Grant MacEwan or University of Alberta

Fiona59 · May 9, 2007

I work with both of their students. Prefer the GMCC bunch over the UofA students.

GMCC for a while was harder to get into than UofA. But GMCC seems to prepare better hands on nurses and their skills are slightly better than the Us.

Having said that it won't count for much in a couple of years because the instructors all change frequently. I rarely see the same clinical group leader twice.

So you would be in Grade 10 or so?

Good luck.

Just A Wanderer · May 9, 2007

I'm a grade 11 student by correspondence, actually.

Thanks for replying! I've been hearing a lot of good things about Grant MacEwan.

Creamsoda, ASN, RN · May 30, 2007

I did the transfer and graduated in 2005. I liked grant mac way better. AT the time I went to school, both schools were doing "context based learning" which I as well as many others thought was a complete joke. Macewan I believe has got rid of that aspect of the program and are back to a traditional style of teaching, where I beleive the U of A still does it. So seeing as how grant mac doesnt do CBL anymore, and has a degree program, if they would have offered it at the time, I would have stayed. I didnt like the U of A so much, definately less hands on.

Context based learning in nursing is where you get different scenarios...it will be a patient profile, and your group has to brainstorm ideas relating to the scenario, so then different people will go home and research different aspects such as pharmacology to that particular situation, someone else will research what the disease process is, someone else will research the psychosocial aspects ect, then everyone comes back to the group with the research and presents it. It doesnt sound like it should be too bad in theory, but I was a huge waste of time where often the group would be focusing on the wrong part of the scenario and not realize it, or someones research would not be correct ect. We all just learned to just read the textbook as that was what we are tested on anyway. The point of all this is, is Macewan doesnt do CBL anymore which is great so I would definately look there first.

Cher

Just A Wanderer · May 30, 2007

Thanks for your input. The U of A's teaching style is one of the things I'm worried about, actually. Some time ago, I chose the U of A BECAUSE of their Context-Based Learning since I'm doing high school by correspondence and I'm used to studying by myself. However, a few people have told me CBL really wasn't that good and that the Grant MacEwan students get more hands-on experience, which I'm looking for.

Pediatric Critical Care Columnist · May 30, 2007

I work with new grads from both programs. I will say that I can usually pick out the U of A grads for their lack of clinical skills and their sense of superiority over the rest of us mere mortals. The look of absolute astonishment they give me when I reveal I have a diploma and not a degree, and have no intention of ever obtaining one is pretty funny! "But you know so much! And you can do so many things!" Gee.

A couple of friends of mine did the post-basic baccalaureate at U of A, graduating in 2005. They were definitely not impressed with CBL and felt it really taught them nothing.

One caveat about GMCC though has to do with their accelerated program. There is virtually NO pediatric content taught and no pediatric clinical either. The entire purpose of the program is to turn out med-surg nurses in as short a time as possible.

Just A Wanderer · May 30, 2007

Thanks for the reply. I'm looking into Grant MacEwan even more now! I definately want to be in a nursing program that offers a lot of clinical experience.

ShannonC83 · Jun 10, 2007

I'm not a nursing student yet (am thinking about doing the degree), but I took a physical education transfer program at the Grant MacEwan and then then U of A (2 years at each). Just from my experience in that program - may not be completely applicable to nursing - but I can definitely say that if I had a choice of schools I would choose Grant MacEwan WAY over the U of A. I found the classes to be much better, the profs were more personable, and the whole college is just a lot nicer.

To me it seemed a lot like the U of A just wanted their money and then you were left to fend for yourself. There are some advantages to the U of A though (more student groups, bigger campus if you want the whole 'university' feel and so on). If you are doing high school by correspondance though, I would likely think you'd be more suited to Grant Mac because the class sizes are a lot smaller. I came from Beaumont (small town on the south side) so I was used to a really small high school. I think that made the transition to university a lot easier - since Grant Mac was a lot more like my high school was compared with the U of A.

Just A Wanderer · Jun 12, 2007

Class size is somewhat of an issue for me - I prefer small class sizes. I haven't attended a "normal" school for almost six years now so I don't want to be too overwhelmed to the point where I'm stressing out bad during the first couple of days. I mean, I know it's normal to feel stress concerning school but I'm planning to take some transfer courses before I even apply to the program so the workload won't be too much for me to handle.

Thanks for your input.

Fiona59 · Jun 12, 2007

I've been wondering how you would "fit" into a normal, scheduled classroom setting. It will be a big change for you. How do you tell with interprersonal politics, head games and some very competitive people?

I'm not trying to put you off, just make you aware of what you are facing. The interviews at GMCC are huge. How do you deal with sitting in a room with large numbers of equally nervous strangers, waiting your turn?

Oh, and Shannon, the only way to become an RN in Alberta is to go the degree route. The last diploma class will graduate in '09.

Just A Wanderer · Jun 13, 2007

Junior high was the last scheduled classroom setting I've been in and that was awhile ago. :uhoh21: You're right, it will be a big change for me but I have been honest with myself concerning how realistic my plans are.

ShannonC83 · Jun 16, 2007

Oh, and Shannon, the only way to become an RN in Alberta is to go the degree route. The last diploma class will graduate in '09.

Thanks for that information. I had heard that that was the case. Is it extremely competitive to get into GM?

I'm also sort of wondering about psychiatric nursing. GM offers a 2 year program in that, so is that going to certify you anymore either?

I wonder where it's easiest to get into nursing (in terms of which school). My GPA from my last year of phys ed wasn't overly high (worked way to much during school) so I have that sort of working against me.