95 Theses of Healthcare Injustice

Published

As someone who no longer belongs to the bedside, I write about the injustice of healthcare.

I am not a bleeder at heart. I took care of many people across different acuities and ages on the floor and in ER, and the ones who truly needed to be there due to sickness, I did not mind at all. But growing up in a very disciplined, strict household, my standards and the patheticness of people, and also the complete injustice of healthcare industry wore me down inside and out.

In this industry, there is no accountability, no responsibility, no justice, no discipline. Hospital is dinged for readmission within 30 days for "not providing enough education", when the individual is hell-bent on feeding on non-compliance. Pain is now 6th vital sign because no one values overcoming pain or suffering anymore, they just want that instantaneous high, instead actually fixing the problem through diet, exercise, lifestyle change. Cons made up some cheeky devices to cheat out hospitals called satisfaction scores, HCAPS, and the hospitals are sworn by them. Instead of valuing the integrity and safety of the their employees, hospitals care more about providing better sandwich, warmer blanket, better resolution TVs, fancier rooms, while the heart and backbones of the care suffer with sub-par insurance, low compensation, dangerous staffing, ignoring the voices of the most important part of the business: their employees.

The hospital staff is reduced to nothing more than a glorified, educated garcon whose primary purpose is to keep people comfortable, happy, satisfied in order to receive "EVERY TIME" in EVERYTHING to scramble as much reimbursement as possible, while in actuality, we are to serve and protect the public from the harm, preventable death, and in every event, do no harm but uplift dignity and preserve humanity.

There is no humanity in narcotic addiction and drug-seeking behavior for the high, in continued alcoholism while on transplant list, in non-compliance to diabetic or CHF regimen, in deliberate laziness to resolve problems, cessation of bad behaviors or street drugs, in continued ugly and rude behaviors that harbor anger, hatred, violence and deceit. Where is dignity in that? I dare say, to me they can go die on their own accord either through OD or chronic illness that they brought on themselves, I will not be demanded to be compassionate and understanding to them to get a check mark on some score sheet. My dignity and standards will not allow that! Part of the blame, belongs to the "patients." Yes, contrary to puplar belief, patients are humans and they have duty to be accountable and responsible like every other humanbeing.

Injustice. I will use that word to describe healthcare. The administrators and policy makers are the biggest reason that brew anger and hatred toward my profession. "I don't care, that doesn't affect me" attitude really sickens me. Let the lowly pleb nurses take the excraments, we will get the bonus for selling the staff short and enjoy weekends and holidays. Well, I am out. I am happy in my cubicle.

" I will not be demanded to be compassionate and understanding to them ".

Compassion and understanding should come naturally with the territory of nursing.

Any civil human being would have the "dignity and standards" to attempt to overcome pain or suffering .

I am no longer at the bedside, I review clinical information in order to approve or deny payment for a hospital admission. Many of these cases... still hurt my nursing heart.

Hurts me you are in a cubicle... working from home is sooo much better.

And this is exactly why many of those suffering burnout/compassion fatigue don't feel safe coming forward. This saddens me.

I think that, if the OP had posted something about being concerned that s/he was starting to experience burnout/compassion fatigue, s/he would have gotten different responses. Instead, s/he posted a rather grandiose rant full of condescension, hostility, and condemnation toward her client population, stating that s/he now understands (unlike any of the rest of us) what is wrong with the healthcare system (and, in the process, implying a resemblance to Martin Luther!), and then suggested that the reason people aren't all agreeing with her/him is because we are too stoopid to realize that s/he is right. I think that's the problem, not that it's not "safe" for people to come here and talk about burnout.

Specializes in Specializes in L/D, newborn, GYN, LTC, Dialysis.

I agree with Elkpark. This is not compassion fatigue but something much more nefarious and dangerous to any patients this person would take care of at the bedside. Like I said, I am glad for him/her that they are no longer in that role. Some people are not meant to do this. The OP is a prime example.

I have suffered a form of compassion fatigue in my nearly 20 year career on and off. I took stock and looked hard at what made me feel that way. Got in touch with what brought me joy in life and separated my work and home lives carefully and was able to overcome it. I will say, I never got to the point where I felt so ugly toward my patients, but if I did, I would definitely move away from direct patient care. It would be unhealthy for all involved.

I think that, if the OP had posted something about being concerned that s/he was starting to experience burnout/compassion fatigue, s/he would have gotten different responses. Instead, s/he posted a rather grandiose rant full of condescension, hostility, and condemnation toward her client population, stating that s/he now understands (unlike any of the rest of us) what is wrong with the healthcare system (and, in the process, implying a resemblance to Martin Luther!), and then suggested that the reason people aren't all agreeing with her/him is because we are too stoopid to realize that s/he is right. I think that's the problem, not that it's not "safe" for people to come here and talk about burnout.

Really? The OP stated:

I understand that you are probably compassionate, good people in heart. But I am also certain that you all are not dumb either

I see the original rant as being more about how the business of healthcare in the USA is being conducted. I see a lot of truth here, that we, as an industry, enable poor health choices in order to turn a profit.

The hospital staff is reduced to nothing more than a glorified, educated garcon whose primary purpose is to keep people comfortable, happy, satisfied in order to receive "EVERY TIME" in EVERYTHING to scramble as much reimbursement as possible, while in actuality, we are to serve and protect the public from the harm, preventable death, and in every event, do no harm but uplift dignity and preserve humanity.

The bolded above is what many believe to be at the core of nursing- I certainly do, and to go into nursing in today's healthcare industry only to realize that it's all about the bottom line is understandably disillusioning- that has been my experience.

I'm certainly in agreement that it's probably for the best that the OP is no longer working at the bedside, but just because I am able to reconcile my moral distress over what I feel nursing should be compared to what it is, does not compel me to take the moral high ground over someone who wasn't able to make that leap.

Specializes in ER.

I certainly learned a lot today from yal today, thank you for all the inputs everyone, especially want to thank those who tried to understand my lame opinion (haha) like Anna Flaxis; regarding whether my opinion is dangerous, I never had a death of a patient due to my negilgence or from doing half-butted work; I thrived to meet all core measures, all door-to-balloon times, door-to-CT times, sepsis initiation protocol, initial 3 hour sepsis bolus, helping out my ED coworkers in need... I can honestly attest that I did my job the best I could and restrained myself from being unnecessarily ugly or rude. I was never a sweet sue to anyone, but I wasn't ugly to anyone either. I thrived on doing well in my job, because that was my duty and responsibility, and that's just how I was raised.

Now concerning my title, I competely agree it's pretty lame title lol. I don't think it's an ER nurse thing, but I can tell you that almost all ER nurses I talked to this about has a spectrum in this feeling, most agreeing having my idea somewhere in the spectrum. As I like to say, I only found two type of nurses: the ones who are miserable, and the ones who learned to tolerate their misery, but never found a happy nurse (of course, the only happy ones were administrators and desk job nurses, which I am one of now). I agree with all of you that I do not belong in bedside nursing, it served me very caustically.

If nursing steered away from business and get-me-money approach, instead really cared about employees and patients, this anger would not be so widespread. But I can't face another day in a hospital where both administration and patients think I am their little lap dog required to bark and sit when told and treat me however they wanted without any repercussion. I can't accept that kind of treatment, or at least how it's perceived to me.

Well, I have been waiting on clinicals from facility UM for hours, and my butt hurts from possible stage 2 pressure decubitus from sitting too long. I will go ahead and stretch. Thanks everyone.

Specializes in GENERAL.
Why isn't this post more popular?

I agree. Lots of these ideas and assertions cut to the bone. Whether I personally agree or disagree with any one of the OP's observations and conclusions involving nursing as it relates to the overall state of health care in this country is inconsequential. There is more than a kernal of truth in what he has to say about these issues that won't go away and does nothing but add to the necessary discourse all members of nursing should engage in to help identify and fix the many things we all see from day to day that need repair. It is not enough to throw-up our hands and say "oh, well, you can't fight city hall."

So when I read provacative words as outlined in the "95 theses" I see these words just as Martin Luther did as a call to arms to examine the established beliefs and practices that that for years have not been responsive to the justifiable needs of nurses, patients and the nation in general.

And besides, as a change of pace, this piece sure beats talking about wanting to slap your co-worker or figuring out how to get into the "easiest" nursing school PDQ.

+ Join the Discussion