those years, why follow through with it? If I could steer clear of the acute care hospital for the remainder of my career, I'd be content.

Some uninformed people insist that real nursing only takes place inside the walls of the acute care hospital setting. People can think whatever they darn well please. As long as I'm happy, secure, and comfortable with the work I'm doing, that's all that matters to me. Patients outside the hospital setting need nurses, too.

I needed to see this. I am also a mellow type B kinda girl. I am miserable in the hospital setting.. As I suspected I would be. I've been thinking maybe I made a mistake starting a career change in nursing but I think I just need a change in scenery. Thank you for sharing.

Specializes in Case mgmt., rehab, (CRRN), LTC & psych.
I needed to see this. I am also a mellow type B kinda girl. I am miserable in the hospital setting.. As I suspected I would be. I've been thinking maybe I made a mistake starting a career change in nursing but I think I just need a change in scenery. Thank you for sharing.

Yep. Not everyone is cut out to work in the hospital setting. It is perfectly okay to admit this. In fact, the sooner one comes to this realization, the happier they'll be due to making more informed career choices.

2 Votes
Specializes in Outpatient/Clinic, ClinDoc.

I never liked working in acute care.. I did a few years, then went off to be a software engineer for about 10 years. After that, never stepped foot in a hospital as an acute care employee again. I did outpatient for the most part, some research and case management.. I do work *in* an acute care hospital now, but I am sitting on the floor reviewing charts so I get to see what I am missing (not!!). :)