Abolishing the Pinning Ceremony

Nurses General Nursing

Published

  1. Should the Pinning Ceremony traditionally held to honor graduate nurses be abolished?

    • 61
      yes
    • 245
      NO

306 members have participated

Hi all,

I am currently a nursing student in a BSN RN program heading into my senior year (woo hoo almost done). I have also been elected Vice President of the Student Nurses Association at my school and today I got hit with a big blow in an officers meeting!! I was advised that the ceremony to honor the culmination of all my and my peers hard work is no longer going to be celebrated; as the school has decided to do away with the pinning ceremony.

Initially, i was at a loss from words. I remembered sitting in my very first nursing class and learning about what a prestigious honor it is to be pinned; to be recognized and welcomed into the the profession of nursing. When I questioned the faculty as to why this decision has been made, there only response was that "The pinning ceremony is more common place in associate programs..." (My school is a BSN program)...they followed with our school "is trying to become a larger school, in terms of the nursing program, and we found that the larger schools no longer have a pinning."

So my question is, is this true? Has it become more common place to not have a pinning ceremony? Is this a long held tradition that has fallen to the way side? If so is there some sort of recognition held in lieu of a pinning? and if so what? Personally, I DO NOT want to let this tradition go and I feel if this is the case it is a shame. Myself and the other officers are trying to gain feedback on this issue. We are also tasked with breaking this information to the rest of our class, whom i feel will be just as upset as I am. However before doing so, we want to have sufficient enough information and a petition prepared in the event the general consensus is to fight for our right to be pinned! Please let me know what you all think of this, or if you have heard that the recent trend is to do away with the pinning and what schools are doing so. My college is located in New York, very close to the city.

Thank you for all your input:)

Specializes in Oncology; medical specialty website.

I didn't actually get to go to my pinning. The ceremony was very religious, and it included some practices that just really collided with my beliefs. You wouldn't believe the flak I took for it. "No one in the history of this school of nursing has ever not attended pinning!" I remember telling them "Well, then I'm about to make history, because I am not going." They threatened to not give me my pin but backed off when I reminded them that it my pin...I paid for it. I wound up being told to sit outside the chapel and wait till the pinning ceremony was over; then I could have my pin, but not before.

I still cherished that pin, even though it was the cause of much angst.

I didn't actually get to go to my pinning. The ceremony was very religious, and it included some practices that just really collided with my beliefs. You wouldn't believe the flak I took for it. "No one in the history of this school of nursing has ever not attended pinning!" I remember telling them "Well, then I'm about to make history, because I am not going." They threatened to not give me my pin but backed off when I reminded them that it my pin...I paid for it. I wound up being told to sit outside the chapel and wait till the pinning ceremony was over; then I could have my pin, but not before.

I still cherished that pin, even though it was the cause of much angst.

Would you mind telling us what kind of practices? I have never been to a pinning and I have no idea what is going to happen at ours but as far as I know, there isn't going to be a religious aspect to it. I could be wrong though...

I'd chew my tongue off before I'd recite that tripe!

That was the worst part of my required pinning ceremony. I just stood there with my stupid little candle and looked down. I wanted to barf. Luckily, I had already tapped that box of wine in the trunk of my car prior to the ceremony, and believe me, I made a beeline to that lovely little box o' heaven right after. Helped wash that awful taste from my mouth.

Specializes in none.
I'd chew my tongue off before I'd recite that tripe!

TRIPE!? Let me tell you of this tripe. I knew this RN that went into the Army as a Medic. He went to Nam. He went into combat. His company were pined down by enemy fire. On guy was wounded out in the open somebody had to go out a get him. The Captain ask for volunteers. My friend said that he would go. But before he did he told me that he recited the oath. He crawled out but half way to the guy, he was hit in the side despite the wound he was able to reach the guy, give him a shot of Morphine and drag him back getting wounded a second time. for his action he was give the Bronze Star and Purple Heart. He said he would have never made it if he didn't say the oath to remind himself that he had sworn before God that he would 'devote himself to those place within his charge. I have recited the oath every day, before I went to any job, for the last 40 years but then what do I know. I'm just a dumb LPN

Specializes in retired LTC.
TRIPE!? Let me tell you of this tripe. I knew this RN that went into the Army as a Medic. He went to Nam. He went into combat. His company were pined down by enemy fire. On guy was wounded out in the open somebody had to go out a get him. The Captain ask for volunteers. My friend said that he would go. But before he did he told me that he recited the oath. He crawled out but half way to the guy, he was hit in the side despite the wound he was able to reach the guy, give him a shot of Morphine and drag him back getting wounded a second time. for his action he was give the Bronze Star and Purple Heart. He said he would have never made it if he didn't say the oath to remind himself that he had sworn before God that he would 'devote himself to those place within his charge. I have recited the oath every day, before I went to any job, for the last 40 years but then what do I know. I'm just a dumb LPN
It's an honor to know you and TY for caring.
Specializes in none.
It's an honor to know you and TY for caring.

Thank You.

Specializes in Peds/outpatient FP,derm,allergy/private duty.

You don't like pinning. We get it. The architecture of your intellect soars way above ours. Let us grovel in the superstitious ooze and you be on your supercool way.

Specializes in Oncology; medical specialty website.
Would you mind telling us what kind of practices? I have never been to a pinning and I have no idea what is going to happen at ours but as far as I know, there isn't going to be a religious aspect to it. I could be wrong though...

I'd rather not, because I would get clobbered by certain posters here. I'll just say that it was very religious, and I didn't feel I cold attend. I do think it was somewhat ironic that they threatened to withhold my pin for not attending a ceremony that focused on religion.

WWJD?

Meh. My school didn't do it in 1986. I guess we were ahead of our time!

It seems silly to me and i wouldn't have gone.

However, I did go to my hooding, but that seems a little more significant.

boy, that last sentence sounds a bit condescending. But to each there own I suppose.

You don't like pinning. We get it. The architecture of your intellect soars way above ours. Let us grovel in the superstitious ooze and you be on your supercool way.

This made me LOL. Loudly.

Specializes in Obstetrics.

It should absolutely happen. It is part of the nursing profession.

I had no idea the pinning ceremony was looked down upon in some circles. I graduated in December from a state university that has both traditional and accelerated BSN programs. The nursing department held our pinning ceremony/awards reception several days before graduation. There were only 24 of us graduating from the ABSN program (we lost 6 students during the 16-month long program), so we were pretty close-knit. Since all 24 of us had graduated from college at least once before, a number of my classmates skipped walking, but almost all of us came to the pinning ceremony. It was a great experience.

We each picked who we wanted to pin us (most picked parents, children, spouses, etc.). I bought one of the official school pins, but you could use another pin if you wanted. The faculty member we selected was the featured speaker, awards were given to extraordinary students, we had the pinning ceremony, and then we said the nursing oath- a modern version, not at all religious, but meaningful (at least to me) and keeping to the philosophy of the program. No candles were lit, but a video of a burning candle was shown while we recited the oath, lol. I don't get why nursing programs would do away with the pinning ceremony, especially if the students fund it themselves.

+ Add a Comment