help me buck the system, please! super-traditional pinning ceremony that nobody wants

Nurses General Nursing

Published

Hi all-

I'm posting this in the general discussion rather than the student discussion, as I want to hear from people who were successful in doing something like this.

I'm the president of my ADN class, graduating this May. We have 17 students, 14 of them women. Our faculty is, almost entirely, *extremely* conservative, and the school is in a very small town. Our pinning ceremony is held in a church, and has pretty significant christian religious overtones, which I have a problem with; I think it's an inappropriate blurring of the line between church and state (this is a state-funded community college), and I've had a few students express discomfort with having the ceremony in this church. By the way- it's only held there for faculty preference; there's plenty of room on campus.

My main concern, though, is the attire for the ceremony. We're being forced to wear white dresses and caps. Now, we have to wear the caps in most clinical rotations, which is enough of an indignity (people think we're kidding, that other staff members are playing practical jokes on them by sending students in the room with caps on...it's nauseating, but I've tried to change this with no success). But I think it's ludicrous to insist we wear them at the pinning ceremony. It's *our* event, not the faculty's. In my opinion, the requirement that women wear dresses is inappropriately sexist, and from a logistical standpoint, *nobody* should be spending money on a white dress that will gather dust forever, when we have the expense of the NCLEX looming in our immediate future.

We have one student who wants to wear a white dress, and the others are adamantly opposed to it. I'm looking for ways to approach the program director with alternatives...I think that I need to have some suggestions, or he's just going to shut it down completely. Personally, this issue is important enough to me that I won't attend the ceremony if we have to wear the dresses. I know of at least 2 other women who plan to do the same thing.

My current plan is to have a meeting with the director and my vice-president to discuss the feelings our class has about the issue, and suggest a couple of alternatives- wearing nice, 'dressy' outfits, or wearing our clinical uniform (white smock and lab coat with navy pants). I'd like to hear from anyone else who had to address this issue, and how you resolved it. I'm also open to any suggestions *anyone* has...this director is extremely old-fashioned (he said he'd have us all wearing black stockings and orthopedic shoes, if he had his way), but he also respects me *specifically* because I'm confident and outspoken. By the way, if this were not the prevailing feeling of the other class members, I'd just skip the ceremony...I'm treating it like a class issue because I feel that's my role as the class president.

Also, please don't try to convince me we should be wearing the dresses. I don't really give a hoot about someone else's traditions that encourage disrespect and sexism, so the 'traditional' nurse's uniform is something I refuse to ever put on my body. I find the caps degrading enough...I am a medical professional in training, and there's nothing more irritating than having a doctor or nurse or patient say, 'how *cute*!!' when I walk into a room. If you disagree with me, I certainly respect your opinion, but I am absolutely certain of my position on this subject.

I certainly hope so!:rolleyes:

LPN7.jpg

Specializes in PICU, Nurse Educator, Clinical Research.

as for being outspoken i think the op is just patting herself on the back...i don't believe that quiet thinking people are 'pushovers'

just remember that the word 'pushover' is your choice, not mine. I don't believe that quiet, thinking people are pushovers. My father is one of the strongest people I know, and he's very quiet. He also has very strong convictions, and raised me to stand up for mine.

and, for the umpteenth time, I'm fighting the dress code on *behalf* of my class. were i the sole dissenter, I'd simply boycott, based on the dress code.

and hey, being outspoken is quite advantageous in nursing. From what I know about her, Ms. Nightengale was pretty outspoken herself.

Specializes in PICU, Nurse Educator, Clinical Research.
Are male nurses expected to wear white caps?
I've asked our *male* program director on several occasions- he always just laughs, but never answers.

one of my classmates is a bald guy in his fifties. I'd give every dollar I own to see him in that cap and white dress. :rolleyes:

Specializes in PICU, Nurse Educator, Clinical Research.
you know, change to reflect the way things are while still respecting tradition is a good thing for nurses.

when we read the nurse's pledge during our pinning ceremony, we recited an updated version.

i dug out my program and found it. here's what we said:

--------------

i solemnly pledge myself in the presence of this assembly to practice my profession with integrity, honesty, and commitment.

i will contribute to the betterment of my profession by working to elevate the standards of nursing care, by adding to nursing's body of knowledge, and by delivering person-centered care.

i will care for individuals, families, and groups with respect, advocating for them and maintaining their confidentiality. i will refrain from administering treatments which will cause harm.

through collaroration, inquiry, and pursuit of wisdom, i will endeavor to safeguard the health and welfare of those committed to my care.

-------------

i think the pledge we read is much better suited to nursing as it is now than the original pledge:

i solemnly pledge myself before god and in the presence of this assembly, to pass my life in purity and to practice my profession faithfully. i will abstain from whatever is deleterious and mischievous, and will not take or knowingly administer any harmful drug. i will do all in my power to maintain and elevate the standard of my profession, and will hold in confidence all personal matters committed to my keeping and all family affairs coming to my knowledge in the practice of my calling. with loyalty will i endeavor to aid the physician in his work, and devote myself to the welfare of those committed to my care.

the pledge we read purposely omitted parts such as pledging before "god," and referring to "purity," "deleterious" or "mischievous" behavior," "my calling," and the "aiding the physician in his work" part.

aside from the "pledging to god" part, the other omitted parts are stereotypes and misconceptions of and about nurses and what we do. the "pledging to god" part was omitted to reflect the diverse cultural and religious make-up of nursing students and nurses. leaving out the "my calling" part helps in recognizing that nursing is a profession of choice and not something that someone is born into.

many schools have changed the pledge to reflect current day nursing practice:

http://www.nurseweek.com/news/features/01-10/nightingale.html

anyway, i don't think florence nightingale would be too upset with the changes:

http://www.care-nurse.com/creeds/nightengale.html

anyway....

wow- i'd totally forgotten about this part. i'm 99% positive they did the original pledge at last year's ceremony. i certainly won't pledge a lot of these things- definitely the stuff about passing my life in purity and abstaining from anything mischevious. and the 'aiding the physician' bit? nope. won't say it.

one thing i don't get- maybe someone with more knowledge of nursing history can fill me in. what's the bit about refraining from *taking* any harmful drug? was this an effort to discourage the use of alcohol? i'm not trying to start another debate, really- i'm truly curious.

thanks again, begalli- i'll be utilizing the links and pledge your class used. good stuff!

Specializes in Med-Surg, Geriatric, Behavioral Health.

Rachel,

You received alot of feedback from us...I hoped it helped you in the position that you plan to take. NRSKARENRN, gave you good feedback. My feedback...way long back...was similar...get with your peers, develop a plan, write it up and present it. You're going to make a heck of a nurse. I have no doubt about this! You generated alot of discussion and a little bit of angst. CCURN, you're OK, buddy. You took a little beating, but hey, I admire you for presenting your position too. Mystery5...thanks for the pics! You brought some flashbacks to us all...some nostalgic, for some traumatic. :) Anyway, the sides have been presented. Rachel, we wish you the best. Let us know how the ceremony turns out...one way or the other. I'll end here with a line that Rachel stated which sums it up in a nutshell... "Need i point out that I'm entering the nursing profession, *not* a convent, or the priesthood?" This is her position. I think we need to respect that. Wishing you the best, Rach!!!!!

Thunderwolf

Specializes in Emergency.

I think the meeting you speak of is a GREAT idea!!! I'm sure the majority will prevail. You are lucky you get a pinning ceremony.......My class didn't get one. I would have been for the all whites, but against the church thing.

congrats on your graduation!!

Our pinning ceremony is held in a church, and has pretty significant christian religious overtones, which I have a problem with; I think it's an inappropriate blurring of the line between church and state (this is a state-funded community college), and I've had a few students express discomfort with having the ceremony in this church.

I've "spot checked" parts of the thread, but I really don't want to wade through the whole thing, so perhaps someone already offered this advice. If so, sorry for the repetition. However, looking only at your posts, Rach, it seems to me that you have gotten pretty beat up over the religious issue, and unfairly beat up at that. I cannot understand why someone would ask a question like "if you don't believe as I do, then why do my beliefs threaten you?" It's a loaded question, to say the least.

I am going to suggest something that I have never, ever suggested before. However, you are attending a state institution, one funded by state and federal funds. You have a right not to have the religious beliefs of the conservative instructors, no matter how widespread in the town where you are at, inflicted upon you. Therefore, I suggest that you and a group of like-minded students contact the ACLU. If you fear retribution for contacting them, don't. If you were attending a private, christian university, then you would have no option. However, attending a public institution does confer on you the right not to have to attend someone else's religious ceremony. In addition, they should not be allowed to hold the ceremony in the church on a "voluntary" basis either. If there is to be a ceremony that honors graduates, then that ceremony should be all inclusive.

As to the dress code, I'm not sure what you can do about that.

Kevin McHugh

Sorry~ Guess I'm outnumbered here.

My vote goes to the traditional pinning. White dress, cap and in a little church would be lovely to me.

At ours, we were to dress in a professional white outfit/scrubs. You should have seen what some of the people called professional....Tacky, very tacky....one girl wore an off white evening gown complete with sequins and little pearls sewn on! :rolleyes:

Again I am not trying to tell anyone how to feel I am trying to undertsand what is so offensive or threatening?

CCU NRS

It isn't a matter of being "offensive" or "threatening." It is a simple matter of preference. It is also a matter of not having someone else's religious beliefs pushed down your throat, which I believe is happening here. As I understand it, it isn't simply that the ceremony is held in the church, but that the ceremony has distinctly religious overtones. THAT's the problem. Someone else already brought up the satanic temple, but let's consider a somewhat less extreme example:

Suppose the director of this program was a Muslim, and wanted to have the pinning ceremony in the local mosque. Further suppose that the director wanted the ceremony to have "distinctly Muslim overtones." Would you be equally OK with that? The issue isn't whether or not class members find someone else's religious beliefs threatening, the issue is whether they should be forced to celebrate their own accomplishment by honoring someone else's religious beliefs.

Kevin McHugh

Sorry~ Guess I'm outnumbered here.

My vote goes to the traditional pinning. White dress, cap and in a little church would be lovely to me.

And since it would be "lovely" to you, the class members who might be Jewish, or Muslim, or XXXXXXXX (fill in the blank) should have to go and honor what would be "lovely" to you? Really, I'm not trying to be confrontational, but try to put yourself in someone else's shoes.

Kevin

Specializes in Fertility.

well said!

I admire the stand she's taking. Now, if only more Nurses' would do the in the work envirnoment, so things can change. It's scary to think I will have to put up with abuse from administration, management, other faculty and patients...when I get into the field (I'm a CMA/Nursing student) I don't plan to take this lying down. The soon to be nurse whom started this post, is the one who will help bring changes in and out of the Nursing world...Kudos to you!!!!

And since it would be "lovely" to you, the class members who might be Jewish, or Muslim, or XXXXXXXX (fill in the blank) should have to go and honor what would be "lovely" to you? Really, I'm not trying to be confrontational, but try to put yourself in someone else's shoes.

Kevin

and isn't a Mosque (and other names that I don't know) also a type of church?

We may have different beliefs, but no matter who we worship....it all boils down to one thing. Like they study in some 12 step groups and other places, the higher power we all have is one who guides us, whether it be God, Buddah, or whatever else....

Yea~ I would be willing to participate with friends or classmates. Yes~ I would be willing to have a more "integrated" ceremony.

I respect those who are different than I, and honor their beliefs. Yes, I would be there and be proud of the diversity in all of us and in the friendship we had.

+ Add a Comment