One Reason For Nursing Burnout

As nurses we walk a fine line between professionalism, providing excellent patient and family care, and our ever-present imperative to maintain "customer satisfaction". While our patients are always our primary priority, we now find ourselves in a culture where the whims of the family are deemed more important by our superiors than the outcomes of our "clients". This dynamic causes a great deal of stress on the nurse's self esteem, and damage to our professional satisfaction. It is part of the reason for the ever-present march of nurses away from the bedside and toward less patient-contact positions. Nurses Announcements Archive Article

First let me say that the events in this story are true; however, the particulars have been changed so as to disguise the event and to eliminate any HIPPA violations. As of 3 PM today I am on vacation. I'm trying to concentrate on all things that are non-work related, but my head is still in the ICU. I spent the last four 12 hour shifts working with an elderly lady who is very ill. All three of her daughters are nurses at other facilities, and they all stayed attentively at her bedside. The first day they handed me a list of things they "didn't want me to forget to do for Mom." These included repositioning, incentive spirometry, feeding her meals, and the like. Well, I've been a nurse for a long time now, but I thought, okay, they are stressed. It's alright. They need to maintain some control in a situation that they have no control.

I made a point to pull up Mom's lab results and scan reports for them to read so they would feel well-informed and able to participate in her care. At the end of the first day, Mom coded. By the time they returned to her room, she had recovered enough to be awake and talking with us. I thought to myself how glad I was this family still had their beloved matriarch. Mom slept poorly that night and was quite lethargic the next day; however, she was appropriate when awake. By 6 PM the ladies had worked themselves into a state of near-hysteria because Mom was "not herself", and had not been strong enough to get up and walk. It had been less than 24 hours since she nearly died, and less than 24 hours since she had major orthopedic surgery. In the midst of their melt-down, they stated we (that would be me) were withholding information about Mom's condition and "not taking them seriously enough".

Okay, it was 6 PM, but I called the surgeon at home and got him to talk with them on the phone to answer their questions. I reminded them they had access (with Mom's approval, of course) to all lab results and scan reports. Their anger only escalated. The next day, part way through the shift I was told the new medication Mom had been given should not have been given without their express approval. Now Mom is alert and oriented and able to make her own decisions. As a matter of fact, Mom is a retired nurse herself. It never occurred to me to call the kids for permission to give her medication. They took this complaint to my manager. Now, I had spent four 12 hour days caring for this precious lady, washing her, feeding her, changing her dressings, and, yes, doing CPR on her. Successfully. I had worked hard...really hard...to care for this patient. Most days I didn't take lunch. I don't regret it for a second, and I certainly don't expect gratitude, but I didn't expect to be kicked in the gut either.

No, I don't do this job for money or for anyone's approval. I am so glad this sweet woman is going to live to go home and resume her gardening and canning and care for her cats. But I am also crushed. I am so frustrated, so depressed, so hurt. I feel hopeless, and just now I don't feel like going back to work at all. Ever. I'm sure I will eventually convince myself to carry on, but this has taken a toll on my spirit. Thank you for letting me vent. No one actually understands what we do but other nurses.

Just remember that you have a heart of gold and that even though your hard work went unnoticed by the family you did the utmost to be a professional. The payoff might not come right away but somewhere somehow someone else might be watching and hearing and it will come back to you. Your concern has reminded me that their are good nurses that took the oath and have stood by it! :saint:

Specializes in Registered Nurse.

I have not worked in ICU/CCU. That said, in hospital units that I have worked, I find nurses and other medical professionals as family/visitors a mixed bag. Sometimes they are helpful and understanding and sometimes they are "not helpful" and more*. If these daughters you speak of did not want certain medications given, they should have voiced that. Obviously, you had an order for this medication. These situations seem more common than ever, and I don't like it. Come on retirement!!!

You did a great job! Enjoy your vacation!

Specializes in PICU, Pediatrics, Trauma.
You are a badass who put a gracious old nurse back in her garden. That is what you need to take on your well deserved vacation.

The daughters have their own junk for whatever reason, just like anyone else who copes poorly under the pressures of fear and guilt and finds a scapegoat.

Totally agree and I like the wording of your first sentence.

OP...others say emotional involvement is your downfall....I don't know how to stay human and not feel emotions at times at work. I think your emotions are more about the hard work, your attempts to do everything the family wanted, and thinking you were doing a great job of including them etc...only to be shot down at every turn. This is very emotionally draining no matter who you are. However...it is the type of thing that burns us out and other things like it. Doing your very best, thinking you are doing a very good job, feeling successful in caring for the patient etc and then have someone...anyone come along...management, family, co-worker...tell you that you didn't do something well or criticize harshly.

It's tough and one of the things we have to deal with as nurses.

Keep taking vacations when able, talk out the tough days with someone, and do whatever you can to stay physically healthy. Get proper sleep and exercise. Sometimes a job change is all it takes to find a new lease on life (career). tOnly you know when he time would be right for this.

Good,luck. I'd love to have you for my nurse.

Specializes in PICU, Pediatrics, Trauma.
Not like you can change all that crazy, but I love getting the family involved in care to literally give them something to do. Part of me thinks it's interesting they didn't help you at all with your work- the family members who are nurses are usually helping me do passive ROM exercises, turning, repositioning, bathing, even basic oral care on those total care patients.

If mobile, they're usually tracking Is and Os, taking their family members for walks, helping me plan med administration ("Dad gets nauseous before he walks, can we give him Zofran beforehand").

I hear ya. Have had those experiences too, but what OP went through also happens. I'm tending towards what others said regarding the guilt factor. Given the attitude of these daughters, I don't think they would have been receptive to "helping". Probably would have complained that OP was having them do "her" work, as opposed to simply wanting to help. Some will be jerks no matter what you do.

As a patient, when I was able, I wrote down my own I's and O's to help the nurse, and tried very hard NOT to use the call light. There are all kinds.

Specializes in PICU, Pediatrics, Trauma.
I think the OP was having a tough time not personalizing the nasty and crazy behaviour she was subjected to. It often helps to recognize that there may be long-standing family dynamics that have nothing to do with the quality of one's care.

Sounds like the OP was trying to work with the family and support them in the situation they were in. Now they're gone, and she's trying to recover from being slimed on a daily basis. At this time, it's the OP who needs our compassion.

Couldn't agree more! There are always some family dynamics that are not personal to the nurse, but the crap left behind is for us to then have to deal with.

Specializes in PICU, Pediatrics, Trauma.
Just remember that you have a heart of gold and that even though your hard work went unnoticed by the family you did the utmost to be a professional. The payoff might not come right away but somewhere somehow someone else might be watching and hearing and it will come back to you. Your concern has reminded me that their are good nurses that took the oath and have stood by it! :saint:

Yes, OP....this is correct and also...Please remember there will also be the families that appreciate very much what you do for them. There also are those who will "make your day" in the opposite way, going above and beyond in thanks and gratitude. They all aren't like this family. Hang in...

Specializes in Huntingtons, LTC, Ortho, Acute Care.

My two cents... Administration and management treat nurses like the show ponies. We're supposed to be sunshine and rainbows at all times and kiss butt always... May as well put petroleum jelly on our teeth so we keep smiling...

Health care has gotten too far away from HEALTH we are not a hotel we are not a restaurant we are not Walmart... Yet are expected to provide "customer service". While I do not condone any nurse being a witch just because there's "no" repercussions.... We shouldn't have to be fake sweet to people for the sake of a satisfaction score. we shouldn't be given scripts from management on what we should or shouldn't say...

This satisfaction based reimbursement and satisfaction scores is the biggest pile of bull-shite I ever encountered in my career! I mean honestly who is going to fondly remember being sick and stuck in an environment they can't control for days? Families and patients shouldn't be calling the shots and dictating our care! We have the knowledge and degrees and most families are lay people with no medical experience and health care professionals have to bend to their wills?! Everyone has the right to know the options and make decisions but to give you a honey do list is bull.

If it wasn't you they complained about itd be someone else, you did fine... Enjoy your vacation and ignore that bull spit. There's just no pleasing some people unfortunately. Sadly these days the nursing career feels like a witch hunt, people no longer trust us and pray we screw up for the chance to sue or complain. Chin up!

I'm sorry patient families and their complaints about nursing is my hot button if you can't tell...

Specializes in Travel, Home Health, Med-Surg.

I have met many family members who claim to be "nurses" only to find out later (with further prodding) that they only call themselves nurses because they once took care of their relative, cat, etc. If these daughters were in fact RN's then they should have been more understanding. That being said, I have had family members and patients who were in fact RN's, some were nice, some were crazy like your experience. I usually try to say something to the crazy ones (whether RN's or claiming to be) like " well I know you understand ...(fill in the blank)...because you are nurse too, right". Usually shuts the know-it-all's" up. Sounds like you are caring and did a great job, don't let them steal your joy!!

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
I have met many family members who claim to be "nurses" only to find out later (with further prodding) that they only call themselves nurses because they once took care of their relative, cat, etc. If these daughters were in fact RN's then they should have been more understanding. That being said, I have had family members and patients who were in fact RN's, some were nice, some were crazy like your experience. I usually try to say something to the crazy ones (whether RN's or claiming to be) like " well I know you understand ...(fill in the blank)...because you are nurse too, right". Usually shuts the know-it-all's" up. Sounds like you are caring and did a great job, don't let them steal your joy!!

Even the RNs don't always possess a clue. My best friend is an RN, but hasn't worked in 35 years since she married Dr. WorldFamousNephrologist. Since she spends more time listening to his work stories than mine, she is more likely to see the physician side of the equation than the nursing side. And yes, she has a mother who is in ICU right this minute and I can be almost certain she's sticking her nose in, albeit in the nicest way possible.

My sister is a Gucci nurse with a staff and a corner office. She hasn't been near an actual patient since 1982, except when our parents have been hospitalized. She's the family member from hell, RN or no. (Once when Dad was in V tach and the entire staff was trying to get him stabilized, she started pitching a fit about getting a more private and comfortable space for my mother to take a nap, and why couldn't she just lie down in that empty bed over there?)

I wanted to reply to you and select some quotes from your post to remind you of everything you had done right, but I would have had to select your whole post! You cared for this woman so well, and I am so sorry her daughters can't see that beyond their stress.

I have been in your situation and have found myself similarly speechless and dumbfounded. As other posters have mentioned, these daughters are angry and scared about their mom and are lashing out at the nearest "responsible party" they can find, and that is you.

I hope you had a great vacation, and returned to find that your manager backed up your thoughtful care to this patient.

When I next find myself in this situation, I'd like to be able to say, directly, to the family, just about what you said:

Now, I spent four 12 hour days caring for this precious lady, washing her, feeding her, changing her dressings, and, yes, doing CPR on her. Successfully. I worked hard...really hard...to care for her. Most days I didn't take lunch. I don't regret it for a second, and I certainly don't expect gratitude, but I don't expect to be kicked in the gut either.”

Imagine how health care could change if we could actually say that to patients and their families!

Thank you all so much for your support! It means a lot!