Understanding the Risk of Firearms: Suicide vs. Homicide

Gun violence is a hot topic these days. Turn on the TV for any length of time, and you will hear stories of firearm homicide. But, did you know that firearm suicide is more common in the U.S? Learn about the statistics of this public health issue and if nurses have a role in the firearms debate. Nurses General Nursing Article

Updated:  

If you watch the news or TV shows, you might be led to believe that there is a high risk of firearm homicide. Researchers from Northeastern University, University of Washington, and Harvard University conducted a study into the perceptions of gun violence and the leading cause of death in the United States. They found that the presence of a firearm in a home increases the risk for suicide, which is more common than firearm homicide.

So, what's behind our misconception about gun violence and how do you educate the community about the real dangers?

Looking at the Numbers

According to the Brady Campaign, the oldest organization in the gun violence prevention movement, 96 people die every day in the United States from gun violence. Of these 96, 34 are murdered, and 59 die from suicide. That means nearly twice as many people die from firearm suicide compared to firearm homicide. There are also 246 people shot daily who survive - 183 are injured in an attack, 49 are shot unintentionally, 4 are shot in a legal intervention, and 11 survive a suicide attempt.

A 2014 study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine reported that access to firearms in the home increases your risk of violent death by suicide, homicide, or unintentional injury. There was a direct correlation to the risk of suicide among people who had access to firearms compared to those without access. The study also reported that the US has one of the highest rates of access to firearms in the world.

Could impulsivity and the ease of access to a gun place some people at a higher risk of committing suicide or homicide? The study suggests that it's possible. Yet, there are no hard data to support the claim. States with the highest rates of firearms, also have a higher percentage of firearm violence compared to non-firearm violence.

Is it a Public Health Issue?

According to the American Public Health Association (APHA), gun violence is an issue that is deeply rooted in our culture and must be addressed through a public health approach. Violence research should be conducted to ensure that guns don't fall into the wrong hands. APHA also believes that access to mental health services must be expanded to those who need it most to decrease the number of suicides by firearms.

Do Nurses Have a Role In the Firearms Debate?

Every day nurses in Emergency Rooms across the country come face-to-face with the gun violence issue. They might deal with victims of homicide, suicide, and unintentional shootings.

Nurses who work in schools have become far too familiar with the issue over the past few years. The National Association of School Nurses released a Position Brief in which they state that school shootings in the US are an urgent public health crisis. The NASN advocates for safe school environments for all children and recognizes the emotional and physical effects that gun violence has on our students. This doesn't account for nurses in the ICU, rehabilitation units, and many other settings that might care for gunshot victims.

Unfortunately, healthcare workers can fall victim to gun violence, too. Recent research has highlighted the prevalence of suicide among nurses. And, gun violence in hospitals and other healthcare facilities seems to happen at an alarming rate. In fact, just a few weeks ago, a young doctor was killed in the parking lot of Mercy Hospital in Chicago at the hands of her former fiancee.

What Can You Do To Help?

Gun violence is a hot political debate these days. No matter which side of the aisle you stand on, as a nurse there are a few things you can do to help keep patients safe:

  1. Educate patients about the risks inherent in having a gun in their home. It's particularly important to speak to parents of young children about safe storage of all firearms.
  2. Connect patients with mental health concerns to services as quickly as possible. Many patients have mental health needs that if left unattended can quickly lead to violence towards themselves or others.
  3. Participate in violence prevention and intervention programs at your hospital or facility. None of us want to discuss or consider that a shooting could happen at our workplace, but unfortunately, the risk is real.
  4. Write to your elected officials to make your viewpoints on the issues known.
  5. Advocate for more research to be done to increase our understanding of homicide, suicide, and those who commit both.

What are your thoughts on the firearm statistics? Do you feel that nurses have a place in the firearm debate? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

Specializes in Pediatrics Retired.
You forgot the Zombies.

I'm OK with regular Zombies but the Zombies that can run scare the BeeJeezus out of me.

Specializes in ER.
...And this has what to do with guns? Or getting accessible mental health help?

Does it matter to you that most of the mass shooters were middle class?

I also object to you listing marriage as a "wholesome family value" when over 1/2 of all marriages end in divorce.

Apparently our world views on what would improve the mental health of society diverge here. I personally believe that unhealthy lifestyles and more unstable families contribute, and that government policies contribute.

Regarding the middle class, that is a segment of society that is very hard pressed today. They are carrying an unfair burden. As I mentioned in another thread, the middle class is being squeezed out of existence by expensive healthcare, taxes, housing, and government resources going elsewhere. Is it a wonder that many are cracking?

Apparently our world views on what would improve the mental health of society diverge here. I personally believe that unhealthy lifestyles and more unstable families contribute, and that government policies contribute.

Regarding the middle class, that is a segment of society that is very hard pressed today. They are carrying an unfair burden. As I mentioned in another thread, the middle class is being squeezed out of existence by expensive healthcare, taxes, housing, and government resources going elsewhere. Is it a wonder that many are cracking?

Yeah, I think easy accessibility to all types guns and kids getting desensitized to/panicking over school shootings, as well as getting all shot up because Jr. Incel got into his Daddy's guns, wreaks more havoc on our society than not being married.

Call me cray, and for for the love of God keep me away from guns.

I watch CNN, and I'm divorced.

I may crack.

Apparently our world views on what would improve the mental health of society diverge here. I personally believe that unhealthy lifestyles and more unstable families contribute, and that government policies contribute.

Regarding the middle class, that is a segment of society that is very hard pressed today. They are carrying an unfair burden. As I mentioned in another thread, the middle class is being squeezed out of existence by expensive healthcare, taxes, housing, and government resources going elsewhere. Is it a wonder that many are cracking?

FWIW, I do agree on the dissolution of the middle class.

Sadly, no one cares, as long as the 1% stay fat, all is well.

Specializes in school nurse.
I'm OK with regular Zombies but the Zombies that can run scare the BeeJeezus out of me.

Yeah, "28 Days Later" totally upended the Zombie paradigm...

Specializes in Pediatrics Retired.
Well, with no money in federal mental health and social services, we may never know what those are.

It's much easier to blame the media.

I think the poorly run welfare state is one negative factor in society. It has rewarded the breakdown of the family structure, and allowed a generation to sit on their butts, smoking pot, playing video games, consuming hot cheetos and soda pop on the pubic dime.

It had done very little to incentivize more wholesome lifestyles like marriage, family values, healthy eating and physical activity, all of which would improve mental and physical health.

...And this has what to do with guns? Or getting accessible mental health help?

Does it matter to you that most of the mass shooters were middle class?

I also object to you listing marriage as a "wholesome family value" when over 1/2 of all marriages end in divorce.

Apparently our world views on what would improve the mental health of society diverge here. I personally believe that unhealthy lifestyles and more unstable families contribute, and that government policies contribute.

Regarding the middle class, that is a segment of society that is very hard pressed today. They are carrying an unfair burden. As I mentioned in another thread, the middle class is being squeezed out of existence by expensive healthcare, taxes, housing, and government resources going elsewhere. Is it a wonder that many are cracking?

This exchange reinforces, to me, that the "cause" isn't the gun itself but, arguably, many social and governmental factors that have paved the way to where we are today; which kinda dovetails back into the OP's subject. The car has to have a driver, the alcohol or drug has to have a consumer, the cigarette has to have a smoker, the gun has to have a shooter. All of these items can kill but none of them are harmful without a human participant.

This exchange reinforces, to me, that the "cause" isn't the gun itself but, arguably, many social and governmental factors that have paved the way to where we are today; which kinda dovetails back into the OP's subject. The car has to have a driver, the alcohol or drug has to have a consumer, the cigarette has to have a smoker, the gun has to have a shooter. All of these items can kill but none of them are harmful without a human participant.

I'm angry and frustrated, too. I don't have guns, so I don't shoot anyone. Easy as pie.

Specializes in Pediatrics Retired.
Yeah, "28 Days Later" totally upended the Zombie paradigm...

OMG, YES...I was exhausted after watching that show!

Specializes in allergy and asthma, urgent care.
This exchange reinforces, to me, that the "cause" isn't the gun itself but, arguably, many social and governmental factors that have paved the way to where we are today; which kinda dovetails back into the OP's subject. The car has to have a driver, the alcohol or drug has to have a consumer, the cigarette has to have a smoker, the gun has to have a shooter. All of these items can kill but none of them are harmful without a human participant.

Well, then maybe guns should be licensed and insured just like cars. Users should have to demonstrate proficiency in their use, just like when someone gets their driver's license.

There's a lot of problems in this country, and the middle class really is getting squeezed. However, I disagree that media exposure to "sexual deviancy" and "sadism" (whatever the heck is meant by that), is the root cause. I feel a real factor is the glorification of guns in this country. As Macawake said earlier, they are a tool and should be used safely. They are not an accessory that everyone needs cause they're "cool".

Bottom line to me-too many people in this country die of gun violence, many of them children. We have to be able to talk about it, do research into the causes, and make appropriate changes to laws, legislation, whatever to change this fact. The NRA should not have the power to block these things from being done. No one wants to take your guns away. We want people to be safe and to stop dying unnecessarily.

Specializes in Pediatrics Retired.
Well, then maybe guns should be licensed and insured just like cars. Users should have to demonstrate proficiency in their use, just like when someone gets their driver's license.

...OldDude

I agree with this. I have a license to carry a handgun in Texas which I obtained after completing a state approved course of classroom instruction and proficiency demonstration. I pay a monthly fee to a firm for "liability insurance" just like I do on my vehicles.

...

There's a lot of problems in this country, and the middle class really is getting squeezed. However, I disagree that media exposure to "sexual deviancy" and "sadism" (whatever the heck is meant by that), is the root cause. I feel a real factor is the glorification of guns in this country. As Macawake said earlier, they are a tool and should be used safely. They are not an accessory that everyone needs cause they're "cool".

...OldDude

Agree with this but must add, glorification of guns is perpetuated by the media so they are complicit in that way. Overall, I think the media, which is profit driven, is a scapegoat on which to blame whatever pet peeve one has on. The media does influence people but I think it's more of a catalyst for various predispositions people have.

...

Bottom line to me-too many people in this country die of gun violence, many of them children. We have to be able to talk about it, do research into the causes, and make appropriate changes to laws, legislation, whatever to change this fact. The NRA should not have the power to block these things from being done. No one wants to take your guns away. We want people to be safe and to stop dying unnecessarily.

...

100% with you here

...

Good info!

Specializes in allergy and asthma, urgent care.
...

100% with you here

...

Good info!

Dude-you are a perfect example of what I think a responsible gun owner is.

Specializes in Pediatrics Retired.
Dude-you are a perfect example of what I think a responsible gun owner is.

Well thank you!! I forgot to add you have to pass a state/federal background check to get a "License to Carry a Handgun" in Texas.